|
A Tale of Two Abbotts A cautionary tale for
genealogists. The paper below confabulates two different James A.
Abbotts into one, and goes through mental gymnastics to reconcile the obvious
discrepancies between the details of the two lives.
I'll leave it to you to untangle the two Abbotts in the sources below; suffice it to say that one died in 1873, another in 1909. Further notes on the 1873 Abbott--who was not the grandfather of the writer--can be found here. The Story Behind the Search for
James A. Abbott
The
history on the following pages has been compiled
over a ten-year period of research. The search has not been a steady
one, as I have become discouraged, moved from one state to another
twice, and had three children since I started. So, there have been
times when there has been no research done at all. In June of 1983 I
decided it was time to do some serious research and find out more of
this man who was only a name to me .When I started this search in 1974, I didn't even know his name. My father rarely spoke of him when I was a child, and when he did, he seemed to resent the fact that his father died when he was only eight years old. He never took me to where James Abbott was buried, even though we lived within 75 miles of the cemetery where he was buried. As a matter of fact, he never told me his father's name. He did take me to his mother's grave, and as a child of 10 I had enough forethought to write the information from her tombstone down in a small book I always carried with me. My father, Theodore Roosevelt Abbott, was 43 years old when I was born in 1944. He died when I was 16 and I didn't start tracing his family until I was 30. Needless to say, a lot of years were wasted, and the many chances for information from family members was lost. When I wrote to my aunt, Ada (Abbott) Ramsdell, she said she thought her father's name was Alec or Elix Abbott. She was the only living relative who might know anything about the family, and as it turned out, most of the information she gave me was wrong (this was not her fault, as she was the baby of the family and only 2 years old when her father died). When I sent for my father's death certificate, his father's name was listed as Alex Abbott, mother's name not given. I suspect the A. in James' name stands for Alex or Alexander. To date this hasn't been proven. Aunt Ada also said that my grandmother's maiden name was Sarah Johnson, that her first husband's name was Johnson, given name unknown. This information also proved to be wrong, and it took me ten years of searching Oregon records to discover that my grandmother's maiden name was Darneille. Her first husband's name was Johnson, as Aunt Ada had said, and I was able to obtain a copy of their marriage license from Coos County, Oregon, in Jan. of 1984. A lot of people have asked me if I was sure James A. Abbott was my grandfather. After all, he was 70 years old when my father was born in 1901, and a lot of people thought that perhaps there was another generation between him and my father. The following history and the documentation I have has proven to me beyond any doubt that this particular James A. Abbott is my grandfather. Sharon
(Abbott) Prigmore
100 A Stafford Dr. Las Vegas, NV 99115 JAMES
A. ABBOTT
James A.
Abbott was born 22 April
1831 in Jackson County, Indiana,1
parents unknown at this
time.2
In
stature, James was a small man by today's standards. He was 5'7," had
a dark complexion, brown hair, and blue eyes.3 He apparently was a
healthy man, for he said that the only illness he had ever had was smallpox.41831--1909 No record has been found of James prior to the filing of his donation land claim in Douglas County, Oregon in 1853.5 According to it James was married on 1 Dec. 1852 in Gentry County, Missouri to Anne M. Shelby.6 He and Anne probably left Missouri in April or May of 1853, as this was the best time of year to make the dangerous trek across the plains to Oregon or California.7 James arrived in Oregon 25 August 1853, and had settled on his land claim in Douglas County by 21 September 1853.8 In October 1853 [sic], while crossing the Blue Mountain Range in Eastern Oregon, their eldest child, Foley O. Abbott, was born.9 In 1855 the Rogue River Indians decided it was time to rid their country of the white people. James helped to organize, and was Captain of, a volunteer company. He fought to the close of the Rogue River Indian War that followed.10 After the Rogue River Indian War (probably in 1858) James moved to Deer Creek, Josephine County, Oregon.11 By 1860, he and Anne had four children; F. O. Abbott (Foley Orlando, son, b. in 1853), W. N. Abbott (William N., son, b. in 1855), L. A. Abbott (Lollie or Lana, dau., b. in 1856),12 and Asahel S. Abbott (son, b. in 1858?).13 A William M. Abbott and D. P. Abbott (possibly his brothers), as well as a W. J. Turpin and Angus Weaver, were also living with him.14 In the early 1860s before the close of the Civil War, negro slaves and their owners were to be found in Josephine County, Oregon. The Abbotts had four slaves, a negro man and wife, and their two children, little Lou and little Abe. The negro man was killed; James gave the boy, little Abe, to General Joe Lane of Roseburg, Douglas County, Oregon, and took the negress and little Lou north with them.15 James was involved in an altercation with a colored man named Alfred Lorry (possibly his slave), on the 27th of July, 1862, in Kerbyville (near Deer