Rogue Valley Hangings
Jackson Maynard or Robert S. Maynard/John Brown, May 10 or 16, 1852:
A short time since, John Brown, of Illinois, became involved with a quarrel with another miner. Upon being called a liar he shot his antagonist, who died almost instantly. We have not been furnished with the name of the deceased. Brown was tried, sentenced to be hung, and was to have been executed on the 16th [sic] inst.
"From Shasta," Sacramento Daily Union, May 24, 1852, page 2
I received a letter a few days ago from John Newsom at the Oregon mines. He states that a gambler shot a man there on the 10th [sic] of May last, and at the expiration of a week, the gentleman pulled hemp!
David Newsom, letter of June 15 from Pleasant Valley, O.T., "From Oregon," Illinois Daily Journal, Springfield, August 9, 1852, page 2
May 29. . . . This may be called "mob law," but it is a government that seems to be necessary in these new settlements, where courts are not organized. Egress to the older settlements is so tedious and expensive that without such government crime would go unpunished, and there could not be order and safety. I understand this democratic surveillance has been deliberately prudent, and its effect salutary. A white man was given counsel, a fair trial before an impartial jury, and hung, for the diabolical murder of a white man. Another white man, for shooting--not mortally--an Indian, was made to pay five horses, ten blankets and thirty dollars, which satisfied perfectly the chief, the tribe, and the wounded Indian, and prevented retaliation.
Nathaniel Coe, "The Territory of Oregon," The Ovid Bee, Ovid, New York, September 22, 1852, page 1
OREGON.--The Oregon Statesman of June 1st contains some items of interest. . . . Robt. S. Maynard, from Illinois, shot a man by the name of J. C. Platt, at Jacksonville, because he had been insulted by him. Maynard was tried by a court jury selected from the citizens, found guilty of murder in the first degree, and executed in three days after.
Illinois Daily Journal, Springfield, July 31, 1852, page 2
Murder and Execution on Rogue River.
A murder was committed at Jacksonville, a small mining village on Rogue River, on the 2nd of May, under the following circumstances: A young man named J. C. Platt, slightly under the influence of liquor, challenged any person to run a foot race with him. Several bystanders selected a man of the name of Robert Maynard, who went by the name of Brown, to accept the challenge. Platt said he was no kind of a man, and that he would not run with him; that he could beat him at anything--fighting or anything else; and that if he ran, he wanted to run against a man. Brown said he was insulted, and that he would shoot Platt. He borrowed a revolver, and afterwards meeting Platt in the street, told him he had insulted him. Platt denied having done so, but said that if Brown was disposed to "take it up," he could do so, at the same time taking off his coat for a fight. Hard words passed between them; Platt said Brown was a liar and a thief; Brown forbade him repeating it; the language was repeated, whereupon Brown drew his revolver and shot him through the left breast. Platt exclaimed, "The damn scoundrel has shot me--arrest him," and fell. He lived but three minutes. Brown was taken into custody, and on the following Tuesday tried. A judge and prosecuting attorney were appointed, and a jury summoned, and a fair trial given him. He was defended by D. B. Brenan, of Portland. An auctioneer, known by the name of "Tom Hyer," acted as prosecuting attorney. The trial lasted twelve hours, when the jury retired, and after deliberating an hour and a half, returned a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree. Brown was heavily ironed and a guard of eight men placed over him. It was moved that he be allowed three weeks to "make his peace with God." The crowd rejected this motion by a large majority. It was then moved that he be allowed three days to prepare for the change, which motion prevailed. Accordingly on Saturday the 8th he was taken in a cart about one mile from town, where a gallows had been erected, and hanged. He has been some time in Oregon, and we learn spent the past winter at Marysville. He talked freely upon the gallows; said he was not sorry for what he had done, on his own account, but he was sorry to afflict his parents and brothers and sisters. He said he should be hung and buried in that grave (pointing to a grave nearby, which had been dug), and that the traveler would point to it and say there lies a man who would not be insulted. He bid the crowd "goodbye," and was swung off. He stated that his relatives lived in Illinois. He was twenty-one years of age.
Oregon Statesman, Oregon City, June 1, 1852, page 2
LYNCHING ON ROGUE RIVER.--Mr. Henkle, of the Express, informs us that the man Brown, of Illinois, who killed John D. Platt, of Iowa, on Rogue River a few weeks since, has been hung. He received a fair and dispassionate trial at the hands of a committee appointed by the miners. Mr. Platt worked at his trade--carpentering--for several months in this place. He leaves a wife to mourn his sad fate, who in all probability is on her way to this country at the present time.--Shasta Courier.
Daily Alta California, San Francisco, June 15, 1852, page 2
Notwithstanding the loose and reckless character of a large portion of the population, unrestrained by the refining influences of organized society, crime was remarkably rare. It is true there was no written law. The hastily prepared handful of territorial laws, borrowed from the Iowa code, generally relating to property rights, had hardly crystallized into shape, and were inoperative at so remote a point from the seat of territorial government, and where there was neither county organization nor judicial officers. But there was a law higher, stronger, more effective than written codes—the stern necessity of mutual protection—and a strong element had the courage and will to enforce it. Justice was administered by the people's court; its findings were singularly correct, its decrees inflexible, its punishments certain. In 1852 the first court of this character was convened. A miner named Potts was shot dead, without provocation, by a gambler named Brown. Immediately every claim was vacated. Men, not angry, but outraged by the dastardly deed, gathered in hundreds, and the assassin was secured. That fine sense of chivalry and fairness, common even on the frontier, prompted a proper investigation, and in the absence of even a justice of the peace, W. W. Fowler, now a resident of California, was appointed judge. A jury of twelve men was selected. The case was tried by the rules of right and wrong, divested of legal technicalities; Brown was clearly proved guilty of a cowardly murder, and taken to an oak grove, a little north of the site of the Presbyterian Church, hanged, and buried under a tree, a few yards west of where the church now stands, and the remains have never been removed. The court was quietly dissolved, the judge disclaiming the right to exercise further jurisdiction, but the lesson was salutary and effective.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 360
In 1852 there were no civil courts established in Jackson County except what was called an [alcalde's] or miner's court, which adopted the common law of the United States as to property, and the Mexican law as to life and death. . . .
The first grave ever dug in Jacksonville was for a white man that was shot down by a gambler, and the next grave was for his murderer, who was convicted by a miner's jury, before W. W. Fowler, "alcalde," and hung on a warrant of the "alcalde." White men and Indians were all liable to the same punishment. It was by high miner's court from which no appeal would lie; it was quick and beneficial.
"Pioneer Times," Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, August 21, 1886, page 2
I slept well that night and next morning started on my road to Jacksonville. When I got near the summit of Siskiyou Mountain I had a splendid view of the Mount Shasta. I met a party coming from Jacksonville. . . . [One of them] told me of a murder at Jacksonville and of the hanging of the murderer by the vigilantes. I knew the man that was hanged; he had a claim next to mine on Humbug, above Minersville; his name was John Brown from Pike County, Illinois.
He had come out in 1849 or 1850, and his father and brother had gone home, back to Illinois, from the southern mines, and he . . . came north and worked on Humbug Creek in 1851 and 1852. . . . Brown was a gambler, and I heard that he used to go with the Indians a great deal before he went to Jacksonville. He was a good foot racer and rassler, very stout build, about 24 or 25 years old.
Dejarlais saw Brown hanged and he says if he had a cool, fair and impartial trial he might have been cleared, but he was tried by excited miners who worked up a prejudice against the gambler, and Brown was called of that class, then very obnoxious to the miners, who had lost money with them, and were mad at them for beating them out of their money. But if they had won it would be all right. But Brown was in a manner justified, for he had great provocation. I will here state the case as I heard it afterward in Jacksonville.
John Brown was considered a gambler and he ran with gamblers, but he was sick and could not work. The man he killed was a large, robust man, over six feet tall and weight over 200 lbs., [who] was drinking and blustering about in Jacksonville that he could out-run, throw down, or whip or out-jump anyone in town. Some men in fun called to Brown to come and run a foot-race against the big Missourian. (Brown was quite fast on foot.) But Brown said he was not well enough to run. But the big Missourian thought that Brown was afraid of him, and he could bluff him because he was sick. So he commenced to dare him to run, and as Brown would not, and turned away from him, he said Brown was nothing but a horse-thieving son of a b---- and he could whip him or outrun or throw him down, and abused Brown to what he could lay his tongue to.
Brown left the crowd and went and got a navy revolver and put it in the bosom of his shirt and down under his belt, and he came back where the big Missourian was still blustering around cursing and swearing at everybody. Brown walked up to him and asked him to repeat his words that he called Brown. The big Missourian came toward Brown and as he came he unbuckled his belt containing his pistol and knife and handed the belt to some friend of his, expecting that Brown had come back to fight him. He came to Brown and said, "You are a lying, gambling, horse-thieving son of a b----," and doubled up his fist to strike Brown when Brown had his hand in his bosom on his pistol, and drew his pistol and shot him through the heart, and he fell back and soon died.
Brown gave himself right up to the city marshal and it caused great excitement. The miners were for lynching Brown right off; others formed a vigilance committee to try him next day. Some thought Brown had done right; some thought not. And what made it worse was that the wife and three children of the Missourian had come out and got there a short time after he was shot, and the miners all sympathized with the widow and her three children, and that her husband had been cruelly murdered by a gambler was adding to the crime against Brown. But he, Brown, still claimed he had done right, that if he had been well he would have fought him, but being weak and sick, he could not look over the names that the Missourian had called him and his mother, and if he had it to do again he would do the same every time. . . . But the friends of the killed man said he was drunk and should have been excusable for what he said.
So the next day the miners all met; they had a vigilance committee and a judge and jury elected by the miners to try Brown, and after a little while the jury found Brown guilty of murder and he was to be hung next day close to town. A guard of fifty men (vigilantes) guarded the jail, and next day he, Brown, was hauled in a wagon to the place of execution. His hands and feet were bound and several hundred horsemen armed with rifles and shotguns ranged along the wagon until they got to the gallows, hastily constructed, not far from Jacksonville. They were careful not to take his fetters off his feet and hands until they got on the gallows, for it was Brown's only hope that they would untie his feet and hands and he would have made a rush for the hills, and in the confusion he might have got away, for no doubt he could have outrun any man afoot on the ground, and they knew it, and kept him tied until they put the rope around his neck. They asked him if he had anything to say; he said only a few words--that he thought he had done right, and if it was to be done over would do the same; bid all friends goodbye and died game. The authorities at Jacksonville apprehended a rescue by the California friends of Brown, but they did not get the news until he was about hung, and it was too far to go to avenge the death by what few friends he had around Yreka or Humbug Creek.
Doyce B. Nunis, ed., The Golden Frontier: The Recollections of Herman Francis Reinhart 1851-1869, written 1887, published 1962, page 36
In May 1852 . . . a miner named Plott was shot and instantly killed by one Brown. The miners and others collected immediately, and surrounded the murderer. Elected a judge and jury of 12, tried and convicted and hung him, erecting a scaffold for the purpose. As there was no jail or handcuffs, the prisoner had to be guarded all the week and Mr. McDonough was one of the guards.
Mrs. R. M. McDonough and Elizabeth T'Vault Kenney, letter of November 26, 1899
"As in all mining towns of California, before county organizations were perfected, an alcalde was elected in each Southern Oregon town to administer justice in all cases. The same was done in Jacksonville. This officer's authority extended over everything, from a petty offense to a trial for life. The day I arrived in Jacksonville, a murder was committed. The murderer was immediately arrested, and the next day a jury was empaneled, a prosecuting attorney and counsel for the defense were appointed, the defendant was duly convicted, and he was sentenced to be executed in 10 days, which sentence was duly carried out. During about one year and a half this was the only court held in what now constitutes the counties of Jackson, Josephine, Lake and Klamath. For about one-half this time I was the alcalde, and had quite a number of interesting cases before me. . . . These alcaldes had but about a dozen laws or articles for their guidance, and no technicalities were allowed. A trial consisted of the statements of the parties and the evidence of witnesses, if any, and the case was decided by the court, or the jury, if either party wished one. There was but little dissatisfaction with the decisions of the court. In fact the whole community was ready to help enforce the decision if it was necessary."
Chauncey Nye, "Early Legislature," Crook County Journal, January 2, 1902, page 1. An edited version was printed in the Medford Mail, January 24, 1902, page 3
FIRST HANGING IN SOUTHERN OREGONIn order to get an intelligent understanding of the situation and the chaotic condition of society prior to and at the time of the execution, it must be explained that the mines on Rich Gulch within the limits of Jacksonville were discovered by a party en route from the Willamette Valley to Yreka late in the fall of 1851. After crossing the Rogue River the party kept near the foothills to avoid the dangerous Indians on Bear Creek, and camped overnight on the present site of Jacksonville. While some of the members were preparing supper, James Pool took a pick and pan and went down to the bed of the gulch to prospect, and was happily surprised to find that every pan yielded the most flattering results. The party made a permanent camp, staked off claims and went to mining. The gulch proved to be very rich. Yreka was at that time a booming mining camp. The flats and gulches in and around the town literally swarmed with men, and the new discoveries from day to day kept the transient population at fever heat. When the news of the discovery of Rich Gulch reached there, exaggerated as discoveries always were in those days, an avalanche of men swept over the Siskiyous, and by the spring of '52, 3000 or 4000 miners were delving in the hills and streams around Jacksonville.
