|
Llewellyn Banks For a precursor movement, see the nuttiness against dancing in 1930-31. The Man Who Tried To Be
Hitler in U.S. By Detective Sergeant
JAMES R. O'BRIEN Oregon State Police NOTE: Revealed here for the first time in any publication is the complete story of a cause célèbre that won for the Medford Mail Tribune the coveted Pulitzer Prize for the year of 1933 for its reporting of this most unusual criminal case.--EDITOR. In 1926, there moved into Jackson County, Oregon--the richest fruit-producing and mining county in the state--Llewellyn A. Banks, a reputedly wealthy and experienced orchardist from Riverside, California. He first bought a large orchard, then, in 1928, purchased an enterprising newspaper, the Medford Daily News. By this time, he was being hailed as one of the leading citizens of the state. People, however, began to wonder just who this man was, when his editorials commenced to be tinged with more than just a trace of radicalism. By 1931, his newspaper was carrying to every corner of the state fiery denouncements of our government. He blasted the so-called moneyed men, the power interests, our courts and our elected officials. All were subjected to daily diatribes of vilification and abuse, and accused of charges originated from grounds wholly fanciful and fantastic. He used his newspaper as a medium to inflame the minds of malcontents. He harangued them, and all who would listen, until he made them think he was a martyr and they were being martyred with him. Thousands, harassed by the lean years of the depression, flocked to his side. During‘this period, there also lived in Medford, the county seat, Earl H. Fehl, editor and publisher of the Pacific Record Herald. Fehl also had long since been gathering editorial fodder from his opinion of the manner in which the affairs of the government were being handled. His writings had always been of a violent nature, often bordering on the very edge of criminal syndicalism. The two publishers, seeing in each other an ally, joined forces. And so was formed the team that, under the pretext of "fighting for the people's cause," was to make criminal history. By 1932, their followers numbering into the thousands and completely under their control, they decided the time had come to reap the financial harvest and make their bid for power by molding a solid organization from the masses. The organization was named the "Good Government Congress," a very disarming title, as we shall soon see. For officers this so-called Good Government Congress elected Henrietta Martin, a noisy agitator, as president; C. H. Brown, her father, secretary; and C. J. Conner, vice president and chairman of the secret membership committee. But they were only puppets. In a separate resolution, Banks was elected honorary president and given full general veto and dictatorial powers. Each member was to be assessed the "small sum" of fifty cents per month. Banks was fast accomplishing his end. Thousands of dollars a month would soon be pouring into his coffers--and he was now the "Dictator." This much accomplished, Banks stepped out to get control of every office in the county and set up his own domain from which he could spread over the entire country like a cancerous sore--through terrorism if need be--and still remain free from prosecution. In the elections of 1932, he set up his own candidate--who was none other than his fellow radical, Earl Fehl--for the important office of County Judge. For the powerful office of Sheriff, he sponsored Gordon L. Schermerhorn, for District Attorney, he sponsored M. O. Wilkins. No great amount of alarm over this was felt by the law-abiding citizens, however, for the incumbents in these offices were men of unimpeachable character, with years of faithful and meritorious service to their credit. But something slipped, Fehl was elected County Judge, and Schermerhorn was elected Sheriff. District Attorney Codding barely managed to hold his office by a slight margin, much to the displeasure of the Dictator. The position of District Attorney, however, was now a farce. He would have no Sheriff to entrust with important confidential investigations, serve warrants, maintain order, etc. Furthermore, he would be facing an adverse County Judge. The election of Fehl to the county judgeship put a powerful weapon in the Dictator's hands, and he did not hesitate to use it in the months to come. The county court then had charge of relief disbursements, could throw open the doors of the county commissary, had charge of roads, appointed election officials and fixed polling places, etc. But most important of all, he would occupy the bench to rule on the destiny of those brought before him for justice, to judge right from wrong, and an unlawful act from a lawful one. In the meantime, District Attorney Codding began receiving tips that all had not been as it should be at the election polls. In view of this, the incumbent Sheriff, Ralph Jennings, an upright and outstanding officer, decided to file suit for a recount in Circuit Court of the election ballots. On the face of the election count, he had been defeated by but 123 votes. The moment the suit was filed, the entire election took on a bad odor. Sheriff-elect Schermerhorn went into hiding immediately to avoid service and summons. After a long and unsuccessful search for him, it became obvious that he intended to remain in hiding until the date of assuming office, January 2nd, 1933. This would permit him to get control of the important and powerful office and hold same until such time as the suit could be acted upon by the courts. A lot could happen during this period. and, unfortunately, it did happen. At twelve o'clock midnight, January 1st, 1933, Earl Fehl automatically became County Judge. At six o'clock in the morning of the same day, there was a strange meeting at the Judge's house. Sheriff-elect Schermerhorn arrived from his hiding place in Northern California, accompanied by two carloads of men. He was sworn in as Sheriff by Judge Fehl and, in turn, he swore in his companions as deputy sheriffs. Promptly at eight o'clock, they marched on the courthouse to take the office by force, if necessary. The retiring Sheriff, however, was perfectly content to let the courts decide the matter, and they met with no resistance. The moment Judge Fehl settled himself in his high-backed chair, he made the announcement, "I am the duly elected Judge of Jackson County--Judge of all the people." Immediately, he plunged the courthouse and the entire county into a maelstrom of discord and strife. The building was continually jammed to capacity with loiterers and agitators. Court sessions became nightmares, and no official could perform his duties in the turmoil that existed. Judge Fehl seemed to be directing his entire efforts to building and enlarging the Good Government Congress. The courthouse auditorium was thrown open to weekly meetings of that organization. No words can describe the situation. Dictator Banks, as he was now being referred to throughout the county, was fast becoming drunk with power. He delivered speeches from the very steps of the courthouse, that were so violent they far exceeded the imagination of any clear-thinking people. He demanded that District Attorney Codding and Circuit Judge Norton, two of the most upright officials in the state, resign at once. They were the only stumbling blocks in his march to complete power. In open speeches to his followers, he encouraged them to seize these officials by force, tie them to whipping posts. If this didn't force their resignations, he suggested use of the hangman's noose. February 2nd, in a speech to his followers, the Dictator declared, "We have now come to the great showdown where blood will have to be spilled." In another on February 10th, he shouted, "The Good. Government Congress serves notice on Circuit Judge Norton and District Attorney Codding, that either you will destroy us or we will destroy you." Then, in a later speech from the courthouse steps, he announced to a howling mob, "I am ready to lead the field in open revolution." The situation was desperate--was fast reaching a climax. The county was rampant with hatred and distrust. People were disposing of their homes and businesses and moving elsewhere to seek peace and safety. Editors of other newspapers throughout the nation were warning the people to suppress this uprising. But the climax was yet to come. Perhaps the reader will wonder why the efficient Oregon State Police were not taking a hand in this vital case. The reason was a simple but binding one. We were not permitted to participate in disputes involving labor troubles or an election contest, except upon orders from the Governor of the State. Inasmuch as an election contest had been involved in this series of atrocities, we were prohibited by law from taking action. A ray of hope appeared on the horizon, however, when, on February 20th, Circuit Judge George Skipworth, occupying the Jackson County bench on the recount case after an affidavit of prejudice had been filed against Circuit Judge Norton, ordered that the election ballots be counted again the following morning in open court. By this time, many were certain that irregularities had existed in the election, and that a recount would automatically remove the radicals from control of the county affairs. Early on the morning of February 21st, I was startled from my sleep by the persistent ringing of my telephone. I was soon wide awake, however, as I listened to the excited voice of my caller. The most openly defiant and brazen act in the history of the state had been committed. The courthouse vault had been broken into, and the ballots, which were to have been counted before Circuit Judge Skipworth, had been stolen. This was too much. District Attorney Codding and Chief McCredie, of the Medford Police, had phoned long distance to Charles P. Pray, Superintendent of State Police, and requested our assistance, stating that the situation had now gotten completely out of their control. Superintendent Pray, after a hasty inquiry into the facts, immediately instructed my superior officer, Captain Lee M. Bown, commanding officer of District Three, to render the District Attorney and city police any and all assistance they might require. I was immediately assigned to investigate the case. Arriving at the scene of the crime, I found that the window of the vault, which is at the rear of the courthouse building, had been smashed in, in such a manner as to permit the burglars to reach in and release the latch. An inventory revealed nothing stolen but ballot pouches. Of these, thirty-six were gone. A search for fingerprints was practically useless. Crowds had been in and out of the vault before my arrival, and, as usual, had handled and disturbed everything. I was fortunate, however, to find, clinging to a sharp corner of the window frame, a small piece of cloth such as that commonly used in the manufacture of men's pants. This tiny fragment of cloth was destined to become of great importance and give us our first break in the case. The information regarding this find was quietly given to state and city police officers present. They were told to mingle with the crowds and watch for some man with torn pants of the same material. Continuing the investigation, my attention was attracted to several significant facts. The steel shutters protecting the window through which entrance had been gained had been left open on the night of the theft. Also, Captain Bown and Chief McCredie discovered the tops of eighteen ballot pouches concealed behind an inspection door off the boiler room which is used to gain access to the plumbing under the building. Extinguishing the fires in the furnaces, we were further rewarded with the discovery of metal clasps and hinges from the tops of approximately a dozen ballot pouches. All of the aforementioned pointed to only one thing--an inside job. It could be no one except some person, or persons, who had access to both the boiler room and the vault. Conferring with County Clerk George Carter, custodian of the vault, we were advised that he had been assisted in the vault on the day of the theft by Mason and Wilbur Sexton, two brothers, aged twenty-one and nineteen respectively. They were fairly well known to the police, their most recent introduction having been gained through a brawl on New Year's Eve, in which there was supposedly a display and the use of knives, resulting in their arrest. After being confined several days, the grand jury, then in session, investigated their case and returned a "not a true bill." Instead of accepting release, however, the brothers remained at the courthouse, and roomed and boarded at the county jail. They were soon known to be circulating literature and ambitiously soliciting new members for the Good Government Congress. There had been considerable comment as to why the Sextons had been kept around the courthouse--perhaps for just such a thing as the ballot theft. In any event, we resolved to find out. Chief McCredie spotted Mason Sexton mingling with crowds in the courthouse. Maneuvering into the right position, the Chief's keen eyes quickly appraised Sexton's pants. He was wearing a pair of the same material as the fragment of cloth found on the window frame--and they were torn in the right leg. Following Sexton around the building, the Chief finally found an opportunity to arrest him and get him to the city jail without being seen. The arrest was handled in this manner, as we did not wish to reveal the trend of our investigation. An hour or so later, his brother, Wilbur, was similarly taken into custody by Captain Bown and myself. When Mason was brought into my office for examination, not a word was spoken as I removed the fragment of cloth from an envelope, matched it to his pants, clipped another small piece from, the trousers and subjected both to microscopical comparison end examination. The cloth was identical. Sexton paled as he watched these proceedings in the ominous silence that prevailed in the room. He knew he was doomed--doomed by a small shred of cloth. But it was not Sexton that we wanted. To send him to prison and leave the leaders free to continue their march of destruction would be accomplishing exactly nothing. For four days and nights, Mason and Wilbur were questioned by Captain Bown, Chief McCredie, Deputy District Attorney Neilson and myself. They were hopelessly trapped, they realized, but as to the leaders, they would not utter one word. When the conversation and questioning drifted into those channels, they would merely "clam up." It was obvious that they felt secure in the thought that they were backed by the strongest influences in the county, and that it would be only a matter of a day or so until they would be out again and free--if they just stayed "right guys." This much they practically admitted. However, as time wore on and no help was forthcoming, they began to wonder. Finally, in the early hours of the morning of the fourth day, Mason, tired, worn out and fighting mad at not being rescued by his cohorts, jumped from his chair and shouted, "I'll talk and talk plenty." We all breathed a sigh of relief, for at last we were going to get the whole story. The confessions of Mason and Wilbur Sexton consisted of fourteen full legal-size, single-spaced typewritten sheets, and contained revelations that left us stunned and shocked. The audacity and brazenness of the perpetrators of the bold theft was beyond comprehension. In their confessions, the brothers told how they had been given permission by Judge Fehl and Sheriff Schermerhorn to live at the jail. In return, they were to obtain new members for the Good Government Congress, etc., as related earlier in this story. Referring to the night of the ballot theft, they told of coming out of the courthouse auditorium, where a meeting of the Congress was being called to order, and encountering in front of the vault a group in serious conversation. In this group were County Judge Fehl; Chief County Jailer John Glenn; Deputy Sheriff Charles Davis; Walter Jones, Mayor of Rogue River and County Road Supervisor; C. J. Conner, Vice President of the Congress; Thomas Brecheen, Ashland ward leader, bond broker and claimant of seven years service in the United States Secret Service; and Milton Sexton, the youths' father, who was merely standing by as a listener. They were asked by Brecheen to join the men. Then, in the presence of the others and without any further ceremony, he bluntly asked them whether they knew the combination to the vault. When they replied they did not, he questioned them about the possibility of getting in through the rear window. They explained the setup inside, stating that there was a collapsible steel shutter inside the window which was not in use at the present time. Judge Fehl, after questioning them to determine whether they were positive in this respect, left to attend the meeting. The boys went on to relate that after the judge left, the rest of the group--with the exception of their father, who took no part in the conversation, and Chief Jailer Glenn, who had to return to his office--went to the boiler room and obtained a crowbar. Deputy Sheriff Davis then tried to pry the window open with the crowbar but found he could not budge it. They then returned to the boiler room and obtained a huge monkey wrench. Mayor Jones smashed the glass in the window, reached in and unfastened the latch. The window open, the rest of the mob swarmed into the vault and began hauling out ballot pouches. There were, the brothers estimated, about twelve or fourteen men engaged in the actual theft. Others were standing guard, armed with pieces of gas pipe, clubs, pistols, etc., in case any state or city police should happen on the scene. Some of the pouches were loaded into a Ford delivery wagon, owned and driven by E. A. Fleming, an active Congress member; others were put in a Willys Knight roadster, owned and driven by Arthur LaDieu, business manager of the Medford Daily News; and more yet were thrown in a Ford coupé, the identity of the owner not being known to the Sextons. In addition to those mentioned earlier as participating in the original plans to rob the vault, they were able to identify Wesley McKitrick, James D. Gaddy, R. C. Cummings, Earl Bryant and C. J. Conner, all active in the Congress, as having taken part in the bold theft. After the cars were loaded, the boys got in with the driver of the Ford coupé and drove out to the Bybee Bridge, which crosses the Rogue River. When they were pulling away from the courthouse with their load of pouches, they passed the Sheriff standing in the shadows of the trees on the back street where he had been watching the theft. As they passed him, he raised his hand in a signal of greeting. After dumping their load of pouches in the river, they returned to Medford and found that the mass meeting was over and everything quiet. Brecheen, however, was still loafing around, and, upon meeting them, he told them there had not been enough pouches stolen and instructed them to go back into the vault and take out fifteen or twenty more. He would go to the Medford Daily News office and get a car to haul them away. The brothers took out what they estimated to be about twenty pouches and carried them into the boiler room to await the coming of the car. After waiting nearly an hour, they became nervous and decided to burn the pouches in the fireboxes. They cut the tops off the bags and hid them behind a door, intending to dispose of them the next day. The sacks and their contents they burned. Finishing this, they returned to the jail and went to bed. The following morning, after the theft had been discovered, they met the Sheriff on the third floor of the courthouse and asked him what would be done about the recount now that the ballots were stolen. His reply was, "You fellows keep your mouths shut about the recount and the ballots being stolen. Don't say a word to anyone, not even to your own mother. If you do, you'll find yourself in serious trouble." When the confessions were completed, we realized for the first time what a deplorable mess the county had got into, and the magnitude of the situation that faced us. The Sheriff--the highest officer of the county--a County Judge and a Mayor were involved in the robbing of the building it was their sworn duty to protect. Surely, a lower and more despicable lot of public officials could not be found anywhere. Continuing our investigation, we located the crowbar used by Deputy Sheriff Davis in his attempt to pry open the vault window. We found that the prying edge fitted the marks on the windows to perfection. The monkey wrench, also recovered, was found, under microscopical examination, to contain flecks of aluminum paint and pulverized bits of glass. Sergeant E. E. Walker of the Game Division of the State Police, accompanied by Officers Roach, Malcolm and Levya, succeeded in retrieving four of the stolen pouches from the Rogue River. All this provided corroboration for Mason's and Wilbur's confession, and our case was beginning to shape up. District Attorney Codding immediately went before Justice of the Peace Coleman and obtained warrants of arrest, charging all the known participants in the brazen theft and five "John Does" with burglary. The stage was now set for the most sensational roundup in Oregon's police history. On the morning of February 25th, just four days after the crime, a group of picked and determined officers gathered at State Police Headquarters. Warrants were distributed, and we were told not to come back until we had got our men. But the arrests were to be made quietly and kept strictly secret until we were ready to announce our move to the public. This also had its psychological effect? on the prisoners, for several, languishing alone in cells, did not know that any of the others had been picked up and consequently believed that they had been singled out and "stooled" on by their former allies. The Sheriff had been lured to my office and arrested. by the Coroner, since no officer excepting the Governor or a Coroner has the power to arrest a Sheriff. Deputies were also lured to my office and the city police station on various pretexts, and, upon arrival, were served with a warrant. So quietly did we work, that no news of the arrests leaked out until the following morning, and by that time we had accounted for all except Judge Fehl, who, in some manner, had been tipped off and fled. We had one other regret. Dictator Banks, the most dangerous of the lot, was still free and at liberty. We had hopes that after the arrests, we might persuade some of the prisoners to talk and give us enough evidence to obtain a warrant for his arrest. But the farther we went, the more apparent it became that he had been his usual cagey self and had covered his tracks well. When the news of the roundup finally broke, it was blazoned across the front pages of every paper throughout the state. Meanwhile, other things had been happening fast and furious, and the events of the day left the people dizzy and reeling. Their Sheriff, chief jailer, a Mayor and others equally as prominent, were all under arrest. The Dictator, suddenly taken aback by this move on our part, was fighting desperately to hold his mob together. Gangs of them were gathering everywhere. There were fights, sluggings, threats and every known form of violence throughout the county. Sirens were screaming continually as heavily armed officers rushed out every few minutes to quell some new uprising. The city jail was fast filling. Leonard Hall. editor and publisher of another local newspaper which had been fighting the "Congress" to the limit and relentlessly exposing the true purpose and intent of this organization, was seized, in the center of the business district during the busiest part of the day, by C. H. Brown, the secretary of the Congress, and L. O. Van Wegen, an organizer. They pinioned his arms around a post and held him while Henrietta Martin, the puppet president, proceeded to lash him furiously across the face with a horsewhip. He was rescued by State Police Lieutenant Dunn and a squad of officers, and Henrietta and her two cohorts were clamped in jail. On the morning of February 27th, we were tipped off that Judge Fehl was back on the bench "meting out justice." Our informants went on to advise us, however, that the Judge had no intention of submitting to arrest. He was surrounded by a mob of his followers, we were told, and if need be, would declare his court in session continually. Then if we tried to serve him with a warrant, he would order deputy sheriffs to arrest us for contempt of court. This was another new one on us in the never-ending succession of surprises. District Attorney Codding was hastily summoned and advised of this new and baffling situation. He finally decided, however, that inasmuch as we were now armed with a warrant from another court ordering us to arrest the Judge, we would be in contempt of that court if we failed to carry out its order. It seemed we were in for it either way. Finally, City Officer Prescott, a veteran of over thirty years service and beloved by all who knew him, and myself, decided that we would serve the warrant on the Judge if we had to turn a fire hose on the mob. We further decided that no deputy sheriffs were going to arrest us until we had completed our mission, at least. Certain that if once we got through the crowd to the Judge we'd bring him out, we loaded our pockets with tear gas bombs and left for the courthouse. As we ascended the stairs, we could see the mob overflowing from the Judge's chambers far into the hall. We were met with scowls and threats, but we realized that to hesitate one moment would start trouble. Not so much as slowing our pace, we began shouldering our way through, and, in a few minutes, we were standing before "His Honor." The warrant was quickly read to him, and he was placed under arrest. When told to accompany us, he hesitated a moment as though deciding whether or not to give an order. It was a tense moment as every eye in that angry mob was focused on Judge Fehl--waiting. Officer Prescott and I gingerly fingered the gas bombs in our pockets and moved back against the windows. One false move from the crowd and the place would be a sorry mess. Judge Fehl apparently realized as much and finally arose to accompany us, ordering that room be made for our passage. This, I believe, was the first time a County Judge has ever been arrested while he sat on the bench. Judge Fehl posted bail, and, as we were planning our next move, startling information came to us that swung us into speedy action. The Judge was now planning another move that not only piled more surprises onto our already overburdened shoulders, but threatened to destroy everything we had accomplished so far. He was issuing writs of habeas corpus for every prisoner we were holding on the theft. This would compel us to expose every bit of evidence we had so far accumulated. Even this would do no good, for we well knew he would turn them loose regardless. Captain Bown, upon learning of this unprecedented move on the part of the Judge, quickly made up his mind what to do. We bundled all our prisoners into fast police cars, and, within forty minutes, they were safely lodged in a neighboring county jail and out of jurisdiction of Judge Fehl. This move was perfectly legal and was made just in the nick of time. However, the near disaster left us wondering what to expect next. Meanwhile, State Police Detective Sergeants Warren and Lumsden, two of the best interrogators in the entire state, and Deputy District Attorney Neilson, a tireless worker who possessed an uncanny ability to worm a confession out of the hardest of criminals, were questioning Wesley McKitrick, a lieutenant of the Dictator and known to be a member of the inner circle. After hours of grilling, he finally broke, making a nineteen-page confession. We were startled and dumbfounded when he revealed Banks' latest and most diabolical plot. Banks was going to order his Sheriff, who was now out on bail, to select 250 trusted members of the Good Government Congress and appoint them deputy sheriffs without salary. Thus, they could go about legally armed and make arrests. He had already selected an abandoned mining bunkhouse deep in the hills and strategically located to withstand attack. The building was solidly built of heavy logs and was practically impregnable. This was to serve as their jail. Then he was going to announce in his paper that detectives from San Francisco, who had been employed by the Good Government Congress, had been secretly investigating the entire case and startling revelations would be forthcoming. This was to be followed by the dramatic announcement that the entire plot was at last exposed, and that the whole thing was a scheme to overthrow the Congress. Circuit Judge Norton and District Attorney Codding were to be accused of being the leaders and of having had the ballots stolen. Investigating officers of the state and city police were to be accused of being their lieutenants. He would further claim that his detectives possessed sufficient indisputable evidence to more than ensure the conviction of the plotters. At this stage, the mob of deputy sheriffs were to descend on the city and state police offices and arrest every officer they could lay their hands on. Then a favorable backwoods justice of the peace was to act as committing magistrate. The officers would be held in the abandoned mine bunkhouse. In the case of the arrests of District Attorney Codding and Circuit Judge Norton, however, it was to be an entirely different matter. They were to be quietly spirited away into the hills, hanged and their bodies disposed of where they would never be found. He would cover the "disappearance" of the Circuit Judge and District Attorney by crying long and loud in his paper that they had fled to escape prosecution, now that the whole plot was "exposed" and they knew that the detectives possessed concrete evidence against them. According to McKitrick, these plans were in the last stages and were practically complete. As a matter of fact, he had been busy for several days prior to his arrest, selecting members to be deputized. He, himself, was to be a captain of the organization when it was completed. No sooner had McKitrick completed his confession than we immediately began making plans to counteract this bold move. We hoped that we might be in time, but as matters now looked, wholesale bloodshed would be inevitable. For we were certainly not going to stop now and leave the citizens of the state to the mercy of this unlawful and ruthless mob, which would not hesitate to tear the county apart to satisfy the whims of the Dictator who led them around like a flock of sheep. Our first move was to throw a heavy bodyguard around District Attorney Codding and Circuit Judge Norton. Then the District Attorney hastily summoned a grand jury. The members were carefully examined as to whether or not they might have any connections with the so-called Good Government Congress. Thomas J. Bell, Jr., was chosen foreman, and they went into session at once. All the evidence in our possession was presented, and, on March 15th, 1933, they returned thirty-two indictments. All those already arrested in connection with the ballot theft were indicted. In addition, Henrietta Martin and her two cohorts in the public horsewhipping of Editor Hall were indicted--as were many other lesser lights--on charges ranging from riotous and disorderly conduct to criminal syndicalism. And finally the Dictator was reached. He was indicted with the others on burglary charges, as we were now able to show from the various confessions that he not only supervised the original planning to rob the courthouse vault, but also had prepared the alibis for his trusted lieutenants. But this was not all. He was also indicted on several charges of criminal syndicalism, which were more than well founded due to his blasphemous, fiery and threatening speeches and newspaper editorials. Hearing of the indictments, a huge mass meeting of the Congress was called by Banks. The leaders were now fighting with their backs to the wall. The Dictator was shouting encouragement to his followers. It was at this meeting that he roared, "I am ready to lead the field in open revolution." He climaxed his speech by stating that he would kill the first officer who tried to serve him a warrant. This he followed with a blaring front page announcement in his paper which stated, "I will spill the blood of any officer who attempts to cross my threshold with a warrant for my arrest." And, sadly enough, this was no idle threat. On the morning following the return of the indictments, when a cold wind was blowing off the Siskiyou Mountains, we made preparations to arrest the raving agitator, Banks. Detective Sergeants Warren and Lumsden were summoned and instructed to follow in a second police car and arrive at the back door of the Dictator's home at the exact moment City Officer Prescott and myself arrived at the front to serve the warrant. We took these precautions because informants had tipped us off that Banks planned to kill whoever came after him, flee through the rear and escape to a mountain hideout. Then he was going to produce witnesses to prove that we attempted to "assassinate" him, and that he had had to kill in order to save his own life. His theory was "Dead men tell no tales." Just as we were preparing to leave, Prescott asked that I delay the matter long enough to permit him to run home and see his wife for a few minutes. She was bedridden, and a trained nurse was in constant attendance. The trouble and strife during the past months and the threats against the lives of the officers, were more than this kindly, motherly woman could bear. Her shattered nerves finally collapsed and she suffered a complete breakdown. And well that Prescott did spend those precious minutes with his ailing wife, for the endearing words he spoke in that short visit were to be the last he would ever speak to her. As I look back on the whole affair now, I cannot help but feel that he had a very definite premonition. Still he did not hesitate one minute to do his sworn duty. How different from the skulking rats we had been dealing with during the past months. When Prescott returned we left at once for Banks' palatial residence at 1000 West Main Street. It was a silent trip. Somehow we seemed to feel that either or both of us would not be coming back. It was definitely certain that the Dictator would attempt to make good his threats. He had gone too far to back out now, and he certainly had every advantage in his favor. He would be concealed behind the walls of his home and could shoot first. We were at the disadvantage that some officer, somewhere, has to face every day. He must first be baptized with gunfire before he can return it. But, we had a sworn duty to perform, even though it might be at the cost of a life. We saw Detective Sergeants Warren and Lumsden taking their places at the rear as we pulled up in front. We had got through this whole nightmare until now without a shot being fired, or a life being lost, and this was to be the last act. If it could only be concluded like the rest. As we mounted the steps of that gloomy dwelling. I was filled with a strange foreboding. When I knocked at the door, there came a faint noise from within--like that made by some one creeping. Tensely we waited, not knowing at what moment a bullet would come crashing through the door. After perhaps a minute, I knocked at the door again. This time it began to open slowly until it reached the length of the burglar chain. We were somewhat relieved to see Mrs. Banks appear at the small opening. Prescott greeted her. "I am sorry, Mrs. Banks," he said, "but we have a warrant for--" He never finished the sentence, for, at that moment, I saw Banks suddenly appear from behind a colonnade in the dining room with a rifle leveled directly at us. He shouted "all right" to Mrs. Banks, and I cried a warning to, my companion, seized him and started shoving him out of the line of fire. But I was too late. Banks squeezed the trigger, and the mushroom bullet struck Prescott first in the hand and then penetrated his body. The momentum of my body carried us both along the porch, finally falling directly in front of a large bay window. I managed somehow to keep the dying officer's head from striking the floor. As I tried to make him comfortable, he muttered two words, "Tell my--" Those were his last. The gallant officer, who had to give a despicable killer the first break, died with but one thought on his mind--his bedridden wife. At his feet lay the warrant for Banks' arrest--covered with blood. As I got up, I looked through the window just in time to see the grinning killer level his rifle at me. I jumped to my feet and pulled out my service pistol. At that instant, the great Dictator showed his true colors. Armed with a high-powered, accurate-shooting rifle, he had but one chance in a thousand of missing. He was afraid to take that chance against a small pistol, afraid that he might miss and himself feel the fatal impact of a bullet. He would kill, yes, but only from behind a woman's skirts. Upon seeing my pistol, he had jumped back behind the colonnade from which he first appeared to deal death. I walked over to the door, tried the latch, and found it locked again. Peering through another window at the other end of the porch, I still could see no one within. Taking refuge behind a pillar. I made the following, notations in my log book: 10:22--Officer
Prescott killed. Banks shot with rifle from dining room.
The reason
for these notations is obvious. Banks was still inside
heavily armed and, should he succeed in completing his
mission, my log
book
would serve as evidence.10:24--exact time this notation. I am on porch. Meanwhile another scene was being enacted behind Banks' home. Hearing the shot, Warren and Lumsden, with drawn revolvers, crept closer to the back porch. Suddenly a man came bounding through the rear doorway and down the steps. Then, he froze in his tracks as he looked into the barrels of two revolvers in the hands of a pair of grim officers. He was E. A. Fleming, out on bail on the burglary charge, and had been discussing defense plans with Banks at the time we arrived. The two detectives handcuffed him to their car and continued their vigil, guarding the rear door and the garage containing Banks' powerful Cadillac coupé, which was ready for flight. I carefully considered my next move. Banks had killed a man, and we would be fully justified in blasting him out of the stronghold. Reinforcements, however, were needed for this. Knowing of a telephone in the hallway of a nearby apartment house, which I could use and still keep the front of the house under observation, I decided to try and reach it. I got to the phone safely and put in my call to Headquarters. Soon the sirens could be heard, and. in a few moments, the place was completely surrounded by fifteen grim-faced officers armed with submachine guns, rifles and tear gas guns. Banks, now realizing that he was hopelessly trapped, decided upon another move to save his cowardly skin. He phoned Captain Bown--who was just leaving to take command of the siege--and offered to surrender. As we were striving to get the fast-gathering crowd out of the line of fire, the Captain drove up, ordering all officers to stay at a distance and hold the crowd back. Then he ran up the steps of that house of death. Was he entering a trap? We felt none too sure as we watched the door slowly open and saw him enter the gloomy interior. Finally the door opened again and Captain Bown emerged, leading the killer. The latter threw out his chest and assumed his favorite pose for the admiration of his followers. But things had suddenly changed. Instead of his great crowd of followers to cheer and idolize him, he faced an angry, howling mob that suddenly broke through the police ranks yelling for a rope. He was completely overcome with surprise. Hearing the threats to hang him, he was glad to run to the car for the protection of the police, the men he swore to kill and one of whose number lay in death on his front porch. The situation was completely reversed. It now became our duty to protect the despicable killer from the very people we had been attempting to protect from him. As we strove to keep the angry crowd back, Banks was hustled into Captain Bown's car, which did not stop until it reached the Josephine County jail in. the neighboring county. Mrs. Banks was also arrested and hustled off to jail. Then, Detective Sergeants Warren and Lumsden and I began an investigation of the premises. The death weapon was lying on a card table in the dining room with the fired shell ejected and another in the chamber ready to deal death. The rifle proved to be a 30.06 Newton, big game rifle and was loaded with the dreaded soft-nosed bullets. Beside it was another gun, a .44 Smith and Wesson revolver with holster and a completely filled cartridge belt. In a hallway leading to the rear door, we found a suitcase fully packed with outdoor clothing, several boxes of ammunition and another gun, a .38 Colt automatic. This find bore out the information we had previously received as to Banks' plans when his arrest would be attempted. And, he was well equipped to continue his campaign of death. Upon examining his records, we were amazed at the calculating mind of the Dictator. He had planned to get full and complete judicial control of Jackson County, from which he could spread and envelop the entire country in his so-called Good Government Congress, and yet remain immune from prosecution. More worthy of note than the power he was attaining was the accompanying wealth. Each member was assessed the "small sum" of fifty cents per month. With a boasted membership of 15,000 after only a few months, this was a nice little racket, if nothing else. Had he gone no farther in increasing his membership roll, he would have a neat income of $90,000 per year. And the amazing part of this monetary plan was the provision made for its control. No payoffs for him or big salaries to henchmen. He was to have complete supervision and control and the only mention made of expenditure of dues was that the money was to be used as "working capital." Although there is much I am not at liberty to reveal regarding the examination of his records, I am firmly convinced the citizens themselves were financing a movement that, had it been permitted to continue a year or two longer, would have brought disastrous results. Our investigation in the Dictator's stronghold completed, we returned to Headquarters. But so enveloped had we been in the events of the day, we all but forgot the possible aftermath. If we thought things were bad before, we were mistaken. The whole county was in an uproar. Everything pointed to a general uprising. Was this killing going to render nil all our efforts to restore peace and law and order? The situation was fast threatening to get completely out of control, and Captain Bown sent an emergency call to State Police Headquarters at Salem for thirty additional patrolmen. It was a county gone mad. In a few hours, state police officers began converging on Medford from all points. The whole third floor of the city hall was turned into quarters for the coming officers. State Police Sergeant E. E. Houston, speeding to the scene with siren screaming, suddenly saw a car dart out of a side road and directly into the path of the speeding police car. There was a screeching of brakes and the squeal of burning rubber; then a terrific crash. Carlos Masters, a Portland realtor, died from his injuries. He was not the last to die before the case was ended. A man upon whose shoulders rested the entire and final responsibility for bringing to an end this terrifying nightmare, was to one day walk out of the courtroom and never return. One thing we were definitely certain of, however, the Good Government Congress was finished. It was obvious that it was an unlawful organization, dedicated to an unlawful purpose, and its existence would no longer be tolerated in any degree if it took the last officer in the state to effect its end. Patrolmen now lost no time in cracking down on mobs gathering in the streets. Agitators were quickly clamped in jail without warrant, warning or ceremony. We were determined to clean it out to the very core. Sunday, March 20th, Officer Prescott was laid to rest. Heads were bowed in sorrow at the largest and most impressive funeral in the history of the state. Over 6,000 persons were in attendance, not counting those that lined the streets as spectators. The services were held in the State Armory. Legionnaires stood at attention the full length of the aisles all. through the service. The casket was placed on the stage, which was solidly banked with flowers. And covering the entire background of the huge platform was the thing for which this gallant officer had given his life, the American flag. We were now faced with the task of bringing the agents of destruction to trial. Not until such was done would the county be restored to peace, happiness and safety. So much depended on the outcome of these vital trials that District Attorney Codding, not wanting to leave any opening for claims of personal prejudice, appealed to Attorney General I. H. Van Winkle for a Special Prosecutor. After a careful study of his staff, the Attorney General appointed Assistant Attorney General William Levins to prosecute the murder and ballot theft. A more capable choice could not have been made, for Mr. Levins had long been known as one of the most noted prosecutors in the state, with a brilliant record of over twenty years' experience as a District Attorney and Assistant Attorney General. Upon arriving in Medford, he was faced with the seemingly impossible task of acquainting himself with all the facts and preparing the cases for trial in the limited time allowed. He would have hundreds of pages of reports, confessions, etc., to review, but he accepted his task willingly and without complaint. The leaders of the Congress, however, were still resting in perfect security insofar as fear of conviction was concerned. But we had not been idle in the meantime, and they were due for a jolt, a jolt that was to quickly jar them out of their indifferent, confident attitude and push them back against the wall in fear. On April 2nd, Wesley McKitrick, the once destined captain of the 250 armed deputies; C. J. Conner, vice president of the Good Government Congress; R. C. Cummings, its organizer; Deputy Sheriff Davis; Earl Bryant; James D. Gaddy, Mason Sexton and Wilbur Sexton, were all brought before Circuit Judge William Duncan for arraignment on the indictments charging them with the crime of burglary. As each in turn was asked what his plea would be, the answer was the same--guilty. Passing of sentence was withheld pending completion of the remaining trials. This threw the leaders into complete disorder, for the pleas revealed that the prisoners had talked and were no longer co-defendants. Their testimony could now be used to secure convictions. On April 12th, Banks and his wife, Edith, were brought into court for arraignment, and it was a dramatic scene. It was to be the first appearance of the Dictator since the killing. Showman that he was, he entered the courtroom, eyes straight ahead, stopped and stood erect to receive the applause of a courtroom filled with his admirers. But there was no sound from the spectators' seats. Slowly he turned his head and gazed to the rear. There were less than a dozen people in that immense room. The vacant seats stared at him like ghosts from a long forgotten past. His empire had crumpled. Visibly shaken by the absence of his once faithful followers and seeing the chances of a "favorable" jury gone, Banks held a hurried conference with his attorneys. Immediately an application for change of venue was filed. The change was granted and the trial set for May 1st, at Eugene, Oregon, before Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth. The day before the date of the trial, Assistant Attorney General Levins announced that he was ready. By this time, he was plainly showing the strain of working feverishly night and day. He was fully cognizant of the vital responsibilities that were his. Should this scheming killer get free, he would renew his efforts to create a reign of terror. The trial of Banks and his wife, on charges of murder in the first degree, opened promptly at 9:30, May 1st. The defendants were represented by Attorneys Frank Lonergan and Joseph Hammersly, of Portland; W. A. Hardy, of Eugene; and W. E. Phipps and T. J. Enright, of Medford. Judge Sturgeon of Los Angeles was also present in an advisory capacity. The trial promised to be the hardest fought legal battle in the history of the state, for no stronger battery of defense attorneys could be found anywhere. Attorneys Lonergan, Hammersly and Hardy are unquestionably three of the best trial lawyers in the State of Oregon. The state was represented by Assistant Attorney General Levins, assisted by District Attorney Codding, Deputy District Attorney Neilson and Special Deputy District Attorney Ralph Moody. The latter was a valuable asset to the prosecution. He was the son of one of the pioneer governors of Oregon, and, after a brilliant career as an attorney, came to Southern Oregon to retire and enjoy a quiet and peaceful life. Instead, he found himself in the midst of the greatest turmoil it had ever been his experience to witness. Seeing the District Attorney taxed to the limit, he volunteered his assistance, which was accepted with great appreciation. Selection of the jury began. The state was under the unfair disadvantage of only one challenge to the two allowed the defense under Oregon law. Regardless of these and other odds against him, Assistant Attorney General Levins went ahead with his important and vital task. At the end of the first day, five jurors had been chosen. The second day the tedious task of selecting the jurors continued until the noon recess. Court convened again at 1:30, but Assistant Attorney General Levins was missing from his place as head of the Prosecution. Then a state police officer entered and whispered to District Attorney Codding. The District Attorney, visibly shocked, sat stunned and frozen to his chair. A moment later, he arose and walked slowly to the bench and whispered a few words to Circuit Judge Skipworth. The gravity of the situation was plainly noticeable as a strange quiet enveloped the entire courtroom. Judge Skipworth turned slowly to the jurors and bailiffs and instructed that they retire to their quarters. Then he announced court adjourned for the day. Visibly shaken by the loss of a lifelong friend, the Judge retired to his chambers. Assistant Attorney General Levins was dead. Completely exhausted by overwork and worry over the weight of responsibility, he had collapsed after a hurried lunch. He was rushed to the office of a local doctor, but died of heart failure before medical aid could be administered. And thus ended a brilliant career. Another noble life sacrificed in the fight against Dictator Banks. Needless to say, the death of Assistant Attorney General Levins was a severe blow to the Prosecution. The State Attorney General now had charge of the case. The District Attorney could not again assume jurisdiction. Yet the trial had started and must go on. To assign another Assistant Attorney General to the case and expect him to acquaint himself with the mass of evidence within a few hours was out of the question. The bad luck that dogged us from the very start of this bizarre case seemed to have at last won. When everything seemed the blackest and we were discouraged to the point of discarding everything, a long distance call came from the state capital, instructing us to rush Special Deputy District Attorney Moody to the office of Attorney General Van Winkle. A fast state police car carried him the eighty miles in as many minutes. Three hours later he was back in Eugene, and in his pocket he carried his new commission as Assistant Attorney General for the State of Oregon. Upon being informed of this move by the astute Attorney General, everyone concerned with the Prosecution took on a new spirit of hopefulness. Although he was in no way prepared to try the case himself, Mr. Moody knew all the facts. He spent the entire night going over the files of the late Mr. Levins, and, by morning, the new Assistant Attorney General announced he was ready to proceed. The jury was not informed of the death of Mr. Levins, and, although visibly curious as to what had happened, they continued without this knowledge until the trial was over. A parade of witnesses marched to the stand and told of the innermost secrets of the Good Government Congress, the threats against the lives of the officers, the plans to develop a new form of government--in fact, everything that has heretofore been explained to the reader. I was the last witness to testify for the State. I spent a day and a half on the stand under direct and cross examination, and my testimony covered everything as related earlier in this story. Assistant Attorney General Moody brought my testimony to a dramatic finale by handing me a stained document and asking me to tell the jury what it was. My answer was: "That is the warrant for Mr. Banks' arrest which Officer Prescott and I were attempting to serve." Mr. Moody then asked what was the red substance with which the document was coated. To this I replied, "The blood of the dead officer, George Prescott." The state's case was complete in every detail. Premeditation was definitely established. We could see no possible defense. As Attorney Hammersly, who made the opening statement to the jury in behalf of the defendants, got into his speech, we began to see what the defense would be. Banks was going to use the same tactics he had used throughout his career in Jackson County. He was going to try and convert the jury to his principles and claim that due to his "fight for the cause of the people," the moneyed men had conspired against him and made plans to silence him by taking his life. Through knowledge of this, he was driven by indescribable fear to take the life of an officer in order to save his own. This mode of defense caused no little amount of consternation to the Prosecution. And why shouldn't it? Banks had successfully swayed thousands in this manner, a much greater task than that of convincing "twelve good men and true." Assistant Attorney General Moody centered his attack on Banks himself. In his closing arguments, he pictured him as a despicable killer, hiding behind the skirts of a woman to take the life of a gallant officer as he performed his sworn duty; an officer who left behind a broken, bedridden wife, who no longer could listen for his footsteps or have his kindly care. The trial was the most bitterly fought on record and ended May 20th, just one day short of three weeks. The jury retired to deliberate and I returned to Medford to await the verdict. As the hours passed and no verdict was forthcoming, Assistant Attorney General Moody and all the rest of us were becoming visibly worried. Saturday passed and Sunday dawned with still no verdict. Was this despicable killer, in spite of a preponderance of evidence, going to escape and again be turned loose on the people to continue his plundering and wrecking? At two o'clock Sunday afternoon, my phone rang. Eagerly I lifted the receiver and listened tensely as I was told the jury had reached a verdict. Mrs. Banks was acquitted as an accomplice. But the Dictator was found guilty of first degree murder with a recommendation of life imprisonment. From this there could be no escape--no parole. The following days saw speedy trials for those held for burglary of the courthouse vault. Defense attorneys fought long and bitterly to secure the freedom of their clients, but the mass of evidence now accumulated was too great. John Glenn was the only one to escape conviction when a jury on the Fourth of July, after being cooped up in the small jury room for two days and nights, found him not guilty. The rest were all found guilty, and the convictions automatically stripped them of their official status. Came the day of sentencing. Davis, Conner, Cummings, Bryant, Caddy and Mason and Wilbur Sexton, all received suspended sentences in view of their assistance to the State. McKitrick, however, although he turned state's evidence, had a past record that could not be overlooked by the Court, and he was sentenced to two years in the Oregon State Penitentiary. Arthur LaDieu, Banks' former business manager, received a similar sentence. All those indicted on the criminal syndicalism and riotous and disorderly conduct charges were handled by the District Attorney's office and dealt with accordingly. Some received prison sentences and others were put on probation. Then came the ringleaders of one of the most diabolical plots on record. Once defiant, brazen and drunk with power, today they stood alone at the end of the road, the ultimate end of all criminals--alone and beaten before the bar of justice they once so openly mocked. Thomas Brecheen, ex-Mayor Jones, ex-Sheriff Schermerhorn and ex-County Judge Fehl were all sentenced to spend the next four years behind the cold, gray walls of the Oregon State Penitentiary. On August 14th, after exhausting every effort to obtain a new trial, the once great Dictator heard the massive gates of the penitentiary close behind him, shutting him off from the outside world and the country that, in his greed for wealth and power, he sought to wreck and plunder. A very befitting end for one who left nothing in his wake but ruin and sorrow. And silenced forever was that organ of hatred and distrust, the Medford Daily News. Back in Jackson County, when it was all over, a strange lull and quiet prevailed as the people once again breathed the air of a free and peaceful land. Near the beautiful city park in Medford where happy people stroll once again, stands a grim reminder, the monument erected in memory of Officer George Prescott. A lasting tribute to a gallant officer who, knowing that he was going to face a blast of death, did not hesitate for one moment to do his duty. True Detective, February 1940, pages 44-102 -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- -
A Peculiar Slant
The writer was somewhat amused with the
text matter
in a column headed "Once in a While" and published by the owner of the Medford Daily News
upon his first page. In this column he asks that all hypocrites stand
up and be counted and vote against him at the fall election, at which
time he will be an independent candidate for the U.S. Senate as an
opponent to Senator McNary.Banks' "Once in a While" Column Contains Many Amusing Chapters In the course of the rambling editorial the writer dealt with everything from the Gold Hill dances and the conditions which he claims to have existed during a celebration in Medford to the gossip of the streets such as he might hear in any town in the United States. He states that America is suffering from a lack of respect of law and order such as it has never suffered before, and we are yet at a loss to decide whether he attributes this to the fact that he is not now Senator or to the fact that the 18th amendment needs repealing. He tells of many cases of drunkenness and disorderly conduct having been publicly flaunted in the city of Medford although his entire story is merely a series of aspersions and insinuations, written no doubt to lead the readers to the belief that some U.S. Senator had been drunk in Medford for several days to the extent that he could not properly conduct himself. We believe that the Medford writer is doing a great injustice to his city, its organizations and the public men who serve this state by merely dealing in generalities when discussing such items of scandal as he took occasion to fill his first-page editorial with. He charges that while a bootlegger was being arrested near that city that whiskey by the gallon was being dispensed by the leading public institution of that city. What is that institution? Is it the public library, the Chamber of Commerce, the Elks Club, the Methodist or some other church? Why didn't the Medford writer tell the whole story? Why did he leave so much to guess at? Is he afraid of the truth, or is his article composed of rumors and misstatements? Does not the text of the Medford writer's story incline one to believe that he too must stand up and be counted. Not content to revile the morals of the county seat, his home, Banks took occasion to tell of things he claims to have seen along the road between Portland, and evidently the nearer he got to Medford the worse the morals of the commonwealth seems to have gotten. He tells of finding three dances in progress, although he mentions only the location of two, and of cars parked along the highway. He relates having seen a young man supporting a very sick young woman who was endeavoring to relieve her system of the wicked bootleg whiskey her companion had given her. That piece of news might be refreshing. How does Mr. Banks know that the young lady had been drinking bootleg whiskey? Young ladies, we understand, get ill from other things than drinking bootleg whiskey, even in Gold Hill. Then, too, how does Mr. Banks know that the young ladies' companion furnished the bootleg, if that was what she had been drinking? And if he knew it was her companion who had furnished the liquor and that it was liquor that she had been drinking and in turn had made her sick why did he not do his duty as a citizen of the United States and of the state which he is asking support to be elected to the U.S. Senate, and have that companion answer for his crime? In all the vices that Mr. Banks tells of in his articles, we fail to find where he has at any time turned a hand to do other than criticize. Mr. Banks states that he is in favor of the repeal of the 18th amendment, but he fails to give a workable plan for handling the situation once the law is repealed. Does he contend that if it were made easy to obtain whiskey that the people would snub it because it is too common? If he does, we feel that he has another thought coming. Times have changed and so have moral persuasions since the days of the saloon and the passing of the 18th amendment. In those good old days even the young lady who might have been considered a trifle loose did not dance with young fellows who had been drinking, and now Mr. Banks says that an honest young lady is ostracized if she does not partake of the stuff. We size up Mr. Banks' article as a typical piece of political balderdash intended to poison the minds of his readers against his competitor in the race for the U.S. Senate. It borders too closely upon mud-slinging, and we have always noticed that in political fracases the one who sings the mud is usually doing so because he has a weak foundation upon which to stand. Central Point Star, August 8, 1930, page 2 MORE BRAINS AND LESS BLOOEY
After reading some of the editorial outbursts of Mr. Llewellyn Banks,
independent candidate for Senator, we do not know whether he wants to
go to the Senate in order to reform it or to get in on some of the easy
"swag" which he seems to feel is floating about the antechambers of our
legislative and administrative assemblies. After reading over Mr.