Creek), Josephine County, Oregon. Lorry was intoxicated and in general was raising a ruckus. When James cautioned him to go home, Alfred became violent, grabbed James' whip from him and struck him with it. James was forced to draw his Bowie knife in defense of himself, killing Alfred Lorry in the scuffle that followed.16 [The report of the coroner's jury wasn't quite so eager to justify the killing. Would the writer have been so ready to forgive if she'd known this J. A. Abbott wasn't her grandfather?] In the fall of 1864 the enthusiasm of many militiamen began to wane concurrent with their enlistments. Because of this, and to prevent the drawing of men from the East who were needed to fight the Civil War then in progress, Governor Gibbs encouraged men to join a brand-new outfit to be led by Indian chaser Col. George Currey. The recruiting drives of the 1st Volunteer Infantry featured pretty young things singing patriotic ditties like "Stand Up for Uncle Sam, My Boy." Either their sex appeal or Oregon patriotism paid off; the regiment was duly mustered, and I Company reached Fort Klamath as a reinforcement in 1865.17 In February 1865, General Alvord asked that Fort Klamath be shifted to his district of Oregon from its incongruous place in the California district of operations. Gen. Irwin McDowell then requested Governor Gibbs of Oregon to reinforce Fort Klamath with the newly mustered I Company of the 1st Oregon Infantry.18 On 8 Feb. 1865, at Kerbyville, Jackson County, Oregon, James enlisted in the army as a member of I Company, 1st Oregon Volunteer Infantry.19 On 4 April 1865 he mustered in at Camp Baker, Oregon.20 He was the company cook21 until I Company was sent to Fort Klamath. James gathered with the other Jackson County volunteers at moldering Camp Baker [It was only four years old, so it probably still had that new camp smell.] for speeches and presentation of a flag, before marching over the Cascades under the command of Captain Franklin B. Sprague. During their arduous trek they bolstered their government-issue rations with elk steak and fresh trout. The footsloggers were met at Williamson River by a cavalry detachment from Fort Klamath, which escorted them to Wood River and a welcome by Fort Klamath's commander, Captain Kelly. Captain Sprague had brought two subalterns and seventy-eight enlisted men with him, so it looked like an army to the cavalrymen of C Company, who were now down to a strength of only forty-five men.22 In July, shortly after arriving at Fort Klamath, James was sent on detached service with the rest of I Company to help open a new wagon road from Fort Klamath to the Rogue River Valley, Oregon.23 During the opening of this road to Union Creek and the Rogue River, via Annie Creek Canyon (along the line of today's Highway 62), two of the men of I Company, John M. Corbell and F. M. Smith, rediscovered Crater Lake.24 In Sept. 1865 I Company was sent to help establish Camp Alvord as a winter headquarters for moves against the Snake Indians of the Steens' Mountain area.25 To accomplish this, the soldiers had to build not only a road, but a poor excuse for a corduroy road, across the miry and treeless area of the Warner Lakes by cutting tules, or marsh reeds, and laying them out as a roadbed. Much of the time it more resembled an artificial or floating pontoon bridge than a road. The men then had to haul wagons out of the morass by hand, when even the fort's tough mules bogged down.26 In October 1865, the Indians cut the road between Fort Klamath and Camp Alvord. The closing of the road made direct communication by express rider with Fort Klamath impractical. Sprague left the fort with ten men on October 23rd to join with Captain Augustus W. Starr at Camp Bidwell for a joint move against the Snake Indians around Alvord. Captain Starr couldn't join him, so gave him ten men and an officer, doubling Sprague's force. On the 28th, after receiving the reinforcements, Capt. Sprague's detachment was ambushed, front and rear, by the Snakes in trenches. Somehow Capt. Sprague managed to turn his force around and dash for Camp Bidwell. Three days later, the Snake Indians struck Camp Alvord, killing a guard and running off sixteen head of cavalry horses.27 When the Indians attacked Camp Alvord, James was there being treated for bronchitis.28 On the 1st of Nov., after recovering, he was sent to Fort Klamath on detached service. It's possible he arrived in time to take part in the "Bread Riot" of 1865.29 "The sixty-odd soldiers had just completed the hard labor of a road gang. Building Camp Alvord with logs that had to be hauled a mile or two from the hills, then marching home to Fort Klamath through snow, mud and rain, had left them pinch-gutted from slim rations. At Sprague River Narrows their scanty supplies were further reduced by the raids of half-wild Indian dogs, and when they arrived at the fort they were not too distantly removed from starvation. So ravenous were the young men that they ignored orders and instead of delivering up their just-distributed flour ration to the post baker to be made into bread (the baker returning fourteen ounces of bread for every eighteen ounces of flour given him, to make the labor worth his while), they prepared to enjoy a great pancake feast in their mess using 'all' of the flour issued them. Ordered to turn in their flour to the baker as was customary, they refused and were arrested for mutiny. They finally