Miners Organize a Court Which Tried and Convicted a Murderer in 1852
----It must be remembered that at this time there were no county organizations, no courts, no executive, judicial or peace officers, and that every man was a law unto himself. And when it is considered that this large influx of excited miners represented every nationality, that every type, color and condition could be found among the throng, that they had been trained and educated under dissimilar influences, entertained different beliefs on political, social, religious and governmental questions, that they were as widely divergent in tastes, inclinations and purposes as the countries from which they came were distant from each other, that there was no common bond of union, fraternity or national brotherhood between them, and no restraints of society--when the anomalous situation is fully understood it is little wonder if crime should have run riot and murder and robbery stalked unpunished through the camps. But though the situation would seem to invite and specially favor reckless and unrestrained lawlessness, yet little comparatively prevailed. A due sense of such prudence and civility as would best inure to personal safety, combined with a wholesome fear of the swift and stem justice of miners, constrained each and all to an observance of those principles of peace and amity which characterize all civilized peoples. And so there was little crime except of a rollicking, social and reckless nature which might be reasonably expected in a large, unorganized community of transient strangers. Such a notable absence of crime under such conditions may be regarded as truly remarkable.
----In April, 1852, a man who was called Brown by his comrades, but whose right name was Jackson Maynard, a gambler, killed Samuel Potts, a rancher, in front of the "Round Tent" a large canvas enclosure built and used for gambling purposes. Potts had taken up the well-known Eagle Mills place, two miles below Ashland, and built a house over the hot spring that issues from the bluff on the south side of the road, and running short on provisions, went to Jacksonville to buy supplies. There was a foot race in town during the afternoon, and the gamblers appear to have been thrown down, at least they thought so, and the race created a great deal of adverse comment among the sporting fraternity. Maynard and Potts had both been drinking and were ugly and quarrelsome, though they were not considered to be drunk. They met at the door of the Round Tent where the race was being discussed, and a quarrel ensued between them, during which Maynard drew his pistol and killed Potts. As far as [is] known Potts made no attempt to assault Maynard, but was shot without provocation other than words in which Maynard was quite as offensive as Potts.
Jackson Hot Springs, March 5, 1916 Oregonian
----A great crowd assembled immediately after the shooting, and the uniform sentiment was that as a matter of self-protection, and as an example to desperadoes and vicious persons, Brown should be arrested and tried, and if found guilty punished in accordance with the judgment of the court before whom he was tried. A. meeting was called, and W. W. Fowler selected as judge and Abe Thompson as sheriff. Thompson at once arrested Brown, and guarded him securely until next day, when 12 disinterested persons, found to be such after careful elimination, were selected as jurors to hear and decide the case. Columbus Simms, afterwards if not at that time Territorial Prosecuting Attorney, appeared for the territory, and David Branen and another attorney whose name I cannot at this time recall appeared for the accused. The trial was commenced and conducted to its close strictly in accordance with the forms of territorial law, and with all the dignity and decorum observed in regularly constituted courts. The same order was maintained, witnesses were examined and cross-examined with the same painstaking care as in authorized courts, the usual objections were made to irrelevant or illegal questions, and the issues carefully considered and passed upon by the judge; and upon conclusion of the testimony, the argument of counsel, and charge of the judge, the jury was locked up in charge of a sworn guard to deliberate upon its verdict. After being out about two hours the jury reported to the guard an agreement, and on returning into court, the foreman handed in a verdict of murder in the first degree. The evidence was so positive and conclusive against the accused that the judge thereupon sentenced the prisoner to be hanged at a certain hour eight days thereafter, and charged the sheriff to guard and safely keep the prisoner till the day and hour named. When the time of execution arrived, the prisoner was brought out under an armed guard of 12 and marched to the gallows which had been previously erected, and having been placed on the platform, the death warrant was read to him, his hands and feet pinioned, and the black cap being drawn over his face, the rope was cut and the condemned man shot down like an arrow, and hung suspended with his neck broken in full view of the great throng that had assembled to witness the hanging.
----This was the first execution in Southern Oregon, and though there were no legally authorized courts, and no executive or peace officers, the whole procedure from the arrest to the execution was carried out strictly in accordance with the criminal practice of the territory save in the matter of indictment and perhaps also as to the early execution after the sentence. Respecting, however, the short time allowed the condemned man after the sentence, it will be remembered that when the Indians Tom and Thompson were tried before United States Judge O. B. McFadden, at Jacksonville, February 7, 1854, for the murder of citizens, they were convicted and the judge only gave them three days' grace, from February 7 to February 10, when they were hanged.
Brown's gallows was constructed by planting four posts in the ground, two long and two short. The platform was swung between them on two ropes, so adjusted as to make the platform secure. The ropes were then brought together at a convenient place where, with a single blow of a hatchet, the platform could be instantly freed. The gallows was erected on the flat in front of the present public school building, and the posts stood there for many years as grim reminders of the penalty meted out by miners to evil-doers.
Brown's [Maynard's?] body was buried on the banks of Daisy Creek, a small stream that issues from Rich Gulch, on a lot afterwards owned and occupied by Hon. C. C. Beekman as residence property, Brown's [Potts'?] remains having been taken up and buried in the old Jacksonville cemetery.
This recital will be news to nine-tenths of the people of Jacksonville, who never heard of Brown or the execution.
It would be interesting to show the alarming increase of crime after the organization of the county, March 7, 1853, but it would make this article too long. While the evil-disposed did not fear the regularly constituted authorities, they had a wholesome dread of the swift and unerring justice of the miners.
W. J. PLYMALE.Roseburg, June 17.
Sunday Oregonian, Portland, June 21, 1903, page 15
First Murder and First Hanging in Rogue River Valley.
The first murder committed in Rogue River Valley by a white man killing a white man took place at Jacksonville in March 1852, when a man known as Brown killed a man by the name of Potts. The incidents connected with this murder are given to the Rogue River Fruit Grower by E. K. Anderson, one of the earliest settlers in Rogue River Valley, and who formerly lived on Anderson Creek, near Talent, but who now resides in Ashland. Mr. Anderson saw the shooting, and he acted as one of the jurymen at the trial of the murderer, and he was one of the guards at the execution of the condemned man. White men had been killed by Indians before this time, but there is every reason to believe that this was the first instance of a white man killing a white man in this valley.
Jacksonville at that time was a mining camp that had been established only about two months, for it was only the previous December that gold had been discovered in Rich Gulch [by] James Pool, who with James Clugage had come that month from Yreka to winter their train of pack horses and mules on the luxuriant grass that then grew all over Rogue River Valley. It was not until January that news of the finding of this new and fabulous rich diggings reached the California old miners, and then there was a rush across the Siskiyou Mountains to the new camp, which had been named in honor of President Jackson, who was then the popular idol of Americans and especially of the Southerners, many of whom were in the rush to Rich Gulch. At that time Jacksonville was a town of tents, though Mr. Anderson thinks there may have been a few cabins built of poles, but if there were he has forgotten them in the 58 years since that eventful spring. The only woodworking tool then possessed by the miners, and by the not over a dozen farmers who within the month had settled in the valley, were axes. With these the miners and ranchers cut the logs for their cabins and in some instances, before froes were brought in, split clapboards with which to roof the cabins.
So far as Mr. Anderson recollects, and his memory is very clear and accurate, Jacksonville, at the time of the killing of Potts, had a population of about 400 men, but there were no women, for it was a month later when the first woman came to the valley. Most of these men were miners, and there was also the large number of gamblers, saloon keepers and camp followers. It was shown at the trial that the murderer Brown was a worthless young man who loafed about the saloons and gambling places. Just before he was hung he stated that his true name was Maynard, but he would not tell anything as to his past history or of his relatives. Potts was a young man who had come to the valley about a month previous to his death and had taken up a land claim on Bear Creek two miles below the present town of Ashland, the land now belonging to D. H. Jackson. On this place are big warm springs, and it was Potts' plan to conduct on his place, in addition to farming, a health resort for the treatment of rheumatism, a trouble that afflicted many of the miners. He was a quiet, industrious young man, but nothing was known of Mr. Anderson as to his previous history.
The day that Potts was killed Mr. Anderson was in Jacksonville for supplies, he then living on the claim that he had taken up three months previously on the stream since named Anderson Creek, he being the first settler in that part of Rogue River Valley. At that time the saloon, gambling, trading and boarding house tents were ranged in fairly regular order along about where now stand the business houses in Jacksonville. Mr. Anderson was standing on the corner where is now the Masonic block, when he saw a man dash out of a saloon tent, and close after him was another man brandishing a pistol. As they reached the middle of the street the rear man shot the man he was pursuing in the back, killing him instantly. It was all done so quickly that the bystanders had no time to prevent the shooting, but smoke from the murderer's pistol had not cleared away when he was covered by half a dozen revolvers and forced to surrender.
There was no law nor no courts at that time in Rogue River Valley, and the murderer had hardly been disarmed when the [men who] quickly gathered made a move to lynch him. This was prevented by Mr. Anderson and other cool-headed men, and it was decided to give Brown a fair trial. A meeting was called and a judge and prosecuting attorney were chosen, and there was also a man selected to act as attorney for the accused. A sheriff and a guard were appointed to take charge of the prisoner. A clerk of the court was also appointed, and this official, from a list of names that had been prepared, drew by lot the names of the six men who were to act as jurymen. Mr. Anderson was one of the men so selected. After the trail had been held he was also made a deputy to the sheriff and assisted in guarding the prisoner and at the execution.
Miner's justice is always swift and sure, and in this case all arrangements for the trial of the murderer were completed by the day following the shooting. In this improvised court the formalities and technicalities of modern courts, that delay procedure and often enable the guilty to escape conviction or at least to avoid punishment for an indefinite time, were not practiced, nor would they have been allowed if attempted. The court held its session in one of the big tents, and the trial lasted but half a day. After the evidence had all been heard the two attorneys made their pleas. Both addresses were short and to the point, that of the prosecuting attorney emphasizing the proof that a willful murder had been committed and that the murderer should be convicted and hung as a punishment that he deserved and also that the execution would be a warning to others criminally inclined. The attorney for the defense conceded that his client had killed the man, but that the homicide had been committed as the result of a drunken row and that the pistol shot had been fired while the accused man's brain was crazed by whiskey, and under these circumstances he asked the court's leniency. The jury quickly came to a decision, and on their verdict the judge sentenced the prisoner to be hung on the following Saturday morning. It was on Tuesday of that week that the murder was committed, and the trial was held Wednesday, but Mr. Anderson is not certain as to these dates, and the events may have been a day later in the week. But he is sure that there was an interval of time allowed the doomed man to arrange his affairs.
The execution took place north of where the courthouse now stands in Jacksonville. Though the entire population of Jacksonville and vicinity were present, there was no disturbance, and the execution was as orderly as those of today that are carried out by regular process of law. Only a few days previous the first wagon had reached Jacksonville, and one of these was made to do duty as a scaffold. [Wagons were passing through the Rogue Valley as early as 1846.] The condemned man was made to stand on the wagon, and then a rope was placed about his neck and made fast to a limb of an oak tree. The wagon was then drawn away, and the man was left swinging in the air and soon died.
From the time of his arrest until his execution Brown maintained a stolid indifference and would make no statement concerning his past life, nor would he give any directions for notifying his relatives or friends in the East of the tragedy that led to his death. Only at the last moment, after his hands and feet had been tied and he was given a last chance to speak, did he tell anything of himself, and then he only stated that his right name was Maynard and that Brown was only his assumed name.
Mr. Anderson took no part in the burial of Potts nor of Brown, and he does not recollect as to where the two men were buried. So far as he can recollect of the early history of Jacksonville Mr. Anderson is of the opinion that the grave dug for Potts was the first one, and that of Brown the second one for burial of a white person in Oregon's first mining town.
Rogue River Fruit Grower, October 1910 Anderson remembered Potts' name as "Plot"; I've changed it for consistency with other memoirs.
One man named Brown shot a man named Potts in the summer of 1852. The guilty one was tried by a jury of which David Linn, father of Fletcher Linn, of Portland, was a member. The slayer was hanged at the present site of an old Presbyterian church.
"Jacksonville Is Real Relic of the Hardy Pioneer Days," Oregonian, Portland, November 6, 1910, page 4
Justice was administered [in early Jacksonville] by the people's court; its findings were singularly correct, its decrees inflexible, its punishment certain. In 1852 the first court of this character was convened; a miner named Potts was shot dead without provocation by a gambler named Brown. Immediately every claim was vacated. Men not angry but outraged by the deed gathered in hundreds, and the assassin was secured. That fine sense of chivalry and fairness common on the frontier prompted a proper investigation, and in the absence of even a justice of the peace, W. W. Fowler was appointed judge and a jury of twelve men was selected. The case was tried by the rules of right and wrong divested of legal technicalities. Brown was readily proved guilty of a cowardly murder and taken to an oak grove a little north of the site of the Presbyterian Church, hanged and buried under a tree a few yards west of where the church now stands and the remains have never been removed. The court was quietly dissolved, the judge disclaiming the right to exercise further jurisdiction, but the lesson was salutary and effective.