Banks' platform we cannot see where he has offered the public anything
to get excited about. True enough he suggests the repeal of the
Eighteenth Amendment and the farm relief measure and the tariff
measure, but what good has that done the public. We were in that
position a few months ago and things were not right then. What the
voters of this country want is men with ability to handle great
problems. What has Mr. Banks to offer. Suppose we repeal the Eighteenth
Amendment. Then we may have the open saloon; a fine cartoon that would
make of life's picture. If the farm relief act were repealed what would
he substitute which would do any good for the farmer. How would Mr.
Banks handle the farmer's problem. That ought to be easy for him; for
is he not a successful farmer? Why don't he let the public know how he
intends to meet these problems. If he can give the people a workable
method of handling the ills of the social fabric of this nation, we do
not believe he would have any difficulty in getting votes.He states that he believes this country has gone to hell. If this is hell we are living in today, it is hard to get any farther regardless of conduct, so why worry any more about it. He says he wants to help the nation out of perdition through the establishment of righteousness in government. But what is Mr. Banks' idea of righteousness in government? Does he think that a saloon on every corner would help? Does he believe that free advent of foreign produce and articles of manufacture into this country would be conducive of good times and high prices. Does he think that turning the farmer loose to individually work out the battle of supply and demand and the proper marketing of their produce is the way to bring to the farmer their independence? These things have all been tried and have been found wanting. Mr. Banks, before he derides and vilifies our present officials for their mismanagement of affairs, should work out a plan of his own for meeting the problems which face the nation and let the voters know how he would have them solved. The destructive type of criticism which he unloads upon the public is not the kind of reading the thinking man wants to read. More brains and less blooey is what the people want. C. J. Shorb, editor, Gold Hill News, September 11, 1930, page 2 IMPRESSIONS AND OBSERVATIONS
Llewellyn A. Banks and I sat down
together in his
office at Medford recently and in answer to my questions he said:OF THE JOURNAL MAN By Fred Lockley "Yes, I am an independent candidate for United States Senator. You are not the political editor of the Journal, so I do not suppose you would be interested in my views along political lines. "I was born at Catawba, Ohio, August 15, 1870. My father comes of Puritan stock, being a descendant of John and Priscilla Alden. My mother's maiden name was Laura Ann Moore. My father was Scotch-Irish and my mother was of French descent. When I was a boy my ambition was to be a school teacher, but after graduating from high school I had to go to work, so I went to Cleveland and landed a job as traveling salesman for a firm that handled fruit. My job was to sell oranges, lemons, bananas and other fruit to retail grocers. After three years on the road I landed a job at the age of 20 as traveling salesman selling goods to wholesale grocers in Ohio, New York state, Indiana, Michigan and Pennsylvania. "You ask why I did not go to college and become a teacher, as I had planned. The reason is not far to seek. There were nine children in our family, and as my father was an orchardist we were as poor as Job's turkey. Father used to pack his peaches and ship them on the boat to Cleveland or Detroit, and the checks were pitifully small when the expenses had been paid. When I was 20 and went on the road selling groceries wholesale I went back to Catawba, Iowa, and established the first cash market for fresh fruit that they had there. When I was 22 years old I got married, quit the road and went into the wholesale fruit business at Cleveland. Today I own 736 acres of good orchard at Medford and 300 acres at Riverside, Cal. In 1923 I was farming 1700 acres of orchard. In California I not only grew fruit, but had a large packing plant for citrus and deciduous fruit. I could talk to you for an hour about the farm relief act and some of the reforms the farmer needs in legislation so there would be no need of farm relief, but I know neither you nor I have the time to go into the question." Oregon Journal, Portland, October 5, 1930, page 10 Typographical Error Corrected.
To the Editor:In reading your editorial "Mayor Walker Muffs a Great Chance," I seem to stumble and wonder whether my memory has failed to serve me in recalling one of the greatest episodes in the greatest drama of the world's history. In the first paragraph of your editorial you refer to Napoleon's defeat at Waterloo, and fix the responsibility on the lateness of Blucher's arriving on the scene. I am not taking the time to refer back to the pages of history, but merely trusting my memory, which is frequently at fault, but as I recall this great event the great English general, the Duke of Wellington, was standing on the battlefield at Waterloo with his watch in his hand, and if I recall correctly, it was 3 o'clock in the afternoon when Wellington remarked, "Blucher or night." Either Blucher had to come up or darkness had to set in, otherwise Wellington would have been defeated--Napoleon would have been victorious and the history of the then known world would have been changed, but Blucher did come up, scattering Napoleon's forces to the four winds, and before nightfall the great Napoleon had given his last command when he cried out, "Save himself who can." If I am correct, this recalls another situation frequently overlooked or forgotten, viz: That in the previous great world war, the English and the Germans were powerful allies, fighting against the French--Blucher a German general; whereas, in the last world war, the French and English were powerful allies fighting against the Germans. If I am mistaken, I will be glad to have you correct me. LLEWELLYN A. BANKS.
Ed. Note.--Mr. Banks is correct. The error in Friday's editorial was
corrected in an editorial Sunday morning--it was the tardiness of
Grouchy, not Blucher, which resulted in Napoleon's defeat."Communications," Medford Mail Tribune, April 7, 1931, page 5 MORNING PAPER HAS DIFFICULTY WITH
PRINTERS
Publication of the Daily News,
morning newspaper, was delayed today, due to a "lockout" of union
printers last night and a breakdown of the press this morning, when the
edition was ready to print.Union Men Locked Out and Morning Issue Delayed-- Open Shop Ultimatum Brings Quick Climax. It was expected to have the regular edition issued early this afternoon. The controversy with the printers has been underway since last Saturday when notices were posted that after September 1 the paper would be operated on an "open shop" basis, with a wage scale of $35 per week. Edward J. Pelkey of Seattle, representative of the International Typographical Union; James C. Murray, president of the local union, and L. A. Banks, publisher, had several conferences the past week, seeking an adjustment. Statement by Banks.
Publisher Banks this morning issued the
following statement:"Notices were posted August 15 in the back shop of the Medford Daily News, declaring that on and after September 1st the News would operate an 'open shop.' "A wage scale of $35 per week, to be effective after September 1st, was also posted. "A conference between Mr. Ed J. Pelkey, representative of the International Typographical Union, and the publisher of the Medford Daily News was held Thursday afternoon--resulting in Mr. Pelkey demanding a 'walkout' on the spot. "Local help was obtained to publish the Medford Daily News this morning, but upon starting the press it was found that it had been 'jimmied'--one of the rollers having been put out of order by a broken casting. "The latter has been repaired, and if nothing else develops, the News will be published before noon today. "The wage scale posted by the News is the same as is being paid in 59 cities throughout the United States, having an average population of 19,849. "All former employees in the back shop were permitted to remain on the News at the new wage scale, but refused to do so upon orders from Mr. Pelkey." Union Statement.
James C. Murray, president of the
Medford Typographical Union, issued a statement as follows:"Six journeymen printers and one apprentice were locked out of the Medford Daily News on Thursday, August 20. "This was the culmination of the declaration of the publisher, during the past year, that he intended to establish his paper on the so-called 'open shop' basis. The union printers were recently given notice that they must notify the publisher whether they desired to remain, and accept a $13 per week wage cut. Very naturally they rejected this proposal. "The wage reduction sought would have placed the Medford printers on the lowest wage scale of any of the 51 local unions in the Northwest, and below the wages prevailing in the industry in the United States and Canada. "Aside from the wage reduction, the 'open shop' demand meant that the union printers must sever their union connections, and sacrifice all old age pension, mortuary benefits and entrance to the printers' home for the aged and sick. "Every one of the News' former employees has families; most of them are home-owners. "At the request of the management, for the past six months these employees have been accepting 30 percent of their wages in due bills, and using their savings to live, with the understanding they would be paid September 1, with continued employment at the accepted wage." Medford Mail Tribune, August 21, 1931, page 1 LOCAL
PRINTERS ASK SHOWDOWN ON 'JIM' CHARGE
DASTARDS.
Report comes to the Daily News
from a man who is willing to make an affidavit that he was offered $100
to "jim" the machinery in our mechanical department. This is
a fair
sample of the policy being pursued by certain people.----
The above item appeared on the first
page of the Daily News
in its Sunday morning issue, and it is evident that the purport was to
lead its readers to believe that "certain people" were members of the
local typographical union, as it is the latest organization in Medford
which the News
is trying to disrupt.When officials of the local union interviewed L. A. Banks regarding the above item and wished to learn if the statement applied to the typographical union, Mr. Banks stated that the man who claimed he had been offered $100 to "jim" the machinery was intoxicated and that he placed no reliance in the truthfulness of the statement and would publish in the following issue a retraction or at least a modification in which the union would be exonerated. To date the News has not made the retraction, though the lying story was broadcast the length of the Pacific Slope. The man whom Banks described as the person who allegedly had been approached to "jim'' the News machinery is believed to be in the county jail on another charge, and an effort was made to have Mr. Banks go with the local union officials and identify the man, but so far he has declined to answer the phone andassist in the identification. This story adds one more myth to the inexhaustible number that the News claims are secretly attempting to undermine and ruin that publication. The story of the News controversy with the typographical union can be told in a nutshell. About the 15th of this month the News posted a notice in the composing room that after September 1st the wages would be $35 per week instead of $48, and that the union would not be recognized. All employees who intended to remain were requested to answer by August 20. E. J. Pelkey, international I.T.U. representative, was called to Medford and together with officials of the local union held a conference with L. A. Banks, who admitted he had no grievance with the local organization but wished to operate his composing room on a much cheaper basis, declining to consider any other attitude than the one he had taken. Mr. Pelkey suggested that as no satisfactory agreement could be reached and as the local printers were to be locked out September 1, that it would be best for all concerned to have the lookout effective instanter, which Mr. Banks indicated was satisfactory to him. As the lockout became effective immediately, no former union employees have been in the composing or press room since that date, so any intimations that machinery had been tampered with by the union workers is a silly, unfounded assertion. If the machinery has gone haywire it is chargeable to the incompetent and inexperienced workmen who succeeded the local printers. L. A. Banks had never intimated that the scale of wages was too high, but about seven months ago asked the employees to accept 30 percent of their salaries for the following six months in due bills payable September 1st. To this the employees agreed, and those who are locked out today are carrying from $300 to nearly $500 due bills in their pockets, patiently waiting for September 1st to arrive, hoping that then they will realize upon the sacrifices they made to assist their employer. The union's contention is that the scale of wages here is on a par with the scales throughout the United States and Canada, that experienced and trained union workmen at $48 per week will conduct the composing room as cheaply, if not cheaper, than a bunch of printing students can at $35 per week salary, and though Mr. Banks may never confess and the public will never know, the local union believes that the Daily News operating expenses are just beginning to soar. The News considers that $35 per week is sufficient salary for a craftsman who sacrificed five years of his life in serving an apprenticeship, but Mr. Banks boasts that he pays 28 fruit packers $44.25 per week, and it is asserted that the art of packing can be learned in two weeks tuition (Signed)
Medford, August 28. (Paid adv.)MEDFORD TYPOGRAPHICAL UNION. A. F. STENNETT, Secretary J. C. MURRAY, President Medford Mail Tribune, August 25, 1931, page 6 WILL ASK BANKS GIVE GRAND JURY EVIDENCE--IF ANY
District Attorney George A. Codding said this afternoon that a subpoena
had been issued out of his office calling upon L. A. Banks, newspaper
publisher, to appear before the grand jury which re-convenes tomorrow
morning to present any and all evidence he may possess relative to
alleged corruption in city and county affairs, miscarriages of justice,
and other charges hurled in the past year. The newspaper publisher will
be requested to present evidence upon which accusations have been made
or sponsored by him.District Attorney Plans Subpoena for Publisher of Accusations Against City and County Officials The subpoena was placed in the hands of Sheriff Jennings for service. During the past several months, a barrage of accusations has been hurled at county and city officials, particularly the district attorney, attacking his honesty, integrity and conduct of his office. The sponsor of the charges, in appearing before the grand jury, will afford that impartial body an opportunity to study and weigh the truth or falsity of the allegations and if the evidence justifies indictments, to return them. Josiah Hibbard of Butte Falls is foreman of the grand jury. The other members are Mrs. Anna Carley of Medford; Leo B. Williams, Medford; Howard A. Hill, Medford; Irving Porter, Ashland; William Barber, Ashland and Reed Charley, Brownsboro. It is doubtful if the Reese Creek still raid, during which Everett Dahack was killed, will be re-investigated, as a regular grand jury, a special grand jury, with a special prosecutor named by the governor, and special investigators, working secretly and named by the governor, have made a thorough inquiry into the case without definite action. It was also a factor in the Fehl-Parr libel suit and the last primary campaign. Calling of the petit jury is doubtful, owing to the docket being practically cleared. It was thought the petit jury would be called for next Monday, but unless there is an increase of cases this will not be done. Circuit Judge H. D. Norton will leave Thursday for Eugene, where Friday and Saturday he will hear a case in the Lane County circuit court. Medford Mail Tribune, May 31, 1932, page 1 BASIS OF BANKS' CHARGES ASKED BY GRAND JURY
Appearance of L. A. Banks before the grand jury was delayed this
afternoon by finishing other matters before the body. Banks reported at
1:30 o'clock and was excused until further notice, which will probably
be late this afternoon.Publisher Scheduled for Appearance Before Inquisitorial Body This Afternoon--Labor Nears End ----
L. A. Banks, newspaper publisher of this city, was scheduled to appear
before the grand jury when it met at 1:30 today for the afternoon
session, to present any evidence he may possess on his published
charges of alleged "miscarriage of justice," corruption in city and
county affairs, "whitewashing of the coroner's jury" in the Reese Creek
still raid, in which Everett Dahack was slain, and any other evidence
of alleged illegalities or wrongdoing in local government affairs.District Attorney George A. Codding said this morning that Banks would be requested to present "fully and freely, upon the entire field of his allegations, including charges pertaining to the Dahack matter." Transcripts Available
Transcripts of the testimony before the regular grand jury, the special
grand jury conducted by a special prosecutor named by the governor, and
the coroner's jury in the Dahack case, will be available. Banks charged
Monday that the coroner's jury was a "whitewash" and that Ted Goetchen,
Lee Smith and Raleigh Matthews of the Eagle Point district, found
guilty of operating the Reese Creek still, were denied the right to
testify.District Attorney Codding stated that the transcript would show that Smith and Goetchen were brought from the county jail to the coroner's jury and when called upon to testify refused, "I think, upon the advice of their attorneys." Matthews was at liberty on bonds at the time of the coroner's jury. Testimony Invited
District Attorney Codding further stated that at the conclusion of the
coroner's inquest, a request was made that anyone present "who knew
anything about the affair" come forward and testify.It is expected that Banks will be before the grand jury most of the afternoon and that the grand jury will conclude its present labors tomorrow noon. The morning session of the grand jury was devoted to hearing testimony in minor cases. Medford Mail Tribune, June 1, 1932, page 1 DEFER ARGUMENT ON BANKS MOTION
Due to the pressure of other legal business, hearing of arguments on
the motion to strike certain paragraphs in the complaint of the libel
suit of George W. Neilson, deputy district attorney, against L. A.
Banks, orchardist, will be deferred for a couple of days.Banks, through his attorney, George M. Roberts, seeks to have stricken from the complaint sentences reading, "Law and order have broken down in Jackson County," and "inflaming the lawless element of Jackson County." The phrases were contained in articles entitled "The Two Georges," and others of the same trend. Neilson, in his complaint, denies a series of sensational charges, and claims the printed material impaired his civilian and official standing. He seeks $50,000 on five counts. Medford Mail Tribune, July 20, 1932, page 3 THIRD SUIT FILED AGAINST BANKS IN LIBEL ALLEGATION
Suit was filed in circuit court this afternoon by James Hall of the
Gold Hill district, against the Medford News Publishing Company, L. A.
Banks, its publisher, and F. A. Bates, Gold Hill miner. It is the third
suit to be filed within the past week against the paper, its publisher,
and Bates. The James suit was filed at 2:37 o'clock this afternoon, the
clerk's office said.The latest action is a companion suit to the one filed last week by Bob McManus, a Gold Hill district miner, also for $50,000. James based his suit on an article headlined "Miner Tells of Woe on Foots Creek," and alleges that it was "maliciously false, defaming and scandalous," that it impaired his standing in the community, and that the article "incited and inflamed the lawless element." A copy of the article is presented as "Exhibit A" in the suit. James asks $25,000 general damages and $25,000 punitive damages. Friday, Ted Dole of the Gold Hill district filed a $50,000 suit against the publishing company, Banks, Bates and the latter's daughter alleging "conspiracy." Guy Bates, named in one of the actions, is no relation to F. A. Bates. Medford Mail Tribune, August 15, 1932, page 1 NEWS PUBLISHER FACES 4TH SUIT IN LIBEL SERIES
A suit for $50,000 damages, based on alleged conspiracy on the part of
the Medford News Publishing company, L. A. Banks, orchardist-publisher,
F. A. Bates, aged Gold Hill miner, and his daughter, Mrs. Margaret
Lund, was filed in the circuit court this afternoon at 1:45 o'clock,
with Guy Bates of Gold Hill as the plaintiff. Guy Bates is no relation
to F. A. Bates.Guy Bates alleges in the complaint that the defendants "connived, conspired and colluded to extort money from the plaintiff," and that as part of the conspiracy the newspaper published a report by F. A. Bates, headlined: "Miner Tells Tale of Woe on Foots Creek," "without investigating its truth or falsity," and that the same was "maliciously false and degrading," and "incited and inflamed the lawless element in the neighborhood of where the plaintiff lived." The plaintiff alleges that the article accused him of "robbing sluice boxes" and "dynamiting mine dams," and that blackmail threats were both written and spoken, and alleges further that threats were made against him and his family. The suit today is the fourth to be filed against the newspaper and its editor and L. A. Banks within a week, each for $50,000 general and punitive damages. Mrs. Margaret Lund is named only as a defendant in the two suits alleging conspiracy. The plaintiffs in the other actions are Hal James, Ted Dole and Bob McManus, all miners and residents of the Gold Hill district. Medford Mail Tribune, August 16, 1932, page 1 BANKS TAX DEBT AT ACUTE STAGE
Charges published Saturday that
the filing of a personal tax execution against L. A. Banks, orchardist
and publisher of the Daily News,
last Thursday evening, were taken as "political reprisals" were branded
Saturday by Sheriff Ralph Jennings as "baseless and unjust, not founded
on fact, and the usual line of 'hooey' to arouse sympathy."Sheriff Jennings said that the personal tax execution was filed "when I learned that the mahogany furniture has been moved from Mr. Banks' office and that the water had been shut off. I then served the personal tax attachment to protect the county's interests, keep the records straight, and stop any cry that I had failed in my official duty and thus become liable to grand jury investigation. Mr. Banks is not being 'persecuted.'" The records of the county clerk's office show that two months ago the county court issued an order that all unpaid personal taxes be collected, or action taken. Advised of the action of the county, Banks requested and received from the county court a further extension of time. The matter then rested until the removal of the furniture was reported to the authorities. Sheriff Jennings said the Banks' personal tax "was in the neighborhood of $1200 and was for the last half of 1929, 1930 and 1931." Medford Mail Tribune, November 14, 1932, page 6 NEWS EMPLOYEES ASK RECEIVERSHIP TO GET BACK PAY
A petition seeking the appointments of a receiver for the Medford News
Publishing Company, L. A. Banks, editor, was filed shortly before noon
today in circuit court by H. T. Hubbard, bookkeeper of the concern, and
one of the four employees discharged by Banks yesterday. Hubbard sets
forth in the petition that he is acting in behalf of "himself and other
creditor employees."Hearing on Petition Set for 9:30 A.M. Thursday--Debts Over $26,000, Assets $20,000 Is Assertion Date of the hearing on the receivership plea is set for tomorrow morning at 9:30 o'clock before Circuit Judge Norton. Hubbard and other employees are represented by attorneys Kelly & Kelly, Frank DeSouza and Porter J. Neff. The appointment of a receiver pending the conclusion of the suit and a final decree for a receiver is sought. Owes $6000 Wages
Hubbard sets forth in the petition that the News owes him $450 for services as bookkeeper and that other employees have due and owing in "excess of $6000" for wages.The petition further holds that the appointment of a receiver is necessary "to protect and conserve the assets and discharge the liabilities" of the paper. It is charged that the debts of the publication are in excess of $26,000 with assets of less than $20,000 and that the publishing company is now insolvent. The petition lists as debts of the concern, besides the $6000 assertedly due employees for wages, $6000 in unsecured open accounts, holders of which threaten suit for collection; $10,000 in promissory notes, long overdue, held by the owners, who threaten foreclosure; $2000 due on Linotypes, with suits for collection threatening, and $1068 in unsecured personal taxes of Jackson County for the years 1929, 1930, 1931 and 1932, for which legal action has been taken to collect. The order for the hearing of the petition for a receiver was signed Tuesday by Circuit Judge Norton. Banks, in today's issue, charged "Dastardly Plot by Manager to Wreck News Plant." The present legal action is the culmination of several months of financial difficulty. Medford Mail Tribune, November 16, 1932, page 1 FORMER OWNERS SUING BANKS ON DAILY NEWS DEBT
The News Publishing Company, L. B. Tuttle, president, filed suit in
circuit court this afternoon against the Medford News Publishing Co.
and L. A. Banks for $11,571.79, assertedly due on promissory notes, and
a chattel mortgage, issued in payment for the plant and equipment.The appointment of a receiver for the publication is also sought. The complaint cites that H. T. Hubbard and three other former employees of the morning paper previously filed a petition for a receiver, but the present plaintiff "holds superior rights." The receiver is sought "to take possession of and conserve the resources" of the paper. Foreclosure of the chattel mortgage and execution of judgment is also asked. The complaint recites that on September 15, 1929, L. A. Banks gave six promissory notes for $3,333.33 each in purchase of the newspaper plant, and that only three of these promissory notes were paid. The News Publishing Company was the founder of the News. Ten days ago H.T. Hubbard and three former employees of the News filed a petition for the appointment of a receiver for the News. An affidavit of prejudice was filed by M. O. Wilkins, attorney for L. A. Banks, against Circuit Judge H. D. Norton. Judge James T. Brand of Coos County was assigned by the state supreme court to hear the case. He is scheduled to hear it tomorrow. Medford Mail Tribune, November 30, 1932, page 1 BANKS SETTLES WITH EMPLOYEES ON BACK WAGES
The receivership petition of H. T. Hubbard and three other former employees against the Medford News
and L. A. Banks, editor-publisher, was settled out of court, by
stipulation. Notice to this effect was filed with Judge James T. Brand
of Coos County in circuit court Saturday morning.Terms of the settlement were not contained in the legal documents, but it was said by attorney Porter J. Neff, and one of the former employees, that a "goodly portion" of the wages due had been paid, and that the balance was secured by nine-month notes, signed by Banks and his wife, Mrs. Edith A. Banks. The creditor-employees were represented by attorney Porter J. Neff, and attorney M. O. Wilkins representing the publication and Banks. Demurrer Overruled
The settlement came when arguments on a demurrer to the complaint had
been finished, and the court at the Friday afternoon session overruled
the demurrer. At the morning session attorney Wilkins informed the
court that the publication and Banks were prepared to tender the $450
due Hubbard. At the morning session, Judge Brand sustained the demurrer
on the grounds that the plaintiff had not made the allegations of
insolvency to comply with the law.Proceedings in the receivership plea of the News Publishing Company, Lee B. Tuttle, against the Medford News Publishing Co. for the foreclosure of a chattel mortgage on the equipment and the collection of three promissory notes signed by Banks for $3,333.33 each, will be called Monday morning before Judge Brand. The News Publishing Company was the original founder of the paper, and sold it to Banks. Say Corporation Dead
The plea asks that a receiver be named to conserve the resources and pay obligations.Attorney M. O. Wilkins yesterday afternoon filed a plea in abatement to the action on the grounds that the News Publishing Company had no "corporate life," because of asserted technicalities. The News Publishing Company is represented by attorneys Gus Newbury and E. E. Kelly. In the Hubbard receivership action, attorney Kelly told the court that the action was instituted not to eliminate the News, but to ensure its continuance and safeguard creditors and the publication itself. Friday afternoon Judge Brand heard motions and demurrers in the four libel suits filed against the paper and L. A. Banks, F.A. Bates and his daughter, Mrs. Margaret Lund, by four Foots Creek miners. Medford Mail Tribune, December 4, 1932, page 1 NEWS ATTORNEYS ENTER DEMURRER IN RECEIVERSHIP
Notice of a demurrer to a separate and further reply to the plea for
the abatement in the receivership suit of the News Publishing Company
against L. A. Banks and the Medford News Publishing Company has been
filed in circuit court by attorneys M. O. Wilkins and John Irwin of
Klamath Falls, counsel for the defendants.The defense claims there are no grounds for denying the plea in abatement, and that the paying of the corporation tax after the filing of the receivership suit does not restore the plaintiffs' corporate being. The plaintiffs hold that the failure to pay the corporation tax is a legal infirmity that is removed by tax payments. Judge Lewelling of the Linn County circuit court, named Thursday by the state supreme court to hear the case when the defense filed affidavits of prejudice against Judge James T. Brand of Coos County and Judge H. D. Norton, is now expected to arrive to hear the case at the opening of court Monday. No definite time for the case has been set. Settlement of the second receivership move, in the same manner as the first one, was reported as broached by the defense. A defense attorney informed county officials and friends that $5000 was in a safety deposit box for payment on the approximate $11,000 sought, with promissory notes for the balance. No official public action to this end has yet been instituted. Medford Mail Tribune, December 9, 1932, page 11 BANKS SUED FOR FORECLOSURE OF PAST DUE NOTES
Suit for foreclosure of mortgages on three alleged causes of action
were filed in circuit court this afternoon against Suncrest Orchards,
Inc., Llewellyn A. Banks and Edith R. Banks, by O. B. Waddell, acting
for the Medford National Bank.The first cause of action is on a promissory note for $4500, issued January 23, 1931, and renewed March 18, 1932. The second cause of action is for $2,028.44, on a promissory note issued June 29, 1932. In the first and second causes of action, Llewellyn A. Banks, Edith R. Banks, Suncrest Orchards, Inc., the Peoples Electric Co. and the State Industrial Accident Commission are named as defendants. The Peoples Electric Company claim a lien for material furnished, and the accident commission a judgment for $283.31. In the above causes of action, the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., is offered as security by mortgagee. The third cause of action is based upon a promissory note for $4500, secured by a mortgage on West Main Street property. Medford Mail Tribune, December 20, 1932, page 1 BANKS SUED FOR NON-PAYMENT IN BUYING BUILDING
Suit for strict foreclosure was filed in circuit court Saturday against
Llewellyn A. Banks by T. E. Pottenger and wife and Elmira W. Wilcox for
$15,538.48, possession of the building on West Main Street occupied by
the Medford News and attorney's fee for $1000.The suit is based upon a contract entered into August 28, 1929 between Pottenger and Banks for the purchase of the property at 117 [sic] West Main Street jointly owned by Pottenger and John W. Cox, deceased. The purchase price, the complaint recites, was $28,000. The terms of the sale, the complaint sets forth was $1000, cash in hand, $9000 in 30 days, and $5000, payable on September 28, on each of the next four years. The complaint alleges that Banks was delinquent in his payments for three years, and on May 25 last, Banks agreed to pay all arrearage prior to September 28 on that date. On September 28 last, an agreement was made whereby Banks was to pay $60 on Thursday of each week. The complaint alleges he defaulted in this, too. It is further alleged in the complaint that Banks is delinquent in tax payments, failed to keep up the insurance policies, and that he has allowed the roof to deteriorate, causing the rear of the building to be water-soaked. A strict foreclosure differs from the ordinary foreclosure in that the usual year's exemption is not allowed ere judgment is entered. Pottenger asks that foreclosure be for a limit of 60 days. Attorney W. E. Phipps appears as counsel for the plaintiff. Medford Mail Tribune, December 25, 1932, page 9 PROTEST MOVE FALLS FLAT
As highly exaggerated as many of the other claims made by editor
L. A.
Banks of Medford, the much advertised March-on-the Courthouse scheduled
for today resulted in a scattered group of crusaders numbering probably
200 of the crowd of about 600 that gathered on the courthouse
ground and nearby streets, according to local people who were
at the
county seat today.MARCH OF 3000 PROVES FARCE; BANKS AND FEHL ADDRESS TAME GROUP Instead of the indignation march demanding the resignation of County Attorney Codding and Commissioner Billings, which was to have included 3000 people of the county, a comparative handful gathered and with no organized demonstration, presented petitions bearing 887 names, asking Codding and Nealon to resign. A few of the group yelled derisively from time to time and some called out asking for justice, but on the whole the group was orderly. Two speeches, one by County Judge Earl Fehl and one by editor Banks, were made, each more or less resorting to the familiar phrases of the election campaign and the editorial columns of the Daily News. Banks also denounced Codding in no uncertain terms and fairly screamed when he asked that he resign. The whole affair is the outgrowth of the mixup since Judge Fehl refused to accept the appointment of R. E. Nealon to the county court after the eleventh-hour resignation of Commissioner Barneburg. Awaiting the decision of County Attorney Codding, Fehl refused to conduct the regular county business, and when it was found that Codding upheld Nealon's appointment, supporters of Fehl started petitions asking for the resignations. On Monday rumors of the proposed march were about, and it was said that Lowell Zundell, candidate for county sheriff on the independent ticket--supported by the Daily News--would be the leader. Zundell denied this emphatically yesterday, however, and Banks stated in his editorial columns that if no one else would he would. The American Legion issued statements that they would stand ready for any emergency, but the march proved only a farce and with the very evident lack of leadership and unity, no guards or patrolling were necessary. Gold Hill News, January 12, 1933, page 1 TWO 'UNREST' MEETS HELD
Llewellyn A. Banks' answer to the Legion-sponsored mass meeting last
Thursday to refute his "false propaganda" was a lengthy resolution
drawn at the "Good Government" Congress at the courthouse Monday night.
The resolution called forLegion-Sponsored Group Flays Banks; Banks Flays Courts all legal proceedings in the circuit court to be held in abeyance until constitutional rights of citizens can be upheld, and also asked for removal of Circuit Judge Harry D. Norton and District Attorney Geo. Codding. The resolution also accused Codding of protecting unlawful, slanderous and libelous publications (referring to the Jacksonville Miner, which has recently started a heavy attack on Banks). According to reports about 750 people crowded to the courthouse for this meeting and organized the Good Government Congress, which is reputedly for the purpose of restoring law and order to the county. Two speakers who addressed this group, Mrs. Henrietta Martin of Central Point and Roy Chandler of Medford, had acted as hecklers at the Legion-sponsored meeting. At last Thursday's gathering more than 1400 fair-minded people heartily cheered speakers who upheld the existing government, county officers and court officials, but booed Chairman E. E. Kelly, when in a moment of exasperation at Chandler he told him he could get out if he didn't like it. The theme of the meeting was that the existing government should be respected and that statements in the Medford Daily News should not be taken as absolute fact without careful investigation. Hearty applause greeted declarations that the office of district attorney had never been better conducted than under District Attorney George A. Codding; that in the court of Circuit Judge Harry D. Norton no one could truthfully say they could not receive a fair trial, and that County Judge Earl Fehl would make an excellent official if editor L. A. Banks of the Daily News would just "commit suicide." The speakers, who included members of the Southern Oregon Bar Association, a Medford minister, Raymond Reter of the Medford Fruitgrowers association, and H. D. Reed, Gold Hill justice of the peace, who handled the famous Bates case. Speakers pointed out that Banks had attacked practically every organization in the county, including the Ministerial Association, the Jackson County Civic League, the Medford Chamber of Commerce, the Merchants' Association, the old Traffic Association, the Fruitgrowers' organization and the medical men's society, as well as numerous individuals of Medford. They also brought out that Mr. Banks, who owns considerable valuable property, has paid no real estate taxes since 1929, and that he has repeatedly dodged foreclosure by his creditors on the grounds that he could not get a fair trial, even after a judge from another district was called on the case. Banks' paper was denounced emphatically by Chairman E. E. Kelly, who said it should not be allowed in the U.S. Mails, and this statement was challenged from the floor as infringing the rights of freedom of speech and of the press. Banks has since attacked the Jacksonville Miner, however. He is also continuing his attacks on the county government, the courts and the bar association. A second "Good Government" mass meeting to be held before the grand jury reconvenes has been announced by Mr. Banks, but no date is set as yet. Gold Hill News, January 26, 1933, page 1
BANKS SUED FOR FRUIT BALANCE
Suit was filed today in circuit
court by William Berthold Barnum against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc.,
L. A. Banks, president, for the collection of $2950.40 allegedly due on
fruit sold in 1931 and 1932.The complaint sets forth two causes of action, the first for $2831.35 and the second for $94.05. Barnum alleges in his complaint that the fruit was purchased for $7300.08, and that $4468.73 was paid, leaving an unpaid balance of $2831.35. Application for a writ of attachment against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., accompanies the suit, which was filed by attorney Porter J. Neff. Medford Mail Tribune, February 1, 1933, page 1
Ray Wants No Mussolini.
To the Editor: In order that my
position may be fully understood by all, will say: Though severing my
connections with the Good Government Congress, I in no way retract from
the stand that I have taken against corrupt conditions known to exist
in Jackson County, nor do I criticize the sincere efforts of L. A.
Banks in the past or at present, but I do not believe in a powerful
organization being placed in the hands and under the dictation of any
man or any group of men within the body of said organization, which
might or might not enact the will and intent of the entire
organization, and believe no action should be taken upon any measure
without due deliberation of and discussion by the entire body.I wish to be true to my convictions, which have come into being through the study of the word of God, and will always be found ready to support any person or cause which I believe to be right, and by the same token, ready to denounce any person or principle which I believe to be wrong and unjust. I believe in giving my entire support to all legally elected officers, city and county, who are doing their duty to promote justice, and to condemn all obstruction to justice wherever found. I have no apology to offer for anything I have said or done, all of which I sincerely believe to have been for the lasting benefit of the organization with which I was associated. All should remember that the truth is a sharp, two-edged sword, will cut both ways, and should be handled with care. Sincerely,
"Communications," Medford Mail Tribune, February 2, 1933, page 6GUY L. RAY.
BANKS ARREST ORDERED ON LIBEL
An information alleging criminal
libel was filed late yesterday before Justice of the Peace L. A.
Roberts in Ashland against L. A. Banks, orchardist and editor and
publisher of the Medford Daily News. The complaint was signed by attorney M. O. Wilkins of Ashland, former counsel for Banks. The
complaint is based upon an editorial printed Thursday morning, charging attorney Wilkins with "attempted extortion."ATTORNEY WILKINS ISSUES COMPLAINT HEARING SATURDAY Charge Based on Editorial of Thursday in Daily News Alleging Extortion Attempt--Bail Set at $2000 The time for the preliminary hearing of the case was set this morning by Justice Roberts for ten o'clock Saturday morning in Ashland. The warrant for the arrest of Banks was presented to Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn late this morning. Over the telephone, Sheriff Schermerhorn in a conversation with Justice Roberts was advised that bail had been fixed at $2000. This noon an extra was issued by the Daily News, with a headline reading "L. A. Banks Will Resist Arrest." The article signed "L.A.B." charges "conspiracies exist in all the courts of Jackson County against Llewellyn A. Banks." The concluding paragraph reads: "We have now come to that great showdown where blood is liable to be spilled--L.A.B." The warrant for the arrest of Banks was first placed in the hands of Constable George J. Prescott, who turned it over to the sheriff's office for service. Medford Mail Tribune, February 3, 1933, page 1
NEFF IN ANSWER TO BANKS' CLAIM OF PERSECUTION
To the Editor:My inclination is to ignore the insane vaporings of L. A. Banks, but it is evident that many well-intentioned people still continue to take his utterances seriously. In such circumstances, it seems necessary to answer the charges he has made against my clients and myself. Mr. Banks prints a mass of figures in an effort to prove that his company is not indebted to E. C. Corn and that the action of Corn vs. Suncrest Orchards, Inc., is based on a trumped-up false claim. The fact is that the Corn action is brought upon a promissory note signed by Mr. Banks himself on behalf of his company and dated March 25, 1932, after the close of the 1931 fruit season. I now have this note in my possession. If Mr. Banks did not owe this money why did he give this note? In any event, he can scarcely blame me because I assumed that a promissory note signed by him represented a legal obligation. The facts which led up to the action of Barnum vs. Suncrest Orchards, Inc. are these: Some two or three years ago L. A. Banks, Howard A. Hill, Wm. B. Barnum, O. B. Morrow, George Schumacher, Marie Schumacher, L. D. Harris and C. H. Taylor borrowed $1000 from W. H. Norcross. The money went to Mr. Schumacher to assist in equipping him to make chemical analyses in connection with arsenic residues on the fruit these parties were growing and shipping. It was agreed among all of these parties that Mr. Banks, who, through his company, Suncrest Orchards, Inc. was handling all of their fruit, should hold out three-quarters of a cent on each box shipped, including the fruit of Mr. Banks and his company, and that this three-quarters of a cent per box should constitute a fund which should be used to pay this $1000 note. Mr. Banks and his company did deduct this three-quarters of a cent from the fruit of these various growers but appropriated the money to his own use and failed to pay Mr. Norcross' note. Finally, Mr. Norcross brought an action against the makers of this note to recover his $1000, less $100 on the principal which had been paid by Mr. Schumacher. Mr. Banks was called upon to protect the other makers of the note and to use the money which he had collected and received to discharge the note in accordance with his agreement. This he failed to do. On the contrary, he has failed to file any answer in the action and there is imminent danger that a judgment will be taken against the other signers of the note, including Mr. Barnum, and that their property will be sold to enforce its collection. If the foregoing statement is not substantially true I invite Mr. Banks to publish over the signature of one or more of these parties, other than himself, their statement of what the true facts are. During all this time Mr. Banks' company has owed Mr. Barnum a large indebtedness, the collection of which he had refrained from pressing, but under the existing conditions Mr. Barnum has felt justified in taking such steps as he could to protect himself and his associates and has done this by bringing an action on his claim and attaching such property of Mr. Banks' company as he can find. The statement that I have ever solicited or sought any business against Mr. Banks or his company is unqualifiedly false. On the contrary, I have consistently discouraged my clients from bringing actions against him. The action of Corn vs. Suncrest Orchards was commenced in November on the instruction of my client, and an attachment was issued and placed in the hands of the sheriff. I personally assumed the responsibility of holding this writ of attachment up in the sheriff's office for more than two months in the vain hope that Mr. Banks could realize from his gold mine sufficient to pay at least a part of the claim. The lien foreclosure suit was brought by me on behalf of the laboring men who had worked on Mr. Banks' mine, and who had not been paid. Have we come to the place in Jackson County where a lawyer cannot assist a laboring man to collect the wages earned by his sweat and brawn? The Alexander claim and the Hubbard Brothers claim were included in the suit at the request of Frank P. Farrell, their attorney, and for the purpose of avoiding the expense of a separate lawsuit. Mr. Banks announces his intention to withdraw from our courts. Doubtless Mr. Kingsley and Mr. Reed, who ran afoul the law enforcement officers of this county, would have been glad to pursue a similar course. PORTER J. NEFF.