complied with orders, but not before Major Rinehart had made an example of sixteen-year-old Pvt. James Corwin Fullerton, the first soldier to refuse to obey orders. Rinehart had him strung up by the thumbs with his toes just brushing the ground. As night fell and a snowstorm howled about the bastions, the rebellious troops heard the ominous rattling of rifles by the guards in company headquarters. They feared the worst. But before the would-be mutineers could plan genuine revolt or a surrender, Fullerton was returned to the guardhouse, where it was a case of standing room only, as almost the whole garrison was under arrest. The major then joined them and read the prisoners the Articles of War, advising them that the crime they had committed was punishable by death, but since the Civil War was over he was not even going to court-martial them. He released them with a warning, and so the Bread Riot ended on a peaceful note." James returned to Camp Alvord in mid-November and apparently stayed there until he returned to Fort Klamath in Jan. 1866. In March 1866, while on detached service to Fort Klamath, James was appointed Corporal.30 He stayed at Fort Klamath until July 1866 when he returned to Camp Alvord.31 He apparently remained at Camp Alvord until his unit was mustered out in July 1867. The most important role of the volunteers in their peace-keeping mission was the maintenance of the scatter of existing army posts in Indian country, and here the force had its work cut out for it. Patrols and reconnaissances had to be continued, for the real threats to Oregon settlements were not Confederate sympathizers, but hostile Indians. The latter were always alert to exploit any weaknesses they could detect in the defenses of the state's exposed settlements and ranches. Oregon's citizens knew that the mere presence of military power, the "showing of the flag," by forts and outposts and patrols, did more to keep the peace on the Indian frontier than all the treaties ever sent to Washington to lie unsigned in the Senate.32 As a child on Deer Creek, Asa, James' son, remembers when his mother put out the lights and locked the doors at times when an Indian "scare" was going the rounds. They were never harmed, however.33 James' company was stationed at Fort Klamath to keep watch over the Klamath Indians, turned peaceful, and the Modocs who, for some reason, were largely off the warpath during the Civil War. Perhaps it was the very presence of Fort Klamath and the men who manned her that kept the Modocs in line.34 The men of I Company, 1st Oregon Infantry, were marched to Jacksonville and mustered out of the service in July 1867.35 James is listed as being on I Company's Muster Out Roll in Jacksonville, Jackson County, Oregon on 19 July, 1867.36 From Jacksonville, he and his family moved to the Idaho Territory.37 The 1870 census shows them living in Idaho City, Boise County, Idaho Territory, near the penitentiary. James and Anne now had seven children, having added three more to their family since 1860; Mary J. Abbott (dau., b. 1865 in Oregon), Edwin S. Abbott (son, b. 1867 in Idaho), and Eugene D. Abbott (son, b. Mar 1870 in Idaho). Asahel was not with the family in 1870 and his whereabouts are unknown.38 From 1867 to 1874, things didn't go very well for James and Anne. For some reason, after nearly 20 years of marriage and seven children, it appears they had been divorced.39 In 1880 Anne was listed as the wife of Asa C. Spooner, and had the three youngest children with her.40 James had since returned to Oregon, as he was found in the 1880 census in Flounce Rock, Jackson County, Oregon.41 He had married again, this time to an Indian woman by the name of Caroline.42 They were probably married in 1872 or 1873, as their first (?) child was born in 1874. They had three children; William Abbott, (son, b. 1874 in Oregon), James Abbott, (son, b. 1876 in Oregon), and Florence Abbott (dau., b. 1879 in Oregon).43 What happened to James and his second family in the next ten years hasn't been determined yet. Sometime between 1880 and 1890 they moved to Bandon, Coos County, Oregon, as James was found living there in the 1890 Oregon Union Veterans census.44 Caroline and some of the children may have still been with him in 1890, for in 1898 he stated on a questionnaire he had to fill out to receive his next quarterly pension payment that he lived in Bandon, Coos County, Oregon, that he was a widower and his wife died 23 Sept. 1896. He also stated, however, that he had no living children at that time.45 What happened to James' and Caroline's children, and if they had more after 1880, is still a mystery.46 Sometime between May 1898 and 1900 James moved to Fourmile, Coos County, Oregon. He was found living there in the 1900 census, and listed as a widower. Sarah Johnson was listed as his housekeeper.47 She was listed as a widow, and there were two children, Mary M. Johnson (b. March 1885 in Oregon), and Willie Johnson (b. Feb. 1889 in Oregon). Both children were listed as boarders in James A. Abbott's house.48 1901 proved to be an eventful year for James Abbott and Sarah Johnson. On 27 Sept. 1901, at Fourmile, Coos County, Oregon, Sarah gave birth to a son. He was named Theodore Roosevelt Abbott.49 In Coquille, Coos County, Oregon, on 15 Nov. 1901, James and Sarah filled out an affidavit for a marriage license.50 They were married on 27 Nov. 1901, at the house of I. D. Smith, the ceremony being performed