"True Tales of Pioneers," Jacksonville Post, August 21, 1920, page 1
"Warty," August 1852:
AN INDIAN HUNG BY THE WHITES.--We learn from Mr. Stewart, of Dugan and Co.'s Express, that an Indian called Warty was hung by the whites at Rogue River a few days ago. This Indian is said to have committed many robberies and other crimes upon the whites and to have been the most reckless one among them. In this case he entered the house of a Mr. Weaver and demanded bread, which was refused him by Mrs. Weaver, who was alone with her children. The Indian proceeded to help himself, and upon being opposed by Mrs. W. drew his knife upon her; an alarm was given by the children, when some men who were at work nearby, hearing the alarm, and knowing the Indian character, arrested him, summoned the neighborhood, tried, condemned, and hung him the same day.
Weekly Oregonian, Portland, August 14, 1852, page 2
Old Taylor and another Indian, June 1853:
An Indian called Old Taylor, brother to Joe and Sam of Rogue River Valley, was hung lately for assisting in the murder of several white men.
"Siskiyou," Sacramento Daily Union, June 27, 1853, page 3
Old Taylor, the chief, and two others, were hung a few days since. Yesterday another marched up to the rope. There is a party of whites forty strong, under Capt. Bates, in hot pursuit of the villains. The Grave Creek Indians must die.
Taylor and party killed seven whites last winter, and then reported them drowned in Rogue River during the storm, for which a portion of this tribe have paid the popular penalty.
"Indian Difficulties in Rogue River," Oregon Statesman, Oregon City, June 28, 1853, page 2
The two Shastas and the Indian boys, August 6, 1853:
Jacksonville, Oregon Aug. 7 / 53I write this in great haste; everything and everybody is in great excitement about Indian war. The Indians of this valley have turned against the whites. They have killed two men and wounded some five or six since last Friday evening. The whites turned out yesterday and killed some six or seven Indians besides hanging three here in town.
John R. Rice, SOHS M42A Box 2, #82-147
On Saturday, Mr. Rhodes Noland was shot dead in his cabin door within a mile of town. The citizens who had been previously preparing for a skirmish, upon receiving intelligence of his murder, immediately started out and in a short time returned with a captive "siwash tyee" ["Indian chief"], who was mustered to an oak tree and there "strung up." During the day three others were hung beside the tyee.
T. McF. Patton, letter of August 6, 1853, Oregon Statesman, Salem, August 30, 1853, page 2
The Rogue River War was commenced by Shasta Indians who had been driven from Shasta Valley. They killed a man named James Kyle, within hearing of the center of the town on the road coming from Yreka Sat. night Aug. 2nd, '53. [This was apparently Thomas Wells/Wills; Kyle was killed on Oct. 7; see below.] This fired the citizens & miners acting made indiscriminate war on the Rogue River Indians. A meeting of the citizens were called that night. They slaughtered indiscriminating war on Rogue River or Shasta Indians, though of the latter there were but few, and so those most guilty suffered the least. Two Indians were captured on Applegate, which is a tributary of Rogue River, lying 8 miles south of Jacksonville. These Indians had on the war paint; they were brought to Jacksonville and in a few hours hung by the citizens and probably justly. But the saddest part of the tale remains to be told. About four o'clock in the evening, two farmers from Butte Creek brought in town a little Indian boy 8 or 9 years old. The cry was Hang him! exterminate the Indian! The miners put a rope around his neck & led him towards the tree where the others were hung. B. F. Dowell mounted a log in the vicinity, made a brief speech to the excited crowd of 1000 men, in behalf of the Indian & humanity. Someone cried out what will you do with him? I replied "Take him to the tavern and feed him at my expense." The excitement subsided & they gave me the Indian. Mr. Dowell removed the rope from his neck & led him toward the tavern. At this moment Martin Angel, an old citizen & brave soldier, rode up in an excited manner, cried out, "hang him! hang him! we've been killing Indians all day!" The excited mob rushed and took the Indian from Mr. Dowell, and in a moment had the boy hanging from the same tree from which the two men were suspended. Mr. Dowell resisted after the rope was placed the second time and cut the rope, but the crowd seized him and held him until the execution occurred. Less than a year and a half after in Jany. '56 Martin Angel paid the forfeit of his crime by being assassinated by the Indians on the road above Jacksonville leading to Crescent City. This boy had been employed with the farmers on Butte Creek--farming. During the Rogue River War Mr. Dowell carried the mail between Cañonville and Yreka as mail contractor, and never was molested by the Indians. After the war, Chief Limpy told him that he could have killed him several times, but that he wouldn't hurt a paper man and one who had tried to save a "tenas tillicum," little papoose.
Interview with Benjamin Franklin Dowell, Bancroft Library MSS P-A 25-26
On the 7th of August, the miners captured two Shasta Indians, one on Jackson Creek, and the other on Applegate. These Indians were both in their war paint when caught. They were brought to Jacksonville and on examination it was found that the bullets belonging to one of their guns were the same size of the one with which Noland was killed. There were other facts and circumstances which tendered to identify them as the guilty parties. They were tried by a miners jury and hanged before 2 o'clock the same day. In my opinion they were justly punished.
(In justice to the military authority at Fort Lane, we will add that they assisted in bringing these Indians to justice, and endorsed the action of the citizens in the matter.--Ed. Tidings)
One of the saddest and most inhuman acts of the whole war remains to be told. Late in the evening of the day those Indians were executed, a small innocent boy about nine years old was brought to Jacksonville by three men from Butte Creek, with whom the boy had been living. The poor little boy on being discovered by the miners [was] taken to a place near where David Linn's cabinet shop is now standing, and near where the scaffold where the two Indians were still hanging. I mounted a log near by, and called the attention of the vast crowd to the solemnity of the act they were about to perpetrate. I called on them to punish the guilty, but to spare the life of the innocent child. While pleading at the top of my voice the crowd gathered around the hangman's tree. Someone called out "what will you do with the boy." I replied, I will take him to a hotel and feed him. I went to him and took him by the hand and started up California Street when Martin Angel came up on horseback and without alighting commenced to harangue the mob against the murderous Indians. He said: "The war was raging all over Rogue River Valley, we have been fighting Indians all day; hang him, hang him; he will make a murderer when he is grown , and would hang you if he had a chance." The mob at once seized the boy and threw a rope around his neck, which I succeeded in cutting twice. I was violently thrown back by an Irishman, of the firm of Miller, Rogers & Co., of the left-hand fork of Jackson Creek. The excitement was so great that I found that my own life was in danger, and I had to withdraw. In a moment more the boy was swinging to a limb. I turned away with a sad heart at this inhuman conduct towards the innocent child, against whom no crime was charged. No mob ever committed a more heartless murder than this.
"The Beginning of the Rogue River War--The Murder of the Indian Boy, etc. etc.," Ashland Tidings, October 25, 1878
Other incidents of the eventful period preceding Lane's campaign of August 21-25, were the capture and shooting of a suspected Indian by Angus Brown, the hanging of an Indian child in the town of Jacksonville, and other acts of that nature, which reflect no credit upon those engaged therein. That stern-visaged war had wrought up people to deeds of this sort, is not very remarkable. Five Indians, it is credibly reported, were hanged in one day, on a tree which stood near David Linn's residence.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 217
1853 was a year of troubles and excitement in the new town. A deadly war had been determined on by the Indians who were every day more emboldened by success; more eager for blood as each successive white life was taken. Several settlers in the outskirts of the valley had been picked off by straggling Indians. One afternoon in August the crack of a "Siwash" rifle was heard just in the eastern edge of town; a riderless mule with a bloody saddle galloped madly along California Street, and was recognized as that of a prominent citizen, Thomas Wills, who had been absent from town but for a few hours. Armed men went instantly to where the shot had been heard, and soon returned with the bleeding body of Mr. Wills, who had received a mortal wound and survived only a few days. This audacious act angered and alarmed the townspeople, and among the families there was intense excitement, there being scarcely a bulletproof habitation in town, which could be easily approached under cover from nearly every direction. To make matters worse, arms were by no means plenty, and there is little doubt that had an attack been made in force, and the savages been willing to risk their skins, they might have captured and destroyed the little town. The people, aroused to a sense of danger, effected a partial organization for defense. Pickets were thrown out nightly, and the greatest vigilance was exercised by day, but notwithstanding all precautions only a few days elapsed until a man named Nolan was shot dead within rifle range of the business street. This species of warfare was exasperating, and it was but a few days before the Indian method of reprisal was resorted to. Two Indian boys, "Little Jim" and another, mere striplings, came into town, perhaps from motives of curiosity, possibly as spies. It was scarcely probable that they were the miscreants who lay in wait at the very threshold of the town to slay unoffending whites; there was not the slightest evidence that they had committed any crime--they were too young to be warriors--but in the bitter anger of the moment it was sufficient that they were Indians. They were soon seized by an excited crowd who scarcely knew what to do with the terror-stricken prisoners, and some of the roughest shrank from the commission of an act that they knew was not brave, and that they feared was hardly just. The mob swayed and surged, wavering between desire and doubt, when T. McF. Patton sprang upon a wagon and in a few words decided the question. The boys were hanged on an oak on the bank of Jackson Creek, while protesting piteously that they had never wronged the whites. Sober reflection brought regret for an act that by no means exalted the white character, and it is very probable that the dreadful savagery subsequently experienced by white families was in retaliation for a deed that, in calmer moments, was regretted as neither courageous nor justifiable.
This was the last session of the people's court in Jackson County, for on September 5, 1853, a regular court was held in Jacksonville, by Hon. Matthew P. Deady, who had just been appointed United States district judge for the Territory of Oregon, by President Pierce.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 362
In August, 1853, [B. F. Dowell] mounted a stump and made a speech to a mob that had a rope around an innocent Indian boy's neck until they wavered so he was permitted to take the rope off the boy's neck, and he took the little fellow by the hand and started for Robinson's Hotel to feed him, and on the way they met a still more infuriated mob, who took the boy back and hung him with the murderers of [Rhodes] Noland.
Benjamin Franklin Dowell, The Heirs of George W. Harris and Mary A. Harris, Indian Depredation Claimants vs. the Rogue River Indians, Cow Creek Indians, and the United States, 1888, page 58
At the close of hostilities [in 1853, Major James Bruce] discovered the peril of entering with but one companion into an armed and excited Indian camp. He performed this intrepid feat at the request of General Lane, who had given the Indians a three days' armistice to come in and conclude a peace, but was annoyed and even perplexed by their failure to do so, and indeed by their entire disappearance. Bruce and R. B. Metcalfe were directed to scout the mountains for the camp of Chief Joseph. After three days' investigation they found him with all his tribe encamped as if for war in a natural fortress. To enter this stronghold and deliver their errand to bring in the Indians was a matter of great delicacy. But descrying the tent of Chief Joseph, which was distinguished by a blue cloth, the spies determined to go to his lodge, relying for safety upon his well-known desire for peace. Before attracting his attention, however, they were seen by the young braves, who assembled in great numbers, running and hooting, and manifestly bent upon spilling the blood of the intruders. Bruce and Metcalfe saw in a moment that their death was imminent; and the Major believes that they must have been slaughtered had not an Indian boy named Sambo suddenly appeared, shouting and averring at the top of his voice that this white man was not to be killed--that he had saved his life and must now be saved. Major Bruce was only too glad to recognize in this youth his Sambo, the Indian formerly the rider of the bell horse on his pack train, whom he had actually saved sometime before at Jacksonville from the hands of the infuriated miners, who were indiscriminately hanging the Indian bell boys then in town. By the shouts and exertions of this faithful Sambo, a diversion was created; and Joseph appeared, by whom the scouts were severely censured for their temerity. Nevertheless they gained time and explained their mission, and at length accomplished their purpose, bringing the chief to General Lane. The Major, however, always thinks with tenderness of the boy Sambo, whose fidelity saved him from a dreadful death.
Elwood Evans, History of the Pacific Northwest Oregon and Washington, vol. II, Portland 1889, page 228
. . . on the fifth [of August, 1853], Thomas J. Wills and Rhodes Noland were killed, and Burrell B. Griffin and one Davis wounded. Hastily formed volunteer companies patrolled the roads and warned settlers, who gathered their families into a few fortified houses, and setting over them a guard, joined the volunteers.
On the seventh of August two Shasta Indians were captured, one on Applegate Creek and the other on Jackson Creek. Both were in war paint, and on investigation were proved guilty of the murder of Wills and Noland, for which they were hung at Jacksonville. Not satisfied with this act of justice, an Indian lad who had nothing whatever to do with the murders was seized and hung by the infuriated miners. So great was the excitement that it was dangerous for a man to suggest mercy.
Frances Fuller Victor, Early Indian Wars of Oregon, 1894, page 308
Two Indian boys came to town [one] named Little Jim and another mere stripling whom the people thought were spies. They were seized by an excited crowd that did not know what to do with the prisoners. The mob wavered between desire and doubt until F. M. Patton decided the question. The boys were hanged on an oak tree near Jackson Creek protesting all the while they had never wronged the whites.
Jessie Beulah Wilson (Jacksonville High School student), "History of Jacksonville," Jacksonville Sentinel, June 5, 1903, page 4
Indian Tom, Indian George and Indian Thompson, January 10, 1854:
It's possible that Indian Tom and Indian Thompson were the same person.