Medford Mail Tribune, February 3, 1933, page 1Editorial Comment
First bloodshed in the Jackson County court fight occurred when the editor of a small paper published
at Jacksonville planted a nice left hook firmly upon the nasal
appendage of a threatening reader of his sheet. It is unfortunate that
such fine communities as Medford and neighboring towns should be torn
by strife of such a minor and wholly unimportant nature. It is,
however, just another example of what can happen when one of two
newspapers in a town happen to have at its head a man who would rather
pick a fight than do constructive work for his town and
community--(Coos Bay Times.)Medford Mail Tribune, February 3, 1933, page 10
Bank's Admirers Post $1,000 Bail
Llewellyn A. Banks, editor of the
Medford Daily News, whose arrest was ordered on a charge of criminal
libel, made by attorney M. O. Wilkins of Ashland, was released under
$1000 bond when arraigned before Justice of the Peace L. A. Roberts of
Ashland yesterday afternoon. Bond was furnished by admirers who jammed
the small courtroom.PUBLISHER MUST FACE GRAND JURY HEARING ON LIBEL Banks waived preliminary hearing and was bound over to the grand jury. Banks was ordered to appear for arraignment at 10 o'clock yesterday, but by arrangement with the sheriff he did not appear until 2 o'clock. Judge L. A. Roberts and the complaining witness, M. O. Wilkin, waited until 10 o'clock, and when Banks did not show up they left. Sheriff Takes Own Time
Judge Roberts declared yesterday
that he did not postpone the time for arraignment, that his order was
for Sheriff Gordon Schermerhorn to produce Banks in court at 10
o'clock. The delay was a voluntary act on the part of the sheriff's
office, as far as the court was concerned, Judge Roberts said, and the
sheriff's office is liable for not carrying out the orders of the
court. Banks had declared in his newspaper that he would resist arrest,
and the officers did not "call his bluff."Several objections to the warrant were raised by the sheriff's office, in that the warrant was not dated and that the warrant itself did not set a time for arraignment. Members of the sheriff's staff also objected to serving the warrant on the grounds that the district attorney [had] refused to swear out warrants for Banks against other persons, but they were advised that their duty was to serve warrants when they were given to them. Fehl to Fore
After Banks' bond was signed by
six sworn property owners, 60 more names were affixed to a subsequent
sheet by landowners who expressed their desire to be included on the
bond. County Judge Earl H. Fehl appeared as a friend of Banks, and
informed the subsequent signers of the bond that they did not waive
their right to jury duty by signing the pledge of support and
confidence. Mrs. Ada Deakin of Ashland raised the question of whether
their right to jury duty was jeopardized.Banks was cheered by his friends, and Judge Roberts admonished the crowd that the dignity of the courtroom must be preserved. Those who attended the arraignment expecting fireworks were disappointed, and some got their first glimpse of legal proceedings. A large crowd standing outside the open windows, on the sidewalk, also gave three cheers for Banks. Asst. Dist. Attorney George Neilson read the statute from the Oregon code that defined criminal libel, and asked Banks if he were represented by an attorney. Banks said that he was not, that he did not wish a hearing, but would be willing for the matter to go directly before the grand jury. Wilkins at Scene
Attorney Wilkins, Judge Roberts, attorney Neilson, Phil Lowd, Banks and Judge Earl H. Fehl were the
chief characters at the hearing. Those who signed the bond were Electa
A. Fehl, wife of Judge Fehl; Howard A. Hill, of Medford, Henrietta B.
Martin, wife of a government radio operator here and president of the
Good Government Congress; W. J. Jones, Rogue River rancher; E. E.
Simmons, Talent merchant; Walter W. Phiede, Eagle Point farmer, and E.
A. Fleming, orchardist of Jacksonville.Mrs. Martin announced that she represented the Good Government Congress, and that the congress was behind Banks to a member. Attorney Wilkins left the court room as soon as his part of the hearing was completed, and returned to his own office next door. Mrs. Martin inspected the warranty bond after it had been signed, with the statement that "too many things have been changed in this country for us to take any chances." She found the bond correct, however. Medford Mail Tribune, February 5, 1933, page 1
Recall Plans Bared at Mass Meeting
The Jackson County legal-political
war which has torn the county for the past two years continued at the
"first assembly of the Good Government Congress" at the Armory,
Saturday morning. Police estimated the crowd at between 1200 and 1500.
The majority of those in attendance, a check of the parked autos
showed, were from the rural sections. Many of this city, drawn by
curiosity, attended. The meeting revealed plans for a campaign to
launch recall movements against the circuit judge and district attorney.POLITICAL PLANS INCLUDE SCALPS CODDING, NORTON L. A. Banks, editor-orchardist, presented a program for the "rehabilitation of Jackson County," which included mine development, building of a cannery, and other constructive enterprises. He climaxed his remarks, however, with the charge "that the rehabilitation would not be a success, until law and order had been established in Jackson County, and the district attorney removed, also the circuit judge." He favored the appointment of "someone who is not a member of the legal profession to the bench." "Law and Order" Record Played
Banks' proposal that the "grand
jury indict the district attorney for malfeasance in office" was
embodied later in a resolution, which was carried. The grand jury was
"memorialized" to indict District Attorney Codding for "malfeasance."The resolution contained the familiar oft-repeated charges that "law and order have been broken down in Jackson County," that "life is not safe," and that "property is being confiscated without due process of law." County Judge E. H. Fehl, announced as a "guest speaker," also addressed the audience, and was given the heartiest round of applause of the session. Judge Fehl said he was "elected by the people and was the representative of all the people," but that "his hands were tied by the other members of the county court." Henrietta B. Martin, wife of a civil service employee, and president of the good government congress, urged all present to go to the Daily News office, and sign petitions for the recall of Circuit Judge Norton and District Attorney Codding. She advised all not registered to proceed to the county clerk's office and register and then sign the recall petitions. County Judge Fehl and Mrs. Martin also urged all to go to Ashland and attend the preliminary hearing of L. A. Banks, in justice court. Banks in his talk declared "that filing of the criminal libel charge was a frame-up to keep him from attending the meeting." Banks held that the justice court had no right to issue a warrant for his arrest on the criminal libel charge, "but that it could only be done by the grand jury, and when that is done, I will submit to arrest gracefully." Mrs. Ada Deakin of Ashland took the platform near the close of the meeting. She also charged that "law and order had broken down," and favored signing of the recall petitions. Mrs. Deakin, in an impassioned speech, also censured attorney M. O. Wilkins for his recent stand. She also attacked the courts and district attorney's office. The session lasted until well past noon, and started to disperse when Chairwoman Martin announced that a collection was in order. The session was good-natured for the most part, and it was evident that the tenseness that characterized previous gatherings the past month had lessened. A group of boys voted "No" on the resolutions, and were rebuked by the chair. A voice in the gallery shouted, "They're not old enough to vote." Medford Mail Tribune, February 5, 1933, page 1
BANKS EVICTION UP TO CREDITOR
A judgment and decree, in
default in favor of T. E. Pottenger and wife and Elmira Cox was handed down yesterday in circuit court,
against L. A. Banks, publisher-editor of the Daily News.The decree provides that Pottenger and co-plaintiffs are entitled to immediate possession. It is further provided that Banks, under Oregon law, may redeem the property within six months by the payment of $18,185.52--the amount of the judgment--and costs amounting to $17.30. The action was not contested. The suit was for possession of the building on West Main Street, occupied by the Daily News, and purchased by Banks. It was averred that Banks had failed to comply with the terms on the contract for the purchase. Medford Mail Tribune, February 5, 1933, page 1
INDICT EDITORS BANKS AND HALL
L. A. Banks, following his
indictment yesterday, appeared at the county jail last night, where he
waited for the return of Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn, who served the
warrant upon him. Howard A. Hill and Mrs. Ariel B. Pomeroy were
qualified as bonds surety in the sum of $1000. The bond was approved by
Circuit Judge H. D. Norton.CRIMINAL LIBEL CHARGES LODGED AGAINST EMBATTLED PAIR WITH BOND SET AT $1000 FOR EACH Allegation of Embezzlement of Fruit Growers Funds by Banks Basis of Findings Against Editor Hall--Banks' Reference to Officers of Law as Bandits Held Violation--Check Forger Also Indicted --Five Not True Bills L. A. Banks, publisher and editor of the Daily News, was indicted on a charge of criminal libel by the grand jury, William T. Grieve of Prospect, foreman. The indictment was based upon an alleged libelous article published in the "Once in Awhile" column and captioned "Banditry," on February 9. The grand jury reported late Saturday. The grand jury also returned a criminal libel indictment against Leonard Hall, publisher and editor of the Jacksonville Miner. The alleged libel was embraced in an article December 30 dealing with allegations of embezzlement, in the Norcross suit. A circuit court jury last week returned a verdict in favor of Norcross, in his suit against L. A. Banks, Howard A. Hill, C. H. Taylor, W. B. Barnum and O. B. Morrow, for the full amount asked. Norcross based his suit upon the claim that Banks had collected funds on a three-quarters of a cent per box basis, from the defendants, for payment of the balance due on the $1000 note, but that no funds had been applied to the payment of the note. Based on Editorial
The indictment against Banks is
based upon an article in the "Once in Awhile'' column, and the entire
article is made a part of the indictment. It was printed two days
following the serving of an attachment on newsprint by Eugene Wright
for back salary allegedly due. This case is now pending in justice
court for decision.The indictment sets forth as alleged specific libel in the article, the following: "Bandits on the public payrolls entered the Medford Daily News on Tuesday." Also, "Following the first outrage where bandits, under the badge of authority of the law, entered a news plant and seized all the newsprint, a friend came to the rescue." Also, "That bandits wearing the badge of authority, in open violation of the laws of the state..." An indictment was also returned against O. O. Clancy, charging check forgeries. $1000 Bail Set
Bail in the indictments against
Hall and Banks were set at $1000, and bench warrants ordered issued for
their appearance.Besides the three true bills, the grand jury returned five not true bills, the same not being made public. The grand jury reported shortly before four o'clock yesterday afternoon, after being in session all week. One of the last witnesses to be called before the grand jury was Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the Good Government Congress. Banks in the past month has frequently commended the present grand jury in his column, and at the Good Government Congress session Friday night praised them from the platform in one of his speeches. Bonds were furnished by Hall immediately following the court procedure with A. W. Pipes and Ralph Woodford as sureties. Medford Mail Tribune, February 12, 1933, page 1
BANKS FOLLOWERS ASK PRESIDENT TO BRING LAW, ORDER
The "Good Government Congress"
held a special "convocation" at the courthouse auditorium Friday night
and adopted a resolution calling upon President Hoover, and the
"progressive senators" to "re-establish law and order in Jackson
County." Between 500 and 600 people packed and jammed the small hall,
and overflowed on the lawn. Many from this city and rural districts
attended out of curiosity "to see the fun." The Rev. T. L Thuemler
opened the meeting with a short prayer, and Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin,
wife of a civil service employee, presided as chairman. L. A. Banks
made three extemporaneous speeches during the course of the evening. He
asked the congress to "be calm, but firm."Threat of Rope for Political Foes Shouted at Mass Meeting-- Calls on Grand Jury Urged by Editor Urges Grand Jury Call.
Banks urged his friends to go
before the grand jury in his behalf, stating that his enemies had been
there. "It is your grand jury," he declared, "and all you have to do is
knock at the door to be admitted." He referred to the times he has
spoken highly of the grand jury and also urged the members of the
congress to crowd the court house at any time Judge Fehl appeared to be
in "dire straits." Moral support for the judge, suggested by a member
of the audience, he described as useless without action. He spoke at
length on the grand jury situation and repeatedly reminded the crowd
that a man's house is his castle. He reviewed the attachment of
newsprint in the Daily News shop and spoke often of "my paper," then
later of "paper belonging to the employees."Cry for Action.
The first part of the meeting was
good-natured, but ominous notes crept in in the latter part. One
speaker, who said he was an ordained minister, declared the "gang was
gathering arms." A woman in the audience, when it was proposed that a
committee wait upon District Attorney Codding and Judge Norton and
demand they "resign immediately," shouted, "don't forget the rope." A
man on the platform shouted he "was tired of resolutions and if Nealon
had no right in the office throw him out." Another speaker on the floor
urged "direct action." Another said, in his travels over the county he
"found people for Judge Fehl, but asking about 'this man Banks'." He
said, "I tell them Banks is just a member like the rest of us."Produce Boycott Urged.
When it was urged that the
"Congress" call upon the grand jury in a body and demand they oust
District Attorney Codding and Judge Norton, Banks arose and cautioned
against "hasty action, as it seldom accomplishes anything." Banks also
opposed a motion presented by W. P. Doty urging a boycott on California
produce. Banks said his "stand probably would be popular," but it was
impractical. Chairwoman Martin observed, "that if we all ship in our
groceries, maybe they will buy our produce." No action was taken on the
Doty motion.A noticeable feature of the Friday night meet was the lack of enthusiasm and applause, in comparison with previous sessions. General comment at random throughout the crowd was "It looks like a political move," "too much talk," "what's it all about anyway," and "it's time to cut out the horseplay." Collection Proposed.
Following the meeting a number
went forward and signed petitions urging the recall of Circuit Judge
Norton and District Attorney Codding. The majority left when a
collection was proposed.Officers of the "Congress," of which L. A. Banks is honorary president, Mrs. Henrietta Martin, president, and her father, C. H. Brown, secretary, were commended by speakers for their work. Attorney M. O. Wilkins was scored. He was on the courthouse lawn, but left when "heckled" by a group of men. Medford Mail Tribune, February 12, 1933, page 5
HOW WE APPEAR IN EYES OF OUTSIDERS
The bark of Llewellyn A. Banks,
editor of the Medford Daily News, seems to have been much more
dangerous than his bite.SUFFERING MEDFORD. (Oregon City Enterprise) A few years ago this man Banks came from California into the fruitful, peaceful valley of which Medford is the metropolis. He engaged in horticulture, and had scarcely established residence in the state when he was stung by the political bug, and in order to have a mouthpiece he acquired the Medford Daily News. He contested the nomination for the U.S. senatorship with Senator McNary. Whether his political disappointment did it, or whether his mouthpiece merely furnished the means to display it, nevertheless this fellow seems to have become obsessed with the notion that the world holds but one honest man, namely Llewellyn A. Banks. All else are crooks conspiring to ruin Mr. Banks. His daily tirades aimed at the courts, the bar association, the county court, the district attorney, the competitive newspaper, the sheriff, the constable, the "gang" have kept the community in continuous turmoil for months. He has gone into convulsions of wrath, snapping right and left at his imaginary enemies and appealing to the mob spirit to rally to his support. He has stirred up a senseless feud from which Jackson County will not recover for years. His diatribes read like the products of a fevered brain. There are suits pending against Banks totaling three hundred thousand dollars, and the climax came last week when creditors tied up his supply of newsprint. The fellow managed to issue his paper, however, with the aid of supporters who obtained a new supply, and the "robbers," "thieves" and "bandits" were duly trounced by Mr. Banks. The editorial resulted in his indictment for criminal libel, and Mr. Banks thereupon served notice he would defy the law. Here are the irate words of the troublesome journalist: "Now my friends, I am back home. I am defending my castle. If any officer of the law attempts to invade my home to illegally deprive me of my liberty or deprive me of my property, I will defend my home just the same as I would if bandits were entering it." That sounded as ominous as the bay of a bloodhound, but as we indicated at the start, all the danger proved to be in the bark. This item subsequently appeared in the news columns of Mr. Banks' paper: "L. A. Banks, upon hearing over the telephone that an indictment had been returned against him charging criminal libel, immediately walked to the county courthouse and there placed himself voluntarily in the hands of the sheriff." And in the same issue a statement by Banks, ending: "The publisher of the News has not been indicted. But the manhood, the honor, of Jackson County has been placed on trial." The enlightened people of Medford and Jackson County, who are justly proud of their culture, must be very tolerant to have so long endured this flow of maniacal stuff, the reverberations of which have gone out in news dispatches to their detriment and chagrin. Medford Mail Tribune, February 15, 1933, page 1
Barrage of Propaganda Implants Idea That Law and Order Broken Down
L. A. Banks, dictator of the "Good
Government Congress," is fast gaining the name of a "super
psychologist" among those of the county who are keeping their heads
and looking into the current turmoil with clear eyes.Clever Psychology Used to Create Distrust; Good Government Congress Built for Dictator's Own Profit ----
Banks has in mind the ultimate
control of county offices, for obvious reasons, and is laying down a
barrage of carefully concealed propaganda to play on the minds of
uninformed folks to gain those ends. The last move in this plan was the
formation of the "Good Government Congress," of which he has complete
control at this time.People Sold.
By means of clever salesmanship,
he has, through his newspaper, sold many of the people of Jackson
County on the idea that there is a breakdown of law and order. He has
done this by carefully concealing certain facts in each case he sets
forth, and in playing to the skies threads of truth in each allegation.
Persons who have not had access to all the facts in the several cases,
and have heard the repeated charges of law breakdown and conspiracies,
have believed the charges, and are now the ones who are supporting
Banks in his efforts to avoid his day of reckoning in court. Many of
these people, it is pointed out, are sincere in their belief that a
breakdown of law and order exists and that something should be done
about it. But they have not studied Banks' activities in the valley,
and his gradual decline into a morass of legal proceedings, and fail to
see the obvious "nigger in the woodpile"--the selfish purpose of their
overlord and dictator.Case Is Cited.
For example:Banks printed a story told to him by F. A. Bates, aged miner of Foots Creek, in which he charged several persons with robbing sluice boxes, and conspiracies. He printed it because the story, as Bates told it, condemned the county law enforcement officers, which was directly in line with Banks' editorial policy. He was sued for libel because of the story, and as a defense he has set about to prove by insinuation that the officers were responsible for the acts of Bates, and DENYING THE RIGHT OF THE COURTS to settle the question as to whether Bates' story was true--or not true. Intimidation Aim.
Having failed in the election to
place his own men in office, with the exception of Earl Fehl, it is now
generally conceded that he seeks to do by intimidation the thing he
couldn't do at the polls. Control of the offices of district attorney
and circuit judge, to say nothing of the sheriff's office, would enable
Banks to successfully combat any effort to bring him to justice or an
accounting.The people comprising the "Good Government Congress" represent varied elements in the county, but while many are sincere, nearly all are UNINFORMED. Some are there because they want costs of government reduced, and blame the county officials for all their troubles. Some feel that law enforcement has failed to gain just and proper ends, and some are seeking relief from unemployment. Still others--a very small group--merely want to raise trouble and enjoy a thrill. Banks, in an address to the Congress last Monday night, openly declared that "nothing could be done for the unemployed or the tax-ridden until the county had removed the bloodstains from its hands." By that simple statement, he rallied the unemployed and the tax-ridden to his support to justify himself in his charges against persons in the Bates case, and Earl Fehl's charges against the officers in the Dahack case. Truth Not All Told.
Chief among the charges laid at
the doorstep of county officers, and upon which the libel suits against
himself and Fehl are based, are the Dahack case and the F. A. Bates
case. In both cases Banks charges a "miscarriage of justice," and
"breakdown of law and order." He has never told all the truth of either
case.The Dahack case, where Everett Dahack was killed by officers who were raiding a still on Reese Creek, has been investigated by three grand juries, including one grand jury headed by a special investigator appointed by the governor. These investigations brought out the fact that Everett Dahack was killed by a bullet fired at Raleigh Mathews, who ran towards a rifle when told to halt. These investigations also proved that those who were present at the killing, besides the officers, were present at the coroner's inquest, but refused to testify. These facts are in direct contradiction to charges made by Banks and Fehl that they were kept in jail at the time of the inquest. Banks and Fehl now clamor for another special prosecutor, after REFUSING TO ACCEPT THE FINDINGS OF THE FIRST SPECIAL PROSECUTOR. Thread Makes Blanket.
The F. A. Bates case is another
case of Banks picking up a thread of truth and weaving a blanket of
false propaganda out of it.F. A. Bates was ordered to leave Jackson County by the authorities, but IT WAS UPON THE REQUEST OF HIS OWN WIFE AND DAUGHTER, who did not want to see him imprisoned. Letters are in the possession of authorities and interested parties that PROVE HE WAS GUILTY OF THREATENING TO COMMIT A FELONY. Banks has seen the letters, but contends they are forgeries. Banks' contention is in direct contradiction to Bates' admission that he wrote the letters. Banks, in his editorials about the Bates case, has failed to mention these letters, preferring to contend that he was "banished by the officers." Medford Mail Tribune, February 17, 1933, page 1
BANKS TO PLEAD EARLY THURSDAY ON INDICTMENTS
L. A. Banks, publisher of the
Medford Daily News, indicted Monday by the grand jury on criminal
syndicalism and criminal libel charges, will appear in circuit court
tomorrow morning at 9:30 o'clock, before Circuit Judge George F.
Skipworth of Eugene to enter a plea. Banks will also enter a plea to
the indictment charging criminal libel, returned against him February 11.No further action has been taken by the district attorney's office relative to a hearing on the qualifications of Banks' bondsmen. Judge Skipworth from the bench intimated that he might be "justified in allowing Mr. Banks to go on his own recognizance." The bondsmen on the first criminal libel indictment are Mrs. Ariel B. Pomeroy and Howard A. Hill, orchardists. The bondsmen on the two last indictments are Claude Ward, a brother-in-law of Banks, and W. J. Jones, mayor of Rogue River. The bond in both instances was fixed at $1000. Leonard Hall, editor of the Jacksonville Miner, indicted for criminal libel for the so-called "Norcross embezzlement case" article, was arraigned yesterday and entered a plea of not guilty. J. R. Woodford and A. W. Pipes appear as his bondsmen in the sum of $1000. Medford Mail Tribune, February 22, 1933, page 1
WHY BANKS HATES CODDING BARED IN RECORD OF COURT
This is the second of a series of articles written by George Codding,
District Attorney, for the purpose of contradicting certain falsehoods
published by L. A. Banks.Dist. Attorney Once Forced Orchardist-Editor to Pay Honest Debt-- Has Been Peevish Ever Since The F. A. Bates Case.
Banks has for many months been
trying to inflame the public about the case of F. A. Bates. While I
consider his falsehoods regarding this case as silly and foolish,.
nevertheless there may be those who believe some of the falsehoods
which the editor of the local morning paper has made. He has stated
that the district attorney BANISHED Bates from Jackson County. This is
false, and Banks knows it is false. It is made because of Banks'
personal dislike for me, and all law officers.Threat to Shoot.
Bates, an old man, had some
interest in property, a part of which is mining property on Foots
Creek. He had been interested in it for several years. Finally he
leased it to two men and they worked it on a percentage basis.One day these men made complaint that Bates had threatened to shoot them; a complaint was lodged in Judge H. D. Reed's court at Gold Hill on a very serious charge. A hearing held according to law, and Judge Reed let Bates go without bail pending final determination of the case, warning him to cause no more trouble. A very short time later Bates again raised a disturbance and Judge Reed, fearing something serious might develop, lasted a warrant of arrest, fixed bail and Bates was placed in the county jail. Bates had been there only a short time when his wife and daughter consulted Mr. Frank DeSouza, an attorney of Medford, in an attempt to get him out. They told Mr. DeSouza that they could not furnish bail for him, but that if they could get him released, they would send him up north where some relative would care for him. Liberty Arranged.
Mr. DeSouza then consulted Bates
and found that it would be agreeable to him. Then Mr. DeSouza, his
attorney, telephoned Judge Reed and proposed that the judge release him
so he could go north according to the suggestion of his wife and
daughter. Judge Reed agreed to the arrangement because he had no desire
to keep the old man in jail, if he could be assured that he would keep
out of trouble. Mr. DeSouza then, MERELY OUT OF COURTESY, called me
regarding the release of Bates.Naturally I had no objection, my only thought being that a serious situation on Foots Creek should be avoided if possible, and I did not want to keep an old man in jail at county expense, if anything else could be done. Bates was released, and at about the same time leased or sold the property on Foots Creek to L. A. Banks and Dr. Swedenburg of Ashland. These purchasers required that Bates leave Foots Creek and remain away, as is shown by the records in the county clerk's office. At a later date the grand jury of Jackson County indicted Bates on the charge filed in Judge Reed's court. The statements of Banks that the district attorney banished Bates from this county are malicious falsehoods, as can be easily shown by the records of the case. Why Banks' Hatred.
Many times I have been asked this
question, "Why does Banks hate you, Codding?" The answer will be found
in volume 180 of the Oregon State Supreme Court Report, page 612. A
case entitled Frank Zuccala vs. Suncrest Orchards, Inc. I forced Banks
to pay an honest debt to a poor farmer.In that case the supreme court said Banks' testimony was "far from convincing." Medford Mail Tribune, February 22, 1933, page 1 BANKS AND NEWS ARE DIVORCED BY ORDER OF COURT
L. A. Banks, orchardist and editor and publisher of the Daily News,
was dispossessed of the newspaper plant Saturday morning, following a
decree handed down in circuit court by Judge W. M. Duncan of Klamath
County, in favor of the News Publishing Company, Lee Tuttle, president,
granting them immediate possession.Before the execution of the judgment could be made, aides of Banks, a number being identified as some of the "Green Springs Mountain Boys," started moving equipment from the News plant. A truck, bearing a license issued to the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., one of the Banks properties, was said to have hauled away one truckload. Part of the moved property was taken to the Pacific Record-Herald building, on Sixth Street, owned by County Judge E. H. Fehl. Another load was moved to an unknown destination. Repossessing of the moved property is being sought. Banks was not on the scene in person. Moving Activity Halted
The moving caused considerable furry along Main Street until Sheriff
Schermerhorn, accompanied by attorney Gus Newbury and Mr. Tuttle,
arrived. The moving halted and the old News Publishing Company
immediately took charge.Most of the desks and typewriters in the business office had been taken. Some of the movable parts of the mechanical department were taken, including Linotype line spaces and metal. [Stealing a Linotype's spacebands incapacitates the machine.] The defiance of a court order caused only mild excitement. The participants were for the most part followers of Banks and his "Good Government Congress." It was said names of most of those assisting in the moving were obtained. Small Crowd Present
A small crowd assembled in the circuit courtroom to hear the ruling of
Judge Duncan. A few known members of the "Good Government Congress"
were present, including Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the
"congress." There were fewer "congressmen" in the courthouse than
usual. Banks was not present.Judge Duncan in a brief verbal ruling granted a decree to the old News Publishing Company. He said that the court was satisfied there had been ample time to prepare a defense, and that the affidavit of prejudice, filed by Banks Friday, was too late, and furthermore that two affidavits of prejudice, the legal number allowed, had already been filed. Banks appeared Friday as his own counsel, and made an effort to further delay the legal action him. The case has been pending since last December, and every possible legal subterfuge employed to postpone Saturday's legal reckoning. Mortgage Decision Later
In the suit of O. B. Waddell, assignee for the Medford National Bank
for the collection of approximately $9000 owed by Banks and wife on
mortgages on his home, and the Suncrest Orchards, Inc. decision was
reserved by Judge Duncan until a later date.Repossession of the News by its founders brings to a close a stormy period in the life of the paper. Banks, as editor, engaged in "personal journalism" and specialized in daily attacks on established institutions and county officials. At first the policy attracted, put the past six months there has been a steady drift away and crystallization of public opinion against methods that kept the county in a constant turmoil. Under Banks' management the morning paper was constantly beset with troubles of all kinds and varieties. Lee Tuttle, who will be editor of the News whether or not it continues as a daily or weekly publication, is a conservative but progressive type of editor, and "stickler for the truth." Medford Mail Tribune, February 26, 1933, page 1
Role of Persecuted Has Often Forced Banks to Sidestep Truth's Pathway
Yesterday's issue of
the Medford Daily News under the signature of L. A. Banks, editor, and
leader of the Good Government Congress, contained a continuation of the
false statements and misleading insinuations that have graced the Daily
News for many months. The statements were made with the definite
purpose of misleading the Banks followers, it is believed, and with the
intention of prejudicing the minds of the people against the courts and
officers of the county.Affidavit Filed by Wilkins While Yet in Banks Council in Foreclosure Suit Instituted by Former Owners Banks claimed in his column that he did not have time to file an affidavit of prejudice against Circuit Judge W. H. Duncan in the suit of Lee Tuttle and the old News Publishing Company against Banks and the Daily News publishing company. This statement is proven absolutely false. Records Show Falsity.
Banks also insinuates
that attorney M. O. Wilkins filed an affidavit of prejudice against
Circuit Judge Harry D. Norton after he had withdrawn as Banks' attorney
in the case, for the purpose of defeating Banks. This claim is also
absolutely false, and Banks could have found it to be false by looking
at the records on file at the county clerk's office.The statement of Banks that appeared in yesterday morning's issue of the Medford Daily News was as follows: "First, we declare that Wilkins was without authority to sign a motion of prejudice before and in behalf of L. A. Banks." Attorney May Prejudice
"The state law is
definite in this respect," attorney Gus Newbury said on Saturday. "The
state law says that either the persons in the suit, or their attorneys,
can file affidavits of prejudice. When Wilkins filed that affidavit
against Judge Norton it was just as legal as the one Banks signed against Judge Brand."A second statement in the Medford Daily News immediately followed the first, which said: "Second, we have reason to believe that this motion of prejudice was prepared and placed in the files after Wilkins had withdrawn as the attorney for L. A. Banks, and after he had demanded the $1857.55 in attorney's fees, which were not due him and on which he held up all of the documents in this and other cases." An inspection of the files at the court house shows that the affidavit of prejudice against Judge Norton, signed by Wilkins, was filed on December 7, 1932, and that Wilkins' letter of resignation, printed in Banks' paper, was mailed to Banks on February 19, 1933. Falsehood Preferred
Banks could have
determined these facts if he had bothered to call the county clerk's
office, or go there himself and personally inspect the files, but he
preferred to intentionally distort the truth to further mislead his
readers and give them the impression he was being persecuted.L. A. Banks himself signed the affidavit of prejudice against Judge Brand, on December 5, which makes the two affidavits of prejudice allowed a litigant, and, according to law, only two affidavits are allowed. Time Was Given
Banks further claims
he did not have time to file affidavits of prejudice against Judge W.
H. Duncan because he received the notice on February 20 that the case
was set for trial on February 24. According to law, the affidavit of
prejudice would have been filed Feb. 20th or Feb 21st. Banks filled the
affidavit of prejudice February 23, or the day after Washington's Birthday, which was too late.Yesterday's editorial was but a continuance of the misleading editorials written by Banks for many months, for the sole purpose of prejudicing the minds of the people against the officers and courts of the county. Many of these people who have been misled now firmly and honestly believe that courts in the county are corrupt, but it is reported from many places that people are changing their minds about Banks and his Good Government Congress since the truth of Banks' charges has been printed. Medford Mail Tribune, February 26, 1933, page 1
BANKS AND NEWS ARE DIVORCED BY ORDER OF COURT
L. A. Banks, orchardist and editor
and publisher of the Daily News, was dispossessed of the newspaper
plant Saturday morning, following a decree handed down in circuit court
by Judge W. M. Duncan of Klamath County, in favor of the News
Publishing Company, Lee Tuttle, president, granting them immediate
possession.Before the execution of the judgment could be made, aides of Banks, a number being identified as some of the "Green Springs Mountain Boys," started moving equipment from the News plant. A truck, bearing a license issued to the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., one of the Banks properties, was said to have hauled away one truckload. Part of the moved property was taken to the Pacific Record Herald building, on Sixth Street, owned by County Judge E. H. Fehl. Another load was moved to an unknown destination. Repossessing of the moved property is being sought. Banks was not on the scene in person. Moving Activity Halted
The moving caused considerable
flurry along Main Street until Sheriff Schermerhorn, accompanied by
attorney Gus Newbury, and Mr. Tuttle arrived. The moving halted, and
the old News Publishing Company immediately took charge.Most of the desks and typewriters in the business office had been taken. Some of the movable parts of the mechanical department were taken, including linotype line spaces and metal. The defiance of a court order caused only mild excitement. The participants were for the most part followers of Banks and his "Good Government Congress." It was said names of most of those assisting in the moving were obtained. Small Crowd Present
A small crowd assembled in the
circuit courtroom to hear the ruling of Judge Duncan. A few known
members of the "Good Government Congress" were present, including Mrs.
Henrietta B. Martin, president of the "congress." There were fewer
"congressmen" in the court house than usual. Banks was not present.Judge Duncan in a brief verbal ruling granted a decree to the old News Publishing Company. He said that the court was satisfied there had been ample time to prepare a defense, and that the affidavit of prejudice, filed by Banks Friday, was too late, and furthermore that two affidavits of prejudice, the legal number allowed, had already been filed. Banks appeared Friday as his own counsel, and made an effort to further delay the legal action [against] him. The case has been pending since last December, and every possible legal subterfuge employed to postpone Saturday's legal reckoning. Mortgage Decision Later
In the suit of O. B. Waddell,
assignee for the Medford National Bank for the collection of
approximately $9000 owed by Banks and wife on mortgages on his home
and the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., decision was reserved by Judge Duncan
until a later date.Repossession of the News by its founders brings to a close a stormy period in the life of the paper. Banks, as editor, engaged in "personal journalism" and specialized in daily attacks on established institutions and county officials. At first the policy attracted, but the past six months there has been a steady drift away and crystallization of public opinion against methods that kept the county in a constant turmoil. Under Banks' management the morning paper was constantly beset with troubles of all kinds and varieties. Lee Tuttle, who will be editor of the News whether or not it continues as a daily or weekly publication, is a conservative and progressive type of editor, and "stickler for the truth." Medford Mail Tribune, February 26, 1933, page 1 Central Point Farmer's Claim on Apples Starts Bitter, Sustained Attack Orchardist-Editor Forced to Settle Up for Fruit Purchased After Taking Case to High Court in Evasion Effort I have been attacked and libeled by Banks, formerly owner of the morning newspaper, on many occasions lately. The public generally want to know the reason for his false statements and vicious attacks. Before I became district attorney in 1929, a farmer living near Central Point came to my law office and placed in my hands a claim against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., which corporation was owned by Banks. The claim was for approximately $1,000, which Banks had agreed to pay for an apple crop. Many times this farmer had tried to get Banks to pay the bill, but he had refused. The apples had been sold outright to Banks for a certain sum per ton. Banks packed the fruit which he had bought and agreed to pay for, and shipped the apples east to market. Fruit Not Wasted.
Somewhere in the East, the United
States government seized and held the fruit because it had not been
properly washed when it was packed. NOW, UNDERSTAND, THIS FRUIT WAS NOT
CONSIGNED TO BANKS, BUT WAS PURCHASED BY HIM AT A CERTAIN AMOUNT PER
TON IN THIS COUNTY.Because the apples had been seized by the United States authorities, Banks refused to pay the farmer, and tried to place the blame for the poor washing onto the FRUITGROWER, WHO HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE WASHING AND PACKING. In trying to avoid the payment of his honest debt, Banks made the following claim, which is quoted from his sworn statement filed in court: "That by reason of the lead arsenate spray in and upon said fruit, the same would not pass government inspection, and was unfavorable and caused the defendant to lose all the freight and icing charges expended in shipping the same, and a sum greatly in excess of the value of said fruit in defending the same against the government libel." This case is known as case No. 2139-L, and can be inspected in the office of our county clerk at any time by anyone. Refused to Pay.
When the claim of this farmer was
placed in my hands, I took it up with Banks and tried to get him to pay
it without a lawsuit. HE REFUSED TO PAY, AND SAID IN EFFECT, "START
COURT ACTION IF YOU WANT TO."A court action was filed and tried in our circuit court, and Banks lost the case. He was still determined not to pay the bill, so he appealed the case to the supreme court. It is reported in volume 130, supreme court records, at page 612. Banks lost the case in supreme court after months of litigation. The farmer, of course, was put to a lot of expense for costs and attorney's fees, besides having to wait months for his money, and this particular farmer needed the money badly. It will be remembered that Banks has bragged many times about paying for seized fruit, even when he was not obliged to, and he has posed as a great benefactor to the fruit industry in this valley. Maybe he is. In any event, here is one reason why Banks dislikes the district attorney, AND IT IS A MATTER OF PUBLIC RECORD IN COURT. Medford Mail Tribune, February 27, 1933, page 1
JUDGMENT TO BARNUM IN SUIT AGAINST BANKS
A default judgment in favor of
William Berthold Barnum against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., L. A.
Banks, president, was returned yesterday in circuit court, in the sum
of $2925.40. A writ of attachment was also issued against the packing
plant of the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., located in the Voorhies Crossing
district.Medford Mail Tribune, February 28, 1933, page 4
BANKS ORCHARD DEBTS ORDERED PAID BY COURT
In a decree and order handed down
in circuit court late yesterday by Circuit Judge William M. Duncan,
judgment is awarded O. B. Waddell in two suits for collection of money
against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., L. A. Banks, president, and against
L. A. Banks and Edith R. Banks. The total amount of the judgment, on
two mortgages against orchard and residential property is $11,028.44.The order also provides that "if through inability or refusal the sheriff fails to act," the coroner shall act, and if the coroner fails or refuses, an elisor shall be named by the court, upon a supplemental order. The decree also provides that the court retain jurisdiction pending final settlement. In the findings and conclusions of the court, it is held that the affidavit of prejudice filed by Banks was not within the time prescribed by law, and further that the prejudice affidavit was not based upon facts. In the judgment against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., $4500 is allowed on the first cause of action, and $2028.44 on the second count; $4500 is allowed in the second action. Involved in the proceedings is unpaid county taxes for the past four years. The case was based upon loans made and secured by mortgages in the orchard property and on residential property in this city. Medford Mail Tribune, March 2, 1933, page 1
PROSPECT SCHOOL BOARD BARS BANKS IN SPEECH PLANS
PROSPECT, Ore., March
7.--(Spl.)--Leaders of the so-called Good Government Congress left here
last night in a huff when the school board denied permission for L. A.
Banks to speak at a meeting scheduled in the school gymnasium.
Permission had previously been granted Earl H. Fehl to speak, but when
he attempted to include the erstwhile editor in the program he was
informed Banks would not be permitted to speak. Fehl, Banks and
Henrietta B. Martin, president of the Good Government Congress, then
left Prospect, according to information obtained here.Permission to Use Gym for Public Address Denied Erstwhile Editor-- G.G. Leaders Leave in Dudgeon Members of the Prospect district school board are Tom Carlton, W. E. Mooney and L. A. Ditsworth. ----
There came to this strife-torn
county today a blessed respite from political turmoil and fantastic
rumors and inflammatory talk. There were signs of peace, and an
undertone of optimism.For the first weekday since January 2, the court house corridors this morning were not filled with loungers and curiosity seekers. A dozen men stood on the sidewalk and laughed and joked. Though it was a non-judicial day, due to the bank moratorium, with no official filings being made and no court in session, many people came on business. Court house officials and workers marveled at the sudden welcome change. Developments of Day
It was also quiet on all other fronts, the developments of the last 24 hours being:The district attorney's office started an investigation of the claim of L. A. Banks, honorary president of the so-called "Good Government Congress," in his court house steps speech Monday, that he had written to the governor and other state officials--"unless we can have justice, I will take the field in revolution against you people--now make the most of it." Strong public disapproval registered of incendiary speeches and launching of grave charges against officials and citizens to fan prejudices. Detention by the state police of John G. Brock, resident of this city, for questioning in connection with the brazen and audacious theft of ballots from a courthouse vault on the eve of the sheriff race recount. Release on $1500 bonds, furnished by Ernest Dahack, Eagle Point, and Alfred Poston, Pinehurst, of C. H. Brown, secretary of the "Good Government Congress," and father of Henrietta B. Martin, president of the organization, following his arrest in the midst of "congressmen," on a tour of the courthouse. Bank Slander Charged
Brown is charged with "slandering
a bank," by reason of an article appearing in the last issue of the
Pacific Record Herald, alleging the provisions of the bank moratorium
had been violated. Brown was arrested by Constable George J. Prescott.
He had been sought since Saturday afternoon.Authorities continue search for missing men wanted on warrants for quizzing in the ballot theft cases. Unmistakable indications that Banks' "revolt talk'' coupled with the courthouse raid had alienated dozens of "Good Government Congress" members, and those more or less tolerant of the organization's activities. Local Unemployed Council voices disapproval of Banks' "courthouse speech," and resent asserted snub by "Good Government Congress" leaders. "Committee of 100'' to continue vigilance to stamp out agitation. At the demonstration yesterday, which lacked the fire and fury of previous gatherings, a stenographic account of the speeches of County Judge E. H. Fehl, Henrietta B. Martin, and L. A. Banks were taken: The speech of Banks, as taken by W. J. Looker, was as follows: Mr. Banks: "You were told a few months ago that if they could close the Daily News that you would have peace in Jackson County. Do you remember that?" (Voices from audience: Yes.) "You were told that Llewellyn A. Banks was a disturber of the peace." (Voice from audience: A riotous man.) "Yes, a riotous man. Now my friends, the Medford Daily News was stolen in this court room, deliberately stolen and delivered into the hands of thieves. How long ago? A week--last Saturday, a week ago on Saturday. What has happened in the way of peace since then? Consider the kind of peace you have." (Voice from audience: We are getting pieces.) "I will show you the peace that crowd of criminals--the gang…(voices from crowd) the kind of peace. They commenced to arrest your citizens and put them into jail incommunicado--as they did in Cuba--picked up our boys--as innocent as lambs, and threw them in among the fleas and lice and held them there incommunicado under five thousand dollars bonds when they did get out, while Joe Cave--the man indicted for murder--was out on $1500 bond, wearing a gun--in a uniform--and I want to say to you, friends, that Joe Cave--the man who was indicted up here, was the man who questioned our boys as to their innocence or guilt." (Voice from the audience: He would know--Laughter.) "Now you don't know half the story. I know you have been lied to--falsified to every day since last Saturday, with no one to answer, and I say to you, my friends--I haven't read one paper, I refuse to read a paper in Jackson County because they are full of falsity. Now we propose to give you a newspaper and we will tell you the truth. (Applause.) "Now I am not asking for sympathy. I see some of the criminals in this crowd, that stole this newspaper. (Laughter.) "I see the criminals in sight here, and I could call their names--a deliberate steal--and you will find someday that Judge Duncan, when he was sent in here--he knew before he got here what he was going to do. Why? Because he had the men already sitting in that room, as soon as he handed down that decision--the greatest crime in the history. "Now one thing more. I am not asking for sympathy, but in the past ten days, since my newspaper has been closed, they have confiscated $200,000 worth of my property in this county--irrespective of law--against the law. Now, what are you going to do about it? I will tell you what I am going to do about it. I say in the presence of this audience--I wrote to Governor Meier today, and to the supreme court of this state today, and to other officials, and told them that unless we could have law and order, that I would take the field against them. (Applause.) "Now you understand what I said? That the letter was sent to Governor Meier, and to Rufus Holman, and the supreme court--unless we can have justice, I will take the field in revolution against you people--now make the most of it." Mrs. Martin: "Now at this time, Judge Fehl asked you to visit the court house, and if you will file through orderly please--always orderly in the Good Government Congress--we thank you." Medford Mail Tribune, March 7, 1933, page 1
BANKS' LETTER TO GOVERNOR NOT SO WILD AS SPEECH
Unofficial information from Salem
today stated that Governor Meier had received a letter from L. A.
Banks, erstwhile editor and orchardist, the contents of which the
executive refused to divulge, stating that the matter had been referred
to Banks, himself.It was understood in the capital city that Banks' letter stated that if order was not preserved in Medford a rebellion would result. But belief was that he had not gone so far as to state that he would lead a revolution. Addressing the so-called Good Government Congress here Monday Banks stated that he had informed Governor Meier, State Treasurer Holman and the supreme court that he would take the field in revolution against them if justice was not restored in Jackson County. Medford Mail Tribune, March 8, 1933, page 1
NEWBURY NAILS REVOLVER YARN TOLD BY BANKS
To the Editor:Mr. Banks, in his "Once in Awhile" column in a recent issue of the Medford Daily News, stated: "I had been informed that Gus Newbury, the attorney, had walked into a barber shop, flourished a revolver, laid it down in the barber shop and made the statement that he was carrying the gun for L. A. Banks." Nobody ever gave Mr. Banks that information. He made it out of whole cloth just as he has made the other stuff out of whole cloth that he has been peddling to the people of Jackson County for more than three years, poisoning the minds of good citizens with stuff that was untrue, and giving unto Jackson County a nationwide reputation for lawlessness and violence that never was committed. This raving of his is merely another one of his spasms of hallucinations, and I doubt not that when he gave expression to it with his pen that he hammered the desk until its timbers rattled and the ink wells leaped to the ceiling, accompanying it with a Comanche yell that caused the rafters to shiver as if a Los Angeles earthquake had struck them. According to a statement of his former attorney Mr. Wilkins, Mr. Banks went to the office of Mr. Wilkins on January 20th, 1933, with two guns strapped on his person and exhibiting them to Mr. Wilkins he waltzed around Mr. Wilkins' office flourishing the guns and said "Now bring on Gus Newbury." Mr. Banks owed the News Publishing Company three promissory notes amounting to $10,000 as a balance due on the purchase price of the machinery and equipment sold to Mr. Banks. These notes were more than two years past due, no payments having been made either on the principal or the interest and he allowed the taxes to accumulate against the property, and in November, 1932, the News Publishing Company, failing to get any satisfaction from Mr. Banks in the matter of paying these promissory notes or any part thereof, brought a suit in the Circuit Court for the collection of these notes and for the foreclosure of the mortgage covering the printing plant. Ordinarily a suit of that kind would be brought to trial within a month; but Mr. Banks resorted to every device possible to avoid a trial of the case. The case was assigned to Judge Brand for trial, and in open court Mr. Banks agreed to have the same tried before Judge Brand on December 10th. On December 10th he repudiated this agreement and filed an affidavit of prejudice against Judge Brand although he had never seen Judge Brand until the case was brought to court. He then filed an affidavit of prejudice against Judge Norton, all for the purpose of preventing a trial of the case. The Supreme Court then assigned the case to Judge Duncan, and although Mr. Banks had never seen Judge Duncan in his life, he came into court and filed an affidavit of prejudice against Judge Duncan. So far as Mr. Banks was concerned it was really true that the courts had ceased to function, but not because of the courts but because of Mr. Banks resorting to the affidavits which he filed charging Judge Brand, Judge Norton and Judge Duncan with prejudice against him. I happened to be one of the attorneys for the News Publishing Company and finally got the decree and judgment against Mr. Banks for something in excess of $12,000.00, and he perhaps never will forgive me for accomplishing that result in the face of his determined opposition to pay the debts which he honestly owed. Undoubtedly that is the reason why he said that I carried a gun in the barber shop, for him. But the statement was made out of whole cloth just as were the affidavits of prejudice against these various judges. GUS NEWBURY.