by H. C. Allen, in Coquille City, Coos County, Oregon.51 In 1901 (probably after their marriage), James and Sarah moved to Eagle Point, Jackson County, Oregon.52 In 1903, on the 9th of February a son, Charles D., was born.53 Three years later, a daughter, Ada M., was added to their family.54 On 12 March 1907 James applied for an additional pension that Congress made available to the men who had fought in the Rogue River Indian War.55 James didn't live long enough to enjoy his third family, for two years later he died, just before Ada's third birthday, on a Wednesday, the 14th of April 1909 at Elk Creek, near Eagle Point, Jackson County, Oregon.56 He lived a long and hopefully a happy life. He crossed the plains to Oregon in 1853 when he was a young man of 22, fought in the Indian wars of 1855-1856, and served his country during the Civil War. He was married three times, and left behind him numerous children. (At least thirteen have been documented.) His life was at least as exciting and dangerous as other early pioneers to the Oregon Territory. He doesn't seem to have been involved in the politics of the day, but he was most certainly involved in the settlement of the Oregon Territory. He was a man who was highly respected by those who knew him. A tribute not to be taken lightly, when you consider that the men and women who settled in Oregon in the 1840s and 1850s had to contend with a great deal of hardship and personal danger. Miscellaneous Information
In a
letter received from Ada
(Abbott) Ramsdell in 1974, Ada said that her father's name was Alec or
Elix Abbott.On Theodore's death certificate, his father's name was given as Alex Abbott. It is possible that James A. Abbott used his given name on legal documents; but went by his middle name, Alex or Alexander in his daily life. What the "A" in his name stands for has not been determined. In James' pension papers, there is an affidavit dated 9 Jan. 1932, and signed by Ace Summers, stating that Sarah's name is Sarah "E." Abbott. This is the first time that Sarah's middle initial has been given. On the widow's pension application that Sarah Abbott filled out in April 1909, she said that James had previously been married 16 April 1885. This could have been Caroline, his second wife. However, Caroline is listed as James' wife in the 1880 census, their oldest child being born in 1874. I would assume that James and Caroline were married about 1873, rather than in 1885. It is possible that there was another wife between Caroline and Sarah. If this is so, then Sarah Darneille Johnson was James A. Abbott's 4th wife and not his third. Sarah also stated that James' first wife died in 1887. Whether this was Anne or another wife not yet found hasn't been determined yet. Anne could have died in 1887. James himself said in 1898 that he was a widower and that his wife died in 1896. This should have been Caroline, but 16 years had elapsed since Caroline was found in the 1880 census with James, and the wife who died in 1896 may have been someone entirely unknown to me as yet. It is possible that Sarah was unaware that she was wife number three, and just juggled dates to fit the information she gave. This remains to be proven. To date, the widow's pension application that Sarah Abbott filed in April 1909 is the only document found that states that James A. Abbott is the father of Theodore R., Charles D., and Ada M. Abbott. All other information has only supported this theory, and not verified it. Compiled by Sharon Abbott Prigmore, 1 May 1984. I've tried to be as accurate as possible, but in this type of work there is always plenty of room for error. I can only guess as to what kind of life James A. Abbott must have led. Most of my information came from the histories I've read that cover this time period. What documentation I have been able to obtain was included in the text or the footnotes. Additions and corrections will be added to this history as new information is found. I am also interested in corresponding and exchanging information with anyone connected with this particular Abbott line. I can be contacted at 100 A Stafford Dr., Las Vegas, NV 89115.
Josephine County Historical Society 508 SW 5th St. Grants Pass, Oregon 97526 2
May 1984
Dear Ms. Murphy,Several months ago you sent me information on the Abbott family. Because of the information you sent I was able to piece together a history of my grandfather, James A. Abbott. I am sending you a copy of this history as well as copies of some of the more important documentation I have collected. I have more documentation and if you would like copies of it; I'll send it also. In the information you sent me last November, there was an article from the Grants Pass Courier, Golden Edition 4/3/1935. It mentions at the end of the story of A. S. Abbott, another article written Oct. 29, 1934. Do you have that story, and if so, could you send a copy of it? I would be more than happy to pay for any copies if you would let me know how much they would cost. I hope this history will be of benefit to the historical society. I feel it's the least I can do, since you have been so helpful in the past. If you should have any ideas on where I might find more information on my grandfather or any of his family, I would appreciate hearing from you, as I am running out of ideas. Sincerely,
Sharon Prigmore 100 A Stafford Dr. Las Vegas, NV 89115 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||