Fort Lane O.T.Sir,
Oct. 12, 1853
On the night of the 7th two Inds. shot a man by the name of Kyle, who was a partner of Wills, one of the persons shot at the commencement of the late war.
It occurred near Willow Springs at about 10 o'clock at night.
The two Inds. belong on the Klamath, though they have spent much of the last year with those in this valley. One of them is related by marriage to Tyee Jo & they both have many friends among the young Indians here. And it was a severe test of the Inds.' desire for peace to be compelled [to] deliver them up. But they did so yesterday morning. They are now in the guard house, where they will be kept until the next term of the dist. court.
I think peace now more firmly settled than ever.
Very respectfully,Joel Palmer Supt. &c.
Your obt. servt.
S. H. Culver
Oct. 13. P.S. Kyle died this morning.
Microcopy of Records of the Oregon Superintendency of Indian Affairs 1848-1873, Reel 12; Letters Received, 1853, No. 66.
INDIAN FAITH.--Mr. James Kyle, an estimable citizen of Jackson County, and partner of Thomas Wills, who was killed in the war, was recently murdered by some Indians near Willow Springs. Col. Wright immediately demand the murderers of the chief Joe, and they were promptly brought in and delivered up, even before Mr. Kyle died, he not having been instantly killed. The Indians will be tried and punished.
This act shows a disposition on the part of Joe, who is the head chief, to observe the requirements of the treaty. A more particular account of this affair will be found in our Fort Lane letter.
Oregon Statesman, Salem, November 8, 1853, page 2
Southern District O.T.
Febry. 14, 1854
The two Indians that I have in custody charged with having been the murderers of James Kyle, also one that was delivered to me as the murderer of Mr. Edwards, were executed on the 10th instant.
One that I had in custody charged with theft was acquitted.
I find it necessary to be constantly among the Indians. They take the loss of these three Indians much to heart (their relations) and must be watched closely. I returned late last night from Applegate Creek & am trying to get all of these relatives in to the agency.
The mail will leave in a short time. I have only time to express the hope that nothing will prevent a farm's being started on the reserve for the benefit of the Indians next spring.
Respectfully yoursJoel Palmer Supt. &c.
S. H. Culver
Microcopy of Records of the Oregon Superintendency of Indian Affairs 1848-1873, Roll 4; Letter Books C:10.
The murderers of Edwards and Kyle were tried in the district court at Jacksonville on the 7th and 8th of January, 1854. They were found guilty and hanged on the following Friday, being the 10th day of January.
The following particulars of the trial of those murderers are gleaned from the records of the court.
The officers of the court were Hon. O. B. McFadden, Judge; C. Sims, Prosecuting Attorney; Matthew G. Kennedy, Sheriff; and Lycurgus Jackson, Clerk.
The grand jury presented indictments against Indian Tom and George for the murder of James C. Kyle.
They were brought into court and arraigned, and having no counsel, the court appointed D. B. Brenan and P. P. Prim to defend them; these attorneys being their choice. Louis Dennis was appointed, in connection with Mr. Culver, to act as interpreters to the court and jury. Indian George was first put on trial, and the following jury was empaneled to try the case: S. D. Vandyke, Edward McCartie, T. Gregard, A. Davis, Robt. Hargadine, A. D. Lake, James Hamlin, Sam'l. Hall, Frederick Alberding, F. Heber and R. Henderson. After hearing the evidence in the case, arguments of counsels and charge of the judge, they rendered a verdict of murder in the first degree. On motion of the prosecuting attorney the court proceeded to pronounce the following sentence as the judgment of the court.
You, Indian George, have been indicted and tried for one of the highest offenses known to the law, to wit: The crime of murder. You have had a fair and impartial trial, as much so as if you had belonged to our own race; you have had the benefit of counsel who did everything for you that was possible. But an intellectual and upright jury, upon a fair and dispassionate examination of the evidence given against you, not only by those whom you suppose to be unfriendly toward your people, but by the chiefs of your own tribe, have found you, Indian George, guilty in manner and form as you stand indicted, of having on the night of the 7th of Oct., 1853, deliberately, and without premeditation and malice, shot Jas. C. Kyle, and as there was no provocation on the part of Mr. Kyle which could justify you in the use of violence toward him, they have said that you are guilty of murder in first degree, an offense which by our laws is punishable by death. It, therefore, becomes my duty to pass on you the sentence approved by our laws.
The sentence of the court is, that you, Indian George, be taken hence by the Sheriff of the county of Jackson, and be by him, the said Sheriff, kept and detained in safe and secure custody until Friday, the 19th day of February, A. D., 1854, and between the hours of 10 o'clock a.m., and 12 a.m., of said day; and that you, Indian George, be taken by the said Sheriff or his lawful deputy of successor in office, on the day and between the hours in that he has last aforesaid, from the place of confinement to a gallows, to be by said Sheriff for that purpose erected at Jacksonville, in the county of Jackson, and there to be hanged by the neck, until you, Indian George, be dead and may God have mercy on your soul.
"The Beginning of the Rogue River War--The Murder of the Indian Boy, etc. etc.," Ashland Tidings, October 25, 1878 A full transcription of the district court docket is here.
On the sixth day of February  a new judge called court. The enemies of Judge Deady had been busy at Washington, it is said, and by the most gross misrepresentation procured his displacement, the executive appointing O. B. McFadden, a citizen of Pennsylvania, to the territorial bench. Court was held in a building next to the "New State " saloon, and it was a most unpretentious temple of justice. The bench was a dry-goods box, covered with a blue blanket, and it is quite probable that the uncomfortable seat occupied by the judge was so irksome that it had something to do with his rapid dispensation of justice. The officers of the court were Columbus Sims, prosecuting attorney; G. Kennedy, sheriff; and Lycurgus Jackson, clerk. On the first day of court, Paine P. Prim and D. B. Brenan were admitted to the bar, and the grand jury was empaneled. On the seventh, true bills were returned against Indians George and Tom, charging them with the murder of James C. Kyle, on 1853; October 7 [sic], on the same day they were arraigned and put upon trial, Prim and Brenan having been appointed counsel for the accused. The proceedings were brief, the evidence, mostly that of Indians, who were anxious to preserve peace with the whites, left no doubt as to the guilt of the prisoners, and the jury, with little deliberation, announced a verdict of guilty. In the meantime the grand jury had found another indictment against Indian Thompson, for the murder of Edwards in the spring of 1853, and he, too, was quickly convicted. On the ninth, it appears from the record, Indian George was sentenced to be "hanged by the neck until dead," the time of execution being fixed between the hours of ten and twelve of the succeeding day; but it does not appear that the other two convicted murderers were ever sentenced; and the impression is left that time was so valuable that, in their cases, the formality was dispensed with. In passing sentence upon George, his honor assured the prisoner, with becoming gravity, that he had had as fair a trial, and as ample means of defense, as if he had belonged to the white race; but the lightning speed with which the judge hurried the doomed wretch out of the world throws a slight cloud on the sincerity of his remarks. Indeed, it can not be fairly doubted that if the murderer had been a white, he would have been granted thirty days for repentance; but his honor probably concluded that the Indian had no soul, and repentance was therefore improbable, although he closed by requesting God to have mercy on the spiritual portion of the culprit. Though the record is silent as to the other two convicted murderers, all three were swung from the same gallows on the tenth of the same month. Large numbers of people came from the mining camps, and a few, whom the news had reached out in the valley, came into town to witness the first legal execution, but the event was marked with decorum, and nine out of ten acquiesced in the justice of the punishment. This was the last court held in Jacksonville by Judge McFadden. Judge Deady's friends had righted matters at Washington and procured his reinstatement, McFadden being transferred to Washington Territory.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 366
Very soon after the construction of the military post was resolved upon, a circumstance occurred which ranks as one of the most important, and at the same time singular, that we have to narrate. This was the murder of James C. Kyle, on the sixth of October, 1853, by Indians from the Table Rock reservation. This sad affair took place within two miles of Fort Lane, at a time when the settlers were congratulating themselves that Indian difficulties were at an end. Kyle was a merchant of Jacksonville, partner of Wills whose untimely and cruel death has been recorded. A rigid examination and investigation of the homicide proved that it was committed by individuals from the reservation, and the chiefs were called upon to surrender the criminals in compliance with the terms of the treaty. They did so, and two Indians, George and Tom, were handed over to the proper authorities, as the murderers of Kyle, while Indian Thompson, tillicum of the same tribe, who has been previously mentioned, was surrendered as the murderer of Edwards. Like Thompson, the other two suspects were tried before Judge McFadden of the United States circuit court, at Jacksonville, in February, 1854. They were found guilty, and hanged two days later.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 231
On the fourth of August  the first act of the new era of hostilities took place, being the murder of Edward Edwards, an old farmer, residing on Bear Creek, about two and a half miles below the town site of Phoenix. In his absence the murderers secreted themselves in his cabin, and on his return at noon, shot him with his own gun, and after pillaging the house fled to the hills. There were but few concerned in the deed, and subsequent developments fixed the guilt upon Indian Thompson, who was surrendered by the chiefs at Table Rock, tried in the United States circuit court in February, 1854, and hanged two days later. According to the prevailing account of the circumstances of this murder, the deed was committed in revenge for an act of injustice perpetrated on an Indian by a Mexican named Debusha, who enticed or abducted a squaw from Jim's village, and when the chief and the woman's husband went to reclaim her they were met by threats of shooting. Naturally disturbed by the affair, the aggrieved brave started upon a tour of vengeance against the white race, killing Edwards and attempting other crimes. Colonel Ross, a prominent actor in the events that followed, identifies the murderer as Pe-oos-e-cut, a nephew of Chief John, of the Applegates, and represents the difficulty substantially as above stated, adding the particulars that Debusha had bought the squaw, of whom the Indian had been the lover. She ran away to a camp on Bear Creek, and the Mexican, with Charles Harris, went to the camp and took her from Pe-oos-e-cut, much to his anger and grief. The disappointed lover next day began venting his rage against the whites by killing cattle and also shot Edwards as described. No sooner had the murder become known, than other savages became imbued with a desire to kill, and during the following fortnight several murders were committed, through treachery mainly.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 213
J. H. Williamson, a prominent flour manufacturer of Muncie, Ind., has been visiting in Jacksonville, accompanied by his wife; the guests of Mrs. E. J. Kubli. Mr. W. is a brother of Mack Williamson, who was killed by a Spaniard in early days and whose murderer was lynched by citizens.
"Personal Mention," Democratic Times, Jacksonville, June 15, 1899, page 3
"Do you remember the Spaniard that killed Alex Williamson?" asked one of the group. "Williamson was foreman of a pack train. A Spaniard driving for him stabbed him, thinking he would be able to get away, but by the merest chance another pack outfit came in sight of the camp just as the murder occurred. They caught the Spaniard, put a rope around his neck and threw the rope over a tree and pulled away. The Spaniard, whose hands were not tied, grabbed the rope above his head and began climbing up. One of the packers grabbed him by the legs and brought him down with a jerk, and hung to him until he had strangled to death. It was swift but sure justice."
Fred Lockley, "A Town That Lives in the Past," Oregon Journal, Portland, November 24, 1912, page 63
George M. Bowen, 1860:
MURDERER TO BE HANGED.--James W. Bowen, convicted by the Circuit Court of Jackson County, Southern Oregon, for murder, has been sentenced to be hung on 19th August.
San Francisco Bulletin, July 25, 1859, page 3
Geo. M. Bowen, convicted of the murder of a Chinaman at Jacksonville, Oregon, was sentenced to be hung on the 10th February next.
"The Overland Mails: Yreka," Los Angeles Star, January 28, 1860, page 3
THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF OREGON, To L. J. C. Duncan, of Jackson County, in said State, George M. Bowen, now under sentence of death, and of said County and State, and to all others to whom these presents shall come, greeting:
KNOW YE, That a petition has been presented to me praying for a commutation of the sentence pronounced against the said Bowen from death to imprisonment for life, and that accompanying said petition are copies of the indictment and evidence used by the State on the trial of the said Bowen; .also, the affidavit of Robert Opp, touching the mortality of the wounds inflicted on the deceased Chinaman of whose death the said Bowen stands convicted.
Now, after having had the aforenamed papers under strict advisement, noting the fact that no post mortem examination, or coroner's inquest were had, and that no Physician was called to testify as to the extent of the injury done the said Chinaman by the wound inflicted, we are of the opinion that common justice would demand that evidence going to show that the deceased Chinaman did not necessarily die from the effects of said wounds, and that if proper care had been given, death need not have ensued therefrom, should be fairly considered by me.
Therefore, for these and other reasons, and to the end that strict justice may prevail, be it known, that I, John Whiteaker, Governor of the State of Oregon, do issue this my warrant unto you the said L. J. C. Duncan, Sheriff of Jackson County, and George M. Bowen, now under sentence of death, directing you, the said Sheriff, to stay the execution of the sentence of the court from the tenth day of February, 1860, to the ninth day of March of the same year, when if no other order shall have been made, you, the said L. J. C. Duncan will proceed to execute the sentence as already directed by the court.
In testimony whereof I have hereunto signed my name and will cause the seal of the State to be affixed this 1st day Of Feb'y., 1860.
By the Governor, JOHN WHITEAKER.
LUCIEN HEATH, Secretary of State.