Medford, March 11.Medford Mail Tribune, March 12, 1933, page 4
Daily News Knocked Down to Former Owners
The Daily News, morning newspaper
here, until three weeks ago published and edited by L. A. Banks, was
sold this morning at ten o'clock, at a sheriff's sale. It was purchased
on a bid of $6500 offered by the News Publishing Company, L. B. Tuttle, president. It was the only bid presented.BANKS FOLLOWERS FAIL TO HALT FALL SHERIFF'S HAMMER Bid of $6500 Only One Heard--Mrs. Martin Wants To See Money-- Action Seen As Ending Long Storm. The sheriff's sale was in pursuance of a judgment and order of sale issued out of circuit [court] against Banks, the erstwhile editor, in a "sum in excess of $12,000." The sale, was forecast as marking the end of hectic agitation and sensational charges in this county. Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn conducted the sale standing atop a chair, first reading the description of the property, to a lobby full of people, including members of the "Good Government Congress," police in plain clothes, and curious local folk. Sheriff Pleads for Bids
There was complete silence during the sheriff's plea for bids. At one time he beseeched:"Surely nobody will let more than $12,000 worth of property go for half or less." He then gave the three warnings of the auctioneer, and declared the property sold to the News Publishing Co., original owners and founders of the newspaper. At this juncture, Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the so-called "Good Government Congress" declared: "Now we want to see the money." "The chief creditor and holder of the mortgage doesn't have to show the money," retorted attorney Gus Newbury. Two city policemen stood guard at the two gates to the main business and editorial rooms. Attorney E. E. Kelly advanced to the counter, and after an exchange of words with Mrs. Martin, requested that the crowd depart. They refused to heed him. Few from G.G.C.
Finally wearying of the banter,
the crowd slowly dissolved. There were not many "Congressmen" present.
Several who have been active in the county turmoil were in the throng,
including a number under arrest and at liberty on bonds in the ballot
stealing and burning investigation. Neither Banks nor County Judge Fehl
were present. Mrs. Electa A. Fehl, who claims to hold a certificate of
delinquency for $1064 in unpaid taxes, was in the crowd.A week ago an appeal was issued in the Pacific Record Herald, urging all "Good Government Congress" members to contribute whatever they could to purchase the plant, "for the re-establishment of the free press." Though a more or less active solicitation was waged, chiefly in the rural districts, the harvest was slim. It was also reported that "moneyed congressmen" were planning to buy the paper, and turn it over to Banks. A large crowd gathered across the street from the newspaper to watch the proceedings. Back to Old Owners
The News, by virtue of the
sheriff's sale, now reverts to its founders and owners. It was
established in 1927 by Lee B. Tuttle, Carl A. Swigart, and others, who
evolved a daily paper from the Jackson County News, a weekly.It was purchased in September, 1929, by L. A. Banks, who came here from California, and mixed journalism with his orchard interests. Banks made a down payment and gave three promissory notes, and a mortgage for the balance. He became delinquent in his payments. Suit for possession and foreclosure were started last December. The litigation has been pending since, with counter claims for wages filed intermittently. Banks from the time of his entry into the Southern Oregon newspaper field wielded a fiery pen. Until legal troubles accumulated, his paper fired daily a barrage of serious unprovable accusations and allegations, against citizens, officials, and organizations. He was openly charged with using the paper for the furtherance of political and personal vengeance. Taxes Delinquent
Banks became delinquent in his
taxes, over a three-year period. and late in December a delinquent tax
certificate was issued against the newspaper. It was taken up by J. T.
Thomas of Ashland and others, in the sum of $1084. Mrs. Electa A. Fehl
in a suit filed in circuit court claimed ownership of this certificate.
Tuesday a restraining order was issued in circuit court
prohibiting any legal action to thwart the sale today.Plans of the purchasers of the property for the future have not been announced. Medford Mail Tribune, March 15, 1933, page 1 L. A. Banks Kills Officer Prescott
Constable George D. Prescott of Medford is dead and L. A. Banks,
fiery editor of the Medford
Daily News,
is charged with murder as the climax of the political upheaval in
Jackson County which resulted in the stealing of ballots in the sheriff
recount three weeks ago.CONSTABLE SHOT AT BANKS HOME WHEN SERVING WARRANT Was Serving Papers for Arrest Following Indictment by Grand Jury for Complicity in Ballot Theft; Banks Rushed Out of District by Police Constable Prescott was killed at ten o'clock this morning on the front porch of Banks' home when he and Capt. Bown of the state police went to serve a bench warrant on Banks, charging him with complicity in the theft. The warrant was the outgrowth of grand jury proceedings yesterday, when indictments were returned against about 20 men in the ballot affair. Previously, Banks had not been arrested in this case, although his business manager and several of his close associates are out on bond, charged with burglary not in a dwelling. In the grand jury indictments the charge read "conspiracy to commit a felony," and involved more than the fifteen persons already arrested on the burglary count. It was in accordance with this latest indictment that Constable Prescott was serving papers on Banks. A group of four state police went with Prescott to Banks' home well armed but hoping to avoid trouble, although Banks had repeatedly stated that he would resist arrest, and it was known that his house was barricaded. According to reports, Mrs. Banks came to the door, which was secured with a chain and could be opened only a few inches. The officers asked for Banks and when he appeared he shot almost without warning and Prescott fell dead with a bullet wound in his heart. Arrested a short time later, Banks was rushed from Medford to an unknown destination for safekeeping. Speeding police cars passed through Gold Hill headed north [i.e., west to Grants Pass] about 11:30 this morning, presumably with Banks in charge. Gold Hill News, March 16, 1933, page 1
BANKS SLAYS G. PRESCOTT
"I shot Prescott, who was trying to force his way into the house, the same as any burglar would."WHEN ARREST ATTEMPTED Long Defiance of Law Climaxed in Killing of Policeman Doing Duty This statement, according to Captain Lee M. Bown of the state police, was made by Llewellyn A. Banks, slayer of Constable George J. Prescott, shortly after he had entered the state police auto that was carrying him to the Josephine County jail. Captain Bown said that Banks answered five or six questions freely, and that he declared he shot Prescott with a rifle. Banks was handcuffed and rushed to Grants Pass, as a precautionary measure. Up to mid-afternoon, no arrangements had been made to secure an attorney for Banks. No effort had been made either to secure the release of Edith R. Banks or Mrs. Arthur LaDieu, held in the woman's ward of the city prison. Banks, according to the officers, was calm and cool, and talkative on the trip. ----
Llewellyn A. Banks, 62, former editor and orchardist, shot and killed
Constable George J. Prescott this morning shortly after 10 o'clock, in
resisting the service of a bench warrant issued as the result of a
secret indictment returned late Wednesday, naming Banks as one of the
20 or mere men indicted for the ballot thefts and destruction on the
night of Monday, February 20, during and following a meeting in the
courthouse of the "Good Government Congress."Banks, arrested nearly an hour after the murder, was rushed by state police to the Josephine County jail at Grants Pass for safekeeping and as a precautionary measure. E. A. Fleming, orchardist, Jacksonville, in the Banks home at the time of the murder, was also held by the authorities. Mrs. Edith R. Banks, wife of the slayer, also was detained at the city police station, as a material witness. Mrs. LaDieu Held.
Mrs. Arthur LaDieu, wife of the former business manager of the Daily News
under Banks' management, was held in the women's ward of the city jail
for an alleged inflammatory remark made after the killing. She was
quoted by officers as saying:"He got just what was coming to him, and you're going to get yours, too, Joe Cave." Mrs. Banks, when placed in the city jail, offered no resistance, and had nothing to say, Officer Cave reported. Banks was arrested at his West Main Street residence by state police, hustled into a waiting auto, and rushed to Grants Pass. Banks grinned as he left, passing near the body of the slain officer. Banks made no statement and did not deny the killing. The murder occurred shortly after 10 o'clock this morning. Constable Prescott and Sergeant James O'Brien of the state police had gone to the Banks home on West Main Street, to serve the warrant. According to the police version, Mrs. Banks opened the door. An instant later there was a shot from within. The bullet splintered the side of the door and struck Constable Prescott in the left shoulder, coursing downward through the heart, and causing instant death. The door was then slammed and locked. Mrs. Banks Calm.
Mrs. Banks, detained in the women's ward of the city jail, was calm, and had no comment to make.The murder stunned and shocked the city and county, and was a crashing climax to a long period of turmoil, of which Banks had been the center. In his last public appearance, at a "protest meeting" of the "Good Government Congress," he declared from the courthouse steps: "Unless justice is restored in Jackson County, I will take the field in revolution." While acting as editor of the morning paper, he frequently expressed incendiary defiance of constituted authority, through the printed word. In many articles he boasted he would resist arrest. Prescott Tries to Speak.
Constable Prescott toppled to the front porch floor. Sergeant O'Brien
bent over him, as he gasped, "Tell my--." The sentence was never
finished.Lieut. O'Brien, realizing that Banks was dangerous, stepped out of range, and at a neighboring house sent in a call for reinforcements. Volunteers kept guard rear and front, to prevent any escape by the murderer. When available police officers and members of the American Legion had assembled, Banks was arrested. A curious crowd watched. Many reported that as he marched to the auto he appeared unperturbed. As soon as the necessary legal arrangements can be made, Banks will be held on first degree murder charge, which is not subject to bail. The slayer will probably be arraigned in Josephine County. The body of Constable Prescott is held at the Conger Funeral Parlors. No funeral arrangements have been announced. The bullet struck the officer in the left shoulder and coursed downward, and lodged in the middle of the back. Mrs. Prescott, the wife, is in feeble health. She has not been advised of the tragic death. A son, Francis, living in Klamath Falls, and a daughter, Mrs. Nota Prescott of Salem, are rushing here. Another son, Paul, lives in this city. Was Widely Known.
Constable Prescott was widely
known and highly popular. He had been a resident of this city for about
20 years.The news of the slaying spread like wildfire throughout the city and county, and the local telephone service was clogged with calls. Knots of men gathered about the streets following the murder. For the most part they were silent. There was no undue excitement. Police Mobilized.
Immediately after the killing, state police from Klamath, Josephine,
Coos and Curry counties were ordered to mobilize here. Peace officers
from the same districts also hastened here and were stationed at the
state police and city police headquarters, and at other advantageous
points. A detail of state police were en route from Salem, and more
were to be dispatched this afternoon.It is expected that the state authorities will take immediate steps to prevent any further moves to keep alive the flames of agitation, and to exercise a firm hand in restoring normalcy. This morning a fair-sized crowd, composed mostly of "Good Government Congress" members, gathered at the courthouse. There was some fevered talk, but for the most part the crowd was good natured, and had gathered in anticipation of developments in the ballot theft indictments returned. Close to 100 people were standing around the courthouse corridors when the news of the murder came. Many rushed to the Banks residence. Serving Warrants.
Constable Prescott was engaged in serving bench warrants upon the men
indicted. He was accompanied by Sgt. James O'Brien of the state police.
They appeared at the court house shortly before ten o'clock. Thence
they proceeded to the Banks home.Constable Prescott had been active in the collection of evidence in the ballot theft case, and had served a number of warrants. Last month he served a writ of attachment on newsprint in the Banks newspaper office. In his "Once in a While" column, the editor attacked the legal procedure, and bitterly flayed Constable Prescott, characterizing him as "a bandit." The last grand jury indicted Banks on a charge of criminal libel for this article. He was also indicted for "criminal syndicalism." He has been at liberty on bonds. Banks Indicted.
Yesterday morning the morning paper was sold under the sheriff's hammer
to the original owner, for $6500. In the afternoon the grand jury
returned a secret indictment, naming Banks as one of the men implicated
in the ballot thefts.For the past six months Banks has been involved in numerous legal woes, in connection with his orchards, newspaper, and mining projects. Most of the suits were for money. Three weeks ago Banks was dispossessed of the paper, on a judgment returned in circuit court. During the hearing Banks acted as his own attorney and left the courtroom during the trial. Banks, the past two weeks, had been issuing a weekly paper from the plant of the Pacific Record Herald. The issue was distributed yesterday, but dated next Saturday, March 18. It contained vitriolic attacks against a local official and the state police, the latter for their activity in the ballot robbery investigation. Came from California.
Banks has been a resident of this city and county for the past five
years, and intermittently for the past ten years. In 1920 he acquired
the morning paper, and spent most of his time here. Previously his
interests were divided between this city and Riverside, Calif. He
became a sort of leader in the fruit industry, and acquired a number of
orchards.In 1930, shortly after obtaining the morning paper, he ran for United States Senator and was overwhelmingly defeated. The depression came, and Banks' interests suffered. His writing became more vehement. He attacked unreservedly state and local officers, and organizations. His bitterness reached a peak during the last campaign. The turn in personal fortunes embittered him, friends said. Since the first of the year, Banks has been a leading figure in the local agitation. He was a speaker at all the courthouse demonstration meets and took an active part in the "Good Government Congress." He was named honorary president of that organization. In recent weeks, the membership in the "congress" has been dwindling away. Banks has a brother living in Oakland, Calif., and it has been reported but not confirmed that the brother was in Banks' home at the time of the slaying. Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 1
BANKS FOLLOWER'S HEAD CRACKED BY INSULTED CITIZEN
L. E. Fitch, prominent member of the so-called Good Government Congress
arrested a short time ago on a charge of "riotous and disorderly
conduct" for alleged participation in flogging with a buggy whip of
Leonard N. Hall, editor of the Jacksonville Miner,
was in the Sacred Heart Hospital this afternoon receiving treatment for
head injuries inflicted this morning, a short time after the slaying of
Officer George Prescott by L. A. Banks, honorary president of the
congress.Fitch, according to his own story, was struck over the head several times with a gun. The attack occurred on West Main Street near the Methodist church. Onlookers who arrived on the scene a few minutes later stated this afternoon that Fitch had contested the right-of-way of an opponent of the Good Government Congress, who was walking toward Banks' home, where the slaying of Prescott occurred. Fitch is also accredited with calling his assailant "stool pigeon" and other uncomplimentary names, after which the man, whose name had not been revealed to officers this afternoon, reached for his gun and cracked Fitch several whacks on the head. The Good Government Congressman was taken to the Jackson County health unit in the county courthouse for first aid treatment and later removed to the Sacred Heart Hospital, where he gave his name as "L. E. Fitch of the Forest Service." His physician could not be contacted this afternoon, but it was understood that his injuries would not be permanent. Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 1 MRS. BANKS TELLS OF THREATS BY HUSBAND TO KILL
Mrs. L. A. Banks, who opened the door this morning through which her
husband shot and killed Officer Prescott, is quoted as stating that she
handed two letters to Officer Prescott, revealing Banks' reasons for
resisting arrest and confirming his previous stand that he would not be
taken and that there would be bloodshed if officers tried to come in.
The letters, according to the statement, were addressed to Chief of
Police McCredie and Captain Lee M. Bown.She is also said to have informed officers that Banks was ready to meet them, that he had done no wrong, and that plans were afoot to railroad him to prison. Mrs. Banks is also claimed to have announced that she would remain in Medford and carry on the fight against the "gang." Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 1 Memorial for Slain Officer Is Legion's Idea
Contributions were already being received this afternoon to erect a
permanent memorial to Constable George J. Prescott, who was this
morning killed by Llewellyn A. Banks. The move is being carried on by
the local American Legion post, Lee C. Garlock stated this afternoon.Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 1 HOME OF BANKS WAS AN ARSENAL POLICE DISCLOSE
That the interior of the Banks house was a miniature arsenal was
discovered when state police investigated the dwelling following the
fatal shooting.There were rifles, revolvers, shotguns, quantities of ammunition and what appeared to be a homemade portable machine gun. All the firearms and ammunition were carted away and placed in safekeeping, but at press time no inventory had been made. That the tragedy was not unexpected in the ranks of the Good Government Congress was indicated by the actions of the ringleaders, at least one and possibly two of them being in the house at the time, and many others in the neighborhood. It is also known that some of the leaders, lacking the nerve to face what was destined to be a showdown, left town late last night and early this morning. It is considered probable that there will be many accomplices involved in the atrocious murder, many of whom will be arrested before the day is over. The heavy hand of the law is expected to extend in many unexpected directions. There was a virtual stampede of Good Government Congress members to get out of the lawless organization, before it was too late. But the officials of the organization either had disappeared or could not find the membership cards. Local lawyers were appealed to and advised members to publicly announce their withdrawals in the press. Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 1 CONGRESSMEN IN POLICE DRAGNET
A score of peace officers this afternoon were making arrests in the
ballot theft and burning case. Joseph Croft, familiar "Good Government
Congress" figure, known as "the man in the cowhide coat" was arrested
this afternoon with two others whose names were not divulged.State police said this afternoon a search was under way for County Judge Fehl, but he had not been located. Authorities expect to have all 21 men indicted for ballot destruction in custody early tonight. Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 1
5 STATE POLICE DUE FROM SALEM
SALEM, Ore., March 16--(AP)--Five members of the state police force
from the Salem headquarters were dispatched to Medford immediately this
morning upon receipt of word from that city of the shooting of
Constable Prescott by Llewellyn A. Banks.More state officers will be dispatched if developments in that city indicate the need for a larger police force, it was announced by Charles Pray, superintendent of state police. Receipt of word of the killing also took another state house employee to Medford. She is Mrs. Nota Henderson, daughter of Constable Prescott, who has been employed in the office of the secretary of state for the past four years. Medford Mail Tribune, March 16, 1933, page 5
The Challenge Is Accepted!
Do the people of Jackson County
want more innocent officers shot down in cold blood, behind the skirts
of some woman?Do they want continued lawlessness, continued pillaging of court houses and burning of ballots? Do they want this reign of terror followed by ANOTHER, until this community is reduced to a shambles, and advertised far and wide as a place where crime is encouraged, sedition lauded, and murder condoned? If they do, then that is precisely what they are going to have. All they need to do now, is TO LIE DOWN AND TAKE IT! There is no regret for this crime on the part of those responsible for it. No remorse. No sympathy for the dead; no human feeling for the bereaved and aged living; not a THOUGHT for the mourning children. The man who fired the fatal shot, who snuffed out the life of a man who had done HIM no wrong, whom HE knew was merely performing his sworn duty, glories in the terrible deed. He proudly tells the world, that under the same circumstances he would KILL again! With a set smile on his face, he walks over the body of his stricken foe, steps off the stage he had prepared with his own hands, to himself escape the fatal sentence he had so pitilessly and wantonly inflicted; and is apparently--SURPRISED!--he did not receive the plaudits of his "Good Government" followers. The woman that had shielded and aided him, that at a given signal stepped aside that the bullet might find a fatal spot, poses proudly for her picture, with a smile on her face--she supposed she shouldn't smile for such a picture--but her amusement couldn't be controlled--she smiled--and smiled--and smiled, adding "This fight will go on!" ANOTHER woman--the president of the Good Government Congress--the woman who boasted of taking the law into her own hands, who declared the ballot boxes that were burned SHOULD have been burned before--has the unspeakable effrontery to claim in one breath she "regrets the tragedy," and in the next: "I would not be a real AMERICAN if I did not continue to fight." "An American!" Continue to fight for WHAT? For BALLOT BURNING, FOR HORSEWHIPPING, FOR DELIBERATE AND PREMEDITATED MURDER! THERE IS THE CHALLENGE, CITIZENS OF JACKSON COUNTY! ARE YOU GOING TO MEET IT! OR ARE YOU GOING TO LAUGH IT OFF--AS JUST ANOTHER ONE OF THOSE "FUNNY THINGS!" Yesterday when the fatal shot was fired, and one of the finest and most fearless officers we have ever had lay crumpled and cold in death, we believed that that shot had at last solved our problem. We felt it would certainly remove the scales from the eyes of Banks' deluded and misguided followers; show them clearly their ghastly and tragic mistake, and putting the leader of this criminal conspiracy to destroy this community behind the bars, would result in the return of peace and security--too late it is true--at too great a price--but we found consolation in that old adage "better late than NEVER!" We were mistaken. We frankly admit our mistake. We underestimated the extent to which this poison had spread; we failed to appreciate the depths of human depravity to which certain sections of Jackson County had fallen. Only a few hours after that editorial was written, this office received an anonymous phone call from some woman who warned this paper to "lay off," who obviously was not only in sympathy with the crime, but rejoiced in it. She agreed with the wife of one of the Good Government leaders, that "George Prescott merely got what was coming to him--that there would be others!" And today, this community is informed, that the fight that has ended in this tragedy, that is solely responsible for it, "MUST GO ON." We don't know how the people of this community feel about it. But we know how this PAPER feels. With that brazenly lawless statement, we heartily agree. That challenge to everything that is right and decent and law-abiding in Medford and Jackson County is promptly accepted. "THE FIGHT MUST GO ON!" Yes, the fight MUST go on--until every individual directly or indirectly involved in this murder is BROUGHT TO JUSTICE! Until EVERY person involved directly or indirectly in the pillaging of the court house and the burning of the ballots, is PUT IN THE PENITENTIARY where he--or she--belongs. Until EVERY person involved, directly or indirectly, in this outrageous and diabolical conspiracy to destroy this community, and overturn the government under which we live--who has contributed in any way--to the campaign of falsehood, character assassination, and calumny--which forms now and has always formed the fertile field in which seeds of hatred and spite have flowered into OUTRIGHT MURDER--is either placed behind the bars or forced to leave this section of Oregon and never return! The issue is plain. It can't be dodged or sidestepped. As this paper called on the people of this community over a month ago to AWAKE--to STAND UP AND BE COUNTED--we now call on them again. And as we declared then, the call is NOT for violence, NOT to return lawlessness with more lawlessness--we need no secret vigilantes, no table-pounding agitation--all we need is what the Mail Tribune knows we have. AN AROUSED AND MILITANT CITIZENSHIP. A citizenship that will support the law enforcement officials we now have; that will stand 100 percent behind constituted authority and the government under which we live; that won't rest, or pause, until this section of Oregon, from Ashland to Rogue River and from the Applegate to Roxy Anne, is cleaned up and freed of these ballot burners, horsewhippers and murderers--and cleaned up and freed of them FOREVER! Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 1
BANKS' DEFENSE PROPAGANDA IS SENT FROM JAIL
The propaganda that has emanated from L. A. Banks, in jail at Grants
Pass for the slaying of Constable George Prescott, on the ground that
he shot in defense of his home and killed an officer performing his
sworn duty as he would "any burglar," has aroused intense feeling
throughout Jackson County and is pointed out as merely another effort
to continue sowing the poison of falsehoods among hs followers in
Southern Oregon.As the law clearly points out, and all authorities agree, when a citizen at home or anywhere else is served with a warrant, he must submit peaceably to service, and any effort to resist is in itself a serious crime. When added to resisting arrest, any person, as Banks did, shoots and kills an officer when engaged in the regular performance of his duties, this act is classified as even a more heinous crime than the killing of a man in the heat of passion and calls for the most extreme penalty that the criminal law allows. Lawyers all assert that this defense Banks is trying to build up only increases the enormity of his crime and accentuates the fact that there is no defense for such a crime whatever. The talk about a man's home being his castle at such a time being simply nonsense--with no standing in law or or jurisprudence whatever. Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 1 PRESCOTT RITES SET FOR SUNDAY AT THE ARMORY
George J. Prescott was born at Rockford, Ill., October 4, 1870, and at
the age of three years moved with his parents to Bagley, Iowa, where he
grew to manhood, and was married to Lottie Ford, who survives and who
is now ill at the Prescott home, 846 East Ninth Street.Three children survive, Francis Prescott, Klamath Falls; Paul of Medford, and Mrs. Nota Henderson, Salem. Also several brothers and sisters residing elsewhere. In 1906, Mr. and Mrs. Prescott and family moved from Iowa to Belgrade, Mont., Gallatin County, where Mr. Prescott later served as chief of police and also as deputy sheriff. In 1920 they came to Medford, and since that time his service to the city of Medford as peace officer is well known to all. George Prescott was a member of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows since a young man, and was a trustee in the local lodge at the time of his death. In this order he had held all the offices and was an ardent worker all of the time for the best interests of the order. He was also a member of the Modern Woodmen and active in the Lions Club, and an executive in the management of the local troop of Boy Scouts. At the outbreak of the World War his age prevented him from enlistment; however, he served every duty where opportunity offered. Funeral services, with Conger Funeral Parlors in charge, will be held at the Armory at 2:30 Sunday, with the Rev. William J. Howell of the Presbyterian church officiating. Interment will be in the family plot in the Medford I.O.O.F. cemetery. Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 1
Indictment of Banks, Wife, Fleming Near
Jackson County grand jury, Theodore J. Bell, Jr., of Grants Pass
foreman, convened at 1:30 o'clock this afternoon to consider the
returning of first degree murder indictments against Llewellyn A.
Banks, the slayer of Constable George J. Prescott, in fulfillment of
his long-boasted defiance of constituted authority; his wife, Edith R.
Banks, and E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist and "Good Government
Congress" worker.Indictments are expected to be returned late today, and the district attorney's office announced that the trio would be arraigned for plea and brought to trial with the least possible delay. Mrs. Banks, transferred with Mrs. Arthur LaDieu from the city to the county jail last night, rested comfortably in a cell with her chief concern about her 12-year-old daughter, and why "Good Government Congresswomen" had not called to proffer consolation. Mrs. Banks maintained the cool and calm mien that followed her detention yesterday, though the mutterings of angry citizens without her cell were said to have perturbed her somewhat. In her one interview after the crime, however, she kept a defiant attitude and, according to officers, treated the entire tragedy, in which she played an important part, flippantly. A report to local authorities this morning from Grants Pass said Banks had started to "worry," though still defiant. He continued to pose as a martyr, and repeated his familiar charges "that justice had collapsed" and that he was the "victim of a frame-up." Fleming Is Serious
Fleming, well known here for the past 15 years, regarded the situation
with more concern and seriousness. He was a caller at the Banks home
when the murder occurred. The authorities are investigating the part he
played before and after the tragedy.None of the three, up to noon, had retained counsel. Neither Banks nor his wife had received word from friend or kin in California, it was reported. Banks is expected to plead insanity, and the state will contest such a defense vigorously. The state will maintain that it was a premeditated murder and that Banks had made threats and boasts that he "would resist arrest" and that he shot from the partial cover of his wife, who stood at the door. The letters signed by Banks, addressed to the chief of police and Captain Lee M. Bown, and found by the body of the slain officer, indicate premeditation, it is claimed. The state is also prepared to show that Banks transacted business and signed deeds and other legal papers a short time before the murder; that his home contained arms, and that the doors were locked with chains. Letters Written Later, Hint
Authorities are also investigating the theory that Banks dictated the
letters after the slaying. Mrs. Banks admits either writing or copying
them. Sergeant James O'Brien, who accompanied Constable Prescott,
denies that any letters were handed to the slain officer, as Mrs. Banks
charges.The state will also show that Banks was warned in a telephone message that he had been indicted, and that a warrant would be served. The authorities last evening questioned Janet Guches, his secretary, regarding what she knew concerning the tragedy and events leading to it. Banks and his wife, in interviews yesterday, both attempted to justify their actions, and Banks condoned the murder by setting forth the plea he was "acting in defense of his home." Mrs. LaDieu Tearful
In the ordinary course of court procedure, Banks and co-defendants
would be brought to trial within two weeks, but it is expected that
every possible legal delay will be invoked by the slayer.The grand jury will also consider the case of Mrs. Arthur LaDieu, arrested yesterday in the police station when she rushed to tell her husband, held as a ballot burner, that Prescott had been killed. She is alleged to have expressed satisfaction at the murder and to have told Officer Cave "And you will get yours." Mrs. LaDieu wept at her imprisonment. An effort will be made to indict her on a felony charge. Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 1 WORTMAN NAMED BANKS RECEIVER
In circuit court this morning F. J. Wortman of Phoenix was named
receiver for the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., of which L. A. Banks, slayer
of Constable Prescott, and his wife are the owners. Wortman was
empowered to take charge at once.The receiver was named upon the application of O. B. Waddell, assignee for the Medford National Bank, recently given a $9000 judgment against Banks for money due on mortgages signed by the accused murderer in 1930 and 1931. At the same time a judgment on a mortgage on the Banks home on West Main Street, where the killing occurred, was ordered, and is approaching foreclosure. Immediately following the slaying, the coroner placed a guard over the Banks home, and no one was allowed to enter. Several applications were rejected yesterday. The custodian will remain in charge until all details of the murder and other angles have been cleared away. Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 1
MRS. LaDIEU IS HELD AS WITNESS IN BANKS PLANS
State police announced today that they were holding Mrs. Arthur LaDieu
as a material witness in the slaying of Constable George Prescott by L.
A. Banks, yesterday. The authorities also said "that several new angles
are developing in the case, which are being scrutinized closely for
leads."The authorities refused to divulge the nature of the "angles," or to deny or confirm a query that a "conference" was held at the Banks home a night or so before the murder. The Banks home is known to have been under surveillance since the threat of a "revolution," and the names of those who attended "the vital conferences" known. Mrs. LaDieu was arrested yesterday when she appeared at the city police station, and asked to see her husband, held on a ballot theft indictment. She expressed satisfaction, it is alleged, at the murder of Constable Prescott and to have told Officer Cave "you will get yours." Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 5
FLOOD OF PHONE CALLS ANSWERED FOLLOWING SHOT
A tornado of telephone calls struck the local exchange yesterday within
a few minutes after the firing of the shot that took the life of
Constable George Prescott on the front porch of the L. A. Banks
residence at 1000 West Main Street. The exchange switchboard, according
to Manager R. B. Hammond, permits 12 operators to work at once. Under
ordinary conditions only five to seven of the "positions" are necessary
to carry the load.Shortly after the tragedy at 10:24, lights began to blink by the hundreds on the switchboard as the girl operators worked frantically to stem the tide of incoming calls. The force was immediately augmented, according to wire chief Jack Ralston, 12 girls being stationed at the board until after noon, when the number of calls began gradually to decrease. Under normal traffic, a girl operator working one "position" at the board can complete 1100 calls per hour. With 12 girls working at top speed, telephone officials estimate 26,640 calls were answered in a period of approximately two hours--the greatest traffic ever experienced at the local exchange. As the tremendous load began to sweep over chief operator Clarita Bernert and her girls, manager Hammond called radio station KMED and asked that a request be broadcast for all to limit telephone use to strictly business as the police and newspapers were being handicapped in use of wire facilities due to the flood of calls. One telephone operator, Mrs. Ada Thornell, who was enjoying her day off duty, had just ordered her lunch at Groceteria No. 2, near the telephone exchange, when she heard the radio in the store broadcasting manager Hammond's appeal. Mrs. Thornell immediately dashed for the telephone office next door, leaving her lunch untasted on the table, and joining in helping keep the telephone subscribers pacified. Another interesting feature of the emergency, according to manager Hammond, was the extraordinarily long conversations indulged in by persons who succeeded in getting their connection. This long use of lines, mainly in discussion of recent events here, was the underlying cause of the number of "line is busy" reports given out by the operators as they answered the calls. Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 6
DEED OF BANKS SHOCKS NEIGHBOR NEWSPAPERS
It will be surprising if L. A. Banks, slayer of a city officer at
Medford, does not set up a defense of insanity. He has long been acting
insanely. It is a great pity he could not have been confined some time
ago. Murder would thus have been averted and a human life saved.(Oregonian.) TRAGEDY AT MEDFORD Banks had openly threatened resistance to any officers of the law who might seek to arrest him. He had openly threatened to take the field in revolution against established authority. It was known that he went armed. Some among his deluded supporters had gone armed also. All these circumstances must set up a presumption of premeditation against the slayer. It is difficult to see how any jury can fail to convict him of murder in the first degree or any court fail to impose the extreme penalty unless insanity shall be proved. There never was a more flagrant exhibition of prostitution of the press than that given by Banks. He used his newspaper to inflame the minds of hillbillies and other simple folks against constituted authority on grounds almost wholly fanciful and fantastic. His own affairs had been going badly for several years, and he had worked himself into a rage against society over it. He indulged in long daily diatribes in his newspaper. He harangued simpletons who would listen until he made them think he was a martyr and that they were being martyred with him. We made them think the courts and officers of the law could be defied with impunity. Some of his followers were mere sick opportunists, but most of them were sincerely deluded. Now there is the climax of murder--committed by Banks. It ought to sober those among his followers who are sincere, and serve as a warning to the others. Such a tragedy ought to show them where they were being led. If Banks and his followers have been contending for anything that matters, that fact does not appear to the neutral informed view. Certainly nothing they have contended for was worth the sacrifice of a human life. The only comfort to be taken from that development is that it will probably mark the beginning of the end of lawlessness in the name of Banksism in Jackson County. ----
"We have now come to that great showdown where blood is liable to be spilled."(Ashland Tidings.) This was the warning issued by L. A. Banks on February 2, while he was publisher of the Medford Daily News--the medium which was used for a period of two years to destroy the peace of Jackson County, to incite men and women to distrust and hatred of their neighbors--and to create in Jackson County an unrest which was climaxed today by the bloodshed which Banks threatened. "Unless justice is restored, I will take the field in revolution," Banks declared on March 6 at a meeting of the so-called Good Government Congress. And today George Prescott, one of the finest officers Jackson County has ever known, lies dead. His blood was spilled by the fiendish creature who preached a doctrine of hatred which has brought to Jackson County a disturbing internal strife which it will require years to eliminate. L. A. Banks, preacher of a doctrine of hatred, suspicion and mob rule, who ran rampant in Jackson County for these two years, today has climaxed his activities in Jackson County by becoming a killer. There is so much that could be said--and yet words are so inadequate. It seems that the internal strife which has done our county such unmeasurable damage could not be settled without this bloodshed. Indifference of the public, or a tendency to sympathize with the chronic complaints of Banks while he edited the Medford Daily News, enabled him to gain power. We should have learned our lesson. ----
At last human blood has been shed in the widespread feud in good old Jackson County.AT THE COST OF A LIFE (Oregon Journal.) Scarcely anything can be more regrettable than the strong play of human passion that for weeks has divided the folks in that splendid district, which nature has so generously endowed. The regret is accentuated by the known high standards of the people whom circumstances and local differences have separated into two hostile camps. The valleys and streams and mountains and scenic beauty of Jackson County are Nature in her best. Sightly old Jacksonville is the center of one of earth's noblest nature pictures, and has history and traditions to match those of any of the pioneer vantage points of the great West with its last frontiers. And in and about Medford and Ashland are scenic wonders, a magnificent outdoors with all the lures and attractions that go with game and trout and salmon streams; and climaxing it all there are culture and hospitality and high human standards seldom matched. And there is in this delightful county a golden story of history, of precious metals and mining and Indians and pioneers that out-romances in actual happenings the storied romances of fiction. To the eye, the famous Table Rocks, visible in the distance, and the mountains in the far environs are a setting that picture to the mind the golden deposits beneath the surface, including actual gold mining under the streets of Jacksonville. In that wonderland of beauty and splendid people and golden history and honorable past may peace return and bitterness vanish and the late past be forgotten and happy days come back. Medford Mail Tribune, March 17, 1933, page 8
HOME RITES HELD FOR ILL WIFE OF MARTYR OFFICER
To the home of Mrs. George J. Prescott, whose condition has been
described as very critical since the premeditated and brutal slaying of
her husband by L. A. Banks Thursday, the body of Officer Prescott was
taken yesterday afternoon.Unable to leave her bed, the stricken widow asked that a short home service be allowed for the Medford constable, for whom public funeral rites will be conducted at the armory this afternoon. The request was granted. Members of the Medford police force, closely associated with "George" for many years, acted as pallbearers. A few immediate friends joined a daughter and two sons at the bedside of Mrs. Prescott, while Rev. W. J. Howell delivered a short sermon. An attending physician stood nearby to administer aid to the failing woman. A few words were said. The casket opened, then closed. And the man, whose heroic service to this community came to a tragic end Thursday with the firing of a rifle, loaded and waiting for him, went out to his house for the last time. Medford Mail Tribune, March 19, 1933, page 1
George Prescott
George Prescott should long be remembered for the kindly manner in
which he executed his official duties. He was modest, quiet and
assuming. If he had a process to serve he served it in a gentlemanly
manner. He took no pleasure out of the misery of the unfortunate.He had been for years a juvenile officer under Judge Ben B. Lindsey, while Judge Lindsey was at the head of the juvenile and family court at Denver. It was Prescott's duty to handle the unfortunate and erring youth whom Lindsey especially sought to help. Yet Prescott served for years in police duty in this city, without this previous service being generally known. By training and nature he was always the friend of youth. Frequently when boys were brought into the police station here he handled their cases himself, and for their best interests. When they were deserving he found them employment, if it could be had. He took a great interest in the high school games. He commissioned some of the high school boys on police duty to maintain order, and through this cooperation performed a great public service. During this depression he was directed to keep the unemployed strangers moving, and while he endeavored to perform this duty, he nevertheless found quarters for these unfortunate people, and made it his business to raise funds by the sale of tickets entitling them to meals at the kitchen that he had helped to create for the purpose of feeding these people. He had a splendid blend of those qualities which make a real human being, and in his quiet, inoffensive way he performed the duties of his office fearlessly and efficiently--the community will want ALL to know that these services were appreciated--E.R.A. Medford Mail Tribune, March 19, 1933, page 4
Banks Holds Defiant Mien in Jail Cell
The grand jury, hearing evidence upon which the district attorney's
office seeks first degree murder indictments against L. A. Banks,
agitator and slayer of Constable George J. Prescott, his wife, Edith R.
Banks, and E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, adjourned Friday
afternoon until Monday morning, to permit the assembling of more
evidence.Banks, in a cell in the Josephine County jail, continued to maintain his defiant attitude, and to claim justification, maintaining that "he shot in defense of his home." He is confined in a cell by himself, under guard, and has no visitors, except his lawyers, T. J. Enright and H. Von Schmalz. His keepers say Banks has expressed no regret for his bloody act. Defense Unrevealed.
No inkling has been given as to what defense Banks will offer.It was reported from Grants Pass that Banks planned to leave the matter of defense "up to Mrs. Banks," and endeavor to shift the blame to her shoulders. The fatal shot was fired with Mrs. Banks as a cover, when she opened the door. Photographs of the murder scene show that Banks stood at least 10 feet behind his mate, out of range, and that he was a good shot, aiming through a narrow opening in the door. The authorities point out that Banks, characteristically, "took no more chances than he had to," and exercised his usual cunning. Fleming Moved.
E. A. Fleming of Jacksonville, arrested at the home of Banks after the
murder, where he was "in conference," and armed, was removed to the
Josephine County jail Friday. His arrest was a shock to his kin, who
have tried to restrain him from taking an active part in the turmoil.
Fleming signed Banks' bond when the first criminal libel action was
filed against the editor. Relatives the following day served notice on
the court that his signature was not binding and that property was not
in his name.Fleming, in the Klan uprising of 1922, was one of the leaders in the Jacksonville district. His incarceration on the murder charge stunned him. Mrs. Banks Calm.
Mrs. Banks, detained in the county jail, retained her composure, and
accepted her predicament calmly. She had a short conference with her
lawyers Friday afternoon, and was visited by her daughter. She has had
no visitors other than these.The authorities report that no word has been heard from Banks' brother, a resident of Oakland, Calif. Banks boasted that his "brother was a millionaire," and would see that he was well represented by attorneys. Officials have taken cognizance of Banks' writings in the past, and noted his printed threats, including: "The time has come for the great showdown. Blood will flow," and his almost constant claims of innocence, when accused of no crime. Defense Long Planned.