Journal of the Proceedings of the Senate, begun Sept. 10, 1860, Salem 1860, Appendix, page 6
Geo. M. Bowen, whose execution, for the murder of a Chinaman, was to have taken place at Jacksonville, Oregon, on Friday last, has been respited until the 9th of March, by Governor Whiteaker.
"Telegraphic," The Daily Appeal, Marysville, California, February 13, 1860, page 2
THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF OREGON, To George M. Bowen, of Jackson County, in said State, and now under sentence of death, and to all others to whom these presents shall come, greeting:
KNOW YE, That a petition praying for a commutation of the sentence pronounced against the said George M. Bowen from death to imprisonment in the Penitentiary for life, has been presented to me, which petition is signed by numerous good citizens of Jackson and Josephine counties, in this State, among whom are the attorneys for the State in the trial and conviction of the said Bowen, the sheriff of Jackson County, the clerk of the court in which the trial was had, and a part of the jury who sat upon the case, as well as many other citizens whose characters entitle them to respect; and,
Know ye further that said petition was accompanied by the affidavits of Robert Opp, Jerome A. Epperson, E. D. Brown and Paul McQuade, the last three of whom were not witnesses in the trial of the said Bowen, all of whom testify and say that in their opinion the wound inflicted on the deceased Chinaman, and charged in the indictment, was not sufficient to produce death if reasonable care had been given; and there having been no post mortem examination, or coroner's inquest held on the, body of the deceased Chinaman, or physician called on the trial to testify as to the extent of the injury inflicted by the said Bowen on the deceased Chinaman, or the mortality of the wound charged in the indictment;
Now, for these reasons, I have deemed it to be my duty to interpose and stay the too rigorous hand of the law; and in the exercise of the power granted by the Constitution of this State to its Executive, and in conformity with the laws of the same, I, John Whiteaker, Governor of the State of Oregon, do grant the petition of Geo. M. Bowen, now in prison in Jackson County, in this State, and under sentence of death, commuting his sentence to that of imprisonment in the Penitentiary of this State, at hard labor, for life, with the following conditions: That if the said George M. Bowen shall escape, or attempt to escape from his guards, keepers or other persons having him in charge, or from any prison in which he may be lodged under the provisions of this warrant, or shall be found at large anywhere within the limits of this State, he shall forfeit all the rights and privileges granted by this commutation, and shall be held to have escaped while under sentence of death; and it is hereby directed that all persons interested in the execution of the sentence pronounced against said Bowen, or in anywise interested in the custody of his person, as well as the keepers of the Penitentiary, that they take this provision of this warrant strictly in charge, and assist in carrying out the same; Provided, That nothing herein contained shall be so construed as to deny the right of the said Bowen to elect between the sentence of the court, as modified by the respite of the Governor, and the provisions of this commutation. ,
In testimony whereof, I have hereunto signed my name, and will cause the seal of State to be affixed, this 1st day of March, 1860,.
By the Governor, JOHN WHITEAKER.
LUCIEN HEATH, Secretary of State.
Journal of the Proceedings of the Senate, begun Sept. 10, 1860, Salem 1860, Appendix, page 7
COMMUTED.--The sentence of Geo. M. Bowen, convicted of killing a Chinaman some time since, has been commuted from death to imprisonment for life in the penitentiary. The Governor acted thus in answer to the petition of over 600 citizens. The provisions of the commutation are--that if the prisoner escapes, or is found at large within the limits of the state, then he is subject to arrest as an outlaw, and the original sentence of death will be executed upon him.
The Oregon Argus, Oregon City, March 24, 1860, page 2
We have too many gamblers, blacklegs and loafers in our midst. There are too many shooting affrays left almost unnoticed, too many murders committed, and the guilty go unpunished. The above-mentioned class of men have too much to say in our courts of pretended justice. No longer ago than last week the deputy sheriff of this county was circulating a petition for the commutation of Bowen's sentence, who was to have been hung on the 10th inst., but his time was prolonged by the Governor, to give them time to get all the signers possible. Bowen, in attempting to rob a Chinaman of his money, killed him, and now a great many say he ought not to be punished for killing a defenseless Chinaman. It seems to me a cowardly act, which he knew he could commit with impunity and run no risk of losing his own life, unless by the execution of the law, which he is about to avoid by the help of many interested friends. I hope, however, that our Gov. will not be blinded on this matter, but let him pull hemp. Everything is ready, the gallows built, the coffin made, the rope purchased and everything in readiness for the execution and interment.
Letter dated February 26, 1860, Oregon Statesman, Oregon City, March 27, 1860, page 1
On the morning of the 19th, one of the guard at the Penitentiary took out three convicts named George Bowen, Joseph Underwood and Tom Langdon--the first and last of whom were sentenced for life, and the other for two or three years--to work in the upper part of town on a ditch for Pentland's water works. Bowen took advantage of the guard, who had his hands in his pockets, by "mugging" him; that is, pushing his head down against his breast, while the other two disarmed him. They then fled.
"Late from Oregon," Sacramento Daily Union, March 30, 1861, page 4
Geo. M. Bowen, the escaped convict and murderer, was shot dead on Monday, about ten miles above Happy Camp, Del Norte County, by the deputy sheriff. Bowen's partner, a Mexican, was also killed by the officer. They were armed with three revolvers and a knife.
"From Oregon," Red Bluff Independent, May 21, 1861, page 3
On the 5th of May, Deputy Sheriff Morris, of Del Norte County, killed the noted Geo. Bowen, highwayman, and another desperado, name unknown. Bowen was an escaped state convict. He had been sentenced to hang for murder in Oregon, but the Governor commuted the punishment to imprisonment, conditionally that he should suffer extreme punishment in the event of his escape and recapture.
"By Telegraph to the Union," Sacramento Daily Union, May 21, 1861, page 2
FILLING ANOTHER MAN'S GRAVE.
BY THE EDITOR.
We had a good many roughs in Southern Oregon twenty years ago, just such fellows as afterwards adorned the pines of Idaho and Montana, and there is a little bit of history connected with one of them that seems to substantiate the doctrine of total depravity and shows that an empty and unowned grave may not be without its uses. His name was George M. Bowen, but more a coward than a desperado, and his game was principally the plunder of Chinese miners. Bowen claimed to be an "honest miner" himself, frequently coming into town for small supplies and for a long time was unsuspected of being merely a thief. He played his game of Chinese tax-gatherer long and successfully, and probably too cowardly to attack nobler game, he shrewdly confined his operations to that docile race. At last the Chinese became tired of the repeated and exorbitant levies on their industry. Bowen haunted them by day and by night, like an evil spirit, and hardly a camp on Applegate escaped his vigilance, and he became a terror to the whole Chinese population of that stream. At last, emboldened by success, Bowen attacked a large camp near O'Brien's and demanded tribute, but the Chinese resisted and in the struggle one of them was killed by the highwayman. A desperate but strategic onset was now made and Bowen, tripped by a rope in the hands of about a dozen of Chinamen, was disarmed, wrapped in a pair of blankets like an Egyptian mummy, brought to Jacksonville by his captors and delivered to the authorities. There seemed to be little doubt of Bowen's guilt, and his face, stamped with the hoof of sin, would have convicted him. It was an ill-looking, a selfish, cruel and hard-featured face, and when brought before Recorder Hayden it was still covered with the lampblack used to disguise it. Waiving an examination, the robber was committed to jail on a charge of murder and his trial set for the July term in 1859. When the case came up, Reed and Burnett appeared in behalf of the prisoner, but after an able and determined effort their client was fairly convicted and sentenced by Judge Prim, now on the supreme bench, to be hanged on Friday the 19th day of August [sic] in that year. Murder had been too frequent, conviction too uncommon, and it was felt that the spirit that prompted violence to the Chinese would grow bolder in time if unrestrained. The prisoner's counsel were alone dissatisfied. With a just professional pride they had made a gallant fight to save his worthless neck and, determined that it should not be broken, they renewed it by carrying the case to the supreme court on a writ of error. The court, then composed of Aaron E. Waite, Chief Justice, and Boise and Prim associates, carefully considering the case at the December term affirming the judgment of the court below and ordering that its mandate be executed within thirty days. The action of the supreme court was not surprising, as the errors were known to be trivial but had given the doomed man a longer lease of life, and it was used by the Rev. Mr. Driver for his conversion. Daily, nightly, for weeks and weeks did the zealous minister pray for and appeal to the better nature of the prisoner, and never did a holy man work more faithfully to prepare a soul for that bar of justice which is higher than all. The man's better nature was but a spark nearly crushed out by a life of crime, but the kindly breath of Christianity resuscitated it and Mr. Driver at last wrung from him words of repentance and contrition and firmly believed that he had accomplished a genuine conversion. There was now a peculiar interest taken in Bowen's case. His attorneys not only chagrined at the prospect of a client suffering the extreme penalty of the law, but moved to compassion by his sorrowful repentance, prepared a petition for executive clemency, asking only for a commutation of his punishment, but Bowen understood himself better than his friends and stubbornly refused to sign the petition himself. It was in vain that his spiritual adviser urged him to make an effort to save a life that hereafter, usefully spent, might be a living lesson of the benignant influence of religion. It was to no purpose that he pictured the ignominy of the gallows. Bowen was happy, and, perhaps, really tired of a life thrown away and forfeited, was determined to be hung. The unfortunate man knew himself well--much better indeed than those who would save him--and argued that if only imprisoned he might be tempted to escape and return to his old business. Yielding to the unceasing efforts of Mr. Driver, who finally impressed the prisoner with the sense of his duty as a free moral agent, Bowen at last signed the petition. There was no telegraph in Oregon at that early day, no line of stages between here and the seat of government, and the document and reasons for its favorable consideration were entrusted to David Linn, then County Treasurer, and about to start for Salem with the Territorial funds. Mr. Linn was faithful to his trust. Not finding Governor Whiteaker at Eugene City, he pushed on to "Cloverdale" and delivered his package to that official with the understanding that the case would be immediately considered and an answer delivered at Eugene on the expected date of Mr. Linn's return. The Governor was prompt and in a few days the messenger turned homewards with a sealed package containing an answer more bitter than senna--sweeter, perhaps, than the honey of Hybla to a human being, but unknown to the bearer. Mr. Linn pushed along over the dreadful roads between here and Eugene City, through mud and snow and storm he crowded his jaded horse, feeling, perhaps, that a human life was in his hands, and arriving worn and weary at Rock Point, distant about thirteen miles from the county seat, late in the night, just prior to the day fixed for the execution. Jacksonville was full of people, and public excitement was at its height. It was to be a gala day in the annals of Southern Oregon justice, and hundreds and hundreds of visitors, with that strange and morbid feeling that desires yet dreads to see a shocking spectacle, came wishing but fearing to see a human being strangled to death. Bowen and his friends were despondent, nothing having been heard from the messenger; the rope was swinging like a hateful, ill-omened thing on the gallows; the grave was dug; the felon's coffin was ready, and as the hours sped quickly on, hope grew faint and fainter still till it died in the heart of the condemned man. The time for the execution had been fixed at 2 p.m., but just at noon Mr. Linn appeared and immediately delivered the Governor's package. The officers of the court were instantly summoned, the package opened in their presence, and the Governor's answer "commuted to imprisonment for life," promulgated to an excited, anxious and half-angry crowd. There was bitter disappointment, but it is doubtful if it was experienced by any more than the prisoner. The air rang with imprecations; for a short time Mr. Linn was cursed for the faithful discharge of a sacred trust, but quiet was soon restored and the crowd left town, many of them, with a strange but human perverseness regretting the loss of an exhibition which they hoped would not take place. The authorities had now come very unsaleable property on their hands. The grave in the potter's field, dug for the malefactor, would hardly afford a quiet resting place for a decent corpse; the overseers of the poor would scarcely dare to lay the bones of a pauper in [illegible] William Casterlin, drunker or less shrewd than the rest, was singled out as the guilty party and held to answer. During his confinement he was allowed to talk to his fellow prisoner, Bowen, frequent speculations on their chances being indulged in, and even when the preparations were made for Bowen's execution he sold his grave and coffin to Casterlin, the delivery being contingent upon Bowen's escape from the gallows. Casterlin was tried at the March term 1860, and by many it is still thought his life was "sworn away." Convicted of murder in the first degree, he was sentenced on the 3rd day of April to be hanged, the 11th day of May being fixed for the execution. Casterlin had no friends, no money; no effort was made to save him; and whether from an economical desire on the part of the officials that unmarketable county property should be utilized, or a public demand that someone should be hanged, the sentence was duly executed by the hand of Sheriff Duncan. It was never known whether the title in fee passed between the two murderers, but at all events the yawning grave was closed, and the "majesty" of the law--that intangible and unknown quantity that so sensitively corresponds with the financial ability of a criminal--fully vindicated.
Bowen was immediately after his reprieve safely lodged in the penitentiary, but having tasted life he wanted liberty and soon made his escape, and true to his instincts at once returned to his bad life. Del Norte County in the northern part of California was now the scene of his operations, and many and fearful were the tales told by the terrified Chinese who had been plundered by the masked and desperate robber. At last the Chinese offered a reward of one thousand dollars for his capture. Hunted and hounded like a wolf, Bowen long eluded his pursuers, but was at last found in a secluded cabin, where he had taken refuge, by the deputy sheriff. Perceiving the officer approach, the highwayman turned quickly to seize his firearms and was instantly shot down, falling mortally wounded. Bowen's intimate knowledge of his own character was fully proved. A career which he feared he might again be driven into by his own bad nature was checked. He died like a wild beast when he might have slid off quietly under the influence of hallowed and sacred things, with full faith in the promises of the Redeemer, and as the last spark flickered out, the memory of the few happy hours he had known seemed to come struggling back, for his last words were--"Wish to God I'd been hung!"
Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, January 29, 1879, page 1
William Casterlin, May 11, 1860:
"In the Midst of Life We Are in Death."
The value of life seems very little in California and the adjoining countries. It is here, a word and a blow--a trifling insult and death. In the interior nearly all carry deadly weapons which are used upon each other upon the slightest provocation, or without provocation at all. Bystanders see the murderous assault made, but often they either cannot or will not interfere. The columns of the daily and weekly press are filled with the narratives of such deeds. Keeping silence, or glossing things over, does not mend the matter. The evil exists among us, in the bad passions, the lack of self-control, and the pernicious usages of a semi-barbarous society. To soften their savage manners and truly civilize our people, we must first know the nature and extent of the resisting causes, and that knowledge can only be obtained by such very accounts. Yet, while they are published for our own use, and to gratify an unrestrainable appetite for news, they also enlighten others at a distance. From other lands then come scandal and disgrace upon our country, while by such means immigration is undoubtedly prevented to a large extent. California, in the minds of many persons in the Atlantic States and in Europe, has always been a byword and a reproach, and men of sober, quiet and peaceable habits naturally fear to trust themselves, their wives and families in such a terrible land--where the Right of Private Revenge stalks unblushingly abroad.
These remarks are suggested by the following report of a case of murder which we find in the Jacksonville Sentinel (Southern Oregon, near the California line) of 10th December:
"On Saturday night last (3rd December), at a place generally known as 'Mooney's,' about seven miles from Jacksonville, Samuel Mooney was shot dead by William Casterlin. The facts of the case, as elicited in an examination on Tuesday before Squire U. S. Hayden, are as follows:
"Casterlin and Mooney had been in Jacksonville together on Saturday, and with two other gentlemen, Dr. Elliott and Squire Abbott, returned to the house where the tragedy occurred after dark. The house was owned by Mooney, but he had recently rented it to Casterlin. On arrival there, Mooney and Abbott got supper ready, and the four persons ate at the table, apparently a friendly companionship. After supper, Casterlin took Mooney to task for having disappointed him in taking some scrip which he had engaged for Mooney, of a gentleman in town. Mooney endeavored to appease Casterlin's ill humor by promising that he would satisfactorily arrange the matter next day. Casterlin then remarked that Mooney had 'made him out a d--n liar,' and added 'Sam Mooney, allow me to tell you that you are a God d--n liar.'
"Mooney did not respond to this insult, but said, 'I am sleepy now, Bill, and want to go to bed. In the morning we will make it all right.'
"Casterlin then swore that 'there should be no sleeping in this house tonight.'
"Mooney quietly said, 'Well, if I can't sleep here I have a hay rick, and will go sleep there.' He then took his blankets and left the house.
"Instantly, Casterlin took down a loaded rifle from the rack, cocked it, and sprang towards the door. Dr. Elliott endeavored to prevent him from going to the door, but Casterlin shoved him aside. Abbott then stepped before him, and begged him to consider what he was about to do. Casterlin swore at Abbott, and told him if he did not step out of the way, he 'would put it through him.' Abbott was obliged to obey, to save his own life. Casterlin fired immediately. A heavy fall and some low moans were heard by Elliott and Abbott. Casterlin seized another rifle from the rack, which Abbott quickly wrested from him. He then got down a double-barreled fowling piece, which fortunately was not loaded.
"Abbott and Elliott then went out to examine Mooney's wound and bring him into the house. After laying him upon the floor, Dr. Elliott made an examination of the body. The ball had penetrated the left collarbone, cut through the windpipe, coursed obliquely and downward and came out a little to the right of the spine, near the junction of and between the fifth and sixth ribs. It had caused instant death. From some coagulated blood which had spurted from the wound upon the left eye and cheek of the deceased, Squire Abbott thought the ball had entered the eye, and said so to Dr. Elliott.
"Casterlin remarked: 'He is not shot in the eye; I know where I hit him; he is shot in the breast.'
"Abbott then told Casterlin that he was a prisoner, to which the latter replied: 'I am willing to give myself up to any of the officers.'
"The assistance of two other persons was then procured. Casterlin was brought to Jacksonville and delivered into the custody of the Sheriff.
"Abbott testified that Casterlin had threatened two weeks previous to the commission of the deed, to 'kill Mooney if ever he laid hand' on him. Dr. Elliott and Squire Abbott were the only witnesses examined. Their evidence was similar in every important point, and most direct against the prisoner. Justice Hayden committed Casterlin to prison upon the charge of murder, to await the action of the grand jury.
"Mooney was about fifty years of age, and bore the reputation of being a quiet, inoffensive man. Himself and the accused lived together at the cabin in which he lost his life. It is not known that there had been any difficulty between them except that about the county scrip on the evening of the murder.
"Casterlin is between forty and forty-five years old, has lived in this valley for some years, and formerly lived in Iowa. He is a cooper by trade. Until this act, he had not given any evidence, so far as we can learn, of such murderous proclivities. He will remain in prison until the next term of the Circuit Court, and till Judge Prim calls up his case."
We may add that the case recorded above is stated by the Jacksonville Sentinel to have been the fourth homicide committed in the two counties of Jackson and Josephine within the previous six weeks.
San Francisco Bulletin, December 23, 1859, page 1
We learn from the Jacksonville Sentinel that Samuel Mooney, an old and well-known citizen of Jackson County, was recently shot by Wm. Casterlin. Mooney was shot in his own house, in the presence of two gentlemen. Casterlin was arrested and committed to jail. . . . Murders are becoming frequent in the southern portion of our state, as well as in the north. Life is held entirely too cheap on the Pacific coast, and it requires at the hands of our courts the adoption of some means to prevent the destruction of human life.
"Letter from the North: Oregon," Daily Alta California, San Francisco, December 25, 1859, page 2
Execution at Jacksonville, Oregon
Wm. Casterlin was hung at Jacksonville on Friday last, for the murder of Samuel Mooney on the 3d of last December. Upon arriving at the spot selected for the execution, Casterlin made a few remarks, disclaiming any willfulness in taking the life of Mooney. These remarks were delivered in a clear, audible tone, and he carried with him to the last moment the same imperturbable demeanor which he had maintained during his trial and upon hearing his death sentence. It is the first legal execution ever held in Jackson County.
Sacramento Daily Union, May 14, 1860, page 2
The original indictment, trial record and execution warrant are in the collection of the Southern Oregon Historical Society, M45A Box 3, Accession No. 1978.15. The document throughout spells his name as "Casterlin."
Tyee George, November 19, 1863:
The event of the hanging of this Indian, Tyee George, on the nineteenth of November, 1863, is well remembered in Jackson County, and with its attendant circumstances has there become one of the principal romances of the time. Some Klamaths sought and obtained from their agent, Rogers, nicknamed "Sugar Foot," permission to reside on the west side of the Cascades. They came in small numbers, their chief men being George and Jack, and made themselves at home, roaming at will over the land and somewhat disturbing the settlers. They were said to have threatened individuals' lives, shot cattle, thrown down fences, and committed divers other misdemeanors. In consequence of these charges, George, who was indiscreet enough to come to town, was arrested in Jacksonville, and immediately delivered over to Charles Drew, commanding the volunteers at Camp Baker. Here his doom was speedily met: for by an unexampled stretch of arbitrary authority, the man in command ordered the Indian's execution at once, and he was hanged in the presence of the soldiery, without the least delay. Jack escaped death, and with the most of his people hastened to safer fields, leaving George's mother, Old Mary, to enact her part in this little but sorrowful drama, by burying her son where he now lies, by the side of her own humble wickiup, and kindling upon his grave the sacred fire that in the beautiful Indian superstition is supposed to guide the wandering soul to the islands of the blessed. Poor old Mary is still known in Jacksonville where her woes and maternal devotion have raised up sympathizing friends; and poetry has lent its aid to make memorable an episode resembling that of Rizpah and her sons, described in the scriptures.
A. G. Walling, History of Southern Oregon, 1884, page 347
Some time after November 18, 1863, George went to Jacksonville and was immediately arrested by volunteers who happened to be in town. He was confined overnight and the next day taken to Camp Baker. Upon his arrival there a short consultation was held among the officers, when the order came from Colonel Drew to hang George at once. A pair of mules was hitched to a wagon, a goods box placed in the bed, the condemned man pinioned and lifted on the box, a rope put around his neck, and with two men holding him, the wagon was driven just outside the parade ground, the rope thrown over the limb of a tree, the wagon driven from under him, and all that was mortal of Tyee George was left suspended in the air. This summary execution gave rise to much severe and adverse criticism, while many endorsed and applauded the act. It must be understood that there was no specific charge against George. He was arrested upon no indictment or information, arraigned before no judge or magistrate, had neither attorney, judge nor jury, and was not court-martialed, but hanged solely upon his reputation as a vicious character and a menace to the public. There appears to have been nothing to warrant this infliction of the death penalty, no condition of affairs that would justify it, and no excuse for the savage and unseemly haste with which the extreme order was carried into execution. In taking an unbiased retrospect of the matter after the smoke has cleared away, and all passion and prejudice have been eliminated, there is no position from which the action can be viewed that will relieve the officers who ordered his execution from the imputation of the most arbitrary and shameful exercise of power. The straight, undisguised English of the fact is that he was unwarrantly lynched under cover of military authority, and the barbarous proceeding cannot be otherwise fitly characterized. This will more fully appear when it is understood the civil courts were in no way under restraint, that they were free to act and open to investigate criminal charges and punish violations of law.
W. J. Plymale, "Sketch of Tyee George and Skookum John," Medford Sun, April 26, 1911, page 3
Lewis O'Neil, March 12, 1886:
ANOTHER MURDER.--Lewis McDaniel, an old settler of this county, was found in a dying condition in the road leading to his residence in Ashland last Thursday night about eight o'clock. The appearances indicated that he had been shot by some party unknown while on his way home, the top of his head being blown off by what appeared to be a shot from a gun. When discovered he was just breathing his last and could not tell who shot him or for what cause. Justice Eubanks subpoenaed a coroner's jury for 10 o'clock Friday and immediately telegraphed District Attorney Kent to attend to take evidence, but the examination had not concluded last night. A man named O'Neil has been arrested on suspicion and is being held to await developments. Mr. McDaniel was something like 48 years of age, married, and was generally supposed to be well fixed in worldly goods. All kinds of rumors are afloat as to what might have been the cause of the murder, and as the coroner's jury had not yet completed its labors last evening we forbear further comment for the present. District Attorney Kent telegraphed last evening that "it was a very rough case."
Oregon Sentinel, November 22, 1884, page 3
THE McDANIEL CASE.--After a thorough investigation of the McDaniel murder case at Ashland, the coroner's jury reported as follows, and O'Neil is now in jail here, having been committed by Justice Eubanks of that place:
We, the undersigned, summoned to inquire into the causes which led to the death of Lewis McDaniel, do find as follows: That the person who was killed was a man by the name of Lewis McDaniel, a resident of Ashland, Jackson County, state of Oregon; that the said Lewis McDaniel was killed on the night of the 20th day of November, A.D. 1884, at about 7:30 o'clock p.m., on Church Street in the town of Ashland, Jackson County, Oregon, by means of a shotgun which had been loaded with buckshot and fired at the deceased from a short distance. And we believe that said gun was held in the hands of a man by the name of Lewis O'Neil when said Lewis McDaniel was killed; and we hereby charge the said Lewis O'Neil with the murder of the said Lewis McDaniel.
Signed by us this 26th day of November A.D. 1884.
H. C. Hill,Oregon Sentinel, November 29, 1884, page 3
B. F. Myer,
J. S. Eubanks, Jr.
The trial of Mrs. Amanda McDaniel, charged with being an accessory in the murder of her husband in Ashland last winter, is just concluded. The jury was composed of the following-named citizens: Wm. Mayfield, of the Meadows; Squire Walton and G. W. Howard, of Medford; J. W. Plymire, of Manzanita; Rufus Cox and Mr. Turpin, of Little Butte; Ralph Dean, of Willow Springs; Frank Parker and B. F. Miller, of Rock Point; Wm. Miller and J. T. Layton, of Applegate; T. J. Keaton, of Poorman's Creek. [omission] as possible. The verdict of not guilty was returned yesterday.
"News of the Northwest: Oregon," Oregonian, Portland, November 26, 1885, page 3
MUST HANG.--A petition for a rehearing in the case of Lewis O'Neil, convicted of the murder of Lewis McDaniel, was denied by the Supreme Court on Tuesday last. He will probably receive his second sentence of death next week, and Governor Moody is the only one that can save him from the gallows. He made an attempt some time ago to starve himself to death but gave it up. It is reported now that he is making a second attempt.
Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, January 16, 1886, page 3
A constant watch is now kept on the murderer O'Neil.
"Local Items," Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, January 23, 1886, page 3
If Lewis O'Neil, the McDaniels murderer, is hung at Jacksonville, on March 12th, 1886, it will be the first hanging in southern Oregon since Casterlin was hung twenty-five years ago.