The files of the newspaper he printed show that since early last
December he began stressing "innocence of wrongdoing" and "frame-up" in
his writings. The authorities hint he was artfully building a defense
against a day of reckoning. It is also claimed that ardent followers
are now spreading the propaganda that "Banks was driven crazy" and "was
hounded."Practically all upstate papers commented widely on the tragedy. The general trend was that the murder was the natural climax of months of vicious agitation and that Banks will "employ the insanity dodge to save his neck." Medford Mail Tribune, March 19, 1933, page 5
L. A. Banks History Here Full of Turmoil from First Days of His Arrival
L. A. Banks, who rolled into Medford for the first time from the south
in about the year 1925 in a flashy Cadillac car, bringing promises, in
the California manner, of unlimited prosperity for the fruit industry
of the Rogue River Valley; pear crops, oblivious to frosts, and
millions to be brought from the land--left Thursday to occupy a cell in
the Josephine County jail. Police sirens screamed through the city to
mark his departure. With guards to the right and the left of him he was
transported to Grants Pass before enraged citizens could do him harm.(By Eva Nealon Hamilton) Charged with murder in the first degree for the slaying of Constable George Prescott, he remains in the Josephine County jail today. Records in the Jackson County clerk's office show that during the years he has lived or held properties in Medford, he has become involved in 31 civil cases and that four criminal charges have been brought against him. It was during the "good years" that Banks came to Medford. Everybody was prospering. He bought extensive lands, paying a little down, giving mortgages for the remainder. Always immaculately clad, he inspired colorful stories of his greatness. The number of suits in his closet was listed at 40, all tailor-made. None priced at less than $100. Pictures of his "palatial" home in Riverside, Cal. and his home in Medford were carried in the newspapers. Frequent interviews on the fruit situation, the futility of smudging and other reactionary ideas of the newcomer were published. Banks still divided his time between California and the Rogue River Valley. About 1921 one of his first known appearances in the court resulted from a disagreement with the United States government over spray residue. The case was tried in the United States court in Illinois. Banks was defeated. In 1929 he bought himself a newspaper to acquire more space, according to the story, for the advancement of his own ideas for the promotion of property interests in the Rogue River Valley. The first issues of the Medford Daily News carried optimistic stories of the agricultural outlook. Guests were invited to visit the plant on West Main Street, which boasted of mahogany furnishings. Gradually a vein of condemnation began to ooze through the lines of the newspaper. An attack was started against the Farmers' Exchange Cooperative. Employees of the newspaper were informed that their goal was to destroy that business. They were sent out into the country for stories, always with instructions not to publish anything favorable. Other concerns were soon added to the list of "condemned" in Banks' newspaper. A complete turnover of staff was reported at the newspaper, to be followed by other "housecleanings." Business houses, the merchants' association, the ministerial association, state officers, the American Legion, county officers, the circuit court, the supreme court, the Elks lodge, the Granges, the chamber of commerce and the bar association were reviled. In 1930 in the midst of his campaign against practically all existing institutions he announced his candidacy for the United States Senate, opposing Senator McNary. He met with overwhelming defeat. In an answer to the News Publishing Company in the recent suit for recovery of the newspaper, he claimed that up to July 1, 1930, he was a resident of California. It was eight days after that date that he filed his acceptance as a candidate for the Senate. According to the Oregon law six months is the period of time required to qualify for citizenship. Following his defeat in the senatorial race, the barrage of criticism continued. Suit after suit was filed against him in the local courts for collection of money. Then came active participation in local politics. Banks joined with Fehl, who was elected county judge. He supported Gordon L. Schermerhorn in the primaries as sheriff candidate but threw him over in the general election to support an independent candidate, Lowell Zundell. Schermerhorn was elected and received his approval. Phil Lowd was highly recommended as a deputy sheriff, but when he served necessary summons against Banks he was condemned in his newspaper, and Ralph Jennings, bitterly opposed by Banks, described as a good sheriff. The barrage of criticism as court cases became more plentiful centered on the district attorney and other county officials. The Good Government Congress was organized to protest against the officials. Banks was made honorary president. When attorney Gus Newbury finally brought the News Publishing Company case into court, after repeated delays on the part of Banks, the latter armed himself with two revolvers, according to his former counsel, M. O. Wilkins, and declared, "Now bring on Gus Newbury." The newspaper was returned to the original owners less than four years after purchased by Banks. Without the newspaper through which to talk he continued his protests through the Good Government Congress, bringing out a weekly newspaper at the Pacific Record Herald plant. Thursday to serve a warrant issued on a grand jury indictment, involving Banks in the theft of ballots from the court house vaults, Officer Prescott called at his home. He was shot and killed. Less than four years after he came to Medford to make his home, Banks left Medford for a jail cell, his arrest on a murder charge bringing a gruesome climax to his stormy period of citizenship here. Medford Mail Tribune, March 19, 1933, page 7
BANKS' BIG ROLL PROVES A MYTH
The authorities today denied the report that a large sum of money was
found upon either L. A. Banks, slayer and agitator, or Edith R. Banks,
his wife, when searched following their arrest last Thursday for the
murder of Constable Prescott.State police said that when searched in the Josephine County jail, Banks "had a couple of dollars in his pockets," which he sent back to his wife. Mrs. Banks, the authorities said, was searched by the county jail matron. She had a "couple of bills in her purse." A legend among Banks followers has been that he carried a large sum of money in a money belt about his waist. The jail register, which Banks and Mrs. Banks both signed, also shows that neither had any large sum of money. They also signed the property book. Medford Mail Tribune, March 20, 1933, page 1 Thousands at Armory Pay Last Respects to Officer George Prescott
Heads were bowed in sorrow and respect Sunday afternoon as more than
four thousand citizens of Jackson County gathered at the Medford armory
to pay their final respects to Constable George J. Prescott, shot down
Thursday morning by Llewellyn A. Banks, orchardist-editor, on the front
porch of the Banks home when serving papers in the execution of his
duty. It was said to be the largest funeral ever held in Medford.The armory, which has a seating capacity of three thousand, had every chair occupied, and Legionnaires and others from points throughout the county stood in long lines at each side of the hall. All standing room was taken, and several hundred left the building when unable to get seats. Reverend William J. Howell, pastor of the First Presbyterian church, opened the services with prayer, and an octette from the Gleemen sang two numbers under the direction of Sebastian Apollo. The Reverend Howell spoke briefly, telling of the fine character and sterling qualities of the peace officer, who had won thousands of friends during his many years in office here. Appropriateness of the services being held in the armory--a structure built in memory of the brave--was mentioned. An American flag the size of the stage formed a background for the platform, and lovely floral arrangements were banked about the casket. At the close of the service, the members of the I.O.O.F. lodge, of which Officer Prescott was a prominent worker, formed a long aisle from the armory to the hearse over a block away. Rebekahs stood behind them. State police, who marched in a body, stood at salute as the casket passed. Acting as pallbearers were the six city police officers with whom Mr. Prescott had served. They were Chief of Police Clatous McCredie, Lou Bloom, William Peck, Joe Cave, J. H. Liggett. and Ray Sloneker. The procession, which City Traffic Officer Thomas H. Robinson led on his motorcycle, was followed by the Elks band. Legionnaires and lodge members were also in the cortege, made up of 114 automobiles. Members of the city fire department and volunteer firemen were stationed on each street corner from the armory to the I.O.O.F. cemetery, where final rites were conducted by the order. The sidewalks to the edge of the city were lined with citizens. Medford's city council attended the services in a body, and officials and deputies from the county court house were also present. Out-of-town people here for the rites included George Alexander of Salem, assistant superintendent of the Oregon State Police; James Manuel, chief of police, Grants Pass; Lee I. Moon of Ashland, federal prohibition investigator, and District Attorney and Mrs. W. T. Miller of Grants Pass. Charles P. Pray, superintendent of the Oregon State Police, left the capitol for Medford, but urgent duties in the north called him back. Members of the Prescott family were in attendance, with the exception of Mrs. Prescott, seriously ill at her home. Medford Mail Tribune, March 20, 1933, page 1
AIR-TIGHT CASE AGAINST BANKS POLICE BELIEVE
The grand jury convened again this afternoon to consider first degree
murder charges against L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor and
orchardist, his wife, Edith R. Banks, and E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville
orchardist, for the ambush slaying of Constable George J. Prescott last
Thursday morning while at the Banks home to serve a warrant.Grand Jury Continues Probe As Special Prosecutor Wm. Levens Eyes Evidence Prepared by Police Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens, named by the governor as special prosecutor of the murder and criminal syndicalism cases, spent yesterday and this morning going over the evidence and confessions collected in the murder and various other cases. He was assisted by the district attorney's office and state police who have assembled what is characterized as "an air-tight case." Two Indictments Hinted
The grand jury was reported as finding two indictments yesterday in
cases connected with the murder. They will be presented to the circuit
court tomorrow, when Circuit Judge W. M. Duncan is expected to return
to the bench here. The grand jury is expected to be in session for a
considerable length of time investigating the large amount of matter in
the restoration of peace in Jackson County.Banks is still confined in the county jail at Grants Pass and maintains his defiant attitude, without a sign of regret or remorse. He is reported as spending his time justifying his crime to his jailmates and guards, and reading. The state will contend that his act was premeditated. Evidence has been found tending to show that Banks expected a rush of followers to his house following the killing. Urged "Congress" Meet
The evening previous he issued his weekly paper, in which he attacked
the state police and belittled the expected indictments for ballot
robbery. The sheet also urged that all "Good Government Congress"
members be present at the trial of Henrietta B. Martin the morning of
the murder. In accordance with this plea, the courthouse corridors were
crowded. At the time, it had been announced, published and broadcast
that the trial of Mrs. Martin would not be held until after the
pressure of business in the district attorney's office had slackened.Many rushed to the Banks home when the murder became known, but the horror of it caused most of his followers to express revulsion, and denounce him bitterly. They left for their homes, and many realized they had been made dupes by a crafty and cunning disturber. The state also has the names of visitors to the Banks home for three or four evenings before the killing. Six or eight cars were parked at the home on these occasions. Wants Outside Lawyer
The authorities reported that Mrs. Banks was making an effort to secure
a Portland or San Francisco lawyer to defend them. Mrs. Banks Monday
sent a telegram to an acquaintance in Salem, asking that he recommend
an attorney. Attorneys Enright of this city, and H. Von Schmalz of
Burns, have been representing the pair to date.So far the brothers of Banks, and relatives of his wife, in California have not come forward with legal aid, according to officials. One of his brothers lives in Oakland, Calif., the other in Los Angeles. Banks claimed both were millionaires. The authorities report they are substantial, law-abiding citizens of moderate means, and highly respected in their communities. Of the three held on information charging first degree murder, E. A. Fleming of Jacksonville alone has shown signs of sorrow, and a deep realization of the seriousness of the crime he faces. Fleming's family vainly used every means in their power to induce him to cease relations with Banks. When Fleming signed the first bond for Banks, on a criminal libel indictment, relatives notified the court that his surety was invalid, as no property was in his name. Medford Mail Tribune, March 22, 1933, page 1 HOME OF BANKS IS TURNED BACK
The home of L. A. Banks, scene of the murder of
Constable George J. Prescott last Thursday, and held under a coroner's
guard since then, was formally turned back to Mrs. Edith R. Banks late
yesterday. The home was placed under guard for the safekeeping of
evidence.The home is under a mortgage for $4500, for which the Medford National Bank recently filed suit for foreclosure. A petition for the guardianship of Ruth Mae Banks, 12, daughter of the accused pair, was filed March 14. The document was first filed the Saturday before the bank holiday was called, and its filing was delayed. Mrs. Edith R. Banks is named guardian. The bonds were ordered corrected this morning in an order signed by the probate court. Some slight legal inadvertence existed. Mrs. Banks is still confined in the county jail without bonds. She requested to be taken to the house, and it was denied. Medford Mail Tribune, March 22, 1933, page 1
BANKS AND WIFE ARE CHARGED IN PRESCOTT DEATH
Llewellyn A. Banks, agitator, former editor and orchardist, and his
wife, Edith R. Banks, in a joint indictment returned this noon by the
grand jury, are charged with first degree murder for the slaying of
Constable George J. Prescott on the morning of March 16, while the
officer was in the act of serving a warrant upon Banks for indictment
as one of the Jackson County ballot thievesFleming's Connection with Ambush of Officer Comes Up Later-- Mrs. Martin Among Lesser Indicted The full text of the indictment read as follows: "Then and there being, and then and there acting together, did then and there unlawfully and feloniously, purposely and of deliberate and premeditated malice, kill one George J. Prescott by then and there shooting him, the said George J. Prescott, with a rifle loaded with powder and bullets, which said rifle he, the said Llewellyn A. Banks, then and there had and held in his hands." No action was taken at this time relative to E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, arrested while attempting to flee the murder scene by the back door. It is understood that the grand jury will consider his case soon. Fleming Nervous.
Fleming, who has been held in the Josephine County jail the past week,
was lodged in the county jail here late yesterday. He was described by
jail attendants as in a high state of nervousness, worn from worry and
losing weight rapidly.Time for the arraignment for pleading of Banks and his wife on the first degree murder indictment has not been set, but will be at an early date, officials indicated. Under the first degree murder charge, they are not subject to bail. Banks is held in the Josephine County jail at Grants Pass; Mrs. Banks in the jail here. Few Present.
The indictments were returned at the noon hour, after the adjournment
of the Schermerhorn ouster proceedings, and received by the court.
Three women spectators, including Mrs. C. H. Brown. mother of Henrietta
B. Martin, eating their lunch in the courtroom; two men spectators and
court attendants were the only persons present. The indictments were
presented and received by Circuit Judge Duncan.At the same time, indictments charging Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the "Good Government Congress," her father, C. H. Brown, secretary of the organization, and L. O. VanWegen and L. E. Fitch with "riotous conduct and disturbing the peace" were returned. The indictment grew out of Mrs. Martin's attempt to buggy-whip Leonard Hall, editor of the Jacksonville Miner, on Saturday, March 4, when she took the law into her own hands to gain redress for an article published in Hall's paper. Fitch and VanWegen are alleged to have attempted to hold Hall, and Brown, her father, to have purchased the buggy whip. Slander Indicted.
[omission] of "slandering a bank," as the result of an article published in the Pacific Record Herald,
a weekly formerly published by Earl H. Fehl, in which Brown charged
over his signature that money had been removed from the Farmers and
Fruitgrowers Bank of this city, contrary to the bank moratorium
regulations. The charge was afterward completely refuted and definitely
proven false and unfounded.Bonds in the buggy-whipping case were fixed at $5000; in the bank slander case at $1500. The first degree murder indictment against Banks and his wife were generally regarded as a foregone conclusion, and they were presented in court during a lull in the proceedings to prevent any "courtroom dramatics." Few outside of official circles knew they were to be returned today. Recess Grand Jury.
Following the presentment of the indictments, the court recessed the
grand jury, subject to the further call of the district attorney's
office and Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens.Proceedings in the indictment against Banks and his wife will be held as fast as legal procedure will permit. It has been indicated that the murder charge will be given the right of way over other criminal matters, and that the ballot theft indictments will come second. These are regarded as the most vital matters. Banks, in his Josephine County jail cell, was reported today as still defiant, and assuming the role of martyrdom. He is under close guard, and smokes cigarettes incessantly. Mrs. Banks was reported as irritable, but calm and confident. Medford Mail Tribune, March 24, 1933, page 1
Mrs. Martin and Banks Enjoy Cigarets' Solace Behind Cold Iron Bars
Her face wreathed in great clouds of smoke from her own cigarettes,
Henrietta B. Martin, president of the Good Government Congress,
indicted by the grand jury for criminal syndicalism, remains decidedly
cheerful in her cell in the Jackson County jail today, her jailers
reported this afternoon.She buys her own and smokes her own, they stated, and has received few callers. Although repeated requests of her followers to visit at her cell have been denied, Mrs. Martin continues gay. Her mother, Mrs. C. H. Brown, has called frequently, but her husband, R. A. Martin, if at all, unidentified [sic]. And while she in her gay pose smokes like a "miniature Vesuvius," L. A. Banks, honorary president of the congress, wreathes his face in a similar barrage in the Josephine County jail at Grants Pass, where he is the last member of the Jackson County group to be retained. E. A. Fleming, charged with him with murder in the first degree for the slaying of Constable Prescott, has been moved to Medford. T. L. Brecheen and C. W. Davis, indicted for the ballot theft, were brought to the local jail several days ago. The expenses of prisoners incarcerated in Grants Pass will be borne by Jackson County, and authorities are expected to transport Banks, also, to Jackson County's jail this week. His chief requests, as reported in Grants Pass, are for more cigarettes. He smokes constantly, the jailers report, while outside the jail strict supervision of traffic and parking is maintained to prevent cars being left near the jail, which houses a killer. Banks' attitude regarding the slaying of the officer remains calm and determined as he blows his smoke rings. He is by no means "downcast" by his imprisonment or the death of the Jackson County officer. Mrs. Banks, who sheltered him in the doorway when the fatal bullet was fired from Banks' rifle, was also calm today, following nervous disorders of yesterday, jailers stated. She was attended by Dr. F. G. Swedenburg of Ashland Thursday and had regained her composure this morning. Like Mrs. Martin, she is alone in her cell and communicates with few persons except her attorneys. Although strong in her determination to carry on her husband's fight in this county, as she told interviewers, she does not exhibit the gaiety that is Mrs. Martin's. Medford Mail Tribune, March 24, 1933, page 9
BANKS' BROTHER IN OHIO ASKS FACTS
Letter from a brother of L. A. Banks, indicted for murder in the first
degree for the slaying March 16 of Constable George Prescott was
received yesterday by Chief of Police Clatous McCredie, from Wakeman,
Ohio.The brother, Clarence C. Banks, for 25 years a police officer in Cleveland, Ohio, wrote for full details regarding the trouble in which Banks is involved. He stated that he had learned of the tragedy through the Plain Dealer and felt that the chief of police would know the truth of the whole case. He further stated that he was shocked at receipt of the news through the press and would not rest until details were learned. The letter was the first word from a relative of the accused man, known received here. Medford Mail Tribune, March 26, 1933, page 1
HAMMERSLY OF PORTLAND MAY BE BANKS' ATTORNEY
Initial steps have been taken by Mrs. Edith R. Banks, jointly indicted
with her husband, L. A. Banks, former agitator, editor, and orchardist,
for first degree murder for the slaying of Constable George J.
Prescott, Thursday morning, March 16, while attempting to serve a
warrant for Banks' arrest as a ballot thief, to retain Joseph
Hammersly of Portland as attorney to conduct the defense.Brother of Slayer Due for Conference on Defense Plans-- No Arraignment Date Set for Slayer. Attorney Hammersly, formerly a resident of Gold Hill and a member of a pioneer Southern Oregon family, was in the city Friday and yesterday, conferring with the accused pair. Hammersly is a former deputy prosecutor for Multnomah County. He is reported to have been recommended by a high state official, to whom Mrs. Banks last Monday sent a telegram seeking suggestions. The name of the state official is said to have been State Treasurer Rufus C. Holman, now en route to old Mexico, and the center of an upstate political storm. Banks' brother, a realtor of Los Angeles and an attorney from that city, are now reported en route. Definite word relative to the retention of attorney Hammersly is expected, soon after a family conference. Attorneys T. J. Enright and H. Von Schmalz of Burns, counsel for County Judge Fehl, and several others indicted for ballot stealing, have been acting as counsel for Banks and his wife. Attorney Von Schmalz said that Banks' brother and attorney were expected to arrive late yesterday, and confirmed Mrs. Banks' statement that additional counsel would be employed, "and would be welcomed." The state now claims to have a complete picture of what happened in the Banks home for an hour before the wanton slaying of Constable Prescott, and that neighbors and pedestrians gave testimony relative to the arrival and departure of persons and autos at the murder scene, over a "rather long period." The grand jury, which is scheduled to meet again this week, for further consideration of testimony in the county turmoil, is expected to take further action in the case of E. A. Fleming of Jacksonville, orchardist, who was in the Banks home at the time of the killing, and was arrested when he attempted to flee by the back door. Fleming is also one of the men indicted in the ballot theft cases. His family for several weeks endeavored to keep him from becoming embroiled in the "good government congress activities," without success. He was an active worker and talker in the ranks. No time has been set for the arraignment and pleading of Banks and his wife to the first degree murder charge. It is not likely to come to pass until after their attorneys have had a chance to study the case, and prepare necessary legal papers. It is not likely that the district attorney's office will be ready to proceed until the grand jury has completed most of its work. Both sides have expressed a desire for an early trial. State police continue to collect evidence in the murder and allied crimes. They are checking back on the past of several of the men accused. The authorities refuse to deny or confirm the report "they have plenty of confessions, and the whole story." Medford Mail Tribune, March 26, 1933, page 1
BANKS LODGED IN MEDFORD CELL
Llewellyn A. Banks, ex-editor and orchardist, jointly indicted with his
wife Edith R. Banks for first degree murder for the slaying of
Constable George J. Prescott on the morning of March 16 last, was
lodged in the county jail here shortly after 11 o'clock this morning.FAMILY CONFAB IS SLATED FOR NAMING LAWYER Accused Slayer of George Prescott Whisked from Grants Pass to Local Bastille Without Trouble. The accused slayer was brought from Josephine County jail at Grants Pass, heavily manacled and under a state police guard. He was taken there on the day of the murder. Has No Cellmate
Banks occupies a cell in the county jail almost directly over the court
house steps from where he preached agitation and threatened revolution
in "protest meetings." He has no cellmate. The cell is large and
commodious, but with no areaway in the rear. The only means of communication is through the door window.No undue excitement accompanied Banks' return here. Few knew he was coming. Jailers said he was cool and normal and smoking the inevitable cigarette when marched into the jail reception lobby. A regulation search was made and Banks placed in his cell. He saw no one but his keepers. His cell is away from the department where former aides accused of ballot robbery and criminal syndicalism are kept. His wife, who has not seen him since the murder, and Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the "Good Government Congress" and chief aide, occupy cells in the women's ward a considerable distance away. Family to Confer
Banks, his wife, and brother W. A. Banks and attorneys expect to hold a
family conference this afternoon. W. A. Banks told authorities that he
would have to return at once to his business in California. At the
conference it is expected counsel will be formally retained. Attorneys
T. J. Enright and H. Von Schmalz have been representing the Banks to
date. Joseph Hammersly of Portland and Glen R. Jack of Oregon City are
upstate lawyers here. Jack, according to Oregon City Information, came
here Saturday afternoon by plane in response to a telephone call.State police report that Banks on the trip from Grants Pass had little to say, but discussed the weather and other casual subjects with officers. He was whisked into this city by the Pacific Highway and down Main Street to the court house. The state police followed the most direct route. Arraignment Delayed
Arraignment of Banks and wife and other indicted men for ballot theft
is not expected until next week. There will be no judge on the local
bench until next week.The grand jury resumed sessions this morning and will probably be in session the entire week, probing other angles to the Prescott murder, the ballot robbery and the criminal syndicalism charges. E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist held in the county jail on an information charging first degree murder for the slaying of Constable Prescott, is worried and has lost considerable weight. Fleming is also under indictment, reports say, for ballot stealing. Courthouse report said he would be called before the grand jury some time this week. Fleming, who was at the Banks home when the slaying occurred, was arrested when he attempted to flee by the back door. His family had vainly endeavored to keep him from the activities of the "Good Government Congress." Ward Still Ill
Claude Ward, brother-in-law of Banks, indicted as one of the ballot
stealers, is seriously ill at his home, it was reported this morning.
He will not be arrested until his health in fully recovered. Ward is
the only indicted man not in jail, or at liberty on bonds.J. F. Wortman, named receiver for the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., one of the Banks orchard holdings, has assumed charge. The Medford National Bank holds a $4500 mortgage against it, in process of foreclosure. A similar legal action is under way against the Banks home, where the Prescott murder took place. No further action has been taken in the affidavit of prejudice filed against Judge W. M. Duncan by County Judge E. H. Fehl. Technicality Delays
It automatically delayed the arraigning of Fehl to enter a plea. Last
week Fehl filed a motion to quash the indictment against him, on the
grounds that Judge Duncan had no authority to receive the indictment,
and that the grand jury did not hold its sessions in the regular grand
jury room.Fehl contends that Judge Duncan was assigned here February 7, to hear the case of O. B. Waddell against L. A. Banks. The supreme court order directs him to hear this case, "and all other business of a judicial nature that may come before him, until further notice." The district attorney's office holds that the indictment against Fehl is legal and valid, and the room in which it was prepared has no effect upon its legality or validity. Medford Mail Tribune, March 27, 1933, page 1
BANKS' BROTHER PLANS DEFENSE ON LOCAL VISIT
W. A. Banks of Tujunga, Cal., brother of Llewellyn A. Banks, who faces
a first degree murder indictment for shooting Constable George J.
Prescott March 16, was a visitor at the Grants Pass and Medford jails
Sunday, calling on his brother and Mrs. Banks, jointly indicted with
her husband.The Californian, accompanied by John A. H. Sturgeon of Monrovia, said he had no statement to make concerning the defense or counsel for L. A. Banks, and that they were here to find out the details of the case. Mr. Banks said he found his brother in "high spirits" in the Josephine County jail, and said his only hope was that L. A. Banks would be able to hold up until after the trial. The two men stated they did not plan to remain here for any length of time, but would probably decide on the attorneys to represent Mr. and Mrs. Banks before leaving. W. A. Banks last saw his brother two years ago, on a trip south, he said Sunday, and hius visit yesterday revealed that the local man's health did not seem as good, he stated. Mr. Sturgeon said that Banks had been receiving excellent care in the Grants Pass jail. The Tujunga man received first reports of the murder the afternoon of March 16 over the radio. He said he had not had time to communicate with his brother, Clarence C., who resides in Wakeman, Ohio. He also has a sister living in Cleveland. Medford Mail Tribune, March 27, 1933, page 3 BANKS AND WIFE ARRAIGNED; WILL PLEAD BY APR. 10
L. A. Banks, agitator, ex-editor and orchardist, and his wife, Edith R.
Banks, charged with first degree murder for the slaying of Constable
George J. Prescott March 16, were arraigned before Circuit Judge W. M.
Duncan this morning. The husband and wife were given until Monday,
April 10, to enter a plea.The accused pair were represented in court by attorney T. J. Enright of this city and Judge Sturgeon of Los Angeles, Calif., who came here Sunday with W. A. Banks, brother of the accused. The state was represented by Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens. The entire proceedings took less than ten minutes. The state indicated that it would desire an early trial, "but without undue haste." The arraignment took place in the same court house where Banks, acting as his own attorney in a civil action a month ago, left in a huff after vigorous thumping of a table. Then the courtroom was packed with sympathizers. Today there was only a handful of people in attendance, including a number of state policemen. Banks wore a dark striped suit, and was calm and silent. He has lost weight since his incarceration. He was escorted to and from his cell by state policemen and chief jailer Fred Kelly. Mrs. Banks, dressed entirely in black, stood by her husband's side and betrayed no nervousness. She was in the custody of the matron. Neither spoke to their attorneys. While no definite announcement is yet forthcoming, it is expected that the trials of the ballot stealing defendants will be called within the month, barring legal delays. It is the intention to arraign all the defendants in the ballot thievery this week, including Arthur LaDieu, Walter J. Jones, mayor of Rogue River, Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn and County Judge E. H. Fehl. Fehl has filed an affidavit of prejudice against Judge Duncan. A new judge will be assigned here to hear his plea, it is thought. The above are at liberty on bonds. Medford Mail Tribune, March 28, 1933, page 1
RECEIVERSHIP FOR SUNCREST SOUGHT BY CREDITOR HOST
Suit for a temporary receivership, and collection of $15,400 allegedly
due, against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., of which L. A. Banks is
president and manager, is sought in a suit filled in circuit court this
afternoon. Halbert S. Deuel of this city is named as temporary receiver.The suit is also directed against Blake, Moffitt & Towne, the Carlton Nursery Co., the State Industrial Accident Commission, E. C. Corn, O. B. Waddell, the Medford National Bank, Miller-Sanford Tractor Co., J. E. Lester and William Berthold Barnum, creditors who have received or have instituted judgment proceedings. The suit asks that a receiver be appointed to protect the orchard properties and make them ready for the 1933 crop, and further recites that L. A. Banks is in jail, charged with an unbailable offense, and is insolvent and unable to meet obligations. The complaint asks that the properties be sold at foreclosure, and that the claim of the First National Bank be first, with the other claims secondary in payment. Four years' back taxes upon the orchard properties amounting to $6.524.19 are also alleged due and collectible. The suit is instituted to protect the rights of creditors, and to continue the orchard business until disposed of according to Oregon law. Medford Mail Tribune, March 28, 1933, page 7 FIVE ADMIT BALLOT THEFT Good Gov't. Congress Members Plead Guilty; Banks and Wife Arraigned They are C. Jean Conner, vice-president of the congress, arrested in an abandoned mine shaft near Gold Hill two weeks ago; Wesley McKitrick, alleged guard of L. A. Banks, slayer of Constable George Prescott; R. C. Cummings of Wimer; Wilbur and Mason Sexton, brothers, the first arrested in the ballot case, and known as "courthouse boarders." It is expected that others indicted will also plead guilty. It is understood that sentence will not be passed until all have come to trial. Banks Arraigned
L. A. Banks and Mrs. Banks were arraigned before Judge Duncan Tuesday
in connection with the murder of Constable Prescott. Only a small group
was present, the time of the hearing not having been made public to
prevent unnecessary disturbance. They were given until April 10 to
enter their pleas on the case.Attorneys Joseph L. Hammersly of Portland, brother of John Hammersly of Gold Hill, and a former resident of the city, will defend the Banks, aided by attorneys Phipps and Enright of Medford. A brother, W. A. Banks of Tujunga, California, came this week and will aid his brother during the trial. Banks is one of the 21 indicted in the ballot case, also. Sensational evidence in the ballot theft was brought out last week during the hearing of the plea to remove Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn from office. Officials also admitted that at least a dozen signed confessions had been secured. Details of what happened the night the ballots were taken continue to come to light. Latest disclosures are that cheers of the Good Government Congress group, in a meeting at the courthouse that night, drowned the noise made when the window was broken through which the thieves gained entrance. It is said that L. A. Banks was making a speech, and as he made an especially sensational statement, leaders of the applause group stamped their feet and cheered. At the same time a Ford car was started back of the courthouse and the combined din drowned the sound of the breaking glass. In another speech made later, Mr. Banks raised aloft his fountain pen with a match stuck under the clip, forming a crude cross. Although those not "on the inside" wondered why this caused so much commotion, it has been revealed that it was a prearranged signal indicating that the ballot stealing was in progress. Gold Hill News, March 30, 1933, page 1
BANKS' MANAGER SUES FOR WAGES
Suit was filed this afternoon in justice court by J. A. (Arthur) LaDieu
against L. A. Banks, for $250, allegedly due for wages while acting as
business manager of the News when the morning paper was under tis control of Banks.A writ of attachment, with Electa A. Fehl as surety, accompanied the complaint. The writ did not specify what was to be attached. LaDieu is under indictment for ballot theft and at liberty on $7500 bonds furnished by Prof. C. Engelhardt, Mrs. Clara Ribley Smith and Mrs A. Pinne. Medford Mail Tribune, March 31, 1933, page 1
BANKS SOLACED BY BIBLE STUDY IN COUNTY JAIL
L. A. Banks, agitator, ex-editor and orchardist, held with his wife,
Edith R. Banks, on a joint indictment charging first degree murder for
the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott on the morning of March
16th, spends most of his waking time reading the Bible, according to
jail attendants. Banks finds solace in the Scriptures. He is an
uncomplaining prisoner. He occupies a large cell alone, directly above
the courthouse steps, where three times since the first of the year he
preached turmoil and advocated revolution.Banks also stands indicted for a role in the bunglesome ballot theft. It was the resistance of the service of a warrant on this charge that brought him to the ignominy of a murderer's cell. Banks is solemn and thoughtful. The only sign of the strain is a slight loss of weight, and a dull pallor to his face. In contrast to Banks and his wife, E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist held on an information charging first degree murder charge, was in a happy mood today and laughed and joked with visitors to the felony cell of the county jail. Fleming was a visitor at the Banks home when the murder was committed. He was arrested while attempting to flee the scene by a back door. Circuit Judge W. M. Duncan is expected to be here the first of the week for proceedings in the ballot-stealing cases. A number of men indicted for the crime are reported to be scheduled to enter guilty pleas then. Five entered guilty pleas this week. Sentence will not be passed until the case is finished. Medford Mail Tribune, March 31, 1933, page 4 BONDHOLDERS OF L. A. BANKS SEEK RECEIVER NAMING
Halbert S. Deuel, named temporary receiver for the Suncrest Orchards,
Inc., has taken charge of the property, pursuant to court order. A
hearing has been ordered for April 21, to show cause why the
receivership should not be made permanent.The receivership was sought upon the application of the First National Bank, acting as trustee for bondholders of the Suncrest Orchards, Inc. No money is owing the First National Bank by the Suncrest Orchards, Inc. The original bond issue floated by L. A. Banks, president and resident manager, was for $25,000. Bonds were sold to people throughout the land. The First National Bank filed suit for the bondholders. The Suncrest Orchards, Inc., include three tracts comprising a total of 202 acres of trees in full bearing. Simultaneous with the appointment of the temporary receiver, suit was started for recovery of $15,400 due on the bond issue, and directed against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc. and creditors holding judgments. The complaint sets forth that the bonds are protected by a first mortgage, and urges that the bonds be paid first. Five years unpaid taxes, amounting to more than $6000, also stand against the orchard property. The complaint further cites that Banks is in custody, charged with an unbailable offense, and is insolvent, and that legal action is necessary to prevent the orchards from deteriorating and to secure the 1933 crop. Medford Mail Tribune, March 31, 1933, page 4
BANKS AND WIFE DRAFT DEFENSE WITH LAWYERS
L. A. Banks, agitator, ex-orchardist and editor, held in the county
jail with his wife, Edith R. Banks, on a joint indictment charging
first degree murder for the wanton slaying of Constable George J.
Prescott on the morning of March 16, held a three-hour conference in
his cell yesterday afternoon with his attorneys, Joseph L. Hammersly of
Portland and William E. Phipps and Thomas J. Enright of this city.Preliminary plans for the defense were mapped, but no definite announcement was made. Another conference is scheduled for today. Near the end of the conference yesterday, Mrs. Banks was brought from her cell and joined it. According to jail attendants, Banks was depressed following the interview, but was in a more cheerful frame of mind this morning. While no definite announcement has been made, it is general belief of lawyers and laymen that Banks will plead insanity as a defense. Former friends of the accused man say it is his personal wish to plead invasion of his constitutional rights as justification for the murder, but it is believed this is contrary to the advice of his attorneys. Letters dictated by Banks to his police and city police, warning them against serving a warrant, and with a threat of bloodshed, will be used as evidence by the state. The letters were found after the slaying. There in also a record that Banks within a half hour of the murder transacted business. His statement, after the crime, that he "shot George Prescott like any other burglar, and would do it again," will also be used by the state. At the Sheriff Schermerhorn ouster hearing, Deputy Sheriff Phil B. Lowd testified that Banks threatened to kill him, "If you ever try to take me out of my home on a warrant." Banks continues to read a Bible daily, but there is no indication he takes this charge against him seriously, Mrs. Banks has begun to weary of jail life, and has adopted a more concerned mien towards the accusation. The pair have but few visitors. In justice court yesterday Janet Guches filed suit against Banks, who formerly employed her as secretary, for $250 for wages, the full amount allowed under the law. A writ of attachment was also issued with the suit. It was filed on Banks' Cadillac coupe. It developed this morning that it is mortgaged, and otherwise legally involved. The holder of the mortgage was reported as having turned back the mortgage to the former secretary. Last week Arthur LaDieu, former business manager for Banks, filed a suit for the same amount, with an attachment. No return has been made as yet upon the attachment by the sheriff's office. Claude Ward, a brother-in-law of Banks, among those indicted for ballot theft, and whose arrest was delayed because of his illness, was reported as convalescing rapidly. He will be arrested as soon as he is pronounced well by his doctor. Medford Mail Tribune, April 4, 1933, page 1
BANKS REQUESTS SHOT OF LIQUOR FOR HIS STOMACH
Application has been made by L. A. Banks, agitator and ex-editor and
orchardist held in the county jail on a first degree murder charge for
the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott, for medicinal liquor, and
the request will be granted. The request was made yesterday to the
county physician, who will write a prescription.According to jail authorities, Banks has a slight touch of stomach trouble and needs a stimulant, due to confinement. Filling of the prescription is possible at a number of local drug stores, under federal law, which permits purchase of a pint every ten days. The prescriptions provide, as a rule, "for three tablespoonfuls a day, when required." The cost of a pint of medicinal liquor runs from $2.50 to $4, depending on age and brand of the beverage. The medicinal liquor will be kept under lock and key, and be in the custody of the matron and chief jailer, who will do the pouring. The stimulant was also requested as a sleep producer. There is nothing unusual in granting the request, a health step, it is said. Attorneys for Banks were today making ready for the first legal steps in their fight to save him from the gallows. No announcement has been made of defense plans, but it is generally conceded by lawyers and laymen that an insanity plea will be the basis of the defense. Banks is said to have objected to this, and desires to introduce a "defense of the castle" plea, on the grounds that "his constitutional rights were invaded" when the warrant was served. If insanity claims are made the basis of the defense, the state is prepared to show by documentary evidence that Banks was rational for a considerable period before the murder, transacted important business but a short time before, and dictated lucid letters to the state police and city police heads but a short time before the actual deed, warning them not to attempt to serve the warrant charging ballot stealing, and threatening bloodshed, and "probably resulting in my own death." The state in contesting the insanity plea, if it is made, will contend among other things that Banks is "a profound egotist, with a tendency to make homicidal threats." Under Oregon law, Mrs. Banks, jointly accused with her husband of murder, cannot testify against her husband. The state alleges she played a leading secondary role. Banks immediately following his arrest declared he acted in defense of his rights, and that [he] "shot Prescott the same as he would any other burglar--and would do it again." Medford Mail Tribune, April 5, 1933, page 1
NOT GUILTY PLEA BY BANKS, WIFE IS PRESENT PLAN
It was announced this afternoon by attorney T. J. Enright that L. A.
Banks and his wife, Edith R. Banks, charged with first degree murder in
the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott, would enter a plea of not
guilty. Attorney Enright did not amplify the statement.The decision whether or not the accused pair would be tried separately or together will be made later. It is the supposition that the defense will be based upon Banks' contention that he was acting in defense of his home when he slew the officer bearing a warrant for his arrest upon an indictment for ballot stealing. It was first reported that Banks would plead not guilty by reason of insanity. Medford Mail Tribune, April 6, 1933, page 1
MYSTERIOUS TAPS NEAR BANKS' CELL KEEP JAILER BUSY
Mysterious tappings in the courthouse last night after midnight kept
chief jailer Fred Kelly alert and exercising vigilance. The tapping,
which sounded like pounding on concrete, was first noticeable about 1
o'clock, and awakened jailer Kelly.He went to the law library directly under the cell holding L. A. Banks, accused murderer of Constable George J. Prescott, on the theory that someone might be attempting to gouge a hole through the wall. Later he went to Banks' cell and found the prisoner sound asleep. Hourly visits were made to Banks' cell, and each time he was unawakened. This morning it was discovered that the tapping noise was made by a workman in putting new curtains in the courthouse, and that it necessitated pecking holes with a chisel on each side of the window. Banks is now suffering from a sore throat and slight cold. A cold cure from the jail medicine chest was given him. His prescription for medicinal liquor has not yet been filled. Banks was reported as having had a stormy session with counsel yesterday. It was announced yesterday by attorney Enright that Banks and his wife, Edith R. Banks, would enter pleas of not guilty when arraigned Monday. This action was not unexpected, and does not preclude Banks from later entering the plea of "not guilty by reason of insanity." It is expected that Banks will offer a plea of self-defense, and that he was acting in "defense of his castle." It is possible that Banks may use all three pleas. Courthouse reports say that Banks objects to an insanity plea because of his extreme vanity. State officials are silent on what evidence they have collected, or the number of witnesses they will call. They will contest an insanity plea, if entered, with evidence that Banks transacted business and performed rational duties almost up to the time of the slaying, and they expect to show he "was a profound egotist, given to homicidal threats," and not insane within the Oregon laws covering the point. The matter of whether Banks and his wife will be tried separately or together will be decided later. Medford Mail Tribune, April 7, 1933, page 1
BANKS, WIFE CLAIM PREJUDICE
L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor and orchardist, and his wife,
Edith R. Banks, jointly indicted for first degree murder for the wanton
slaying of Constable George J. Prescott March 16th last, employed the
law's delay this morning in circuit court when arraigned for pleading
to the charge.LAW TECHNICALITY DELAYS TRIAL FOR PRESCOTT SLAYER Usual Stereotyped Objection Entered for Pair-- New Judge to Be Appointed Soon Is Expectation An affidavit of prejudice against Circuit Judge William M. Duncan of Klamath County was filed shortly before ten o'clock by Banks' attorneys, Joseph Hammersly of Portland and T. J. Enright and William E. Phipps of this city. The affidavit was in the usual stereotyped form, and alleged that the defendants could not secure a fair and impartial trial before Judge Duncan, and that the legal move was not made for the purpose of delay. New Judge Coming Soon
Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens asked the court to wire
the supreme court, requesting the assignment of a new judge. The court
said it would make the request immediately. It is anticipated that the
high court will take quick action, and that a new judge to hear the
plea will be here Thursday or Friday.Under Oregon law, the defendants have the right to file another affidavit of prejudice, and it is predicted such action will be taken with the new appointment when made. The new Oregon law, passed by the last session of the legislature, limiting affidavits of prejudice to one without producing evidence to prove their contention, is not effective until June 9. Affidavits of prejudice filed by former Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn and County Judge Earl H. Fehl and 21 others indicted for ballot theft were not brought to the attention of the court this morning. The state asked for a continuance. Schermerhorn was scheduled to enter a plea today. His attorney, Frank J. Newman, filed a prejudice affidavit shortly before ten o'clock. Early Trial sought
It is the evident intention of the state to move for an early trial of
the murder charge against Banks and his wife, and to take up routine
matters in connection with the ballot theft charges thereafter. The
state hopes to have all the cases at issue by the end of the week, and
the trial dates set.Thomas L. Brecheen, claimant of "25 years personal friendship with President Roosevelt," Oliver Martin and Joseph Croft, indicted for ballot theft, entered pleas of not guilty this morning. Banks and his wife, under guard of three husky state policemen and chief jailer Fred Kelly, entered the courtroom through the judge's chambers shortly after 11 o'clock. They took seats among their attorneys. Banks was dressed in a freshly pressed light-colored spring suit, with a diamond pin in his necktie. Jail attendants said he spent most of the morning preparing for the courtroom appearance. Outside of paleness, and loss of jauntiness, there was no noticeable change in the man. He smiled wanly upon the well-filled court room. Glances at Crowd
Mrs. Banks was dressed in black, and as soon as seated started a
conversation with counsel. Her husband had little to say, but cast many
sidelong glances at the crowd.The proceedings, as far as the Banks were concerned, took less than five minutes, and they then were ordered back to their cells. The courtroom crowd was limited to the seating capacity. A few people lingered in the hall, which was under guard of special officers, Among the early arrivals were Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the "Good Government Congress," and catspaw of Banks, accompanied by her father, C. H. Brown, and Mrs. C. H. Brown. Mrs. Martin wore a new hat. Court was delayed an hour, owing to auto trouble, and Judge Duncan reached the bench an hour late. Medford Mail Tribune, April 10, 1933, page 1
BANKS IS SUED BY SCHUMACHER
George Schumacher, chemist, this afternoon filed suit against the
Suncrest Orchards, Inc., and L. A. Banks for $1715, due for asserted
professional services rendered for Banks and the Pear Growers
Association in the cultivation, propagation, and packing of pears. The
complaint sets forth that it was agreed that Schumacher should receive
three-quarters of one cent for each packed box, and that no part was
paid, "though frequently demanded."Medford Mail Tribune, April 11, 1933, page 1
BANKS' SECRETARY GIVEN JUDGMENT
Judgment on attachment was decreed this morning in Justice of the Peace
William R. Coleman's court, in favor of Janet Clement Guches against L.
A. Banks, her former employer. She sought $250, the full amount under
the law, for wages as stenographer, allegedly due.The attachment covers the following items, now said to be in the Daily News office: One mahogany counter, one wicker davenport, one office partition, one furnace, one oil burner, two swinging gates, one piece of linoleum, one filing stool, one wicker chair, one wicker stool, and two oil paintings. The plaintiff was formerly secretary for Banks, and is said to have been at the home of Banks on the morning of the Prescott slaying, but left a short time before the grim tragedy. Medford Mail Tribune, April 11, 1933, page 8
BANKS TO ASK CHANGE OF VENUE
In scarcely audible voices, L. A. Banks, former editor and orchardist,
and his wife, Edith R. Banks, this morning entered pleas of not guilty
to the indictment charging first degree murder for the slaying of
Constable George J. Prescott at the Banks home on the morning of March
16, while the officer was endeavoring to serve a warrant for Banks'
arrest on a ballot theft charge.NOT GUILTY PLEA ENTERED BY PAIR ON ARRAIGNMENT Ex-Editor and Wife Murmur Denial of Murdering Prescott-- Attorney Says Move Not for Delay. The defense, in a surprise move, served notice of its intention to file a motion for a change of venue, through attorney W. E. Phipps. Attorney T. J. Enright informed the court that the motion would be filed by tomorrow morning, and the court set that time for hearing of arguments. Deny Delay Object
The two defendants entered their not guilty pleas before Circuit Judge
George F. Skipworth of Lane County, assigned by the state supreme court
to hear the case. The upstate jurist will hear the case in its
entirety, it is expected. The defense has another day in which to file
an affidavit of prejudice, but this move is not anticipated.Attorney Phipps in serving notice of a change of venue informed the court that "in spite of the propaganda in the papers, the defense is not seeking delay." The court replied, "I am here only to hear the case." Murmur Denials
Banks, attired in a dark gray suit, was first to plea. He answered in a
low voice, "Not guilty." Mrs. Banks then spoke the same words, in
exceedingly low voice, heavy with nervousness. The couple were then
escorted back to their cells by the state police, the sheriff, jail
matron, and chief jailer.The entire proceeding took less than ten minutes. Arguments on the change of venue motion will be heard tomorrow, and attorney Phipps stated the motion would be supported by affidavits. The change of venue motion, it is said, will contend that owing to the state of public opinion, the defendants would have their constitutional rights jeopardized, and owing to the wide publicity, difficulty would be experienced in securing a jury. The state will contest the motion. Court Room Filled
Promptly at 9:30 o'clock, Judge Skipworth ascended the bench. The
seating capacity of the courtroom was filled a half hour earlier. The
bailiff ordered a man in the rear of the room to be seated, with the
words: "No one is allowed to stand." Attorney Phipps was the only
member of defense counsel present when court was called. Attorney
Enright entered a few minutes later.Henrietta B. Martin, president of the late so-called "Good Government Congress," and active lieutenant of Banks in his political efforts, and her mother, Mrs. C. H. Brown, arrived too late to gain entry to the court room. The door bailiff denied admission because all of the seats were occupied. Mrs. Martin was disappointed, but made no effort to gain entrance after the emphatic refusal. Change Up to Court
The court has the right, under Oregon law, following the arguments of
both sides to deny or grant the motion for a change of venue. The
court, in the event the change to another county is granted, has the
right to designate the county in which the trial shall be held.Following the completion of the change of venue plea, the court will set the trial date. The motion for a change of venue was unexpected. If granted all the witnesses in the case would be transported to the new trial site, and the expense would be greatly enhanced. Following the entering of pleas Banks and his wife had no comment. Jail attendants said the pair were affected by the proceedings, and are beginning to view the charge against them seriously. In the courtroom at the time were petit jurors called to serve in a civil action. Judge Skipworth, assigned to the case yesterday by the state supreme court following the filing of an affidavit of prejudice against Judge W. M. Duncan of Klamath County, arrived last night by auto, after a day in his own court. He was accompanied by Mrs. Skipworth. Continue Ballot Case
The state, through Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens, asked
that the ballot theft cases, in which Judge Duncan was disqualified by
filing of six affidavits of prejudice, be continued further. Judge
Skipworth asked if any actions were to be presented.The affidavits of prejudice were filed by County Judge Fehl, former Sheriff Schermerhorn, J. C. Croft, Walter Jones, mayor of Rogue River, John Glenn, former county jailer, and Arthur LaDieu, all indicted on the ballot stealing charge. The state has indicated that it desires to try the Banks murder cases first, and to clear away the preliminary legal moves before taking up the ballot theft cases. The matter of whether or not Banks and his mate will be tried together or separately is a decision that rests exclusively with the defense. Medford Mail Tribune, April 12, 1933, page 1
BANKS GRANTED VENUE CHANGE
L. A. Banks, ex-editor and orchardist, and his wife, Edith R. Banks,
charged with first degree murder for the slaying March 16 of Constable
George J. Prescott, will be tried in Lane County, it was announced this
afternoon when the change of venue requested by the defense was granted
by Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth. May 1 was set as date for the
opening of the trial. Expenses of all witnesses from Jackson to Lane
County and return will be borne by this county, it was also reported
this afternoon.TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR LANE COUNTY STARTING MAY 1 Judge Skipworth Orders Former Orchardist-Editor and Wife on Trial for Murder at Early Date Curry County Wanted.
When the change of venue motion was granted in court by Judge Skipworth
he indicated that Douglas County would be the site of the trial. The
defense counsel, through W. E. Phipps, proposed Curry County, which was
rejected by the court. The defense objected to placing the trial in
Josephine County, charging that "scurrilous" articles had been
published in the Grants Pass newspapers.Judge Skipworth left the bench to telephone Judge Hamilton of Douglas County, to determine if the state docket would permit a speedy trial. Time and place of the trial was announced later in the afternoon. In granting the motion for a change of venue the court held "that, owing to the situation here which permeates every corner of the county, in the court's judgment an impartial trial could not be secured." The court observed that it would require weeks to obtain a jury, and "that the ends of justice would best be served by moving the trial to another county." The defense entered an affidavit signed by the two defendants charging that the press and citizens of the county, including the "Committee of 100, was engaged in the dissemination of false, defamatory and prejudicial matter," and "that mob violence had been threatened by friends of the slain officer." The affidavit further admitted that Banks was, previous to the crime, devoted to the publication of a newspaper "devoted to criticism," and that by so doing he had aroused the "enmity of business men, citizens, organizations and interests of the county." Attorney W. E. Phipps read excerpts from the Mail Tribune which he characterized as prejudicial to the defendants, including one editorial and an article giving a history of Banks' career here [March 19, above]. He charged that the press published "highly colored articles" against the defendants. The [account], before attorney Phipps had finished reading all the press comments, was cut short by the court, who at the same time advised the state "that in my judgment the trial and case should be moved to another county, for the best interests of all concerned." The state made no resistance to the change, following the ruling of the court. Banks throughout the short proceedings sat with quiet demeanor but took a lively interest in the acts of his attorneys at the finish. Both defendants were more serious than on their previous appearances. The courtroom crowd was again limited to the seating capacity. Medford Mail Tribune, April 13, 1933, page 1 BANKS ASKS CHANGE VENUE
Probable change of venue to either Klamath Falls or Grants Pass was the
new development this week in the coming trial of L. A. Banks and his
wife, Edith R. Banks, charged with the slaying of Officer George
Prescott.Wants Trial Where Jury Is Not Likely to Be Prejudiced The change was asked by the defense, after the appointment of Judge G. F. Skipworth of Lane County to succeed Judge W. M. Duncan of Klamath County appointed earlier to hear cases at this term of Jackson County court. Judge Skipworth will hear the trial wherever it is held, unless a second affidavit of prejudice is filed. This is not thought likely. Both Mr. and Mrs. Banks entered pleas of not guilty before Judge Skipworth Wednesday morning. They are charged jointly with the murder, but whether they will be tried jointly rests with their counsel to decide. Officer Prescott was killed by a shot from a gun in the hands of L. A. Banks, March 16. Mrs. Banks held the door open through which her husband fired the shot, and it is alleged that she is also guilty of crime. Prescott had gone to the Banks home in Medford to serve a warrant for Banks' arrest on a charge of having aided in the ballot stealing early in February. Mrs. Banks came to the door in response to his knock, but refused to accept the paper or allow it read, and was about to close the door when Banks called a warning to her to "duck" and fired, killing Prescott. It is understood that the twenty men charged with the ballot theft will not be tried until the murder case has been tried. Gold Hill News, April 13, 1933, page 1 BANKS' PROPERTY TO BE SOLD FOR DEBT TOMORROW Judgment in the Waddell case has been entered in circuit court, and the sale has been set for tomorrow morning at ten o'clock at the courthouse. The judgment is against that portion of the Suncrest Orchard, Inc., known as the Pepper & Taylor tract on one cause, and on the other against residential property on West Main Street, where the murder of Constable Prescott occurred. The home was originally built by John M. Root, and was purchased by Banks when he first came here. The sale will be from the front steps of the courthouse, almost directly beneath the windows of the cell Banks now occupies. It was on these same steps that Banks appeared as orator to "demonstrations," and from which in his last public remarks he proclaimed a "revolution." The action scheduled for tomorrow is independent of the suit filed recently by the First National Bank, acting as agents for bondholders of the Suncrest Orchards. Inc., against Banks and creditors of the orchard company, seeking $15,000. In this action, H. S. Deuel was named temporary receiver. A hearing to make the receivership permanent is set for a week from tomorrow, Saturday, April 22. Medford Mail Tribune, April 14, 1933, page 1
Banks Trial Expense $6,000-$10,000
It is estimated that the expense of trying Llewellyn A. Banks and his
wife, Edith R. Banks, charged with murder, in Lane County will cost
approximately $1000 per day. Jackson County pays all cost, which
includes judge's salary, juror fees, witness fees, mileage between this
county and Eugene, transportation of defendants, subsistence for them,
and incidental expenses such as stenographers and bailiffs.ESTIMATE $1000 DAILY COST FOR TRYING SLAYERS Judge, Jurors, Witnesses and Mileage Will Pile Up Expense-- Joint or Separate Trial Not Yet Decided The trial is expected to last not longer than six days, which would bring the estimated cost to $6000 for joint trials and to approximately $10,000 if separate trials were asked by the defendants. Local Jail Safer
Banks and his wife will probably be taken to Eugene the Saturday before
Monday, May 1. The county jail here is regarded as more modern and safe
than the Lane County bastille.The question of mileage for witnesses remains to be settled. In counties over a population of 50,000, the state law names 10¢ per mile. Lane County is in this classification. In counties below 50,000 population, which includes Jackson County, the mileage fee is 15¢. Whether the Lane County or the Jackson County rate will obtain remains to be determined. Many To Testify
Witnesses will probably be ordered to report Monday, May 1, starting
date of the trial, at the Lane County courthouse. The number of
witnesses to be called is still problematical. The state may call
around 25, and the defense probably as many.The two defendants, indicted jointly, have the right under Oregon law to decide whether they shall be tried separately or together. The decision rests with them. If separate trials were asked, the cost would be proportionately more, but the mileage costs would be eliminated, as the witnesses would be kept in Eugene, and the second trial started as soon as the first was concluded. Many county officials figure that the Lane County trial costs would be less than the case would incur here, as less time would be expended in securing, questioning, and mileage for jurors. ----
Ruling of Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth transferring the trial to
Lane County of Llewellyn A. Banks, agitator, former editor and
orchardist, and his wife, Edith R. Banks, charged with first degree
murder for the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott on the morning
of March 16 while Banks was resisting service of a warrant for ballot
stealing, was viewed today by Jackson County citizens generally as a
wise and just decision, alike for defense and state and future public
welfare.The court ordered the trial held in Eugene, starting Monday, May 1, after Douglas County had been considered and Josephine and Curry counties proposed. Judge Skipworth, after telephone communication with Douglas County authorities, learned that no jury term would be held there before May 23 and, following a short conference with attorneys for both sides, ordered the case heard in Lane County. Defendant Satisfied
According to jail attendants, Banks, following the granting of the
change of venue, expressed satisfaction. Banks and his wife will
probably not be transferred to the Lane County jail until a few days
before the trial. The order granting the venue directs that both
defendants be held in their present cells "until further orders of the
court." Banks assumed a more serious mien at the Thursday afternoon
proceedings. He glanced over the legal papers prepared by counsel and
then passed them to his wife for her signature. During most of the
proceedings he sat with chin resting on his folded hands and in deep
thought.The state made no resistance to the change following the comment of the court that "it is my judgment no fair and impartial trial could be secured here, where an unusual situation, akin to no murder trial ever held in the state, permeates every nook and corner of the county, and the air is heavy with the cross-currents of many prejudices." Hard to Get Jury Here
The court further observed: "You would be weeks in securing a jury,
which would offset the expense of moving the trial to another county."
The court also observed that "the court, the state and the defense have
a solemn duty to perform in seeing that the defendants have a fair and
impartial trial--they face the most serious of all criminal charges."The court also ordered that all original papers and transcripts in the murder case be transferred at once to the county clerk of Lane County, in the personal custody of Lee M. Bown, state police captain for the Southern Oregon district. The defense was allowed two weeks' time to make ready for trial at their own suggestion. They have the right to ask further time if they see fit. Would Spare Strain
The general public, long stirred by political turmoil and agitation,
also expressed satisfaction that the trial would be held in another
county. It was felt by many that the change of venue would spare the
county the fevered emotional strain of the trial, and the attendant
public excitement, also that a verdict by a jury drawn in another
county, once returned, would prevent the case from being a
controversial or political issue in Jackson County for months if not
years.Judge Skipworth will retain jurisdiction in the case and will hear it in his own district. He indicated he desired to dispose of the trial as quickly as possible, consistent with justice and the law. The trial date is approximately six weeks after the murder of Constable Prescott. Judge Skipworth and wife, who accompanied him here, returned to Eugene today. He was assigned here on an affidavit of prejudice filed by Banks against Judge Wm. Duncan of Klamath County. Medford Mail Tribune, April 14, 1933, page 1
Banks in Women's Ward and Wife in Hotel During Trial
EUGENE, April 15.--(Spl.)--When Mrs. L. A. Banks comes to trial here it
will be the first time a woman has been tried for murder in Lane
County. There is no matron at the Lane County jail, so special
provisions will have to be made for the housing of the Jackson County
woman. She will probably be placed in the city jail or in a hotel room
with an attendant.The women's cell of the county jail will be scrubbed and cleaned to receive Banks. The Lane County jail is old and out of date. Medford Mail Tribune, April 16, 1933, page 1
SELF-DEFENSE IS VIEWED AS ARCH OF BANKS' CASE
There are three lines of defense, under Oregon law, for L. A. Banks and
his wife, Edith R. Banks, awaiting trial at Eugene, Oregon, Monday, May
1, on a charge of first degree murder for the slaying of Constable
George J. Prescott March 16 last, while the former editor-orchardist
was resisting arrest on a warrant issued on an indictment charging
ballot-stealing.Three Lines Possible Under Oregon Law Say Attorneys-- Inkling Given, But No Definite Statement The defenses possible, attorneys say, are not guilty by reason of insanity, which Banks is reported to have scorned, self-defense, which embodies proof or belief of great bodily harm, or non-commission of the crime, by reason of not being present at the scene, or the crime was committed by another, or "third party." All three defenses can be used together or separately. The defense of Mrs. Banks, which is closely linked with that of her mate, lawyers said, will be that as an accessory. If such, she acted unwittingly, and in a wifely manner, without questioning the intentions of her mate. The Oregon law holds an accessory equally guilty in the commission of a crime. Inkling Given
Self-defense is viewed by local lawyers as the probable keynote of the
Banks fight for his life. They say an inkling of this was given in the
change of venue hearing, when the accused pair filed an affidavit
alleging that Banks' writings in vitriolic criticism has caused
"enmity" in the public mind and blamed the press and "Committee of 100"
for the asserted attitude. A supplementary defense plea, it is
forecast, will also claim that Banks, the principal actor in the tragic
drama, was acting under an emotional strain and in the belief that he
was "defending his castle."The state has indicated that in opposition to any defense that may be offered, it will introduce evidence to show that Banks acted with premeditation over a considerable portion of time; that Constable Prescott [acted] in the lawful performance of sworn duty, and that the fatal shot was fired in fulfillment of oft-repeated written and spoken threats against life. Among the state witnesses will probably be former Deputy Sheriff Phil Lowd, who testified at the Schermerhorn ouster hearing that Banks had threatened his life "if you ever try to take me out of my house on a warrant." Defense counsel have given no indication of their defense, and it is highly probable that it will not be definitely known until revealed in the Lane County courthouse during the course of the trial. The state will also probably combat any insanity defense, with contention that Banks was "a profound egotist with homicidal threat tendencies," and prove that he performed rational acts. in a normal manner before and after the murder. Banks Home Sold
Another chapter in the tangled financial affairs of Banks in this
valley was recorded Saturday morning, when from the courthouse steps,
at a sheriff's sale, his home on West Main Street, where Constable
Prescott was slain, was sold on a bid of $2,495.55. At the same time
the Pepper & Taylor orchard tract, one of Banks' several orchard
holdings in this section, was sold on a bid of $8,052.46. Both
properties were sold on judgments issued in favor of O. B. Waddell,
acting as assignee for the Medford National Bank for payments of
mortgages issued on promissory notes for loans of approximately $11,000
from the banks to Banks in 1929-1930.The home was originally built by John M. Root, a former well-known local resident, at a cost of between $7500 and $10,000, about 20 years ago. It was purchased by Banks for $8000 several years ago. The Pepper & Taylor tract during the boom days here sold for $45,000, and was first purchased by J. F. Wortman of Phoenix for $25,000. Banks is said to have agreed to purchased it for $40,000. The Suncrest Orchard, Inc., bondholders have a suit pending against the property, with other units for $155,000 allegedly due on bonds. Only a few people witnessed the sale, including two former employees of Banks. The only bidder was attorney George M. Roberts, acting for the Medford National Bank and its assignee, O. B. Waddell. The sale was from the courthouse steps, almost directly beneath the window of the cell occupied by Banks. From the steps Banks addressed "demonstrations," and in his last speech therefrom proclaimed a "revolution." In Better Spirits
According to jail attendants, Banks since the granting of the change of
venue has shown a revived confidence and cheerfulness. He eats well,
sleeps well, and spends his waking hours reading Harvard classics, the
Bible, playing solitaire and exercising in his cell, which is the
largest and most comfortable in the county jail. He sees his wife daily
and is allowed visits with friends and kin.The state started Saturday to arrange the preliminary details of the transfer of the case to Lane County, per court orders. The county clerk's office next week will have certified copies of the originals, and the original copies of the records in the case, prepared for delivery to the county clerk of Lane County by the state police, under the personal supervision of Capt. Lee M. Bown. Banks and Mrs. Banks will be held in the county jail "until further orders of the court," which probably means they will not be taken to Lane County for the trial until a short time before it opens. As soon as the Banks murder trial is completed the state will proceed at once with the trial of the ballot-stealing cases. Medford Mail Tribune, April 16, 1933, page 1
MATTHEWS SUES BANKS ON NOTE
Suit was filed in circuit court late yesterday by R. A. Matthews
against L. A. Banks [and] his wife, Edith R. Banks, for $5000,
allegedly loaned on a note secured by a mortgage on a portion of the
Pepper & Taylor orchard tract, which was in Banks' hands.O. B. Waddell, as assignee for the Medford National Bank, and W. H. Norcross of the Central Point district, and the News Publishing Company are named as joint defendants. All three parties obtained judgments against Banks. The Medford National Bank foreclosed on its judgment last Saturday at a sheriff's sale of the orchard and home property. Norcross sued last winter, obtaining judgment against Banks and others. It was in this case that Banks refused to answer a subpoena from the circuit court, and in his defiance of constituted authority wrote the court [a] letter, refusing to answer the summons. Medford Mail Tribune, April 18, 1933, page 2
NURSERY SUING BANKS ON TREES
The Carlton Nursery Co. today filed suit in circuit court against the
Suncrest Orchards, Inc., L. A. Banks, president, and seven parties who
have obtained judgments against the Suncrest Orchards in the past six
months.The nursery company asks for $435.05 for trees furnished and planted for the orchard company in 1930, for which it asserts it has not received payment. The tangled financial affairs of Banks have resulted in a number of actions being filed against him and his orchard company, most of them before he was placed in jail to answer to a first degree murder charge. Next Saturday a hearing is scheduled in circuit court to make permanent the receivership of H. S. Deuel, who was named temporary receiver following the filing of a suit for $15,000 by bondholders of the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., for money due. Last Saturday a portion of Banks' orchard holdings and his home on West Main Street, where Constable George J. Prescott was slain, was sold on judgments for money loaned by the Medford National Bank. It was reported that a move was afoot to file an involuntary petition for Banks in federal court at Portland for the benefit of creditors, but his attorney reported he knew nothing of the plan. Banks yesterday, following several sessions with attorneys for creditors, issued a request to the chief jailer that in the future they be referred to his counsel. The request was granted. Medford Mail Tribune, April 19, 1933, page 3
INTIMATE BANKS AND WIFE STAND TRIAL TOGETHER
The decision whether they will be tried together or separately rests
with L. A. Banks, former editor and orchardist, and his wife, Edith
Robertine Banks, jointly indicted for first degree murder for the
slaying of Constable George J. Prescott on the morning of March 16th,
while Banks was resisting service of a warrant on an indictment
charging ballot theft. The two defendants have been advised by counsel
[that] the matter is one for their own determination.Friends of the accused intimate that they will face the Lane County jury, which will decide their fate, together. The trial is scheduled to start Monday, May 1, at Eugene. Oregon law gives them the right to decide, any time before the actual start of the trial. The state has announced it would try Banks first, in the event separate trials were asked. Attorney T. J. Enright, one of the counsel for Banks, said yesterday that the defense would be founded upon the general plea of not guilty. Under this plea the defense will have the right to introduce evidence to show insanity, self-defense, "defense of the castle," and gives them a wide latitude in the matter of evidence. Under the general not guilty plea the defense can use one or all of the possible defenses. The defense attorney said that between 15 and 20 witnesses would be called in their behalf. The state will contend that Banks acted with premeditation and without justification, that he was "legally sane" at the time of the firing of the fatal shot, that his spoken and written words, immediately after and before the murder, and his acts for the same period were rational and sane. Banks' notes to city and state officials, warning them of "bloodshed," and his statement to the state police and in the Josephine County jail will constitute part of the evidence to be introduced against him at the trial. Attorneys of the city and county see a similarity between the Banks case and that of Dr. Richard M. Brumfield, insofar as legal insanity is concerned. Dr. Brumfield, a Roseburg dentist, slew a hermit by the name of William D. Russell, to perpetrate an insurance hoax. He was convicted and sentenced to hang. Insanity was interposed as a defense. In the Brumfield trial, the Oregon law covering insanity as a defense was carried to the state supreme court and upheld in a ruling on an appeal. The Oregon law holds that insanity when used as a defense must be sufficiently shown as "dethroning reason," and that eccentricities or delusions of the defendant is not insanity within the legal meaning of the term. The insanity under the Oregon law must be proved "beyond a reasonable doubt." Because of the prominence of Brumfield in Douglas County, and the fiendish premeditation involved in the murder of Russell, the trial attracted state and national attention. Brumfield was arrested in Canada where he was employed as a farmhand and made his escape by wearing women's garments. Medford Mail Tribune, April 20, 1933, page 5 "Intimate" in the headline is a verb.
BANKS WORRYING; PACES CELL AS COURT DAY NEAR
L. A. Banks, agitator and former orchardist, scheduled to go on trial
Monday, May 1, for the murder of Constable George J. Prescott on the
morning of March 16 last, while Banks was resisting service of a
warrant on a ballot theft indictment, has changed from the Bible to
psychology as a solace, according to county jail attendants.Slayer of Prescott Turns from Bible to Psychology Study to While Away Hours in County Bastille Banks has told friends and jailers that he "expects to be on the stand three days." He expresses confidence to acquaintances, but jailers say that the past week he has been worried and has spent several sleepless nights, pacing his cell. He still maintains a bold front to visitors but has requested that attorneys in the many civil suits against him be denied interviews, but instead referred to his counsel. Mrs. Banks Calm
Mrs. Banks retains her calm
attitude and whenever allowed to see her mate gives him cheer as much
as possible.Despite claims to the contrary, there is a strong belief in legal circles that Banks will plead "not guilty by reason of insanity." Lawyers of the county and state have expressed the opinion that it is the only defense, and that his counsel will go against their client's wish and employ it in the Eugene trial. An insanity defense must be presented by alienists and medical experts. It is pointed out that if the insanity defense is used Mrs. Banks' position is made more precarious as an accessory. The state contends her opening the door, through which Banks fired the shot that slew Constable Prescott, enabled her mate to use the rifle and at the same time disarmed the arresting officers of suspicion and gave him the protection of the center room from which he fired. The state holds that if Banks had opened the door himself he would not have been able to use the rifle and that the officers would have taken more precaution. Knew Officers Coming
The state will also show that Banks knew the officers were coming to
his house with a warrant; that he wrote notes warning them he would
resist arrest and threatening bloodshed; that Banks was not above the
service of a legal process, despite his written and spoken defiance of
constituted authority; that the murder was premeditated with willful
and wanton malice, and that plans for flight had been made. Threats
against the law written by Banks will also be introduced and his
statement following his arrest attempting to justify his act, and his
boast that he "would do it again."The state will contest any insanity claims with the contention that Banks is not, and was not, insane, but "rational, and a profound egotist given to homicidal boasts and threats." Woman Creates Scene
Wednesday was visiting day at the county jail, and kin of many of the
prisoners came. One was a woman from Ashland who created a mild scene
when denied a visit with Banks. Her loud talk ceased when the chief
jailer threatened expulsion.Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens, who has charge of the murder prosecution, returned this morning from Salem, Eugene and other upstate points. He will remain here until the Saturday before the Lane County trial of Banks, arranging details. Medford Mail Tribune, April 21, 1933, page 3
26 WITNESSES FOR STATE CALLED IN TRIAL OF BANKS
The state will start serving subpoenas Monday, for its witnesses in the
trial of L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor and orchardist, and
his wife, Edith Robertine Banks, charged with first degree murder for
slaying March 16 last Constable George J. Prescott, as a tragic climax
to many weeks of turmoil in this county.Subpoenas Served Monday--Bankruptcy Petition in Federal Court Against Accused by Local Creditors The state will call 26 witnesses, and all will be ordered to report at the Lane County courthouse in Eugene on Monday, May 1, when the trial will start. The defense has stated it expects to call 20 witnesses. Banks and his wife will be removed to the Lane County jail the last of next week upon a court order, under the direction of the state police and the sheriffs of Lane and Jackson counties. As much secrecy as possible will accompany the transfer, and once made a heavy guard will be placed over Banks. They will be kept in separate jails, owing to the lack of prison accommodations in Eugene. The trial will be concluded in a week, it is forecast. In federal court, at Portland yesterday, a petition was filed asking that Banks and his wife be adjudged bankrupts. The petitioners are the Southern Oregon Gas Corporation, whose claim is based on a promissory note for $10. George Schumacher, who claims there is due him for chemist services, $175, and Moore Hamilton, former Banks employee, who holds a promissory note for $50. It is expected that the petition will be augmented by claims of other creditors. In circuit court here yesterday, Judge H. D. Norton issued an order making Halbert S. Deuel receiver for the Suncrest Orchards, Inc. The receivership application was made upon a suit for $15,400, instituted by the First National Bank in behalf of bondholders. Deuel was directed to take charge of the properties "[illegible] the final determination of the case." He was named a temporary receiver March 21 last. Signs multiply that insanity will be the foundation of the Banks defense, with supplemental pleas. The state will contend that Banks knew the difference between right and wrong, and is not insane, under the meaning of the term in Oregon law. They will hold that "eccentricity," "delusions of greatness," "morbid tendencies," and "profound egotism with an inclination to make homicidal threats and boasts" is not insanity. Banks is said to be opposed to the insanity plea. Circuit Judge Skipworth of Eugene, who will hear the trial, has ordered space cleared in the courtroom for lawyers, witnesses, and the press. A ruling that the courtroom be cleared at noon has also been issued, and only those able to procure seating space will be admitted to the courtroom. The court also forbids eating lunch in the courtroom. Attorney Joe Hammersly of Portland conferred yesterday with associate counsel, attorneys T. J. Enright and W. E. Phipps. They will confer with Banks and wife in the county jail today, and map final plans of defense. Medford Mail Tribune, April 23, 1933, page 1
BROTHER-IN-LAW OF BANKS COMING WEST FOR TRIAL
George F. Moran, former owner of
the Cleveland Plain Dealer, and his wife, Evelyn, sister of L. A.
Banks, who goes on trial for first degree murder next Monday in Eugene,
will be among relatives of the accused man in Oregon for the trial, W.
E. Phipps, defense counsel, announced today.Mr. Phipps received a wire today from the retired Ohio resident stating that he would arrive in Portland with his wife on the Great Northern Friday and would stay at the Benson Hotel until continuing to Eugene for the trial. He asked attorney Phipps to inform Mr. Banks of his plans. Attorney Phipps stated that he would be leaving Medford Thursday for Eugene to prepare for the opening of the trial Monday. The defense is ready to present its case, he stated, adding that he saw no cause for any possible delay in the trial. Joseph L. Hammersly of Portland, who will also represent Banks and wife, Edith R. Banks, jointly indicted for the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott, has returned to Portland after a long conference with the accused and attorneys here. Asked about plans of the defense, attorney Phipps explained that he would have no statement to make regarding steps to be taken to uphold the plea of not guilty before opening of the trial. Such a revelation, he stated, would be unethical. Attorney Phipps was uncertain today whether or not other relatives of Banks and wife would attend the trial in Eugene. Banks has two brothers in Southern California, C. O. Banks and W. A. Banks. The latter came to Medford soon after Officer Prescott was killed to confer with his brother. At that time he intended to return for the trial. Another brother resides in Ohio, but has not communicated with Banks' attorneys. Medford Mail Tribune, April 25, 1933, page 1
BANKS AND WIFE 'SPRUCE UP' FOR MURDER HEARING
Edith Robertine Banks, jointly
charged with her husband, L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor and
orchardist, with first degree murder, for the slaying of Constable
George J. Prescott, has two new hats, according to jail attendants, for
her court appearances when the trial starts in the Lane County
courthouse at Eugene next Monday, May 1.Banks himself yesterday had a haircut at the hands of Edwin Malkemus, one of the minor aides and orators of his "Good Government Congress," at liberty after detention in the county jail following the ballot robbery indictments. The central figure of Jackson County's most turbulent period--always a nifty dresser--sent out his clothes to be pressed for the most important event of his life. The day of departure of the Banks for Lane County has not been divulged by the authorities, except that it will be "Friday, Saturday or Sunday," and that the two will travel apart, under heavy guard of state police and the sheriffs of the two counties. In Eugene, owing to the lack of facilities, Banks will be held in the county jail, and his mate in the women's ward of the Eugene city jail. Judge Skipworth, before whom the trial will be heard, is expected to issue the order for their removal the last of the week. Banks had another conference with his three attorneys yesterday. It is understood that attorney William E. Phipps will handle the legal phases of the trial, requiring intimate knowledge of the law, and attorney Joseph R. Hammersly of Portland, for many years a deputy Multnomah County prosecutor, will conduct the case before the jury, assisted by attorney Tom J. Enright, who is slated to make one of the closing pleas to the jury. Lane County, where the trial will be held, is manifesting no undue interest in the proceedings, involving a murder in which they have no more than the normal curiosity that accompanies cases of a similar nature. The court has issued orders there will be no all-day parking in the courtroom, and no lunches therein during the noon hour, and the courtroom will be cleared at the close of each session. The crowd will be limited to the seating capacity of the room, which has 225 seats. The state has announced it will call 26 witnesses, and has most of the subpoenas served. The defense has not announced how many witnesses it will call, nor what its defense will be. Medford Mail Tribune, April 25, 1933, page 1
TENSION ON BANKS COUPLE TIGHTENS AS TRIAL NEARING
Tension of waiting for their trial
at Eugene Monday on a first degree murder charge, for the slaying
March 16 last of Constable George J. Prescott, has started to tell upon
both L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor and orchardist, and his
wife, Edith Robertine Banks.Former Editor Spends Restless Night After Confab with Counsel-- Two-Ply Defense Now Rumored. Banks spent a sleepless night last night, according to jail attendants, Yesterday he had a three-hour conference in his cell with his counsel and devoted all his waking moments to studying his own defense plans. Mrs. Banks, according to her keepers, has started to lose the cheerful confidence of the early days of her incarceration, despite the purchase of two new hats for wear during the trial, Draw Venire Saturday
Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth,
who will hear the trial at Eugene, has ordered the drawing of a special Lane County jury venire, to report Monday for the trial.The drawing will probably take place Saturday morning, in the presence of counsel for both sides, and under the direction of the court. The present jury list was excused yesterday from further service, according to reports from Eugene. Selection of a jury to decide the fate of the accused pair is not expected to require over a day and a half. No inkling has been forthcoming as to the nature of the defense, but it is hinted it will be a "two-ply," based upon self-defense and insanity, and that three witnesses will be introduced to allege that the slain officer made threats against the slayer. The state has witnesses to refute this claim. Must Be Really Insane
In an insanity defense, under the
Oregon law, the burden of the proof rests with the defense, and it must
be beyond a reasonable doubt. To be legally insane, in this state,
a defendant must be unable to distinguish between right and wrong.The state will contend that Banks was rational before and after the killing, that he dictated intelligible letters and transacted business up to a few minutes before the murder. His statement when arrested, claiming justification, with the statement that "I shot him the same as I would any other burglar, and would do it again." The state will also contend that "exaggerated ego," "morbid propensities," "delusions of grandeur," and "tendencies to utter homicidal threats and boasts" do not comprise insanity, under the legal description of the term. Law Backs Prescott
Documentary evidence of the state
will include photographs and maps of the murder house, letters written
by Banks, and the indictment for ballot theft, and the blood-soaked
warrant Constable Prescott held for service when murdered. The state
will also hold that Constable Prescott as a duly elected, qualified,
and acting officer of the law, and possessed of a legal process, was
within his rights and duties, whatever may have been the attitude of
Banks towards its service.Mrs. Banks appears as an accessory to the murder, and the law makes no distinction from the actual slayer. Medford Mail Tribune, April 26, 1933, page 8
BANKS, WIFE TO EUGENE CELLS
L. A. Banks, agitator and former
editor and orchardist, and his wife, Edith Robertine Banks, were
removed from the county jail shortly before 11 o'clock this morning and
speeded in a closed automobile to the Lane County jail at Eugene, where
they will go on trial Monday before Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth,
charged with first degree murder for the wanton slaying of Constable
George F. Prescott, March 16 last, while Banks was resisting service
of a warrant for ballot theft.ACCUSED SLAYERS TRANSFERRED FOR MURDER HEARING Lane County Sheriff and Deputy Take Couple from Jackson Jail at Eleven O'Clock on Short Notice The accused pair, surprised by the order to make ready for the trip, expressed regret they had no opportunity to say goodbye to followers, were in charge of Sheriff C. A. Swarts and Chief Deputy Sheriff George Canaday. The removal was upon an order signed by Circuit Judge Skipworth of Lane County. Fifteen minutes after their arrival, the Lane County officials were on their way north. Few Knew Plans.
Few outside of the authorities
knew of the plans. The couple were handcuffed and taken to the rear
door of the courthouse by elevator, and thence to the waiting car.Mrs. Banks took two new hats, which she will wear during the trial. Banks' wardrobe consisted of two suits of clothes. Sheriff Swarts expects to make a leisurely trip to Eugene, with no stops. Banks will be detained in the county jail, under guard; his wife will be held in the women's ward of the Eugene city jail. They will probably make their first appearance in a Lane County court tomorrow morning, when additional jurors for their trial will be drawn in the presence of counsel for both sides Prosecutors to Leave.
Assistant Attorney General William
S. Levens, District Attorney George A. Codding and attorney Ralph
Moody, of state counsel, will leave this afternoon for Eugene.
Attorney William E. Phipps of defense counsel will also
leave today. Attorney Joe Hammersly of Portland will arrive in Eugene
tomorrow morning.It is expected that Mrs. George F. Moran of Cleveland, Ohio, who with her husband came to Oregon this week to attend the trial, will visit Banks in his cell row. They have been in Portland since Tuesday. The 26 witnesses subpoenaed by the state have been ordered to report at Eugene next Monday morning at opening of court. Banks Takes Nip.
Banks was nervous last night, and
secured a physician's prescription of a pint of medicinal liquor for
his stomach and his nerves. He was allowed a visit with Mrs. Banks
yesterday, who was in good spirits and apparently not depressed by
approaching events. Both, according to jailers, are confident of the
outcome.Attorney Phipps said today that no decision had been made and none would probably be made until the trial opening on whether or not the pair will be tried separately or together. In any event, the state has announced that Banks will be tried first. Yesterday was visiting day at the county jail, and both the accused had a number of visitors. Medford Mail Tribune, April 27, 1933, page 1
BANKS CATSPAWS CLAIM PREJUDICE EXCLUDES DUNCAN
Affidavits of prejudice were filed
this morning against Circuit Judge William M. Duncan of Klamath Falls
by Oliver Martin, indicted for ballot theft, and L. O. VanWegen and L.
E. Fitch, indicted for "disorderly and riotous conduct" in connection
with the attempted buggy whipping of Leonard A. Hall, editor of the
Jacksonville Miner, by Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president and active
worker in the late so-called "Good Government Congress."All three are at liberty on bonds and all three allege they cannot receive a fair and impartial trial before Judge Duncan, and that the action is not taken for the purposes of delay. VanWegen and Fitch are alleged to have attempted to hold Hall while Mrs. Martin wielded the buggy whip. VanWegen also awaits a decision in justice court on a gun-toting charge. Fitch, on the morning of the Constable Prescott murder, was hit, it is claimed, in the head with the butt end of a pistol in the hands of R. E. Burton, an aged man. Fitch was in the hospital three days as a result. Fitch and Mrs. Martin made efforts the past week to secure a warrant for Burton's arrest without success. C. H. Brown, father of Mrs. Martin, is also at liberty on the buggy whipping count, and also on an indictment charging slandering of a bank. Brown has not been noted around the court house for several days. Officials say he has been ill, and spending his time at home working in a garden. As soon as the Banks murder trial is over the state will take steps to bring the ballot stealing cases to trial as speedily as possible. It is anticipated a number of legal delays will be encountered. It is expected that a new judge will be assigned for the trials. Practically all of the defendants have filed affidavits of prejudice. The ballot theft defendants include, among others, County Judge Fehl, suspended Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn, Walter Jones, mayor of Rogue River; John Glenn, former county jailer, and Arthur LaDieu, former business aide of Banks. Eight of the men indicted for ballot theft have entered pleas of guilty, and the state intimates more guilty pleas are to come. The state maintains extreme secrecy over its evidence, but now admits "a perfect picture of the vote stealing" will be presented in court. During the past week or ten days a number of citizens from all parts of the county have called upon county offices and requested that early action be taken in the ballot theft to the end that the case be settled once and for all, and be removed as a source of agitation. Officials explained that it is imperative that the murder trial be heard first, and for that reason the kindred case has been unavoidably delayed. Medford Mail Tribune, April 27, 1933, page 1 BANKS GO ON TRIAL MONDAY
Tension of waiting for their trial at Eugene Monday, on a first degree
murder charge for the slaying March 16 of Constable George J. Prescott,
has started to tell upon both L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor
and orchardist, and his wife Edith Robertine Banks.Lane County Courthouse Is Scene of Trial for Ex-Editor and Wife Banks spent a sleepless night Tuesday, according to jail attendants. Yesterday he had a three-hour conference in his cell with his counsel and devoted all his waking moments to study his own defense plans. Mrs. Banks, according to her keepers, has started to lose the cheerful confidence of the early days of her incarceration, despite the purchase of two new hats, for wear during the trial. Draw Venire Saturday
Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth, who will hear the trial at Eugene,
has ordered the drawing of a special Lane County jury venire, to report
Monday for trial.The drawing will probably take place Saturday morning, in the presence of counsel for both sides, and under the direction of the court. The present jury list was excused yesterday from further service, according to reports from Eugene. Selection of a jury to decide the fate of the accused pair is not expected to require over a day and a half. No inkling has been forthcoming as to the nature of the defense, but it is hinted it will be a a "two-ply," based upon self-defense and insanity, and that three witnesses will be introduced to allege that the slain officer made threats against the slayer. The state has witnesses to refute this claim. Must Be Really Insane
In an insanity defense, under the Oregon law, the burden of the proof
rests with the defense, and it must be beyond a reasonable doubt. To be
legally insane, in this state, a defendant must be unable to
distinguish between right and wrong.The state will contend that Banks was rational before and after the killing, that he dictated intelligible letters and transacted business up to a few minutes before the murder. His statement, when arrested, claiming justification, with the statement that "I shot him the same as I would any other burglar, and would do it again." The state will also contend that "exaggerated ego," "morbid propensities," "delusions of grandeur," and "tendencies to utter homicidal threats and boasts" do not comprise insanity, under the legal description of the term. Law Backs Prescott
Documentary evidence of the state will include photographs and maps of
the murder house, letters written by Banks, and the indictment for
ballot theft, and the blood-soaked warrant Constable Prescott held for
service when murdered. The state will also hold that Constable Prescott
as duly elected, qualified. and acting officer of the law, and
possessed of a legal process was within his rights and duties, whatever
may have been the attitude of Banks towards its service.Mrs. Banks appears as an accessory to the murder, and the law makes no distinction between an accessory and the actual slayer. Gold Hill News, April 27, 1933, page 1 BANKS WITNESSES SEEKING ADVANCE ON FEE PAYMENT
Application was made yesterday to
the county clerk for advancement of fees for witnesses for the defense
in the trial, starting Monday at Eugene, of L. A. Banks, agitator,
former editor and orchardist, and his wife, Edith Robertine Banks, for
first degree murder for the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott on
the morning of March 16 last. The murder came while Banks was resisting
service of a warrant issued on an indictment charging ballot theft.Application Made by Judge Earl Fehl on Behalf of Banks Followers Who Declare They Are Broke The application was referred to Circuit Judge George F. Skipworth of Eugene, who has jurisdiction over the case, and it is anticipated that a ruling will be made late today or early tomorrow, after the materiality of some of the witnesses has been passed upon. Say They're Broke
The application is based upon the
claim that the witnesses have no funds to pay their own way. The
application was made by County Judge Fehl to County Clerk Carter, who
immediately referred the matter to the Lane County court.The defense witnesses are said to number 20, and to include a number of persons closely allied with Banks in the "Good Government Congress"-bred turmoil. The estate's list of witnesses will be less than the 26 first tabulated, as two of the witnesses since the murder have moved considerable distances, and the expense of fees and mileage to Eugene is not warranted by the value of their testimony. Both are said to concern telephone calls Mrs. Banks is said to have made following the killing. Fleming State Witness
E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville
orchardist, detained in the county jail since the murder, will be one
of the chief witnesses called by the state. Fleming was present in the
Banks home for a considerable time before the murder. He fled when the
officers reached the porch of the Banks home and was arrested by state
police on guard at the back door.Dr. C. I. Drummond, county physician, who conducted an autopsy following the murder, whose testimony would establish the cause and nature of the wounds that brought the death of Constable Prescott, was confined to his home today with illness, but was expected to be able to go to Eugene by Monday. Banks and his wife, in charge of chief jailer Fred Kelly and Matron Daniels, arrived at Eugene late yesterday afternoon on the Shasta Limited. Following their departure from the county jail by auto they were taken to Central Point, where they boarded the northbound train and occupied a compartment. Both were in a cheerful mood when they reached Eugene. Mrs. Banks, according to press dispatches, left her fur coat on the train, and it was recovered by a deputy sheriff. Visitors Barred
Judge Skipworth, immediately
following the incarceration, issued an order prohibiting visitors or
interviews to the couple in their cells.The transfer of the Banks from the county jail to the scene of their trial was accomplished with speed and secrecy, and the switch to the train was not generally known. The move from the county jail was on short notice. It was first reported that the accused pair would leave Sunday morning. No official announcement has been made by counsel for Banks as to what defense will be employed. Attorneys generally believe it will be self-defense with an insanity defense interposed. Hints have been broadcast that the defense will attempt to prove by witnesses that the slain officer made threats against Banks. To controvert this testimony, the state will produce written words of Banks wherein he made threats against officers and that he had published threats to kill Deputy Sheriff Phil Lowd if he ever tried "to take him from his home on a warrant." Lowd testified to this effect at the Sheriff Schermerhorn ouster proceedings. The state will also introduce stenographic reports of Banks' "Congress" speeches, including his revolution proclamation from the court house steps, to show that he was defiant of constituted authority and at the time of the murder facing 35 civil and legal proceedings. Profound Egotist
To controvert an insanity plea,
the state will produce evidence that Banks was "a profound
egotist, given to homicidal boasts and threats"; that he was rational
before, during and after the slaying; that he knew, and now knows, the
difference between right and wrong, within the legal meaning of
insanity, and that practically up to time of the firing of the fatal
shot transacted business matters.The trial is not expected to last more than next week. The testimony will be largely confined to the tragic events of March 16. The state will also show malice and premeditation, including plans for flight after the killing. Medford Mail Tribune, April 28, 1933, page 1
Banks Says Jail Life "Important Experience," in Brief Eugene Talk
In the brief, guarded interviews
to Eugene newspapers the day following their incarceration in Lane
County to await trial for first degree murder, L. A. Banks, slayer of
Constable George J. Prescott, described his six weeks in the Jackson
County jail as the "most valuable and important experience in my
lifetime," expressed gratitude to Lane County officials for courtesies
shown him and his wife, but was wary of comment on the killing, which
he termed "the accident."The interviews gave a hint that the former orchardist and editor will endeavor to renew his showmanship, faintly paints himself as a martyr, and mentions his daughter here with kin and a granddaughter in California. Banks declares he has spent his jail days reading the Bible and the philosophers, and closed his remarks with the words: "If the truth does not win, I will not win." Mrs. Banks declined with the statement: "Just tell the truth, and it will be all right." Both the defendants were cheerful and confident, and declared they "awaited the trial with eagerness." The interview, written by Helena Wadleigh. a Banks employee shortly after he assumed control of the News, was as follows. "I was once told by a friend that a man is not a full man until he spent a month in jail. I only smiled and did not believe it, but now, after spending six weeks in jail, I consider it the most valuable and most important experience of my lifetime," Llewellyn A. Banks declared cheerfully yesterday from the Lane County jail cell. "I have read in the past six weeks the lives of all the philosophers from the beginning of history, Plato, Aristotle Cicero and all the others. "Some of the stories at Medford told of my reading my Bible--I did too. I always do--but not all humped up and prayerful as it made me sound. "I have rested a great deal, and Mrs. Banks has had a world of rest, almost like being in hospital." A calm confidence was displayed by the 62-year-old defendant. "If the truth does not win, I will not win," he said simply. An elaboration of his plea of not guilty was refused smilingly. "The facts properly belong before the court, and there they will be placed." Banks, when held in the Josephine County jail at Grants Pass, was interviewed by a press association in which he declared he "shot in defense of my home." This was the day following the murder. The Eugene interview was his first since then. Medford Mail Tribune, April 30, 1933, page 1 STAGE ALL SET AT EUGENE FOR TRIAL OF BANKS
Public interest of Jackson County
will shift this week to the pioneer Lane County courthouse at Eugene,
where L. A. Banks, agitator and former editor and publisher, and his
wife, Edith Robertine Banks, go on trial for first degree murder for
the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott, March 16th last, while
Banks was resisting service of a warrant for ballot-stealing, and in
fulfillment of oft-spoken and published threats against constituted
authority.Insanity and Threats by Slain Officer Hinted As Defense-- Interview Vital Cog in State's Case. The extreme penalty upon conviction of the crime charged, under Oregon law, is death upon the gallows. The jury may recommend life imprisonment. Verdicts in lesser degrees may be outlined by the court in its final instructions. Mrs. Banks is listed as an accessory. The Oregon law holds an accessory equally guilty. While no definite announcement has come from the defense counsel, it is thought it will embody every element helpful to the cause of the defendants, with self-defense and insanity as the keynotes. It is highly probable the two defendants will elect to be tried together. Banks, it is predicted. will plead temporary insanity on the grounds of emotional strain, brought about by financial worries and personal troubles, and interpose the further plea of self-defense, on the allegation that the slain officer had made threats against him. The state will endeavor to refute the charge, if made, that the slain officer made threats against Banks, by testimony of a half dozen witnesses who within 30 minutes before the slaying talked with Constable Prescott. They will testify that the murdered officer spoke kindly of his murderer, and decried their warnings that he would "make good his threats." Among the strongest links of evidence to be introduced by the state will be the words of Banks before and after the murder. These include his interview with the United Press, in the Grants Pass jail; his letters to the state police and city police, warning that his arrest "would result in bloodshed, and probably my own death," and articles in which he threatened violence in opposition to constituted authority. Banks, in the Grants Pass jail interview, said: "I shot Constable George Prescott in defense of my home. "Poor George. I am sorry for him, but under the circumstances I could not have acted differently, and I would do the same thing again if anyone attempted to force his way into my home, as I have repeatedly warned them by letters and statements." The interview in full will be introduced to show premeditation and malice. It will also be shown that Banks planned flight after the killing, and had an auto ready to escape. The plan miscarried. E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, present in the Banks home at the time of the murder, was taken to Eugene Friday and will be one of the chief witnesses for the state, who also indicate they will introduce "two or three surprise witnesses." Most of the Jackson County witnesses, including county officials, will leave early Monday morning for Eugene. The first day will be devoted it is expected to securing a jury. A panel of 48 new jurors has been drawn. The first witness is expected to be called by Tuesday afternoon and the trial finished by the end of this week. Judge Skipworth yesterday issued an order directing Jackson County to pay $1000 to Lane County for fees for defense witnesses. The money will not be advanced as proposed, and the court will pass upon the materiality of their testimony. The court yesterday also refused to issue an order granting "to any group" reserved space in the courtroom. Attendance will be limited to 225 persons, the capacity of the court room, and it will be cleared after every session. Medford Mail Tribune, April 30, 1933, page 1
BANKS AIDES SPRING SURPRISES
EUGENE, Ore., May 1.--(AP)--Jurors
accepted subject to challenge in the Banks trial late today were as
follows:Persecution Claim Appears Foundation of Case in Defense Mrs. Madge B. Addison, Isaac J. Yates, Addison Williams, B. Harry Brabham, Charles Stephens, Nellie H. Tyson, Thomas Pearce, R. H. Townsend, J. A. Phelps, Rhoda Hampton. Attorneys were examining the eleventh juror at 3 o'clock today. Following the acceptance of twelve jurors, they will be subject to twelve challenges by the defense and six by the state. ----
EUGENE, Ore., May 1.--(AP)--With
the defense springing surprise after surprise, the murder trial of
Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford publisher, and his wife, Edith R.