"Short Stops," The Daily Astorian, March 10, 1886, page 3
THE EXECUTION.--If nothing unlooked-for appears, O'Neil, the murderer, will have expiated his crime on the gallows before another issue of the Sentinel appears. The Sisters of Mercy pay him regular visits, but all other visitors are excluded. O'Neil will not yet acknowledge his case as hopeless and is said to be as defiant and saucy as ever. Mr. Moon, a relation of his from Colusa, Cal., was here this week making a last effort to have the sentence commuted and is now at Salem to get an interview with Governor Moody. Should this fail the condemned man will be executed in the courthouse yard at 12:30 p.m. on Friday next. A high board fence will enclose the scaffold, and only a few spectators will be allowed inside. The Jacksonville Fire Department will be called out on that day to act as guards and to assist the Sheriff in keeping peace and order.
Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, March 6, 1886, page 3
On Friday, March 12, 1886, Lewis O'Neil suffered the extreme penalty of the law, by hanging until he was dead, for the murder of Lewis McDaniel, committed at Ashland November 20, 1884. The facts in the case have been told so often that they are well known, and it will always be remembered that it was a cold-blooded murder, the assassin giving his victim no warning whatever and shooting him in the side of the face. The execution took place in an enclosure specially built for that purpose in the courthouse yard in the presence of about 120 spectators, the fire co. acting as guards. At two o'clock the condemned man, in charge of Sheriff Jacobs and his deputies and accompanied by Rev. Father Blanchet, his spiritual advisor, ascended the scaffold, when the Sheriff read the death warrant and then asked O'Neil if he had anything to say. Contrary to general expectations he would not confess and would say nothing one way or the other, Father Blanchet speaking for him, stating that the prisoner had nothing to say. The noose was then adjusted by the Sheriff, and at 2:15 the trap fell and Lewis O'Neil was no more, his neck having been broken, and he died almost without a struggle. Drs. Aiken, Robinson, Lempert and DeBar were present, and after hanging about 15 minutes they pronounced him dead, when he was cut down and placed in a coffin that had been prepared for that purpose. A large crowd of people collected on the outside of the courthouse yard during the time, but the best of order prevailed, and all dispersed quietly after the work was done. O'Neil's body was kept until today at the request of relatives, when he was buried in the Jacksonville Cemetery, and so endeth the chapter.
----To show what O'Neil was writing to his friends after his sentence and before his execution we submit the following, dictated by the condemned man and written down by one of the guards acting as death watch:
Substance of letter written to Mrs. McDaniel, in Jan. '86: "Mandy, you know that I told you several times while you were in this place awaiting trial not to be uneasy but if possible to have your trial put back until I could hear what action the supreme court would take in my case. If I was denied a new trial, and you were found guilty, I would come to your relief and clear you by taking the whole responsibility on myself, although I am innocent, but if you could not have your trial put back and that you were found guilty you should never hang or go to the penitentiary for I would save you. Now you have been tried and come clear, and it is in your power to save my life. You can do it by coming into town and swear that you did the killing, and that I had neither hand, act nor part in it, or any knowledge of it. That would clear me, and the law could not hurt you, as it says plainly that no man's life shall be put in jeopardy twice for the same offense. Then I could employ one of the best lawyers in California and come on the state of Oregon for heavy damages, and I would divide equally, or if that was not enough, I would give you all, so I hope you will not delay as I know you can save my life and the disgrace will be no worse on you than it is now."
To Mr. Egerton [sic], San Francisco, Cal., Feb. 1886--"Dear sir: Please see what the law is or what could be done to Mrs. McDaniel in case she would relieve me by taking the whole responsibility herself. Please let me know as soon as possible."
Letter to Mrs. Fouts, Jan. 1886--"Have Joe and Al do all they can to find the man I sold the gun to or anyone that would do that for me. The gun that was seen with me is not the gun displayed in court. The gun I had was not quite as long as the gun they had in court, and instead of a dragon's head being carved on the stock it was a lion's head. It looked very much like the gun that was in court, but was not the same."
Letter to Johns, Feb. 1886:--"Try and get someone to clear me by swearing that they done the killing and that will clear me. Then I will come back on the state for heavy damages and will make it all right with whoever will do it, then they can clear themselves by proving where they were on the 20th of Nov. 1884, the night McDaniel was killed. He was shot with buckshot on [the] left side of the head on Church Street, Ashland, within about 70 yards of his house."
Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, March 13, 1886, page 2
The coffin for O'Neil was made by George Reives, our wagon maker.
Tickets for admission to see the hanging of O'Neil were in demand yesterday, and as high as $5 was paid for a piece of pasteboard granting that privilege.
We claim to speak the truth when we say that every precinct in the county was represented in Jacksonville yesterday. None of them came into see the hanging, but other business of importance called them to town.
"Local Items," Oregon Sentinel, Jacksonville, March 13, 1886, page 3
JACKSONVILLE, March 12.--The McDaniel murder case, which has been in our circuit court since November 18, 1884, has finally terminated in the hanging of Lewis O'Neil, the murderer.
At 1:40 Sheriff Jacobs reported O'Neil as having an interview with friends, at which time he asked for stimulants, they being granted.
An assemblage of about 120 was admitted into the enclosure prepared for the occasion, including thirty members of the Jacksonville fire department, who acted as guards.
At 2:10 the condemned man, accompanied by F. X. Blanchet, priest, Sheriff Jacobs and his two deputies, appeared on the scaffold, O'Neil showing no nervousness whatever. Being placed on the trap door, the sheriff read his death warrant for him. After this he was asked if he had anything to say, but this was answered by Father Blanchet, saying that O'Neil had nothing to say.
The prisoner's feet and hands were then tied, and the black cap placed over his head. The rope was adjusted around his neck, and at 2:15 O'Neil was suspended in mid-air, at the end of six feet of rope. He was pronounced dead by three attending physicians, Aiken, Robinson and DeBar, eight minutes after the fall.
It is rumored that O'Neil made a secret confession to Father Blanchet while in his cell. A few days before the execution O'Neil wrote a letter to his brother at Grave Creek, requesting that he come and suffer the death penalty. Being quite old, he said, it would not be so hard on him, and therefore allow O'Neil the privilege of caring for his family of six children, now residing in California. Since the receipt of the letter O'Neil, of Grave Creek, has died, aged 72 years.
"O'Neil, the Murderer, Hanged at Jacksonville," Oregonian, March 13, 1886, page 1
Lewis O'Neil was hanged at Jacksonville last Friday, for the murder of Lewis McDaniel at Ashland in November '84. This is the first hanging in southern Oregon since 1861 [sic].
The Daily Astorian, March 14, 1886, page 3
MUST HAVE BEEN AFRAID.--On Tuesday evening Mrs. Amanda McDaniel took the northbound train at Medford. Whether or not she has returned to this county we have not heard. Her departure on the evening before the execution of O'Neil has caused much comment.--[Jacksonville Sentinel. From which it might have been inferred that she was afraid O'Neil might "confess" all he knew.
Oregon Statesman, Salem, March 23, 1886, page 3
The Spirits Plead for the Reprieve of a Condemned Murderer.
Editor of Golden Gate:
Recently I heard the report that the jail in which O'Neil is imprisoned is haunted. The Sheriff changed the prisoner to another cell, then placed everything properly in the vacated cell, locked the door and kept the key in his pocket until the next morning, when, to his surprise, on opening the cell, he found everything in it out of place. Others besides the Sheriff and the prisoner heard and saw strange things which they could not account for except they were spooks.
On Wednesday, March 4th, I had a seance with Mrs. R., and heard three raps from a slate which we knew to be fresh cleaned, and at the time lay upon the shelf several feet from where we sat. I took it up and found the following written upon it, which was to the medium, and to myself, as much unexpected as this account is to any who may read it:
FATHER BEESON:--I cannot rest while that poor man is in bondage. You and I must do all that we can for him. I, and other spirits, have been with him a long time. The man who did the deed will confess sometime. He is very unhappy. O'Neil is innocent.
LEWIS MACDANIELS. [sic]On March 5th the following was written by the medium while in the unconscious trance:
DEAR FRIENDS OF JACKSON COUNTY:--I have come to tell you not to hang that man on suspicion. He is not guilty of murder. There are three persons concerned in it. Sheriff Jacobs is a man of truth. He must ask the spirits that come to the cell. They will tell him the circumstances of the murder.
LEWIS MACDANIELS.After a brief rest the medium wrote as follows:
FRIENDS:--Think if it were yourselves (who have dear children) to be led to the gallows while innocent. God help the poor man.
JUDGE EDMONDS.I asked and had the privilege to be locked up in the haunted cell for one night, but being disappointed in my anticipated interview with the spirited visitors, I again went to the medium and received the following answer:
We were with the Governor of Oregon last night trying to impress him to act right for the prisoner. The Governor is kind, but there were so many false oaths on the trial that it is hard for him to counteract them.
I then asked if I could do anything more in the case, and received the following answer from the spirit:
Write to the Governor.
So I wrote to Gov. Moody as follows:
Dear Sir:--The prisoner, O'Neil, is condemned by circumstantial evidence, and as there is a possibility that the witness, the jury and the judge may all have made a fatal mistake, which you alone can correct, I therefore respectfully ask that you will reprieve him, for one month, to test the truth of additional evidence, which can be given.
JOHN BEESON.After some delay at the Executive Office, and the exchange of several telegrams, it was decided "that the condemned man has had every opportunity to disprove his guilt which a fair and impartial trial by jury could afford; and that so far as it be possible to prove a deed by evidence, other than that by an actual witness, the condemned man has been proven guilty of a deliberately planned and intelligently executed murder--a murder which fills to the fullest extent the measure of crime, which under our laws demands the execution of the criminal."
TALENT, Oregon, March 15, '86.
February 27, 1955 Medford Mail Tribune. Never trust newspaper captions--
this gallows was built specially for the O'Neil hanging.
Frank Lawrence Smith, scheduled May 26, 1899:
PETER NELSON FOULLY SLAIN.
One of the most atrocious crimes ever perpetrated in Southern Oregon was made known to our people on the morning of Tuesday, February 15th.
Peter Nelson, a man thirty-odd years of age, was assaulted Tuesday morning on a moving freight train between Medford and Central Point and pushed from the car for dead. While Nelson was seriously wounded, he was not dead, and after the train had passed he wandered about, finally reaching Vinton Beall's farm, from which place, Tuesday afternoon, he was brought to Medford, where he died soon after.
The body was taken to a vacant store room on South Front Street where a postmortem examination was made and a coroner's inquest was held, conducted by Coroner Kirchgessner and District Attorney Jeffrey.
The evidence which was brought out at the inquest is in substance here given: Freight train No. 31, conductor Dickey, passed Medford at 12:10 Tuesday morning and did not stop until Central Point was reached. Hired help employed on the Beall ranch testified that deceased came to their window at 2:50 Tuesday morning and that he awakened them by rapping on the window glass. They told him to go to the porch and they would get up and see what was wanted. He went to the porch and sat down. The men got up and upon finding the man was hurt they awakened Mr. Beall. A drink of coffee was given him, also some water, but all efforts to get him to speak and tell of his injuries were futile, as the only words spoken, and these very incoherently, were "Minnesota," and "fell off the train." About eight o'clock Tuesday morning a conveyance was made ready and he was brought to Medford. Other evidence was brought out which is given in the narrative of the investigation of the case which followed.
The postmortem examination disclosed the fact that the deceased was injured in no other place than about the head, there not being so much as a bruise of the flesh or an abrasion of skin on the body, which fact was evidence conclusive that he was the victim of foul play and that instead of falling from the train and receiving his injuries that way he had been beaten over the head by one or more assailants with a sharp-edged instrument in a boxcar and had been pushed out of the door while the train was in motion.
He was thrown from the train near the edge of the Ish pasture, about two miles north of Medford. An investigation of the ground thereabouts and further on toward Central Point furnishes ample evidence that robbery was the object of the assault. The dirt was soft where he struck the ground, and quite a depression was made by his body in the side of a slight embankment. Right at this place blood was found on the ground in considerable quantity at and on all sides from the place where he struck, indicating a staggering movement when he attempted to arise. About 200 yards this side of where the body struck was found his hat. Further along the track, to the north 200 or 300 yards, was found a pair of blankets, unrolled, and upon which there was a great amount of blood; 200 yards further along the track was found a small sack in which were a revolver and some loose cartridges. A pack cover was found still further on and just beyond that another pair of blankets, then came another hat--this one evidently the hat of one of the assailants. After passing the Beall crossing an empty grain sack that had been ripped open was found and near this were found a whisk broom, quite a large book, upon "The Laws of Nature," book on mining laws, a small dictionary and a small testament. Near Mrs. Fries' place within the incorporate limits of Central Point was found a fairly good satchel. On this the lock had been broken and the sides cut open with a knife. What evidently had been the contents of the satchel were strewn about for some distance and consisted of a suit of clothing, a new shirt, suit of underclothing and two purses--the latter open and empty, but from the appearance of the inside they had but recently contained either gold or silver money in considerable amount. At this point were tracks of two men who had evidently jumped from the car when the train slowed up for Central Point and had made the onslaughter of the satchel while on the ground. There were also shavings covered with blood which had evidently stuck to the boots of the men and were brought from the car with them. All this evidence was brought out before the coroner's jury, as well as some considerable more which is as yet incomplete. In one of the books was found a road receipt from the Willows, Calif. road district, and it was by this that his name, "Peter Nelson," was learned. The jury adjourned until one o'clock Thursday when they were to reconvene, but they were called together Wednesday at one o'clock to examine several witnesses who went from Medford to Gold Hill on that same freight train Tuesday morning. They were examined separately but their evidence threw no light on the crime.