Banks, got under way in Judge Skipworth's court today with "persecution
to the point of desperation" indicated as its main line of
counter-attack.The selection of the jury was the first business after the court was opened and the defense put this important work in the hands of Charles A. Hardy, of Eugene, one of the best known trial lawyers in Lane County, with a long experience and vast acquaintance back of him. Add Legal Talent.
Also the defense added to its
battery of legal talent Frank J. Lonergan, of Portland, long-time
member of the Oregon legislature and speaker of the house, who has a
reputation as one of the cleverest defense lawyers in the state.It is expected he will handle much of the cross-examination of witnesses on political phases of the drama. This gives the defense five attorneys--Hardy, Lonergan, T. J. Enright of Medford, W. E. Phipps of Medford, and Joe Hammersly of Portland. Judge G. F. Skipworth opened the court in a businesslike manner, and the work of selecting a jury was begun. The defense did not move for separate trials for Banks and his wife, and the two are being tried together. The jury may, however, bring in separate verdicts in the case. They are charged with the first degree murder of George J. Prescott, Medford constable. Questions Show Defense Basis.
As the questioning of the first
juror was begun, Hardy indicated the direction in which the defense
counsel will move when he asked:"If the evidence shows that L. A. Banks had, over a period of time, believed he was the victim of persecution, and that he had labored under that impression until it became unendurable, could you as a juror conceive a person being in that condition and bring in a verdict accordingly?" The state objected to this line of questioning, but the judge overruled the objection. "The question," Hardy continued, "is not whether Banks was right in believing he was persecuted but simply one of what was in his mind at the time." Defensive Mood Theory.
From this tine of questioning,
observers were led to believe the defense will attempt to show that
Banks was the victim of conditions which left him in a defensive mood
and that he shot Prescott, not out of "premeditated malice," but as the
defensive gesture of an overwrought mind.The courtroom was crowded as the trial got under way. Eight prospective jurors had been questioned and passed by noon, but the state and defense are still entitled to challenge the prospects. Medford Mail Tribune, May 1, 1933, page 1
LEVENS SPECIAL PROSECUTOR IN BANKS CASE
EUGENE, May 2.--(AP)--A jury of
six men and six women was completed in circuit court here this
afternoon to hear the murder trial of Llewellyn A. Banks and his wife,
Edith R. Banks.DIES SUDDENLY COURT STUNNED BY QUICK TURN; JURY COMPLETE Assistant Attorney General Succumbs in Doctor's Office After Brief Illness During Morning Hours The jurors follow: Madge A. Addison, Isaac J. Yates, Will T. Townsend, Charles E. Ashby, Pearl Wicks, Mrs. D. D. Conley, Mrs. Lucy Ludford, Mrs. Myrl B. Lightfoot, J. A. Phelps, Soren Winther, L. K. Page and Mrs. Jessie Bertsch. Two alternatives being questioned were Raymond Dunning and Lee Young. ----
EUGENE, Ore., May
2.--(AP)--William S. Levens, aged about 58, former director of
prohibition in Oregon, died here today.Levens was here as assistant attorney general, directing the prosecution in the murder trial of Llewellyn A. Banks. He died after being taken to a doctor's office here shortly after court convened following the noon recess. Mr. Levens died shortly before 2 o'clock in a local doctor's office. He had not been in the Banks trial proceedings during the morning because of not feeling well. Ralph E. Moody, old friend of Mr. Levens, and associated with Mr. Levens in the handling of the case for the state, will carry on, it was said. The courtroom was stunned by announcement of Mr. Levens' death, but it was decided to finish drawing of the jury and then adjourn. The jury is nearly drawn, and the case is expected to hear opening statements Wednesday morning. Levens was formerly district attorney of Baker County. He was appointed state prohibition enforcement officer and in 1928 ran for attorney general of Oregon. He was regarded as a liberal, but was unrelenting in his attempts to enforce prohibition. He was appointed prohibition commissioner in 1925 while still prosecutor of Baker County, taking office at a time when the enforcement of the dry laws was in a chaotic condition. Arriving from Baker by train, he was met by reporters who asked him if he planned any radical changes. "Radical?" he queried, "I couldn't be radical if I wanted to be; I don't know how." ----
EUGENE, Ore., May 2.--(AP)--With
five "challenges" left to the defense and three to the state, the
selection of a jury was nearing completion in the Banks case here
Tuesday morning.Llewellyn A. Banks and his wife, Edith R. Banks, are facing a first degree murder charge, and as the state and defense saw their "challenges" thinning down and the jury nearly seated, they were training their big guns on the few remaining jurors with renewed intensity. Persecution Claim Stressed
The defense, which intimated it
would use "persecution to a point of desperation" as its theme,
continued this line of questioning today but concentrated also on
assuring itself that the death of George F. Prescott, Medford
constable, would not be given special significance by the jurors
because he was an officer. The farmers on the jury panel were also
rigorously questioned in regard to their views on cooperative marketing
projects, to which Banks is vigorously opposed.The state contented itself with questions as to the juror's prejudices and the assurance that the state would be given a fair hearing as well as the defense. It was believed the opening statements would be made this afternoon. Mrs. Callison Excused
Frances Callison, wife of Prince
G. Callison, Oregon football coach, was excused from the jury panel
when she said she had lived in Medford for several years and knew many
of the people involved.Both Banks and his wife will take the stand in their own defense later in the week, it was revealed here today by W. E. Phipps, Medford attorney on the defense staff and a personal friend of the defendants. The courthouse was crowded again today as the second day of the trial started, and several times Judge G. F. Skipworth had to rap for order as amusing replies from rural jurors brought forth bursts of laughter. ----
EUGENE, Ore., May 2.--(AP)--With
prospects of the jury box being filled and at least a few of the many
witnesses taking the stand before the day is over, the trial of
Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford editor and orchardist, and his wife,
Edith R. Banks, on charges of first degree murder swung into its second
day today.The charges were brought against the two for the death of George Prescott, Medford constable, fatally shot when he attempted to serve a warrant on Banks at his Medford residence. The trial was moved here on request of the defense for a change of venue from Jackson County. Charles A. Hardy, Eugene trial attorney who is widely acquainted in Lane County, was retained by the defense in a last-minute surprise move and almost entirely directed the defense questioning of prospective jurors. Banks, who came to Medford from Riverside, Calif., was the center of a political storm that engulfed Jackson County for months. He organized the "good government congress," which demanded resignations of many county officers. Indicted in Ballot Theft
Later he was among more than a
score indicted for the theft of ballots from the county courthouse on
the eve of a recount to determine the legality of the election of
Sheriff Gordon Schermerhorn, whom Banks had supported. It was when
Prescott attempted to serve the warrant in this case that he was slain.The defense indicated in its questioning of jurors that it will attempt to show Banks was "persecuted to the point of desperation." Banks Is Calm
Aside from a reflective tapping of
his fingers on the arm of his chair, Banks gave no outward evidence of
nervousness as his trial got under way. Mrs. Banks smiled assuringly at
him from time to time.Banks wore a light gray Norfolk suit. His wife wore a close-fitting black straw hat and a sealskin coat. Both watched intently as the attorneys proceeded with examination of prospective jurors. Housewives, farmers, loggers and laborers were largely represented on the venire from which the jury was being drawn. Medford Mail Tribune, May 2, 1933, page 1
BANKS FLOODED WITH LAWSUITS FOR NINE YEARS
Thirty-five legal actions, both
civil and criminal, have been filed against L. A. Banks in circuit
court in Jackson County since 1924, according to the files at the
county clerk's office. Twenty-nine actions were civil, and six criminal.Included in the criminal actions is a grand jury indictment for criminal syndicalism, dated February 20, and an indictment for burglary not in a dwelling in connection with the ballot thefts, dated March 15. Two actions were for criminal libel, and one for contempt of court. The murder indictment was the last, and the one upon which he is now being tried. Most of the civil actions are for money allegedly due others, although some were for damages for libel. The list was prepared for use in the trial at Eugene. Medford Mail Tribune, May 2, 1933, page 8
Banks Is Subdued Figure As Law's Wheels Travel
EUGENE, May 2.--L. A. Banks,
former editor and orchardist, now central figure in Southern Oregon's
most sensational murder trial since the notorious DeAutremont trial of
June, 1927, is a subdued figure as he sits, listening with something
more than passing interest to the grim mechanics of the law revolve to
decide his fate. At infrequent times there are flashes of his old
fire--but always he returns very soon to an attitude of deep meditation.Toward Fateful Decision Admiring Women Wait Opportunity for Chat with Accused Former Publisher in Murder Trial at Eugene By ARTHUR PERRY In his seat, flanked on three sides by lawyers and friends, he is barely visible to jurors and spectators. At times Tuesday, Banks had to crane his neck to see the jury box over the heads of his own counsel. He wore a suit of dark material with pin stripes. On one side, between the two defendants and next to Mrs. Banks, sits Charles P. Moran of Cleveland, Ohio, Banks' brother-in-law. On the other side, at arm's length, sits attorney Thomas J. Enright, with whom he frequently confers. Directly in front, at a table jointly occupied by the state, sit attorneys Hammersly, Lonergan and Hardy--all masters of legal craft. Banks shows no visible signs of nervousness in the courtroom, but there is a slight change in his manner whenever his counsel mentions "persecution to the point of desperation." Outside the courtroom he is calm and respectfully pleasant. He came to court Tuesday morning under escort of the sheriff, a few minutes after the arrival of Mrs. Banks and the matron. Banks spoke cheerily to the gathering of lawyers, officers and newspapermen in the anteroom. During the morning recess, he conversed animatedly with Mrs. Ariel B. Pomeroy, who was later joined by her husband. He spent half of the 10-minute recess in the anteroom smoking, and shook hands with a Medford newspaperman attending the trial. He made no comment save "They are not making much haste." Mrs. Martin on Hand.
Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, chief
lieutenant of Banks in the activities of the "Good Government
Congress," waited in the back of the courtroom for a chance to speak to
Banks. She was asked for an interview by Eugene newspaperwomen, and
granted it briefly.Mrs. Banks, facing trial with her mate, sits most of the time with eager attention for all that is transpiring as the drama in her life unfolds. At odd moments she sits with downcast eyes in deep contemplation. Both Banks and Mrs. Banks expressed deep regret at the sudden passing of Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens Tuesday. News of his death cast a somber note over the courtroom and the two gray-haired defendants. Levens complained to Medford friends Tuesday morning that he was ill, but dismissed it as of no consequence. Soon after court opened he excused himself and retired to his room. Shortly before noon a physician was called. Just before court opened in the afternoon he was stricken. As soon as the jury was selected, Circuit Judge Skipworth adjourned court until Wednesday afternoon. District Attorney George A. Codding then formally notified the attorney general's office at Salem of the death. Moody to Prosecute.
Attorney Ralph E. Moody was named
assistant Attorney General late Tuesday, and will have charge of the
murder trial and ballot theft cases. He has been engaged in both cases
since their inception. Moody has had wide experience in the law. He was
in the legal department of the Southern Pacific railroad and engaged in
securing the right-of-way for the Marshfield branch of that road. In the Harding and Coolidge administrations he was a U.S.
assistant attorney general. He came to Medford about five years ago, and
for a time was in the law office of A. E. Reames.Of the five attorneys engaged in the Banks case, Charles A. Hardy of Eugene is the most impressive. Master of Suavity.
Recognized as one of the leading
criminal lawyers of the state, and one of the two ranking counselors
of Lane County, he is master of courtroom suavity, addressing all his
queries to the jury in a conversational tone, with flashes of brilliant
legal thinking. He is a man of pleasing appearance and personality,
described by acquaintances as "a lawyer who knows his way around any
kind of a trial." He enjoys a wide acquaintance in Lane County. His retention by the defense is regarded as "a master stroke."Another brilliant barrister associated with Hardy is attorney Frank Lonergan of Portland, no freshman himself in the arts of court procedure. Lonergan is a high state figure of the Knights of Columbus, speaker of the state legislative house, and a fiery cross-examiner. Once he was renowned as a football player in this state--for the Multnomah Club of Portland. He has a statewide acquaintance. At the Tuesday morning session, attorney Hardy questioned the jurors; Lonergan watched intently every word and move, and conferred several times with Banks and Charles P. Moran of Cleveland, Oho, former newspaper publisher. Lonergan also filed a motion before the court for a transcript of the proceedings. Attorney Lonergan spoke but once during the morning session of court, and then to say: "That's a bit argumentative. I would like to hear some questions asked." He was objecting to the state's questioning of Soren Winther, a prospective juror, later excused. The remainder of the defense's battery of attorneys--Joseph L. Hammersly of Portland and attorneys W. E. Phipps and T. J. Enright of Medford played busy, if silent roles, and took copious notes. Jurors Know County.
Mrs. Pearl Wicks, who 20 years ago
taught school in the Butte Falls district of Jackson County, is one of
the 12 jurors and two alternates impaneled in the case.Mrs. Jessie Bertsch of Springfield, the last juror selected, after the defense had exhausted all its challenges, said in response to queries that she had friends in Jackson County, and named them as the families of Dr. Martenson, Harry Gillette and Harry Gile. Mrs. Bertsch said her Medford acquaintance was small. Mrs. Wicks said she knew few, if any, Jackson County residents now. Neither Mrs. Wicks nor Mrs. Bertsch, they testified, had any intimate knowledge of the Jackson County turmoil, had never talked about it, and all they knew about it was "what they saw in the headlines, and paid little attention." The age of the jurors range from Mrs. Bertsch, perhaps 35 years old, to Mrs. Madge P. Addison of Lorraine, perhaps 65, and L. K. Page, about the same age, and a retired sea captain. Mrs. Addison, a trim matron, was dressed in black. Other women members are Mrs. Myrl Lightfoot, a young Eugene housewife, Mrs. D. D. Conley of Crow, a farmer's wife, and Mrs. Lucy Ludford of Eugene. The remaining personnel of the jury is composed of Charles G. Ashby, clerk, Eugene; Will L. Townsend, laborer, London; Isaac P. Yates, laborer, Blachly, and J. D. Phelps, a farmer of Goshen. Raymond Dunning, farmer, and Lee Young, forester, are alternates. Jury Evenly Divided.
The jury is divided--six to
six--between men and women, and none of either sex, they told the
court, have conscientious scruples against capital punishment.The court directed that the jurors return to their homes and make preparations for a long stay away from their families. They were cautioned "not to read the newspapers" during their term of service, and were placed in the hands of bailiffs st 5:30 o'clock. The court advised the jury they "would be accorded every comfort possible, and all your wants will be cared for by the bailiffs." Only one of the many jurors examined Tuesday expressed any conscientious scruples against hanging as a penalty for conviction of first degree murder. He was Virgil Ayers, 20, a young farmer. Attorney Moody of Medford, who questioned the jurors, stressed the capital punishment angle in his queries, and frequently declared, "whether Banks was an editor or an orchardist is not an issue in this trial." Attorney Handy for the defense, when questioning some jurors, asked if "the fact that Banks aroused antagonism by his attacks on farm marketing methods and sales of produce" and "might be assumed to be radical in some of his views of these subjects, would influence you in your verdict." Attorney Hardy touched lightly on "the persecution to the point of desperation" question. He asked Arthur S. Olsen, a Creswell storekeeper, if he could realize the position of a man under great mental stress. Olesen was excused by the court on the showing that he was acquainted with a number of state police officers. Medford Mail Tribune, May 3, 1933, page 1
Amazing Web of Banks Plots Bared in State's Opening Statement
EUGENE, Ore., May 2.--(AP)--With
the state claiming it can prove L. A. Banks shot Constable George
Prescott as the culminating crime in a series of cleverly dramatized
political plots, the trial of the ex-Medford publisher and his wife got
under way this afternoon.Cold-Blooded Murderer Proud of Deed, Declares Prosecuting Attorney The first order of procedure following the reading of the indictment was the "opening statements," the formal declaration of what each side seeks to prove. Testimony taking comes next. Ralph E. Moody, taking the place of William S. Levens (who died suddenly yesterday) painted a startling picture of the chief defendant as a fanatical rogue. More Surprises.
For the defense, Joe Hammersly
opened some more of the promised "bag of surprises" by meeting the
state's charges head-on with the statement that the defense would be
able to disprove every one of them and show that Banks in defending his
home against assault put no personal malice against Prescott behind
his bullets.The aged Moody, former Assistant United States attorney general, entered the courtroom Wednesday afternoon armed with papers from Governor Meier appointing him assistant state attorney general. He was sworn in Wednesday morning by Judge G. F. Skipworth of the circuit court and will be the state's chief prosecutor in the case. Speaking without a prepared statement and taking each of the state's proposed proofs in their order, he told the jury that Llewellyn A. Banks and his wife, Edith R. Banks, knowingly and willfully killed the Medford constable, Banks by pulling the trigger of the rifle and Mrs. Banks by holding the door part way open to give him a dead shot. Mrs. Banks Unmoved.
Mrs. Banks appeared unmoved as the state's case was mapped out, but Banks drummed nervously on the arm of his chair with his fingers.The jury of six men and six women, picked yesterday afternoon and isolated from their friends and relatives until the case is over, leaned forward in the box as the state opened its case. The packed courtroom, from which many spectators had been turned away, was likewise tense as Moody, still visibly shaken by the death of his friend and colleague, dramatically presented the state's opening charges. Insanity will not be the defense plea. This was indicated by Hammersly as he opened the defense statement. The defense will seek to prove that the shooting was the defensive gesture of a "cornered creature in the defense of his home." "Mrs. Banks? She is just a wife and mother who had no part in the affair. Her presence here would be ridiculous if it were not pathetic." Banks was pictured by the state as a cold-blooded murderer, proud of his deed, and Mrs. Banks as his willing accomplice. ----
EUGENE, Ore., May
3.--(AP)--Prosecuting attorneys trying Llewellyn A. Banks and his wife,
Edith R. Banks, for first degree murder, today were rechecking their
plans, a move made necessary by the sudden death from heart attack
yesterday of William S. Levens, 60, assistant state attorney general
assigned to handle the trial.Although selection of the jury was completed yesterday after word of Levens' death reached the court, Circuit Judge G. F. Skipworth later ordered adjournment until 1:30 p.m. today to allow the prosecution to reorganize itself. Moody Takes Helm.
With this in view, Ralph Moody of
Medford, former assistant United States attorney general, was hurriedly
sworn in last night as special assistant state attorney general to
assume charge of the case for the state. Moody had already identified
himself with the prosecution at the request of Levens, long a friend of
his, and he was questioning prospective jurors yesterday when word was
received that Levens had died in a doctor's office nearby.The jury, completed late yesterday, remained locked up today pending resumption of the trial. Judge Skipworth, in ordering them locked up last night, indicated that procedure would be followed until the trial is over. Cooperatives Factor.
Deserting temporarily its line of
questioning of prospective jurors in accordance with its theory that
Banks was "persecuted to a point of desperation," and was in an
overwrought frame of mind when Constable Prescott was shot, the defense
yesterday sought the views of the panel on cooperative farm projects
and marketing. While editing a Medford paper, Banks had made a vigorous
fight against such farm enterprises. The state confined its questions
largely as to the jurors' prejudices and the assurance the state as
well as the defense would be given a fair hearing.Moody Authorized.
Assistant State Attorney General
J. M. Devers, whose work is largely confined to the state highway
commission, came here from Salem last night with the papers authorizing
Moody to carry on the work started by Levens.Moody was assistant United States attorney general under the Harding and Coolidge administrations, and a considered one of the most colorful attorneys in this state. Assisting him with the prosecution are George Codding, district attorney of Jackson County, and Deputy District Attorney Neilson, also of Medford. Medford Mail Tribune, May 3, 1933, page 1
BANKS DEFENSE WITNESSES ASK SPEED FOR FEES
EUGENE, May 3.--Twelve witnesses
for the defense--all more or less active in the activities of the "Good
Government Congress"--became public Tuesday, when they applied to the
clerk of Lane County for mileage fees. Circuit Judge George F.
Skipworth directed the Jackson County district attorney to approve
their mileage, following the filing of a request for same by Defense
Counsel Thomas J.By ARTHUR PERRY Enright. The defense witnesses are: J. Arthur LaDieu, former business manager for Banks' morning newspaper, and at liberty under $7500 bonds for ballot theft. Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the "Good Government Congress," catspaw of Banks in the tumultuous days of January and February, and at liberty on $2500 bonds for "riotous conduct" in connection with the buggy-whipping of Leonard A. Hall, editor of the Jacksonville Miner. Walter Jones, mayor of Rogue River, on liberty on $7500 bonds for ballot theft, and one of the leading figures in several of the courthouse "demonstrations." L. O. VanWegen, tong-time resident of Jackson County, asserted aide of Mrs. Martin in her street lashing effort, reputed "congressman," and at liberty on $1500 bonds for "riotous conduct." Amos W. Walker, deputy sheriff named by County Judge Earl H. Fehl, at his home on the morning suspended Sheriff Gordon L. Schermerhorn was sworn into office. Walker was deposed as probation officer for the county court, upon the recommendation of the grand jury. Mrs. Ariel B. Pomeroy, intimate friend of Mr. and Mrs. Banks, and active in "Good Government Congress" activities. May Powell, Jackson County resident and bondswoman for some of those indicted for ballot theft. P. M. Morrison of the Ashland district, close friend of Thomas L. Brecheen, held in the county jail awaiting long-deferred bonds for ballot theft. Mrs. Mae Murray, Effie Lewis, John Wheeler and B. A. Boyce, all residents of Jackson County, are the remaining defense witnesses. According to state officials, a number of the defense witnesses as above listed have secured apartments a block away from the courthouse. Attorney William E. Phipps of Medford, of the defense counsel, said Tuesday that "fifteen or sixteen witnesses--maybe more--would be called in Banks' behalf." Attorney Phipps thought the trial would be concluded by the end of the week Besides the above, the following Medford and Jackson County people are attending the trial, as witnesses or spectators: Mr. and Mrs. Henry Fluhrer. The Fluhrer plane landed here Sunday on a return trip from Portland, and is undergoing slight mechanical repairs and waiting for the weather to clear, before taking off for home. George Hilton of Grants Pass, former Medford resident, and Tom H. Pankey of Central Point, County Engineer Paul B. Rynning, Henry W. Conger, former coroner, W. J. Looker, court reporter, engaged in taking stenographic notes; Sam Carey. clerk and former ad solicitor of the Banks paper, Virgil Edington, Gold Hill High School boy; Sheriff-Appointee Walter J. Olmscheid, Attorney E. E Kelly, Chief of Police Clatous McCredie, County Clerk George R. Carter, County Physician C. I. Drummond and former County Physician B. C. Wilson. Medford Mail Tribune, May 3, 1933, page 1
BANKS INTERESTS ARE SUED AGAIN
Two petitions in bankruptcy were
filed against the L. A. Banks interests yesterday. The first is against
Mr. Banks and his wife, Edith R. Banks, the hearing upon which is set
for May 13. The second is against the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., and the
hearing will be May 17.Attorney Frank DeSouza represents the petitioners in the case against Mr. and Mrs. Banks, and attorneys Roberts and McAllister those against the Suncrest Orchards. Attorney A. C. Hough of Grants Pass represents the defendants in both cases. The hearings will determine whether or not Mr. and Mrs. Banks and the Suncrest Orchards, Inc., should be adjudicated involuntary bankruptcy. Medford Mail Tribune, May 3, 1933, page 6
BANKS WITNESSES TO BE SEARCHED
EUGENE, Ore., May 3.--(UP)--Fearing theft of important evidence in the first degree
murder trial of Mr. and Mrs. Llewellyn A. Banks, Sheriff C. A.
Swarts has placed an armed guard around the Lane County courthouse.Banks is alleged to have shot Constable George Prescott when the officer tried to serve a warrant on him for alleged complicity in theft of election ballots in Jackson County. All doors and windows were locked, with only the front door open to privileged officials. Witnesses, many of whom are from Jackson County, will be searched for concealed weapons before they are allowed to enter the courtroom to testify. Medford Mail Tribune, May 3, 1933, page 7
FLEMING TELLS BANKS THREATS
EUGENE, Ore., May 4.--(AP)--A
horrible picture of sudden death was painted by Officer James O'Brien
of the state police as he described in grim detail the killing of his
friend, Constable George F. Prescott, in Medford March 16.CLOSE COMPANION OF KILLER TAKES STAND FOR STATE Appearance of Man Who Was with Agitating Editor at Time [of] Murder Creates Stir at Eugene Trial Called to the witness stand by the state in the trial of Llewellyn A. Banks and his wife, O'Brien told of accompanying Prescott to the Banks home on the morning he was slain. "We went up on the porch to serve a warrant on Banks. I knocked on the door and Mrs. Banks opened it. 'What is it?' she asked. 'I have a warrant for Mr. Banks,' Prescott told her. Mrs. Banks started to close the door and Prescott put his foot on the threshold. "'Just a minute,' he said. 'I'll read it!' Just then I looked through the window and saw Banks leveling his rifle. Banks called 'Look out!' I tried to pull Prescott down out of the way, but there was an explosion in my face. The bullet struck Prescott's hand before entering his body. Splinters of bone and flesh hit my eyes. Prescott's teeth fell out of his mouth." ----
EUGENE, Ore., May 4.--(AP)--A. E.
Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, who was in the Banks home at the time
of the Prescott killing, took the stand in the Banks murder trial
Thursday and told a graphic story of the events which immediately
preceded the Medford tragedy.He was brought from his cell, where he has been held incommunicado by the state as a material witness, and his appearance created the biggest stir of excitement in a morning crowded with surprises and the exchange of biting repartee between state and defense counsel. Is Key Witness
Fleming was the second witness of
the morning and the fourth called by the state. He has been heralded as
the biggest gun in the prosecution arsenal, for it is on his testimony
the state hopes to convict Mr. and Mrs. Llewellyn A. Banks for the
premeditated murder of Constable Prescott. Fleming followed Verne
Shangle, Medford photographer, who identified pictures presented in
evidence by the prosecution."I am being framed on the ballot charges," Fleming quoted Banks as saying. "I have written letters warning them (the officers) not to come. They will never take me except over dead bodies, and even then I will be carried out feet first." Didn't See Shooting
Fleming did not see the shooting,
according to his testimony, as Banks had warned him to leave when the
officers were heard at the door. He did see the top of Prescott's head
over the window, however, and said he could identify the officer, as he
had known Prescott many years.As Fleming started out through the back of the house he heard Banks say: "Get out" or "Look out," and almost simultaneously he heard the sound of a gun. Fleming said he "kept going" and was arrested by an officer as he went out the back door. The first surprise of the morning came when Frank Lonergan of the defense staff moved that "all evidence presented by the state be excluded, as the district attorney's office of Lane County was not represented on the prosecution counsel and therefore the entire procedure was illegal." Would Dismiss Case
Had the defense move been
sustained by Judge Skipworth it would have virtually amounted to a
dismissal of the case. While it is believed the defense had no hope of
the move being sustained, it wanted the legal strategy written into the
records in case of subsequent appeals.The counsel for the state and the defense, who had maintained an air of friendliness during the selection of the jury and the opening statements, grew hostile during today as the questions of Shangle, Medford photographer, got under way. Crowd Enjoys Clashes
Several skirmishes between Moody
and Lonergan drew spontaneous bursts of appreciation and enjoyment from
the crowd, and Judge Skipworth had to instruct the bailiff to maintain
order.Shangle identified pictures of the Banks residence, the door through which the bullet passed, the interior of the house and other routine photographs which were submitted as evidence. A shudder swept through the press box and gallery as photographs of Prescott's body were identified by Shangle, but the pictures were not submitted as evidence and as yet the jury has not been allowed to see them. Nor were they referred to any questioning as the Prescott pictures were discussed simply as photographs taken on the morning of March 16. A picture of a rifle, revolver and cartridge belt taken at the Banks home following the shooting was not admitted in evidence when defense counsel objected on the grounds they had not yet been identified in any way as being connected with the case. ----
EUGENE, Ore., May 4.--(AP)--The
opening arguments concluded, the state prepared today to put its
witnesses on in rapid succession in the circuit court trial here of
Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford editor, and his wife, Edith R.
Banks, for first degree murder.Two witnesses were called before yesterday's half-day session was concluded. Most of the session, shortened because of the sudden death Tuesday of William S. Levens, special prosecuting attorney, was devoted to arguments. Says He's Fanatical
The state declared that Banks is a
"fanatical rogue," who shot and killed George Prescott, Medford
constable, in cold blood when he attempted to serve a
warrant on him March 16 at his home. The defense answered that the
former editor was "a cornered creature," who, overwrought by county
officials who had persecuted him, slew the constable as a defensive
move to protect his home. The trial, now in its fourth day, was moved
here from Medford on a change of venue.Defense attorneys, reviewing Banks' life, disclosed that he had made and lost several fortunes. Born in Ohio and raised on a fruit farm, he entered the fruit distributing business. There he successfully built up a fortune, but lost it in the panic of 1907. He went to Riverside, Cal., where he acquired possession of a citrus ranch of 1000 acres. The defense said that Banks fought with an association that purchased from producers at what he believed was an unfair price. Center of Quarrels
He came to Oregon in 1921 after
having loaned a Rogue Valley orchardist $25,000. In Jackson County he
paid $200,000 for 650 acres of orchard lands. Banks quarreled with a
packers' association for similar reasons he had found in the south, the
defense declared, and this was the beginning of a series of disputes
that spread when Banks acquired control of a Medford daily newspaper
and reached its climax in recent months in a county-wide storm. In
those last months Banks demanded the wholesale resignation of county
officers and organized the "Good Government Congress" to work toward
that goal.Ballots Stolen
On the eve of a recount to
determine the legality of the election of Sheriff Schermerhorn, whom
Banks had supported, 10,000 ballots were stolen from the county court
house. Banks was one of more than a score indicted in this connection,
and it was when Prescott attempted to serve the resulting warrant that
he met his death.George Carter, county clerk of Jackson County, was the first witness called. He produced the warrants taken from the body of the constable after he was shot. Over the objection of the defense, these were introduced along with copies of the indictment. Paul B. Rynning, Jackson County engineer, introduced a floor plan of the Banks residence. Medford Mail Tribune, May 4, 1933, page 1
STATE WILL CALL MANY WITNESSES IN TRYING BANKS
EUGENE, May 3.--Suspended Sheriff
Gordon L. Schermerhorn and Dr. F. G. Swedenburg of Ashland were added
Wednesday to the list of witnesses for the defense in the trial of L.
A. Banks and his wife, Edith Robertine Banks, charged with first
degree murder for the slaying of Constable George J. Prescott. Dr.
Swedenburg was associated with Banks in orchard and the Black Channel
mine deals, and was his physician. The nature of his forthcoming
testimony has not been revealed, but it is believed to be along medical
lines. By ARTHUR PERRY. Suspended Sheriff Schermerhorn visited the Banks home shortly after the murder and was with state and city police during the first examinations of the scene. Two Medford photographers--Verne Shangle and B. R. Harwood--have been subpoenaed to produce photographs of the scene of the slaying, exterior and interior. The photos will show where Banks stood when he fired the fatal shot, the door, and Mrs. Banks' position near the door. Shangle is listed as a state witness, Harwood as a defense witness. Mrs. J. C. Barnes. well-known Medford woman, F. M. Rodman, and Miss Charlotte de Ford of Tillamook, Ore., have also been called as state witnesses. Mrs. Barnes and Rodman live near the Banks home, and from their windows and porch watched the arrival of Constable Prescott and Sergeant James O'Brien of the state police. with the warrant. Miss de Ford was a visitor in Medford at the time. The list of state witnesses, as submitted to the Lane County clerk's office, is as follows: E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, in the Banks home as a visitor at the time of the murder; Thomas Williams, Medford youth, who Mrs. Banks gave a note to deliver to the state police, as he walked by the murder spot; Tommy Curran, a spectator at the Banks home immediately following the tragedy; attorney E. E. Kelly, Janet Clements Guches, secretary to Banks, who left the Banks home 15 minutes before the slaying, after taking dictation from Banks. Mrs. Guches departed as Fleming entered the Banks home. Her husband, Chester Guches, is also called as a witness for the state. Clatous McCredie, Medford chief of police, close personal friend of the slain officer, among the first to arrive at the murder spot; Dr. C. I. Drummond, county physician and Dr. B. C. Wilson, former county physician, who conducted an autopsy over the murdered officer; County Clerk George R. Carter, who will testify to legal documents and warrants in the case, and Earl Bryant of Jacksonville, who entered a plea of guilty in the ballot theft case, and whose home last winter was set fire, while his family slept. Nick Kayl, the home owner, confessed he planned to burn down the house to collect the insurance. Kayl is now serving five years in state prison. Chief jailer Fred Kelly, in close touch with Banks since his incarceration, County Engineer Paul B. Rynning, attorney Gus Newbury, W. H. Conger, former coroner, Captain Lee M. Bown, who arrested Banks, and escorted him to the Josephine County jail, and Sergeant James O'Brien, of the state police, who accompanied Constable Prescott to the porch of the home, where the murder occurred. It is reported that the state has other witnesses in reserve it will call in rebuttal if the defense evidence warrants. The complete list of defense witnesses, as submitted to the Lane County clerk, is as follows: Mrs. Ariel Burton Pomeroy, intimate friend of the Banks, and active in "Good Government Congress" circles; Mrs. Henrietta B. Martin, president of the "Good Government Congress" and its chairman at all assemblies; J. Arthur LaDieu, former business manager for the Banks newspaper, and indicted for ballot theft; L. O. VanWegen, asserted chauffeur of Mrs. Martin, and her companion on the buggy-whipping of editor Leonard N. Hall of the Jacksonville Miner; Amos C. Walker of Central Point, a deputy sheriff the first two months of the year; P. M. Morrison of the Ashland district, and friend of Tom Brecheen, held in the county jail for ballot theft due to inability to raise $7500 bonds; A. J. Cox, John Wheeler, Effie Jones, May Murray and May Powell. Medford Mail Tribune, May 4, 1933, page 1
TRIAL TO JURORS BY WEDNESDAY IS GUESS IN EUGENE
EUGENE, May 3.--Attorneys and
officials connected with the murder trial of L. A. Banks, former
Medford orchardist and editor, and his wife, Edith Robertine Banks,
predict that the case will be in the hands of the jury not later than
next Wednesday, May 10. All the evidence in the case, it is
anticipated, will be concluded by early Monday.(By Arthur Perry) The better part of a day and a half is expected to be allotted to the attorneys for closing arguments of both state and defense. The instructions of the court are also expected to require an hour or more. Closing arguments for the state will be made by attorney Ralph E. Moody of Medford, named assistant attorney general to handle the case following the sudden death of Assistant Attorney General William S. Levens, Tuesday, and District Attorney George A. Codding. Closing defense arguments will be made by attorneys Charles A. Hardy of Eugene and Frank J. Lonergan of Portland, who entered the defense at the eleventh hour, and are known as brilliant pleaders and orators. Attorney Tom J. Enright, a personal friend of Banks and personal counsel in many matters, will also make a closing jury address, it is expected. The main oratorical burden of the defense is expected to rest upon attorneys Hardy and Lonergan. Banks was closeted with his counsel until late Tuesday night in his cell in the county jail here, and another conference was held Wednesday morning. Attorney William E. Phipps of the defense has announced that both Banks and Mrs. Banks will be called to the stand in their own behalf and as chief witnesses for the defense. Interest of Eugene in the trial is still normal and lacks the local angle, intensely. The afternoon crowds so far have been large, but many empty seats at the morning sessions. The trial lacks the fervor of recent similar gatherings in Medford, in which Banks was an actor. Here it is only a passing topic of conversation in hotel lobbies, cigar stores and on street corners. The court room where the drama of Jackson County will be retold is about the size of the court house at home, and seats 225 people. A liberal space is roped off for jurors and witnesses, and the balance of the space is open to spectators. A stern bailiff stands at the main door. When the court room is comfortably filled the spectators are barred. There is no further entrance until recess. Circuit Judge Skipworth is a strict disciplinarian. Any giggling, or undue commotion, brings immediate rapping of the gavel and the words: "Mr. Bailiff, maintain order." The opening statements Wednesday afternoon brought a number of Medford lads and lassies, now at the University of Oregon, to the trial, including a number of law students. High school students of civics are also desirous of seeing court procedure at close range. Medford Mail Tribune, May 4, 1933, page 1
Tragedy at Banks Home Reviewed by Prosecutor in Opening Declaration
EUGENE, May 4.--The state of
Oregon, through its assistant attorney general, Ralph E. Moody of
Medford, in the opening statement in the trial of L. A. Banks and his
wife, Edith R. Banks, charged with first degree murder for the slaying
of Constable George J. Prescott last March 16, pictured the former
editor, orchardist and agitator as a "murderer who laid in wait for
the coming of Constable Prescott, fired through a narrow opening in the
door, opened by his wife, and slew him. It was deliberate and
premeditated. It was the culmination of a series of cleverly dramatized
plots."Defense Points to Stormy Career in Move To Show Slaying Result of Strain; Wife Depressed in Court By ARTHUR PERRY "The defendant, after the commission of the crime, admitted it, in press interviews, seemed proud of it, and said he would do it again." The prosecutor, near the close of his 45-minute address, pictured the Banks home on the murder morning. For the defense, attorney Joseph L. Hammersly of Portland said in part: "Defendant Banks had been under a severe mental strain for months. He had packed his hunting paraphernalia for a hunting trip. He wanted to get away from the Jackson County turmoil. For ten days before the unfortunate climax, defendant Banks never left his home. He even had a barber come to shave him. People came to him, many of them, telling him of threats against him and his property. This man Fleming came, and told him things. Told him he would be arrested for inciting a revolution. Mr. Banks then dictated two notes, addressed to the officers. He was ready to leave. He wanted to get away from the trouble. Then the officers came. He saw Mrs. Banks, who had answered the knock, struggling to keep the officers out. She was trying to keep the door shut with all her might. Banks believed the door would be broken down. He viewed the officers as marauders. "Then, under the mental strain of many months, he fired. He couldn't see. But the bullet sped its way, and killed George Prescott." Attorney Hammersly, in his remarks, pictured Banks as "a fiery crusader, battling for the rights of the underdog" and "paying cash for the first time in the history of Jackson County for fruit, and saving $800,000 a year for the small growers." He traced Banks' ancestry back to the Mayflower, and reviewed his life, from a young man in Ohio, until he was induced by a friend to make an investment in Rogue River Valley. Mention of his father visibly affected Banks. "Defendant Banks accumulated a considerable fortune by his fruit distributing business in Ohio--one of the largest agencies of its kind in the country. He lost everything in the panic of 1907. In the language of the street, he was "wiped out completely. "He knew the fruit business," continued Hammersly. "He came to California. From 1910 to 1926, he transacted a business that totaled more than $20,000,000. He was operating as an independent--buying for cash. He came in conflict with other interests, buying on assignments." The coming of Banks was outlined then by his counsel to the Rogue River. He made an initial investment of $25,000, the attorney said, "and then, perhaps fascinated by the beauties of Southern Oregon, purchased 650 acres of orchard land." His entry into the newspaper field was then told. "Defendant Banks was not a newspaper editor--he was not a writer. He denounced the packing association, bankers, and other big interests. Again he was brought into conflict. It grew intensity, until it culminated in the tragedy of March 16. He was a crusader in his views." Assistant Attorney General Moody confined the state's case to the events of March 16. After the introductory remarks, attorney Moody, his rich voice booming to the farthest corner of the courtroom, said, "The state expects to prove the following facts, and so doing will receive a verdict of conviction. "In February of this year, a burglary took place in the courthouse of Jackson County, at Medford, Oregon, and official ballots were stolen from a vault. On March 15 last, the grand jury of Jackson County returned an indictment. Among those indicted was this defendant, L. A. Banks. The indictments were reported to the circuit court. "Bench warrants were issued for the arrest of the indicted men, and placed in the hands of Constable George J. Prescott, because the sheriff was among the indicted men. Constable Prescott, assisted by the state police and other officers, started to serve the warrants. Some arrests had already been made." Attorney Moody then described dramatically the incidents immediately preceding the fatal shooting, as follows: Mr. Prescott and Officer O'Brien of the state police went to the front door of the Banks home at 1000 West Main Street, in the city of Medford. They rapped, and Mrs. Banks opened the door, asking: "Who is there?" Mr. Prescott replied: "I am sorry. but I have a warrant for the arrest of your husband, Mr. Banks." "The door was opened five or six inches," Moody continued, as the packed courtroom and jury listened with high interest, "held by a burglar chain. Mr. O'Brien looked through the window of the door. He saw Mr. Banks, 30 or 35 feet away, and he had in his hand a Newton .30-.065 high-powered big game rifle. Mr. O'Brien saw him aiming deliberately at the door. He said to Mr. Prescott, 'Look out!' and started to press him away, but this defendant shot through the five-inch crack in the door. The bullet hit Mr. Prescott's hand as he was withdrawing the warrant, and passed into the body, causing practically instant death. Mr. Prescott did not live long enough to complete the sentence on his lips. "Officer O'Brien stood so close to his companion that the blood from the hand wound splattered on his clothing, and splinters from the door, as the bullet passed through the edge, hit him in the eye. For safety's sake, O'Brien laid down on the porch. He then looked through another window, and saw Banks reloading his rifle. He knew it would be suicide to enter. He went for assistance. "Immediately following the crime, Mr. Banks was cool, calm and collected. Immediately following the crime, Mrs. Banks was calm, cool and collected. They acted with deliberation and premeditation," attorney Moody declared. The chief state attorney declared that E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, "will testify that shortly after he arrived at the Banks home, Banks said to him: "I understand there are warrants out for my arrest. No officer will take me. If they try it, I will walk out over their dead body." Fleming, counsel said, tried to dissuade Banks, who replied: "I am going to do it." "Fleming will testify further," Moody declared, "that when the rap came, Mrs. Banks started for the door, and as she did so, said to her mate: "The officers are here." Banks replied, the state said Fleming will testify: "Hand them the letters I dictated this morning." The letters, addressed to the heads of the state police and city police, declared Banks would not submit to arrest, and threatened bloodshed. "Just before the fatal shot was fired," Fleming will testify, "Banks called to his wife, 'Look out!' and she stepped out of range. "There were other people in the Banks home that tragic morning. From the witness stand they will tell you that Banks told them: 'Go away, there might be trouble.'" Mrs. Banks' "proceed in order" note to the officers was also cited. "The evidence the state will present will warrant a conviction of these two defendants at your hands. Every essential fact will be proven, beyond reasonable doubt." Attorney Moody, in his opening statement, made no mention of the death penalty. Attorney Hammersly of the defense said during the recess that the defense would be "a general defense of not guilty, which permits the use of all defenses." However, from his speech, court observers drew the conclusion self-defense, defense of the home, and great mental strain would be stressed. During the opening statement of attorney Moody, Banks was visibly nervous, and at one time his brother-in-law, Charles P. Moran of Cleveland, O., placed his hand on his shoulder, and comfortingly patted him. Banks visibly brightened after attorney Hammersly started speaking, and conferred often with attorneys Phipps and Enright. Mrs. Charles P. Moran, a sister of Banks, occupied a seat by Mrs. Banks Wednesday afternoon. Mrs. Banks sat with bowed head most of the afternoon, in a very solemn mood, seldom lifting her eyes from the floor. The jury of six men and six women paid keen attention to both attorneys. The courtroom was full, with a large crowd in the hallway. The defense asked that all witnesses be excluded, leaving a large vacant space. Spectators were then admitted, as the court admonished, "Now don't let the whole town in, Mr. Bailiff." When court adjourned, the judge said, laughingly: "Don't all the spectators try to get out at once, or somebody might get hurt." Medford Mail Tribune, May 4, 1933, page 1 BANKS TRIAL BEGUN MONDAY
Defended by an imposing array of legal talent, L. A. Banks, former
editor and orchardist of Medford, went on trial Monday at Eugene for
the murder of Officer George Prescott."Persecution" Is Defense Plea to Jury of Six Men and Six Women A jury of six men and six women was completed Tuesday evening, and the trial progressed yesterday with the opening statements of prosecuting and defense attorneys, who outlined the points they will seek to prove to win their respective cases. The death Tuesday afternoon of Prosecuting Attorney Levens, who was handling the state's case, interrupted progress of the trial until Wednesday afternoon, when it was resumed with Ralph E. Moody of Medford, former United States Attorney, as chief counsel for the state. He received his appointment from Governor Julius L. Meier. Banks' attorneys revealed Monday while questioning prospective jurors that they would seek to prove that the killing of Prescott was the climax of long persecution endured by Banks, and that the act was the result of "persecution to the point of desperation." The state proposes to prove that Banks was a "fanatical rogue" and that the murder climaxed his attempts to gain political power by stirring up farmers and others in the Rogue River Valley. The defense maintains that on the morning of the shooting Banks was preparing to go to the mountains for a rest, following his many financial difficulties which resulted in civil cases causing him to lose his newspaper and much orchard property. They stated that he was taking with him his rifle and revolver and that when the officers arrived to arrest him he snatched up the rifle and fired at the men who personified the troubles that had hounded him for months. E. A. Fleming, one of his followers who was in the home at the time, quotes Banks as having said that "Warrants have been issued for me, but no officer will take me. If they try it, I will walk out over their dead bodies." The defense holds that this was a statement of a man persecuted beyond endurance, while the state will seek to show that Banks had planned the shooting and had fortified his home until it was a veritable arsenal for just such an occasion. With the presenting of evidence under way Wednesday afternoon, the first witness, County Clerk Geo. R. Carter, introduced the blood-stained warrants taken from Prescott's body soon after the shooting. The warrants, together with copies of an indictment for ballot theft, were admitted as evidence over protests of the defense. Paul B. Rynning, second witness, presented a map of the commodious Banks home showing the positions of the principals in the murder and other important physical aspects. Gold Hill News, May 4, 1933, page 1
Hot Exchange Marks Quiz of Policeman O'Brien in Banks Trial
EUGENE, Ore., May 5.--(AP)--"We
did!" On these two words, said to have been uttered by Mrs. Edith R.