Deceased was seen in Medford Monday afternoon and by Al Crystal, bartender for Court Hall, he was identified as a man to whom he sold a glass of beer that afternoon. Mr. Crystal noticed particularly that he had a peculiar-shaped pack on his back and an unusually large one. He also had a Winchester rifle with him, which has not been found by the searchers of evidence.
The wounds which were inflicted were a continuous fracture of the skull from over the left eye almost over the extreme top of the head to the base of the skull on the back, and in one place near the top of the head the skull was mashed in as if done with the head of a railroad spike protruding from a stick. The same instrument had also inflicted a severe wound over the left eye. At the back of the head the scalp had been removed to the size of half one's hand--like an edged instrument had struck the head and slipped down the back.
The remains were interred in Odd Fellows cemetery Tuesday afternoon and Wednesday a number of citizens "chipped in" and sent a telegram to his brother, who is reported to be living at Nelson, Calif.
The car in which the awful assault was made was returned to Medford Wednesday evening. As soon as it was ascertained that there had been foul play agent Lippincott telegraphed the railroad division superintendent, and he gave orders for agents to inspect all empty cars at their stations, resulting in the finding of proof of trouble in a C.P. car, No. 32,792, which had been "set out" at Gold Hill on Tuesday morning. This was reported and the agent was instructed to seal the car doors, which were not again opened until yesterday morning, when the coroner and jury made a close inspection of its interior.
An examination disclosed the fact that there was a great quantity of blood on the door post, or jamb, on the west side of the car; that the assault had been made at one end of the car; that the body had been dragged to the door and thrown out and that the blood on the door post was where the victim's head had struck when he was thrown from the car. The car floor was covered with planer shavings, and on these was found a trail of blood from the end of the car to the door. At the end of the car was a pool of blood which indicated that the man had been assaulted there while lying on his blanket asleep. A hinge from one of the car ventilators was missing from the car, and the presumption is that it was with this that the assault was made.
There was found pieces of a candle in the car, also a nickel in money showing that the man's pockets were ransacked before he was thrown off. There was also found a piece of a shawl strap and cigarette papers. After this examination there was no further evidence to be adduced by the jury and the following verdict was given.
"We, the jury empaneled to examine into the death of Peter Nelson, find that he came to his death from being struck on the head with some heavy instrument; that killing was murder and that the perpetrators thereof are unknown to the jury."
Medford Mail, February 18, 1898
Chris. Ulrich is at work upon the scaffold upon which Frank Smith will be executed next Friday.
Sheriff Orme has had a high fence built around the jail yard, in order that the execution of Frank Smith may be as private as possible. Chris. Keegan and Thos. Mooney did the work.
"Local Notes," Democratic Times, Jacksonville, May 22, 1899, page 3
Smith Will Pay the Penalty.
It does not seem as if Gov. Geer intends to interfere with the execution of the sentence of death which has been imposed on Frank Smith, the condemned murderer of Peter Nelson. The scaffold, which is the same one that was used in the execution of Lewis O'Neil in 1885, is in position, and everything is ready for the last act of the tragedy that will have cost two lives. Smith still takes his approaching end coolly, though he is now feeling more concerned. He seems to have embraced religion, and shows a determination to meet his fate bravely. Rev. L. P. Desmarais, his spiritual adviser, will probably attend him in his last moments. Sheriff Orme has issued a number of invitations, and the gruesome spectacle will probably be witnessed by about a hundred persons.
Democratic Times, Jacksonville, May 25, 1899, page 3
COMMUTED.The following telegram was last night sent by the governor to Sheriff Alexander Orme, at Jacksonville: ''You are hereby notified that I have this day commuted the sentence of death standing against Frank Lawrence Smith, in Jackson County, and who is now in your charge, to be hanged on the 26th of this month, to a life sentence in state's prison, and you are hereby directed to withhold the execution of said death sentence. You will please acknowledge the receipt of this message at once by wire."
The Sentence of the Jackson County Murderer Was Suspended.
Letters and Petitions Showing Mental Imbecility--A History of the Crime.
The governor was influenced, in ordering the commutation of Smith's sentence, by the receipt of numerous letters and petitions from Jackson County residents, representing that the accused is a mental imbecile and recommending that the death sentence be commuted. Governor Geer received letters from C. B. Watson, district attorney for Jackson County; Hon. E. V. Carter, Wm. Colvig, A. E. Reames, Charles Nickell, and many others. Numerous signed petitions from the prominent business men of Jacksonville and leading physicians were also received telling of Smith's mental condition. Communications were also received at the executive office from authorities in New Jersey, stating that Smith was considered a weak-minded boy before leaving that state.
The following letter written by Rev. Tetlow, director of the St. Francis Industrial School, at Eddington, Pennsylvania, and addressed to Rev. L. P. Desmarais, of Jacksonville, Oregon, is a fair sample for the numerous letters received by Gov. Geer, in Smith's behalf: "This is to certify that Frank Lawrence Smith, now a prisoner in the county jail at Jacksonville, Oregon, and under sentence of death for the murder of one Peter Nelson, was an inmate of St. Francis Industrial School, at Eddington, Pennsylvania, from July 17, 1888 to July 3, 1892. The aforesaid Frank Lawrence Smith whilst in the institution proved to be a very weak-minded boy, in fact one bordering on craziness, and was dismissed on the 3rd of July, and handed over to his mother, as not being a proper and safe subject for that institution. I suppose this same idiocy has brought him where he stands today."
HISTORY OF THE CRIME.On Sunday morning, February 13, 1898, there arrived in Ashland, Or., on the northbound freight train of the Southern Pacific Company, one Peter Nelson, a Swede, aged 37 years, bound for Portland, having tramped and beaten his way on the railroad from the Sacramento Valley, where he had been working as a farm hand. He had in his possession a small, new trunk, containing his clothes and underwear, a pair of blankets and about $110 in money on his person. He remained in Ashland the following night, making a few acquaintances in the vicinity of the depot, to whom he conveyed the information that he was going to Portland to seek work and would hunt up a countryman of his there, named Erickson, whom he thought would assist him in obtaining employment in the city.
He had evidently been traveling in company with other tramps before reaching Ashland, for while here he was accosted by an Italian who was bound north and whom he had seen before, but desired to have nothing to do with. Nelson left town on Monday night's freight train. Somewhere between Medford and Central Point he fell off the moving train and was badly stunned, but was able to walk to a nearby residence, where he appeared about 2 o'clock Tuesday morning, February 15, and awoke the family, who found Nelson with his skull fearfully fractured and the scalp torn and bleeding. The man talked rather incoherently, and after being taken to Medford for medical treatment, died soon afterward.
There was every evidence that the Swede had been assaulted and robbed by his companions and then thrown off the moving train, for dead. His valise and personal effects were cut open and the contents scattered along the railroad track, and quantities of blood were found on some of the clothing which had been rolled up and placed in a sack, his pocketbook had been cut open and was found empty. The car in which the assault, robbery and murder took place gave evidence of a bloody struggle.
The Italian, Joe Lasalle, alias "Blackey," was suspected and there was evidence that several had been implicated in the affair. The efforts of the officers to discover the criminals was rewarded soon after the arrest at Roseburg of Frank Lawrence Smith and another man, who was afterwards discharged. "Blackey," however, who had always been suspected at the instigator of the crime, and is thus charged by Smith, was never apprehended. There has been a suspicion that after Nelson had been beaten to death with the iron coupling-pin, which was used as a weapon, that Smith made away with "Blackey," but this theory is not generally credited.
Smith, who was 20 years of age on the last of this month, and who is a native of Pennsylvania, his relatives now reside at Trenton, N.J., and according to his own statements, are not in good repute, themselves, was tried in the circuit court of Jackson County at the April, 1898, term and was convicted of murder in the first degree. Smith was sentenced by John Hanna to be hung, the date being fixed for June 10. A stay of execution was secured and the case was taken to the supreme court, where the lower court's rulings were affirmed. On the 1st day of [the] April, 1899, term of court, Smith was again brought before Judge Hanna, who again pronounced sentence upon him, and fixing the date for his execution for May 26.
----Ashland, Ore., May 26.--News of the action of Governor Geer in commuting the sentence of Frank Smith to life imprisonment reached Jacksonville at 2 o'clock this morning. Upon receipt of the dispatch the sheriff went to the jail to inform Smith of the news. Upon being awakened and told of the governor's action, Smith got up and danced around the cell, yet not surprised, for he professed to believe all along that the sentence would be commuted.
How Smith Received the News.
Daily Capital Journal, Salem, May 26, 1899, page
SMITH'S SENTENCE COMMUTED
Frank Lawrence Smith is still in the land of the living, Gov. Geer having commuted the sentence of death imposed on him by the courts to that of life imprisonment at almost the last hour. The following telegram of commutation was received at Ashland late on the night before the day set for the execution, and was delivered by messenger to Sheriff Orme in the morning, at about two o'clock:
EXECUTIVE OFFICE,ALEX. ORME, Sheriff of Jackson Co.:
Salem, Or., May 15.
You are hereby notified that I have this day commuted the sentence of death standing against Frank Lawrence Smith in Jackson County, and who is in your charge, to be hanged on the 26th of the month, to life sentence in the state prison; and you are hereby directed to withhold the execution of said sentence. You will please acknowledge the receipt at once by wire.
T. T. GEER,Smith, who had fallen into what he thought was his last earthly slumber, was notified of this change in the situation, and has been almost beside himself with joy ever since. He had made up his mind that his hours on earth were numbered, for all hope had apparently vanished, and he seemed determined to meet his fate bravely. In fact, he had already parceled out his few possessions to relatives and friends, and tried on the clothes in which he expected to mount the scaffold the next morning, besides writing to his mother and sister, who live in Trenton, New Jersey, and bidding them farewell.
Governor of Oregon.
Only once during his long confinement did Smith show any signs of breaking down, and that was when Rev. L. P. Desmarais, on Thursday afternoon, informed him that he must prepare for the worst. He cried bitterly for a few minutes, but recovered his composure soon after the priest's departure.
Smith still strenuously maintains his innocence of the murder of which he was convicted, and those who expected him to make a confession at any time would have been disappointed. On Thursday night he had prepared the following statement, which he intended to make on the scaffold:
"I, Frank Lawrence Smith, now standing upon the gallows, do solemnly and publicly declare that I never murdered Peter Nelson, and never assisted any other person in the act of murdering Peter Nelson. I forgive all my enemies. I pray God to bless my poor old mother and my sister. I wish to thank Rev. Father Desmarais, the sheriff and his deputy, and also the death-watch, Mr. Carney, for all their kindness towards me. I go to my God for justice and mercy. O sacred heart of Jesus, have mercy on me. O blessed Virgin Mary, pray for me. Into thy hands, O Lord, I commend my soul. Amen."
As is usual in such cases, Gov. Geer was severely criticized by many for what others thing was an act of mercy and justice. He evidently thought he had more than one very good reason for commuting Smith's sentence, for several prominent attorneys and physicians, well acquainted with the case, and also a number of leading citizens of Southern Oregon, to say nothing of a petition signed by a large number of people, recommended and suggested the action he took. Gov. Geer's principal reason, however, was that Smith is an imbecile and therefore not accountable. He has a certificate from St. Francis Industrial School, Eddington, Pa., stating that Smith was an inmate of that institution from 1888 to 1892, and was discharged for not being a safe subject.
Democratic Times, Jacksonville, May 29, 1899, page 3
The scaffold erected for the execution of Frank L. Smith and the high fence surrounding it were removed last Saturday.
"Local Notes," Democratic Times, Jacksonville, May 29, 1899, page 3
Chas. Carney, who has been acting as death watch at the county jail for several weeks past, continued his vigil until Smith was taken to Salem.
A big crowd was in Jacksonville Friday, to witness the execution of Frank L. Smith. Many more would have been here, had the news of the commutation not spread.
Frank L. Smith, who will serve the balance of his life in the Oregon penitentiary, was taken to Salem by Sheriff Orme and G. F. Merriman of Medford. He was 21 years old a short time since, being born in Reynoldsville, Pa., May 21, 1878.
"Local Notes," Democratic Times, Jacksonville, May 29, 1899, page 3
Frank Smith was diagnosed with schizophrenia after eight years in prison and admitted to the Oregon State Mental Hospital in 1907. He died of gangrene of the lungs in 1915. His cremated remains still remain at the institution, unclaimed.
Smith's aborted execution was the last in Southern Oregon. (O'Neil's was the last to be carried out.) In 1903 the Oregon Legislature passed a bill requiring all executions to be carried out at the Oregon State Penitentiary in Salem.
Senate Bill No. 3, which passed the House, and will now go to the Governor for approval, provides that in future, whenever the death penalty has been imposed, the execution shall take place at the state penitentiary.
"Brief Mention," Democratic Times, Jacksonville, February 18, 1903, page 2
Last revised May 13, 2020