Banks in answer to the question, "Who killed Prescott?" the state hopes
to convict the wife of the Medford ex-publisher, along with her
husband, for the death of the Jackson County constable.DEFENSE CENTERS HEAVY FIRE UPON PAL OF PRESCOTT Irish Tempers Flare As Lonergan for Accused Pair Insinuates Guns Arranged in Agitator-Editor's Home As a hushed audience leaned forward this afternoon, Tommy Williams, oil truck driver, dramatically told of his conversation with Mrs. Banks as he stood beside the body of the fallen officer. Had Note for Police
Mrs. Banks had handed Williams a
note to be given to the state police. The note read: "Come and get
George Prescott and you will be all right. Then proceed in order.--Mrs.
Banks.""I had been driving past the house in my truck when Mrs. Banks waved for me to come over. 1 hesitated. Her arm was sticking out through the door and in her hand was what looked like a letter," said Williams. "I approached but did not go up on the porch. She asked me again and then a third time. Finally I went up on the porch. She handed me the note, which was on a card. I read it. Pointed to Body
"I said, 'Where is he?' (referring to Prescott)."She said, 'There,' and pointed to the body. "I said. 'Who killed him?' "She said, 'We did!' "I took the note to the state police." Thus was the opening shot fired in the state's case against Mrs. Banks, who thus far has figured only casually in the state's evidence against the couple. Williams testified just before the court adjourned for an hour as a gesture of respect to Wm. S. Levens, chief prosecutor, who died this week. The jury was instructed to disregard Mrs. Banks' note and conversation as far as it concerned Mr. Banks, but the evidence was admitted in the state's case against the woman. Perl Criticized
Williams had followed Frank Perl, Jackson County coroner, and H. W. Conger, Medford undertaker, who handled
the body of Prescott.Perl's part in the case was roughly criticized by attorney Frank Lonergan, chief of the defense counsel, who forced the coroner to admit he had not taken charge of the weapon used in the killing and had not examined Prescott's weapon to see if it was loaded or had been fired. Prescott's revolver was still in its holster when the coroner investigated and was later taken by the state police, according to Perl. The rifle allegedly used by Banks was also taken by the state police despite the fact, as Lonergan put it, that the coroner's duty was to take charge of such evidence. ----
EUGENE, Ore., May 5.--(AP)--A
spectacular battle of words enlivened the murder trial of Llewellyn A.
Banks and his wife, Edith R. Banks, here today as Frank Lonergan, chief
of defense counsel, and Officer James O'Brien, state policeman, matched
wits in cross-examination.O'Brien, a detective sergeant of the state police, was the officer who accompanied George J. Prescott to the Banks home on the morning of the Medford tragedy. He had testified for the state Thursday afternoon and his cross-examination was continued Friday. Under Hot Fire
Every item of O'Brien's testimony
for the state was subjected to a withering fire by the Portland
attorney, with the officer standing his ground. It was when Lonergan
dropped his demeanor of quiet interest in O'Brien's answers and
suddenly turned on the officer with the question, "Is it not true that
you arranged the rifle, the revolver and the cartridges on the table
where you later testified Banks had placed them" that O'Brien became
angered.Denial Entered
"It most certainly was nothing of
the sort!" he replied heatedly. "I had nothing to do with the weapons
except to see them as I entered the room!"Benton C. Wilson, Medford doctor, who took part in the autopsy following the death of Prescott, was next called by the state and testified that the bullet wound in Prescott's hand had been surrounded by splinters of wood. The bullet had entered the constable's body at the shoulder, ranged down into the body and the pieces of metal were found under the skin in Prescott's back. Kelly on Stand
Col. E. E. Kelly, Medford
attorney, was the state's second witness of the day. He said he had
arrived at the Banks home after the killing and just before Banks was
arrested. Kelly said he had wiped the blood off the face of Officer
O'Brien and had taken splinters of wood out of O'Brien's eye. Kelly
identified the bullets used as soft-nosed bullets of the hunting
variety.Court was to be resumed at 1:30 o'clock with a one-hour recess between 2:30 and 3:30 during the funeral of W. S. Levens in Salem. Levens was the state's chief prosecutor, who died here this week. ----
EUGENE, May 5.--(AP)--Rapid
progress in putting on the state's witnesses was expected today, since
two of the principal witnesses gave their testimony yesterday, and the
possibility was seen that the defense might start calling its witnesses
before the weekend adjournment is taken.The two principal witnesses who testified yesterday were Sergeant Jas. O'Brien of the state police and E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist, who were present at Banks' home in Medford when Constable George Prescott was killed as he attempted to serve a warrant on Banks, former editor and orchardist. It is in connection with this slaying that Banks and his wife are being tried. Went with Prescott
O'Brien testified that he went
with Prescott to serve a warrant issued after Banks was indicted with
several others in connection with the theft of ballots from the Jackson
County courthouse. When Mrs. Banks opened the door, O'Brien stated,
Prescott put his foot on the threshold. Then Banks leveled a rifle at
the constable, O'Brien said, and fired. The bullet pierced Prescott's
heart.Fleming, an associate of Banks in the "Good Government Congress" organized by the accused man to seek the resignation of several county officers, said he was with Banks when Prescott appeared at the door. Banks told Fleming he had better leave, he testified. As he ran out the back door he heard Banks shout "Get out" or "Look out," an exclamation that was punctuated with a rifle shot. Frameup Alleged
The Jacksonville orchardist stated that Banks had once remarked to him before the shooting:"I am being framed on the ballot charges. I have written letters warning them (the officers) not to come. They will never take me except over dead bodies, and even then I will be carried out feet first." The trial was removed to Eugene on a defense motion for a change of venue. The defense has set forth that the former editor, who was for months the center of a county-wide political storm, shot the officer as "the final gesture of an overwrought mind in defense of his home after having been driven to desperation by persecution." This persecution, the defense has insisted, was at the hands of county officials whose resignations Banks had demanded. Medford Mail Tribune, May 5, 1933, page 1
Fehl Attempted Framing of Banks Is Testimony by Fleming During Trial
EUGENE, May 4.--E. A. Fleming, 67,
well-known Jacksonville orchardist, at the home of L. A. Banks at the
time Banks fired the shot that slew Constable George J. Prescott, on
March 16 last, and Sergeant-Detective James O'Brien, companion of the
slain official on his last tragic official mission, gave sensational
testimony Thursday at the trial of the former editor and orchardist
and his wife, Edith Robertine Banks, charged with first degree murder.Threat to Slay Arresting Officers Related by Close Friend of Agitator As Details of Murder Bared By ARTHUR PERRY Fleming enlivened the somber proceedings with his laconic replies to questions. O'Brien identified the death weapon--a high-power big game rifle--and the blood-stained bench warrants, and a note Mrs. Banks sent to officers, by Tommy Williams. Fleming told of threats made by Banks a few minutes before the slaying. O'Brien told of looking through a window and seeing Banks calmly reloading his rifle after Prescott had fallen, mortally stricken, on the front porch of the Banks home. He identified also four fragments of bullets removed at an autopsy in his presence, from the body of the slain official. Both were two of the major witnesses for the state, and links in vital corroborative evidence to come. Fleming testified that he came to Banks' home on the morning of the murder, in the auto of Earl Bryant, one of the eight men who have entered pleas of guilty to ballot theft. Fleming came to confer about calling a meeting of the "Good Government Congress," to collect funds for the defense of the men arrested on the charge. Banks and Fleming exchanged greetings. Mrs. Banks was present, Fleming testified. The two men seated themselves. Mrs. Banks was busy nearby. Frameup Suspected.
Soon thereafter Banks said:"Fehl and Coleman held a long conference yesterday. They planned a political swap, and will make me the 'goat' in this ballot business. They can't do it. I understand there is a warrant out for my arrest. If any officers try to arrest me, I will go out over their dead bodies, feet first." "I said: 'O, Mr. Banks, don't do that. It will cause you a lot of trouble.' " According to Fleming's testimony, Banks replied: "I am going to do it. I said I was going to, and I will." Fleming swore that Banks told him he had dictated two letters that morning, warning the officers not to come, and that when a rap came at the door, Mrs. Banks started to answer, and Banks said to him: "You better go." Fleming testified he made ready to obey. Janet Clements Guches, former secretary of Banks, and her husband were in the Banks home when Fleming arrived, and they left with the words: "We are going to the farm." Left by Back Door.
Banks told his wife to "deliver the letters I dictated," when she told him "The officers are coming."Fleming, his overcoat on his arm, went towards the back door, as the officers came to the front door. Half the distance, he heard a shot. Then he heard a woman's voice he would not positively identify as that of Mrs. Banks say: "We have shot Prescott." Fleming testified he left by the back door, and was arrested by state police and held ever since as a material witness. Under cross-examination by attorney Lonergan, Fleming made rapid sallies, calling the defense chief "Brother." The crowded courtroom laughed when Fleming identified himself as "John Doe No. 1" named in the ballot theft indictments. Banks laughed heartily at the reply, but Mrs. Banks retained her solemn, meditative attitude. Telling of his exit from the Banks residence, Fleming added: "Yes, I thought it was the longest house I ever saw." This brought another smile from Banks, who was in a far more cheerful mood than on the previous day. Fleming was on the stand two hours--at the start of the morning and the opening of the afternoon session. Under cross-examination by the defense, Fleming vigorously denied that he had told defense attorney Tom Enright and Arthur LaDieu, during a visit to the Josephine County jail, he had not seen Mrs. Banks in the house the morning of the killing. The state brought out to the jury that LaDieu was a former Banks aide, on redirect examination. The detention of Fleming in jail since the murder, as a material witness, was stressed by attorney Lonergan. Fleming denied he had been promised immunity, and resented, his replies indicated, his detention. The defense counsel's inferences that Fleming was illegally detained brought no immediate contradiction from the state. Sergeant O'Brien of the state police described the actual killing, said that with Constable Prescott he had gone to the Banks home to serve a bench warrant for ballot theft on Banks. He testified the entire proceedings took "less than a minute." O'Brien stated: "As Mrs. Banks opened the door, I heard Mr. Prescott say: 'I have a warrant for your husband's arrest.' I was looking through a window, in the door, and I saw Mr. Banks with a rifle leveled to his shoulder. I said to Mr. Prescott, at the same time trying to pull him away, 'Look out!' Then came the explosion. The bullet hit the constable in the hand. The flesh splattered in my face, and splinters flew from where the bullet struck the door, and hit me in the eye. Mr. Prescott started to fall, as I grabbed him. We both lost our balance, as we fell to the porch. As I lay there, I looked through another window, and saw Mr. Banks calmly reloading the rifle. I went for reinforcements. The entire proceedings did not take more than six or seven seconds." O'Brien also said he saw Fleming running to the rear of the home. O'Brien then told of informing the state police headquarters, and the arrest of Banks. The court ordered reference to the proposed use of poison gas stricken. The state police sergeant identified the bloody bench warrant issued for the arrest of Banks, after it had been further identified by County Clerk Carter, recalled to the stand for the purpose. The ghastly relic of the murder was then read and passed to the jury. He also identified the firearms found in Banks' home after the murder. O'Brien Grilled.
Under cross-examination by
attorney Lonergan, Sergeant O'Brien was subjected to a mildly
sarcastic grilling. The defense counsel questioned him about the number
of the state police in Medford on the day of the murder, and if
Greyhound stages, for whom he formerly worked, were not "owned by the
Southern Pacific." He questioned him pointedly relative to his
experience as an investigator, and by what authority the state police
had to assist in the serving of bench warrants. The defense has given
hints it would attack the legality of the ballot theft indictment against Banks, and the bench warrant for his
arrest. Sergeant O'Brien was still under cross-examination at the
close of the Thursday session.No State Objections.
The defense objected to the
introduction of the bench warrants, the death rifle, and revolver and
holster, found on a table in the Banks home after the murder. They were
overruled by the court. The state did not register an objection the
entire day.O'Brien pointed out on the floor plan of the Banks house where Mrs. Banks told him her husband stood when he fired the fatal shot, and where he had stood while reloading his weapon. Verne Shangle, Medford photographer, was the first witness called [and] identified a score of photographs, showing exterior and interior views of the Banks home. Some were taken within an hour after the murder; others were taken on April 21. A large crowd attended the afternoon session, and a number of Medford people were in the audience, including a number of university students. The proceedings were devoted chiefly to identification of evidence, and long cross-examinations. At times there were vivid high points that awakened alike the interest of the spectators and jurors. Medford Mail Tribune, May 5, 1933, page 1
FEHL IN DENIAL PLANNED FRAME FOR L. A. BANKS
County Judge Earl H. Fehl flatly
denied the statement made by E. A. Fleming, Jacksonville orchardist and
Banks follower, who testified on the witness stand in Eugene yesterday
that Banks had said, on the morning before he shot Officer George
Prescott, that ''Fehl and Coleman are trying to frame me on the ballot
theft, and were closeted two hours yesterday afternoon.""It isn't true." Fehl said. "Coleman and I did not plan to frame Banks. "I should say I wouldn't frame Banks," Fehl continued. "Coleman and I did not have a conference on the afternoon before Prescott was killed." Fehl refused to comment further, except to make a statement about "newspapers printing the truth." Judge W. R. Coleman, with whom Banks claimed Fehl conspired to "frame him" on the ballot theft, laughed at the story as "ridiculous." "I had a talk with Fehl some time before Banks killed Prescott," Coleman said, "but we didn't mention Banks' name and we didn't mention ballots. Our talk was about other matters entirely, and whoever carried that story to Banks was crazy, if it was ever carried to him. We were in Fehl's private office, however, and I told Fehl at that time that I'd gladly give five dollars, if 99 other friends of his would, to carry his Parr case to the supreme court to determine whether or not he got justice in circuit court here. "No," Coleman said, "Fehl and I didn't frame Banks." Medford Mail Tribune, May 5, 1933, page 1
Testimony Connects Wife of Banks with Slaying
EUGENE, Ore., May
6.--(AP)--Further testimony designed to connect Mrs. Edith R. Banks
with the slaying March 16 of George Prescott, Medford constable, was
introduced by the state today just before the first week of the trial
of the woman and her husband, Llewellyn A. Banks, for first degree
murder was concluded.'WE HAD TO SHOOT' WOMAN IS QUOTED BY STATE OFFICER Trooper Warren on Stand Saturday--Recess Taken at Noon to Monday Morning--House Searched. The testimony was that of Clyde Warren of the state police, who quoted Mrs. Banks as observing to him: "Prescott was trying to break into our home. We had to shoot!" The state trooper was put on the witness stand after Tommy Williams, truck driver, a state witness, had testified that Mrs. Banks said: "We did it!" when he asked who killed Prescott. The constable was shot when he attempted to serve a warrant on Banks, former editor and orchardist, at his home. Most of the testimony this week was introduced by the state to establish that Banks fired the fatal shot. Warren's testimony, like that of Tommy Williams, oil truck driver, given Friday, was admitted as evidence only against Mrs. Banks. The jury was instructed to disregard it as far as it concerned Banks, accused of the actual shooting of the officer. Warren's testimony and subsequent cross-examination took up the entire morning session, and he was still being subjected to the bitter fire of questions from defense attorney Frank Lonergan when court adjourned until Monday morning. Judge Skipworth decided against a Saturday afternoon session. "I questioned Mrs. Banks in her house following the shooting of Prescott," said Warren. "I asked her what happened. She said Prescott had tried to break into their home and Banks shot him. "Mrs. Banks said she had gone to the door in answer to a knock and called to her husband that George Prescott was there. Banks instructed her to give Prescott two letters lying on the table. They were addressed to Captain Lee Bown of the state police and Chief McCredie of Medford. Mrs. Banks said she gave Prescott the letters and he tried to force his way in. Banks shouted, 'Look out!' and she jumped back. "Mrs. Banks said: 'Prescott was trying to break into our home. We had to shoot.'" Warren also identified articles found in the Banks home following the killing. In Banks' bedroom he found a suitcase partly packed and containing, among other things, a quantity of ammunition. There were also outdoor clothes and high leather boots lying beside the suitcase, Warren said, On cross-examination he admitted that state officers thoroughly searched the place, although they had no search warrant. Lonergan also asked him if he found a letter in a coat pocket in one of the closets addressed to "Daddy" and signed "Mother." Warren said he read it. The contents of the letter were not revealed. Court will be resumed at 9:30 o'clock Monday morning. Ralph E. Moody, chief of the prosecution counsel, said today it would probably be Monday or Tuesday before the state could complete its case against the couple. Medford Mail Tribune, May 7, 1933, page 1 PILE UP FACTS AGAINST BANKS
After winning many contested points, and introducing much damaging
evidence during the week, prosecuting attorneys in the case of the
State versus Mr. and Mrs. Llewellyn A. Banks will rest their case
today, with the defense preparing to present their case tomorrow.Own Statements, Notes and Guns Introduced; Defense Opens Tomorrow The statement, "We did it," alleged to have been made by Mrs. Banks when asked by Tommy Williams, truck driver, who had killed Constable Prescott, was one of the strongest bits of testimony against her, individually, brought out during the trial. Mrs. Banks called Williams to the house shortly after the killing, to deliver a note to police. Mrs. Banks is also quoted as saying to state policeman Clyde Warren, "Prescott was trying to break into our home. We had to shoot." A mysterious note which has often been referred to, but whose contents has not been revealed to the jury, has figured prominently this week. It was found in a pocket of a coat belonging to Mr. Banks when the house was searched, and is to "Daddy," and signed "Mother." The defense contends that the state has not proved that the note really belongs to the defendants. Other notes addressed to police, stating that if they sought to arrest Banks there would be bloodshed, were admitted. It has been hinted that the mystery note refers to the Banks policy in resisting arrest, and that the best place to make their "stand" was at home. The prosecution scored heavily Tuesday when the court admitted as evidence a pistol, cartridge belt, holster and shells found hidden under a woman's coat on a cot in the Banks home, during the close search of the house on March 16, the day of the murder. Ralph Moody, state's attorney, contended that the presence of the revolver at the scene of the crime tended to show the existence of a conspiracy, backed by a deliberate and premeditated plan, in which both defendants took part. The court held that as the defendants are charged with first degree murder, the state must show premeditation and deliberation, and that this paraphernalia, although not directly connected with the commission of the crime, "were competent as evidence to show the intent and preparation of the defendants." Thirteen witnesses are to be called by the defense, which has hinted through a spokesman that insanity will be included in the plea for Mr. Banks. His attorneys state that they have a very strong case and are confident that they can prove Mr. and Mrs. Banks are not guilty of the murder as indicted. They seem to be "leery" of the so-called "mystery" note, however, and have stated that they will do all in their power to suppress it. Gold Hill News, May 11, 1933, page 1 BANKS CASE MAY GO TO JURY SATURDAY
The Banks
case will go to the jury about Saturday noon, it is predicted in
dispatches from Eugene today.The defense opened its case last Saturday, and during the week has endeavored to show that Banks was in deadly fear of officers and political enemies, and that Prescott had often made threats against his life. Witnesses for Banks have testified that a gun fell from the officer's hand when he was shot by Banks, but the state claims that Prescott's gun was taken from its holster at the undertaking parlors. Defense alienists who heard Banks testify have stated that he was temporarily insane. The state scored, however, when they forced the alienists to admit that he was not insane when he prepared for the coming of officers by fortifying his home. A variety of character witnesses took the stand, those for the defense having nothing but high praise for the defendant's truthfulness and high moral standing, while state witnesses were just as certain that his reputation was poor, and that he was a consistent troublemaker. Many and varied predictions are being made as to the jury's decision, ranging from acquittal to life imprisonment or hanging for Banks, while Mrs. Banks is expected to get a light sentence, if any. Gold Hill News, May 18, 1933, page 1 BANKS GETS LIFE TERM
Llewellyn A. Banks drew a life sentence, and his wife, Edith Robertine
Banks, was acquitted Sunday, when the jury returned its verdict in
their trial of Mr. and Mrs. Banks for the murder of Constable George J.
Prescott, at Eugene.Wife of Slayer Acquitted; Perjury by Defense to Be Investigated The jury found Banks guilty of second degree murder, which carries a mandatory life sentence, under the Oregon law. In a statement issued Monday, Banks said that he would appeal, and his brother-in-law, George Moran, of Cleveland, Ohio, declared that they had only begun the fight for Banks' freedom. In the meantime, steps are being taken to prosecute for perjury, four witnesses for the defense, who had testified that they were eyewitnesses to the shooting, that they had heard Prescott threaten Banks when he tried to enter the house, and that they had seen a gun drop from the officer's hand when he fell on the porch at the Banks home. The state consistently proved that there was no one besides the officers in the street near the Banks home at the time Prescott attempted to serve Banks with a warrant for his arrest in the matter of the ballot stealing last January. State witnesses also testified that the four self-styled eyewitnesses had been in far-distant places at the time of the shooting. Constable Prescott was shot to death last March 16 when he went to the Banks home with State Policeman O'Brien to arrest Banks. Mrs. Banks came to the door, which was secured with a chain, and refused to accept the warrant or let the officer in. Then Banks appeared, and with a sharp warning to Mrs. Banks, fired through the narrow opening to kill the officer. The trial has held the interest of the state for the past three weeks. It is the forerunner of several cases which are the outgrowth of the political turmoil in Jackson County since last fall. In a short time the ballot theft cases will be opened, involving about twenty residents of this county, most of them members of the Good Government Congress, organized by Banks. Gold Hill News, May 25, 1933, page 1 L. A. BANKS GIVEN MORE APPEAL TIME
Six days additional time for filing a motion for a new trial in the
case of L. A. Banks, convicted of murdering Constable George J.
Prescott, has been granted Banks' attorneys, Judge George F.
Skipworth
of Eugene said Tuesday.Gold Hill News, June 15, 1933, page 1 Banks Asks Retrial, Claiming
Errors
L. A. Banks, who was convicted of the murder of Constable George
Prescott, in a trial at Eugene last month, has filed a motion for a
retrial, on the grounds of irregularities in court proceedings, and
errors in law, misconduct of Prosecuting Attorney Moody, and
insufficient evidence to warrant the verdict of guilty.Banks is still in the Pacific Hospital at Eugene, recuperating from a recent operation. He will be there three or four days yet, physicians say. Mrs. Banks is in Eugene, also. Gold Hill News, June 22, 1933, page 1 Banks' Liberty Is Curtailed by
Order of Moody, Monday
L.
A. Banks, former Medford publisher who was convicted for the murder of
Officer Prescott of Medford, and who has been supposed to have been
confined to the Eugene jail pending his appeal for a new trial, has
been enjoying too many liberties, according to Ralph E. Moody,
assistant state attorney general, who acted Monday morning to curtail
the murderer's liberties.Reports have been percolating through grapevine channels for several weeks that Banks was given unusual liberties. One report was that he had been seen on the Eugene golf course, enjoying a pleasant game of golf with some associates, apparently without any worry about the life sentence that was meted to him or without any restrictions, despite the fact that he is a convicted murderer. Another report was that he had been seen frequently driving about the city in company with his wife, and attendants of course who always went with him, and another that he had been allowed to attend moving picture shows. Prosecutor Moody Monday morning phoned to Sheriff Swarts of Lane County, notifying him that Banks must be kept in the jail without being given these unusual liberties unless he was given a court order to do so. The sheriff is reported to have stated that he had extended these liberties to Banks upon the statement of a physician that Banks would probably go insane if cooped up constantly in the jail cell. Despite this, Prosecutor Moody informed the sheriff that he had no right to extend this freedom and these liberties unless such was approved by the court. The indication is that hereafter no grapevine reports concerning these antics will be heard here. Gold Hill News, August 3, 1933, page 4 BANKS' SENTENCE COMING FRIDAY
L. A. Banks, convicted slayer of
Constable George J. Prescott, March 16, will be sentenced Friday
morning at 9:30 o'clock, in the Lane County courthouse, by Circuit
Judge George F. Skipworth.Banks was convicted of second degree murder, and the penalty is life imprisonment. Two criminal libel, two criminal syndicalism and a ballot theft indictment against Banks in the circuit court were ordered dismissed by the court, upon motion of Assistant Attorney General Ralph E. Moody. Banks, in the ordinary course of procedure, will be "dressed in" at the state prison early Friday afternoon. Eugene is 72 miles from Salem, and prisoners are taken from Lane County by auto, upon infliction of sentence. Friends in this city state that Mrs. Banks, who has been in Eugene since her husband's conviction May 22, will make her home in Salem in the future, after a short visit in California. Medford Mail Tribune, August 9, 1933, page 1 MR. BANKS WRITES A BOOK
Llewellyn A. Banks, convicted of murder in the second degree and
awaiting sentence in Lane County prison, has written a book. This was
better employment than brooding darkly. It lifted the mind of the
prisoner out of the abyss, and though in all likelihood the volume is
not a contribution to letters, its preparation was important to the
well-being of the author. And to his credit it should be said that the
book does not treat of his own troubles.Yet the obsession which drove Banks the editor to murder, until he becomes Banks the criminal, is evident in the brief review of this work that thus far has been afforded us. From his cell, as he did in the sunlight when he was free, Banks believes he perceives the world to be decadent and doomed. The messianic delusion persists, we may safely assume. And how the author reconciles his own disregard for authority and order, which culminated in the worst of crimes, with his opinion that he alone knows what is amiss with humanity, does not appear. These zealots that deal in confused and epithetical generalities, assailing things as they are on the theory that whatever is, is wrong, do not regard themselves as under least obligation to be logical. For illogic to them is logic of the first water, lucent, irrefutable. Thus Banks in his book, as in his sad life. The book is called "Weighed in the Balance," meaning of course that our civilization has been weighed and found wanting. Poor fatuous scribbler. There is much amiss with the world, and a deal that might easily be righter, but it wasn't the world that was weighed and found wanting. It was the zealot who, without sufficient intelligence, or the requisite information, convinced himself that he was a man with a mission, and drummed up a following of unwisdom, and pursued his conceit to an end bitter as gall and wormwood. Words were the undoing of Llewellyn A. Banks. The orotund, ponderous sound of them.--Oregonian. Gold Hill News, August 10, 1933, page 2 AUDIT FINDS 55¢
SHORTAGE
The county audit completed this week has revealed that the sheriff
office "mishandled" accounts to the extent that 50¢ cannot be
accounted
for, and that the clerk's office is short five cents in the three-year
period covered by auditor Haines. The check of records covers all
offices and funds, and shows that the total amount handled for the
three-year period was $5,472,259.38.Costs County $2,500.00 to Prove Fehl Charges False It cost Jackson County $2500 to find out that her officials kept careful records, in spite of repeated rumors to the contrary. Serious allegations had been made by L. A. Banks and former County Judge Earl H. Fehl that the funds of the sheriff and clerk's office were "mishandled," and their hints and veiled accusations gained such strength in the rural districts that the audit was finally ordered to clear up the situation. The opening paragraph of the 153-page report reads: "I hereby certify that in my opinion, with the exception of minor errors, discrepancies, and omissions reported hereinafter, all monies collected during the three years ending December 31, 1932 for taxes, fines, and bail forfeitures, fees, licenses, amounts due from other incomes have been deposited with the county treasurer in accordance with statutes in effect, and have been disbursed on authorized vouchers, or remain on hand." Auditor Haines further stated, "In my opinion, the discrepancies found are no different than those to be found in any other counties, and not as bad as in many." Auditor Haines further said the "errors, discrepancies, and omissions" were "clerical errors," such as appear in any business, and could be easily rectified. The report contains no sensational or unusual matter, and none of the charges and accusations hurled by Earl H. Fehl and L. A. Banks against the handling of county affairs are supported in the audit. Fehl in "congress" meetings in rural areas frequently voiced serious accusations, and Banks repeated them in his newspaper. The report shows that the sheriff's office under Ralph G. Jennings handled $1,444,686.03 during the three years period, and the recorded cash receipts of the office show a 50-cent shortage. Fehl and Banks hinted in their allegations that the sheriff office funds were "mishandled." The clerk's office, another point of veiled attack by Banks and Fehl, handled $18,858.39. The audit shows the clerk's accounts were off a nickel during the regime of Delilia Stevens Meyer. The audit shows that the county offices handled in 1932 the sum of $1,432.361.07; in 1931 the sum of $1,929,187.98 and in 1930 the sum of $2,110,710.33. The total amount for the three-year period was $5,472,259.38. Gold Hill News, August 24, 1933, page 1 Campaign for Cleaner Politics
Gives Pulitzer Award to Editor
By LESLIE J. SMITH
MEDFORD, Ore., May 10 (AP)--A straight-thinking newspaperman, who
pitted clear editorial persuasion against the forces of political
insurrection, directed the campaign which won for his paper the
Pulitzer Prize for "the most distinguished and meritorious public
service rendered by an American newspaper" in 1933.
He is Robert W. Ruhl, 54-year-old editor of the Medford Mail Tribune and once a schoolmate of President Roosevelt at Harvard. He helped smash an upheaval in Jackson County which threatened guerrilla warfare in the first six months of 1933. Puhl's fight began when Llewellyn A. Banks, 70, an orchardist, developed political ambition and bought a newspaper plant to aid his desires. Stirred into a violent temper by what he thought were gross wrongs perpetrated by city and county officials and fellow residents of the Rogue River Valley, Banks organized his "Good Government Congress." Through his paper, the Daily News, he harangued the citizens and pleaded for support. "Ropes and nooses" for some county officials were demanded. The first bombshell burst when 10,000 general election ballots were stolen from the county courthouse on the eve of a recount on charges of fraud. In addition to the ballot theft charge, Banks was the defendant at that time in two criminal libel cases, one criminal syndicalism charge, and 18 or 20 lawsuits. Banks published an extra edition of his paper declaring he would resist arrest. "We have now come to that great showdown," his paper asserted, "where blood is likely to be spilled." Members of the "Good Government Congress" threatened to "take over Jackson County." Banks' prediction of bloodshed materialized on the morning of March 16, 1933. Constable George Prescott of Medford walked up the steps of Banks' residence with a warrant for the man's arrest. A rifle bullet blew off the top of his head. "I shot Prescott," Banks shouted as he stepped over the prostrate body. "He was trying to force his way into my house as any burglar would!" Banks was sentenced to life imprisonment. "Militant journalism," so called, had no place in editor Ruhl's program. He won his case with expressions of calm, deliberate judgment. Niagara Falls Gazette, May 10, 1934, page 7 L. A. BANKS DIES IN PRISON WARD;
RITES SATURDAY
Salem, Ore., Sept. 22--(U.P.)--Funeral
services were held here today
for Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford newspaper publisher, who died in
the state prison hospital yesterday.Banks was serving a life sentence in the penitentiary for the murder of Constable George Prescott, March 16, 1933. The murder occurred when Prescott called at Banks' home to serve a warrant charging the ex-publisher with complicity in a ballot theft. Banks came to the Rogue River Valley in the middle 1920s from Riverside, Cal., and became active in the pear industry, purchasing and securing control of several orchards. He purchased a local weekly and converted it into a daily. In the early stages of the depression the properties of Banks became involved in litigation, as well as his newspaper. A period of community stress followed, climaxed by the "ballot thefts," and the slaying of Constable Prescott, at the then Banks home on West Main Street, on the morning of March 16, 1933. Banks went on trial at Eugene, on a change of venue, May 2, 1933, and was found guilty of murder in a second degree, and sentenced to life imprisonment. The case attracted nationwide attention. In prison, Banks at first made efforts to secure executive clemency, all being denied. Of late years little had been heard of him. He was about 78 years of age and born in Ohio. At the time of his trial his wife and child and Cleveland, O., kin were present. Medford Mail Tribune, September 23, 1945, page 1 Ex-Medford Publisher Dies in Pen
Hospital
SALEM, Sept. 22.--(U.P.)--Funeral arrangements were arranged Saturday
for Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford newspaper publisher,
who died in
the state prison hospital Friday night.Banks was serving a life sentence for the murder of Constable George Prescott, whom he shot with a rifle on March 16, 1933, when Prescott called at Banks' home in Medford to serve a warrant charging the ex-publisher with complicity in a ballot theft. He was 75. The shooting of Llewellyn A. Banks of George Prescott followed a long legal entanglement involving a ballot theft case concerning the legality of the election of Gordon L. Schermerhorn as sheriff of Jackson County in 1932. The shooting occurred when Prescott attempted to serve a warrant for Banks' arrest. Oregon Journal, Portland, September 23, 1945, page 1 Ex-Publisher Dies in Prison
SALEM, Sept. 23 (Special)--Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford
newspaper
publisher, died late Friday in the state prison hospital. Death was
ascribed to natural causes.He was serving a life sentence for the murder of Constable George Prescott of Medford, whom he shot with a rifle March 16, 1933, when Prescott called at Banks' home in Medford to serve a warrant charging the publisher with complicity in a ballot theft. A former candidate for the United States Senate, he was a native of Ohio. The murder of Prescott, tied in with the Jackson County ballot theft case, was one of Oregon's big news stories in 1933. Oregonian, Portland, September 23, 1945, page 1 Prison Death of Medford Publisher
When the life sentence of Llewellyn A. Banks, former Medford publisher
and orchardist, was terminated by death, after 11 years of imprisonment
in Oregon state penitentiary, Saturday, it marked the final chapter of
a history of smoldering hatreds and violence in Jackson County
political warfare, in which Banks had been a major participant.Writes Finis to Jackson County Case The story of Banks' trial for the murder of George J. Prescott, Medford constable, who was attempting to serve papers charging the editor with complicity in the now famous Jackson County ballot theft case, was one of Oregon's biggest news stories in 1933. The trial terminated Banks' bitter campaign as honorary chairman of the so-called "Good Government Congress," to oust from political office a group of public officials and judges with whom he had fought a lengthy war in his newspaper, the Medford Daily News. Revolution Hinted At one point several months before the murder of Prescott, Banks promised, at a protest demonstration at the Jackson County courthouse, that he was ready "to take the field in revolution unless justice is restored in Jackson County." Banks, for several weeks preceding the time when his newspaper was repossessed by the original owners, carried on a campaign in condemnation of Constable Prescott, who entered the newspaper office to attach newsprint in satisfaction of a judgment awarded Gene Wright, an ex-employee of the Daily News. Banks stated in his issue of February 4, 1933, the year of Prescott's murder: "I serve notice on the gang. I mean business. Either you are going to destroy me physically or I am going to drive you out of Jackson County. Someone is going to pay the penalty." Bought Daily News Banks had made his home in Medford for about five years at the time of the murder, dividing his time between the region, where he had orchard properties, and California. In 1929 he purchased the Daily News, returned to the original owners by a court order on February 25, 1933. In 1930 he ran for United states Senator from Oregon in opposition to the late Charles L. McNary. He won overwhelming defeat. His campaign advertisements were an outspoken indictment of the industrial East, the United States Steel Corporation and hundreds of kindred industries, which, he said, constituted the "capitalist group, frequently referred to as Wall Street." After January 1, 1933, he was prominently allied with the agitation in the county to remove from office Circuit Judge H. D. Norton, District Attorney Codding and Commissioner R. E. Nealon. Attacked Savagely Banks savagely attacked, and was equally strongly opposed by, Leonard Hall, then editor of the Jacksonville Miner. Both of the editors were indicted by the Jackson County grand jury on charges of criminal libel. They represented opposing camps in the factional strife which divided the county into two camps. The ballot box thefts occurred following the election to sheriff of Gordon L. Schermerhorn, which was contested by ex-Sheriff Ralph Jennings. On the eve of a recount of the 10,000 ballots, brought about by court order, the ballot boxes were stolen from the Jackson County courthouse basement. Many arrests followed the thefts, and among those arrested were several officials of the "Good Government Congress," organized by Banks and supported by him through his repeated attacks on men, officials and organizations at Medford. The arrests had a sobering effect on the congress members. Representative citizens of Medford organized a "committee of one hundred" to uphold constituted authority and put an end to the political strife disrupting the internal life of the city and county. Prescott was shot on the steps of the Banks residence as he arrived to serve papers charging Banks' complicity in the ballot box thefts. He fell with a shot through the heart, and lay on the porch for an hour while police lay siege to the house. Banks, according to newspaper accounts of the murder, gave himself up and "smiled as he walked past the bloody form of the slain policeman." He was put in a car and rushed to Grants Pass, where he was placed in jail, while crowds threatened violence. Banks' home, said state police, was a "miniature arsenal." Banks, in print and in public, had frequently said he would not submit to arrest. Mrs. Banks and her husband were both charged with first-degree murder. The editor was found guilty at Eugene by Judge G. F. Skipworth on a charge of second-degree murder, and received a sentence of life imprisonment, which was mandatory under Oregon law. Mrs. Banks was acquitted. Oregonian, Portland, September 23, 1945, page 13 Death of L. A. Banks Recalls
Hectic Time in Jackson County
Memories of the most violent period of Jackson County political history
were stirred Sunday with the news that Llewellyn A. Banks, 75, former
Medford publisher and orchardist, had died Saturday in the Oregon state
penitentiary after serving 11 years of a life imprisonment term.
According to word received by county officials here, death was due to
cancer. Banks was one of the major figures in the turmoil which focused
nationwide attention on Medford and Jackson County in 1933 and which
ended in murder, arrests for a large group of people and sensational
trials for Banks and five others.Banks' arrest for the murder of Constable Geo. J. Prescott and the trial brought to an end the editor's bitter campaign as honorary chairman of the "Good Government Congress" to put out of office a group of public officials whom he harassed through the columns of his newspaper, the Medford Daily News. Ran for Office
Banks entered the political picture in Jackson County in 1928
when he
came here from Riverside, Calif., and purchased an orchard. In 1929 he
purchased the Daily
News,
then a weekly, and converted it to a daily. He ran for the office of
United States Senator from Oregon in 1930 in opposition to the late
Charles L. McNary and was overwhelmingly defeated. In his campaign he
uttered outspoken indictments against national industrialists and firms
which he said made up the "capitalist group, frequently referred to as
Wall Street."Early in 1933 Banks allied himself with the movement to remove from office Circuit Judge H. D. Norton, District Attorney George Codding and Commissioner R. E. Nealon. At one time Banks stated at a public meeting at the county courthouse that he was ready "to take the field in revolution unless justice is restored in Jackson County." He carried on a campaign in condemnation of Constable Prescott after Prescott had entered the newspaper office to attach newsprint in satisfaction of a judgment which had been awarded Eugene Wright, an ex-employee of the News. Threat Issued
In his issue of Feb. 4, 1933, he stated, "I serve notice on the gang. I
mean business. Either you are going to destroy me physically or I am
going to drive you out of Jackson County. Someone is going to pay the
penalty."He carried on a savage war of words with Leonard Hall, then editor of the Jacksonville Miner, and both editors were indicted by the Jackson County grand jury on charges of criminal libel. The two men represented opposing factions into which the county became divided during the strife. The now famous "ballot box theft case" followed the election as sheriff of Gordon L. Schermerhorn, which was contested by ex-Sheriff Ralph Jennings. The evening before a recount of the ballots, ordered by the court, was to take place, the ballot boxes were stolen from the Jackson County courthouse basement. Arrests Made
Several officials of the "Good Government Congress" were arrested in
connection with the ballot theft. This had a sobering effect on some of
the members of the Congress, and representative citizens of Medford
organized a "committee of 100 to uphold constituted authority and put
an end to the political strife disrupting the internal life of the city
and county."Boiling point in the case was reached when Constable Prescott, charged with the duty of serving papers on Banks charging the editor with complicity in the ballot theft, was shot on the steps of the Banks residence on West Main Street. Shot through the heart, he lay on the porch for an hour while police laid siege to the house. Home Was Arsenal
Newspaper stories of the affair stated that Banks gave himself up and
"smiled as he walked past the bloody form of the slain policeman."
Rushed to Grants Pass by car, Banks was jailed there to avoid crowds
which threatened violence here. State police, who searched the Banks'
home, reported that it was a "miniature arsenal," and Banks had often
declared that he would never submit to arrest.In the days which followed Banks and his wife were both charged with murder and 15 of Banks' followers, including three county officials, the sheriff, county judge and jailer, and the mayor of Rogue River, were indicted for ballot theft. Five, including Banks, were found guilty and sentenced to prison, the editor being convicted by a jury at Eugene and sentenced by Judge G. F. Skipworth. Mrs. Banks was acquitted. Others pleaded guilty and served terms. Among those convicted of the ballot theft was County Judge Earl H. Fehl, who was removed from office by the governor and served a term in the penitentiary, from where he was later removed to the state hospital. Medford Mail Tribune, September 24, 1945, page 3 Last revised December 17, 2024 |
|